Italian Food Company Express in Tavernier - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Amazing square pizza, yummy cacio e pepe, fresh house salad, and great bruschetta too! Key lime pie was also good too. Quick service and great staff as well.

love italian food company Tavernier/Express the pizza and pasta is great! the market is awesome, small but has their brand pastas, imported pomodoro sauces from Naples, the yellow cherry tomatoes from the vesuvius volcano and more items that they use. great place with great food and items.

Very nice place. Very friendly.

Amazing food and service! Rasih our server was accommodating and knowledgeable about the menu. Truffle mushroom pizza delicious!!

Rasih was an amazing server and the food was spectacular.

Amazing food and service rasih.

Had a great experience, a wonderful surprise just happened upon them and had an amazing time

Extraordinary and truly authentic italian food (rated by someone living in “Monaco di Bavaria”! Can strongly recommend the tiramisu (and if course everything else on the card). Fair prices and friendly service!

Very nice little restaurant, friendly service, good food

We were pleasantly surprised the pizza was excellent. It turned out to a delicious pizza and great service. Rashi was fantastic. Will definitely come back

Very casual restaurant, self seating but still good service. Food was great, seems Italian to me but I’m not Italian. Went three times in the span of two days, I think that speaks to their quality. Had two pastas and a pizza; the pasta was elegant and the pizza was delicious. The different pastas have wonderful sauces and the pizza was lightly crispy in the crust but soft in the middle. Slightly on the more expensive side but definitely one of the better restaurants in the area.

All is amaizing, Best restaurant in Tavernier and service, 10 Star if possible, thanks for the amaizing night!

Every time we eat here the food is 10/10 the Veronica pizza is a must .

My family and I cannot stop talking about how good the food is. If you want excellent Italian food, this is the real deal.

Great food, great service. We will be back and visiting the other locations. Thank you.

Great food. Cozy and clean. Server was great.

Most Excellent! Low key great food. Highly recommended.

I ordered take out. The online ordering was confusing and sent my order to the wrong location. Forwhat I paid, I expected more from the pizza. Small slices and it wasn't well flavored. Eggplant parm was salty.

It was a perfect tip from Google. Great service, delicious food. Nice place.

The pizza was larger than we thought it would be. Rectangle thick crust.

Large party and the staff did not disappoint. Great fun was had by everyone. Laughing, singing and dancing all great Italy style. The food waa amazing! So authentic.

I did not think I would be interested in having Italian food at the keys, but let me tell you- this place is a hidden gem! Service was fantastic, the restaurant was super clean, and most importantly the food we had was fantastic! We're definitely coming back in the future.

A thoroughly enjoyable experience. Both pasta dishes were really good (especially the Pasta All'Amatriciana, which I had on the advice of the host). The service was similarly very good. The host was especially friendly, and after a convo about trips to Italy offered us free samples of the pizza (!), which were delicious. All the food is super-fresh. As per other reviews, the outside does not do justice to a very nice interior. First rate in every respect :)

This place was absolutely great. The food was outstanding and so was the service. I got the meatball sandwich, it was very good.

Amazing food topped only by fantastic service from Mehmet. Pizza is a must. We will be back!

Their Special - Roman Casio e Pepe is amazing! We also had the Super Margherita pizza which was so good. Highly recommend when in Tavernier!

Hands down the BEST Italian food I have personally eaten. I had the Roman Cacio e pepe and my wife had the super margherita pizza and both dishes were fantastic! The atmosphere was great and the service even better! I can’t wait to try their other locations the next time I am in the Florida Keys.

Fantastic Italian food- very genuine to traditional food. Generous portions and great service!

Amazing pizza and good draft beer (although not many options). Has a nice ambience...the outside does not reflect the inside...it's really nice inside. We will certainly return as it was awesome!

Food was amazing! One of the best restaurant we had while visiting Florida and the Keys. We ordered the “seafood pasta” and “ pasta all’ amatriciana”. The seafood pasta takes the cake. Great portion of food for a reasonable! Visitors From cali with love!

I highly recommend this place. The food, and vibe is one you definitely want to experience. Owners are amazing, hard-working entrepreneurs.

Amazing food & attention was great!

Food was way more then delicious words can't explain how mouth watering this beautiful craft of art they call food is I shed tears thinking of my plate the owner was the nicest person I've ever had the pleasure of meeting and speaking to don't even question it get in your car and break speeding laws and come here now to eat COME NOWWWW YOU COULD NOT GO WRONG WITH ANY DISH

The seafood pasta is absolutely fantastic. Ask for a little bit of spice for a pleasant suprise

The owner was the nicest man I’ve ever met in my entire existence. The food was to die for, i genuinely teared up eating my bolognese. My friends and family will remember this outing for decades to come.

Amazing atmosphere, very attentive to the customers food was amazing a waited barely anytime for it. Would recommend an will be back forsure

Fun place, good food and really fast. Love the atmosphere and music.

Loved the spaghetti and meatballs!

We are glad to have the Italian Food Company Express so close to home. My wife had the Pesto Gnocchi with Shrimp, and I had the Lasagna. Save room for dessert. Their tiramisu and chocolate mousse are excellent.

Here the impressions from the Italian vacation come back. Food and service are very good.

I had an absolutely wonderful dining experience at this restaurant. The ambiance was perfect, with a cozy and authentic Italian atmosphere. The food was exceptional, bursting with flavor and beautifully presented. I must also give a special mention to our server, Rasih, who was incredibly attentive and made sure our meal was perfect from start to finish. His friendly demeanor and excellent service truly enhanced our evening. Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a top-notch Italian dining experience!

Thanks for serving us, nice food, cozy place and great staff

Great food very good service a restaurant that everyone should visit thank you very much Rasih

Caccio e peppe was phenomenal, great service, lovely atmosphere :))

This place can't get out of its own way. Tries to be something it isn't, and that's authentic Italian. We're here for 9 days and thought we would give this place a chance. When I saw the menu, I stayed against my better judgemental. First came in and was told to sit where we wanted. After sitting g where we wanted was moved to a 4 top because the 6 top is already reserved... my family and 4 other senior citizens only ones in the whole place. Ask if there is a kids menu available formy 10 year old and was mumbled at by the waiter and never offered a child's menu. We ordered water, per usual, and perused the menu. Everything is rudimentary dishes, and everything is an add on. I ordered the gnocchi colognes, and my wife and son ordered Alfredo. 10 year old didn't see anything because we weren't offered a menu for her. Tried to eat the gnocchi and it was bland. Found one half of a cherry tomato I. The whole dish and barely enough meat to feed an ant. Son left his plate because his wasn't seasoned. Wife and little girl split herss and neither ate half of their serving. We got yhr check and it was 74 bucks. We've eaten Italian in Atlanta, nashville, chattanooga, Dallas, sant Antonio, and Los Angeles. I've never been this disappointed in a meal. Only reason I'm posting this review is because I'm sitting g here getting madder by the minute....

Food was amazing! Service was wonderful! Place a little run down but cute too. Recommended!

This food, especially the roman style pizza, especially the truffle mushroom arugula pizza, is an incredible, fresh, beautiful food experience. Elevated far above the norm. Thank you for creating food that turns out so classy and with obvious deliberate love and care. The quality of the ingredients, preparation and presentation is impressive. Thank you. Kimberly

They were nice and the service is amazing and I loved the place 😁😁😁👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

On the pricier side but food is fantastic! Service is attentive. I would definitely go back again

Honestly, we love this place for lunch and dinner. We have never been disappointed. The marinara is one of the best I have ever had and the flavor of the olive oil is delicious. I prefer this smaller location to the much bigger one further south. It is small and quaint with good service.

The atmosphere was less than I look for. I have had better food.

Best pizza you could eat in Tavernier if not in all Florida's key. Also, their seafood pasta is pretty good .

OMG HOW DELICIOUS! The food was amazing!! You have to order the clams in wine sauce, and for dessert, the nutella panini. The staff were super friendly and adorable! Our second time here and will definitely be coming back!

Amazing authentic food . Great pizza .

Excellent food. The best pizzas we have eaten in Florida. Thanks to Nelly for her attention, and her “to go” service👌

Rasih is an amazingly Service oriented server with a great attitude and awesome. Awesome recommendations. i’ve been to all of their restaurants in the keys, and because this one was smaller, I was hesitant, now it’s my favorite because of the food and of course, rasih’s smile!!! Highly recommend

This is the third Italian Food Company in the keys and like the other two DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!!! Different menu, different style pizza and our waiter Rasih was amazing! Service oriented, sweet and his recommendations were spot on!!! Food is fire!!! Will definitely be back since we were already regulars of this chain.

A friend recently invited me to lunch, my choice of restaurants! I immediately recalled my more than wonderful experience at the Italian Food Company-I cannot believe I waited weeks to write a review because that dining experience was so-really good food and wine, great quaint atmosphere, my daughter said it was like dining in Italy itself and Mehmet our waiter was more than exceptional!

Owner choose pizza special Margarita And omg seafood pasta fabulous Penne tuna puttaneaca was amazing Thank you chef Bonito and Richard And great service Mehmet 👏 we see you soon

Great Italian restaurant! Delicious food and exceptional customer service. Our waiter, Mehmet, made us feel special and welcome. Chefs Bonita and Vanessa know how to make an excellent pizza and focaccia. Highly recommend Italian Food Company on Key Largo.

Great food, awesome service BONITA AND VANESSA

Overpriced. The pasta had too much black pepper.

The Veronica pizza never disappoints and our server Mehmet was awesome!

Very unassuming spot where everything was excellent. Good selection of wine to go with some great pasta dishes and pizza. Highly recommend.

Simply divine! The food is incredibly delicious. We come from Switzerland and have never had such good Italian food in America - hats off! The service was very friendly and the restaurant is very nicely decorated. You feel like you're in Italy. The prices are very fair and the portions are a good size. The tiramisu for dessert was the crowning glory. We will be back definitely!

I forgot to take the picture before I started eating it but OMG this rigatoni carbonara is so good I couldn’t wait 🥰💛 check them out!

The absolute most amazing food - pizza, chicken pesto, chicken parm, bruschetta, Amalfi salad - we have ever had. Vacationing in the Keys for 10 days and have already decided to not only come back multiple times but bought sauce and pasta to take home. Literally the best pizza any of us have ever had in our lives. I’ve never recommended anything more. (Tavernier location)

The food is absolutely phenomenal. Real ingredients that you can read! The service is fantastic and we will definitely be back. Don’t drive by the Tavernier location… you will be missing out on amazing food!!!

The pizzas are magnificently airy, crispy, very good and very well served. The pesto pasta was very flavored with basil. The wines were good. The servers were attentive and very friendly. We could have thought we were in Rome.

Great great Anniversary dinner here! Christopher add Rahis were amazingly personal and made our dinner so much fun!!!

What a great place to go eat and have a great time Food was awesome and the environment was incredible Recommended 💯 %

Staff was excellent food was outstanding

Pleasantly surprised just how good the food was. Will return!

It’s like I’ve never had italian food before! The food is soo soo good! The vibes are super cute! The staff is very friendly and sweet! We’re vegetarians, and had soo many amazing options This is the best meal of our girls trip!!!

Amaziinggg food!! I am a vegetarian and loved the food here! We ended up trying all the pastas. Rasih here has been really sweet too. Definitely would recommend for authentic and amazing Italian food.

Me and my wife would always order to go and we wanted to give it a try and dine in. The food as always was amazing and the experience is really pleasant, good music, good food, and our server Ray gave us the best service. I definitely recommend this place

Everything is just so good. My favorite are the paninis and cannolis, but there’s no going wrong, excellent service. Staff is fast, fun and super receptive. Recommend it a lot

It was amazing ambiance. We love cacio Pepe and super margherita pizza. Thank you rasih.

Delicious italian place and the service was amazing

Me and my family came to this place and we are amazed! The pizzas and pastas, everything was delicious. Our server Ray had complete knowledge about the menu and helped us throughout our whole meal. Definitely coming back.

Family dinner at location in Tavernier. Delicious food, family friendly, and some of the best service we've had in the Keys (thank you, Ray!).

So, we went here, was told the pizza is roman style and is good. Decided to try it. It's worthy of the drive. The first thing the menu isn't large but very accommodating. Ordered the eggplant stack, it's a non breaded version, think more Sicilian style, it was really good, could see how this and a nice piece of fresh bread would make an awesome meal. Flavors were on point, and it did not disappoint us. Next wife ordered a sandwich, this too was amazing, everything was fresh, the bread was so light, so crunchy, so fresh, and took us back to Italy 🇮🇹. Layered perfectly with salty prosciutto ham, fresh mozzarella, fresh rocket, and a very nice portion, too. I ordered mushroom pizza, wow, nice portion, nice toppings, but the crust, oh man, that crust. I was so light, crunch, and perftly done with a.slight bit of charring that makes it taste so good. It's not burnt, not well done, just slightly charred. I could not stop eating it. The house olive oil is some of the best, and they sell it in-house. If you're near here. DO NOT MISS THIS PLACE. And if you want to really have a great time, ask for Ray, he was great, knew all the ingredients, was prompt, very nice and is a great waiter, he made our experience even better. Only 4 stars on the atmosphere because it's loud but so very worth it. Actually, I'm changing it to 5 stars cause this place is awesome. The waiter here is so knowledgeable about all the food and everything, we did try the Tavernier location and were disappointed in the pizza and eggplant. I don't know who the chef is at the Islamorada location, but he is the best.

Sauce and meatballs are delicious. Possibly the best pizza in Florida. Definitely worth stopping by.

Food and Service was GREAT! I especially enjoyed the meatballs. Service and vibe was also great.

The food there was simply amazing, the pizza and pasta simply baked to perfection. Our waitress, Dina, was extremely nice and exceptional in serving and making us feel comfortable and welcomed. Overall, was a great experience and would recommend!

If you like Italian and great service in the keys this is the place to go and all reasonably priced !

The best lasagna I’ve ever had in my life

Excellent service from the staff. Chef Richard is a “pizza wizard”. People need to try their pizzas when they visit the Keys.

Truly excellent food…very authentic Italian. The Roma pizza is fermented for 80+ hours and very difficult to find elsewhere. Lasagna is special

Avoid the tourist trap restaurants with the big billboards. Real made from scratch food was an unexpected surprise along the main road.

Mehmet was unreal!! Thank you guys so much for making a great night for me and my family. FANTASTIC ITALIAN FOOD!!! And I’m from the Northeast 🤌 also try the pizza!!

Food was excellent and service was even better!!!!

Great little restaurant with a fun atmosphere. Delicious food and very friendly staff. Mehmet was an amazing waiter. I would highly recommend this restaurant and would definitely come here again.

Amazing food and service! The fiocchi di pera is so good!

Very lovely place. Delicious food and good service. I will definitely come back.

I have ate at the key largo location and thought it was excellent. I tried the Tavernier location and wasn't impressed. I ordered a glass of wine and chicken Parma the food was literally on my table within 3 minutes. My wine came at least 5 minutes later. The spaghetti and chicken were still cold. I sent it back and they warmed it up. The spaghetti was so so. I think cardboard would have tasted better than the burnt chicken. I left the chicken.I had to ask for Parmesan cheese and spoon for the spaghetti The male waiter came to take care of me and was good , he wasn't my waiter. I went to the counter to see if the manager was in. I saw the kitchen staff taking a knife to the bottom of a pizza to scrape off the burnt bottom. This is my first review ever and I have never sent food back in my 64 years. I just hope this company hasn't grown to fast. I really enjoyed the the key largo location 2 times prior to this experience

First time customers and we loved it! Friendly service, the pizza was amazing, my whole family was in agreement which rarely happens! :)

Food and atmosphere are fantastic!!! Rashi is a great server, very professional. It's always top notch.

Adorable little restaurant with the BEST pizza!! Must stop in!!!!

Food was so good and the atmosphere was so cute! Our waiter, Rasih was amazing!!