Calypso's in Tavernier - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Definitely recommend the Seahorse Sandwich

Delicious food, we ate Tunas Tacos and traditional Steak, both wonderful! We had delicious lemon juice! Everything natural, organic, fresh and healthy! The people who served us were friendly and receptive! A mandatory stop for anyone traveling to or from Key West!

Absolutely incredible food and atmosphere! We went for lunch, and everything was wonderful! I recommend the lemonade and the hogfish tacos were to die for. Listen to the host as what she says about her food is true word for word!

After a long trip down rt 1 from capecoral fl was looking for something quick to eat ran into this joint and wow blown away. Fresh tasty everything made to order lots of passion and good company. Got the fish rueben and might be the best sandwich I ever had so I ordered a second one! It's a small little place with good company and amazing food will be back!!!

Really quaint and very personalized place. Simple food with very fresh and excellent quality products. Highly recommended!!!!

Food is the best I have had in the Keys. The owner is very friendly and helpful. Wr loved it so much we came back for dinner on the same day.

Incredible food we will definitely be stopping there on our way back through. We would give it 10 stars if we could.

My brother Tim brought me here for lunch one day last week, and my goodnesses, that was the best fish sandwich I ever had! I also got the sheet crab soup, which was amazing! Don't sleep on this place! Definitely hit it up for an amazing lunch!

Yum yum yum! All of the food was so fresh and delicious. We had the crab stuffed fish sandwich, crab soup and the special, shrimp stuffed fish sunrise — all of it was amazing!

Omg the shrimp tacos are soooo good, the homemade lemominade is great. The service was amazing and she gave us many local recomandations. Totally recomend to stop for a bite.

Excellent she-crab soup and fish tacos! This place is a great hole-in-the-wall, hidden gem type of restaurant.

Tasty, healthy, friendly. How could you ask for more in a beautiful Florida Keys!!!!

Well seasoned meat and excellent fish tacos

Food was really good and well prepared. It is a small place, but don't overlook it. Well worth the stop.

Best value in our trip to the keys. Wahoo portions were large, well seasoned, and cooked well. Recommended.

Amazing!!! We randomly stopped here on our drive to key west, food was delicious and people were very kind. Highly recommend the soup!

Seriously our best fish sandwiches during our stay in the Keys. The Rueben and the Filet-oh-wish were incredible. The advice to take the wahoo fish was the best advice - meaty and fresh. Amazing. No credit card though - had to drive back to get cash, but boy was it worth the extra miles!!! Wish it wasn’t our last day so we could go back! Lovely staff too!

Stopped here back in October. I live in New England and had a shrimp taco up here last night that struck up two memories about Calypso's. Holy heck the food here was amazing the Tacos my wife and I had were absolutely killer, and number two I forgot to review when I was down here. I wish I could get this level of well crafted shrimp tacos up here in the North. This will be our first stop when we are back in the area for sure!

Tiny hole in the wall, we actually drove right by it the first time but the food is amazing! Service top notch. Highly recommend!

Simplemente delicioso. La mejor comida que hemos probado en Miami y también la más sana y con la mejor calidad de los ingredientes. ¡Y la más barata! Además, la dueña es un encanto de persona. No os perdáis este sitio, no os arrepentiréis. Traed cash, no aceptan tarjetas

Amazing food and great conversation witb the staff. I had the she crab soup and the seahorse sandwich, both of which were topnotch, especially considering the price. Awesome place!

A fabulous restaurant! Best meal we had while visiting the Keys. Tacos, She crab soup, salads - outstanding! A small roadside restaurant that's worth the trip. Bring cash. No credit cards.

Fresh and healthy food at a great price, very nice staff

We ordered the crab soup, crab stuffed shrimp and both the tacos (shrimp & tuna). Loved all of them 😍 Special note should be made about the sauces in the taco and stuffed shrimp - delicious and unique. If you enjoy seafood, this is a hidden gem along the Keys highway near Islamorada.

perfect crab soup! worth to stop here for a while

Food is excellent!! Healthy and tasty.

The reviews for this place are no joke. This might be the first time I craved a restaurant twice. I wanted to eat here everyday I was in key west but it’s a little far from downtown. Everything I ate was beyond delicious. This restaurant might be small but it is dishing up some of Floridas best food. I can not recommend this restaurant enough seriously. I had shrimp tacos which were so creamy and fresh. I’m craving it just by writing this review haha. I have no pictures to post because I inhaled everything in a minute.

Wow, wow, what fresh and amazing food. The restaurant is small but the is vast. Must try but they accept only cash. Thank you guys and keep it up. 👏👍

She crab soup was divine, filet oh wish was the best fish sandwich we've ever had and cheese steak blew my mind! Wow!!

Absolutely fantastic food. Stop on the way down. Stop on the way back up.

The best fish tacos we had in the Keys, and at a very reasonable price. The tuna was a religious experience!

This a gem in your way to key west is located in the MM 92. We ordered the Todd and the Big Mick hamburger, all ingredients are from Canada, no genetic modified products all naturals, I only can said is excellent and I recommend it 100%.

Amazing food definitely recommend for fish people

The most amazing burgers I have ever tasted! The staff are great and the Chef has mad skills! I would definetly recommend getting the Mexi Burger and their fresh lemonade, but don't forget to bring cash!

The perfect lunch spot! Loved the she crab soup, shrimp tacos and the hibiscus tea Arnold Palmer. Highly recommend!

Best burgers in the keys. So juicy. The tuna tacos were amazing as well. She crab soup was good as well as the lemonade. Low key unassuming place for good eats. Cash only.

Fantastic cuisine, this food would be 4X more expensive at fancy restaurant, get INCREDIBLE value and quality in a relaxed atmosphere. Yes, as others have stated... try the She-Crab soup!

Nice local chefs to by from , excellent food ! Really nice family!!!

Excellent! Prenez la soupe de crabes puis partager vous les tacos au thon et aux crevettes ! Vraiment délicieux !!! Et la propriétaire est adorable !

What a gem! My friend had been to the previous location and swore this place would ruin me for she-crab soup. We arrived just before it got busy and enjoyed chatting with Shelby and her dad who was in the back cooking. The soup was excellent, with big chunks of crab and a few extra shakes of sherry, yum. Also the best black beans I've ever had - I literally raised the bowl to my lips to drink the rest of the sauce! My horseradish tuna was delicious, as was my friend's Black Magic hogfish. Get the cupcakes from Shelby's "Cobra Bites" bakery while you can - ohmygosh, the Tropi-Colada was out of this world. We'll be back every time we visit, without fail! April 2022: still just as good! Mexi burger was excellent.