Cedar Lodge Supper Club - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Small friendly efficient restaurant with fantastic food and drinks!

Amazing food and wonderful wait staff!!🥰

Good service hot tasty food 😋 always good 👍

I was astonished by the speed with which we were seated without a reservation. The fritter was exceptional. Subsequently, I enjoyed the most delectable salad I've had in an extended period. The French onion soup was exceptionally excellent. The prime rib was exquisitely seasoned, delivering one of the most delightful flavors I have ever experienced in any kind of meat. Asparagus was flawlessly prepared. With all these elements, having a superior waiter contributed to the most pleasant dining experience possible.

It has been several years since we have been to Cedar Lodge. They didn't disappoint. We ate there for my birthday and I'm so happy went there.

Went twice in 3 days. Amazing food, great bar service, fresh Guinness tap, amazing fish, and steaks were incredible (blue cheese). Can't wait to return!

The establishment is very friendly and upbeat!

We had an absolutely amazing experience. Friendly staff, fast turnaround, and amazing food for such a great price!

I had the seafood combo which is perch, haddock, shrimp and sea scallops. If you love seafood order this, scallops and shrimp are excellent. My wife had tenderloin tips and scallops combo. The tips are extremely tender and very flavorful. Try the strawberry soup. it's great.

A heavyset bartender was very rude. Walked in wasn’t in the door 20 seconds and was hollered at. We were looking for a spot at the bar to sit. The bar has maybe 25 barstools. We just stopped in for a drink and the heavy bartender runs up to us and had to mention AGAIN we are done serving food! I heard her and said ok! Then she runs up to me to tell us again “ we’re done serving food! I turned to her and said I heard you! First of there’s no need to come out from bar. We will not comeback due to our first impression she left.

Love the fritter and strawberry soup!! So unique.

Both of our streaks were underdone, my prime rib was saturated in pepper. The "strawberry soup" that I read great reviews about is nothing more than over sugared pureed strawberries. It was very loud. Difficult for my wife and me to carry a conversation. Nothing in the building to knock down the acoustics. The service was good, 4 or 5 waitresses for the ten or so tables. With a couple drinks each, we spent about $125 for the two of us, after tips.

We travel all over for supper clubs, and this is our number 1. Small but food, service, and drinks are excellent. Must get the fritter!

Ok. My backstory first. Drive past this place every week, and have noticed it prior to driving past every day for work. Been on the buckelist for some time. We go in today, packed in a great way. All the patrons were very orderly and courteous with new faces coming in. Invited us to the bar to get an old fashioned, and helped us out with the process: You order a drink and say you want to order, and they will find you. We were skeptical, but sure schnitzel, they found us to order. Drinks were great with an amazing offering, and pretty great beer selection as well. Food: Amazing staff handling thr seating, and offering suggestions. Love the sweet tooth integration with orders (have to visit to see what I mean). Spot on Fritters to start?!?!?! Strawberry soup?? Think the cold slurry that is the best part of a strawberry Sunday. Unexpected, but great! Steak was a great cut and prepared exactly how I ordered- chef recommendation. My wife got the perch, which was light and amazing as well. To finish, we got the pistachio cheesecake. What. The. Heck. Amazing. VERY well done- kudos to the female chef that was on the edge thinking it was too sweet, from what we heard... Been on the buckelist for some time, glad we stopped and will be back. Thank you folks, and CHEERS!

Kelen and her staff are top notch, 👌 people pleasers! Great drinks phenomenal food and fantastic service. Cozy supper club vibes with big city service! You need to try the chicken marsala and the bacon wrapped Cajun shrimp. We love you guys! Keep up the great work!

Fabulous food that overflowed the plate. People, both staff and regulars, were delightfully welcoming. Atmosphere that was warm and inviting. Exactly what my soul needed. Definitely will be coming again. Thank you for a very pleasant evening and the wonderful meal.

Loved the classic supper club charm. Starting with a warm fluffy apple fritter is definitely a highlight before having a thick cut ribeye. Steaks were cooked less than we would’ve liked, but overall good. Just be sure to order one grade higher than usual.

I wish there was more space inside because the food and service was incredible but waiting to be seated was beyond cramped.

Always a great meal at Cedar Lodge. Top notch service every time!

Great, fun place. Excellent fish.

From the second you walk in the door you are greeted with a warm smile and they take your drink order. Service was very quick and attentive. Food was excellent. Recommendations are the fritter, strawberry soup or extremely cheesy French onion. Finish your meal off with prime rib and an ice cream drink! Well worth the drive no matter where you are coming from, we drive 30 minutes to dine here.

Finally stopped in after passing many times and it was well worth it. It was Friday night around 5:30 and the place was busy. I quickly got a bar stool and the bartenders were prompt with a beverage and menu. The group next to me invited me into their conversation which was very kind of them and enjoyable. My order of Perch with rice and a Fritter was taken within a half hour and within the next half hour I was seated. The Fritter was amazing, a perfect start, the salad was fresh and crispy. The perch fillets were good sized and lightly breaded and the rice was cooked and seasoned well. For dessert I enjoyed the chocolate chip muffin from the bread basket. Again it was delicious. An extra bonus, the dinner and beverage was under $25. The food, service and atmosphere will bring me back again!

Great small supper club. Best to have reservations as it is busy. If you go often enough, it becomes a Cheers atmosphere where everyone knows your name!!

Food was great, service was just as good. Small cozy place. Fantastic food for a reasonable price. We will definitely be back.

Been going to this place for over 17 years. Food is outstanding! Service is great😊 Atmosphere is Wisconsin Supper Club at its finest!

Meat was under cooked and needed to be sent back. Other than that, food was delicious and service was awesome.

My husband and I stopped here for dinner to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Such a cute, quaint little place with great food and an inviting atmosphere. Waitstaff was very friendly as well. We will definitely be returning.

Stopped in for breakfast, it was fantastic! Super fast, attentive, and friendly staff! Food was fresh and very delicious. Prices were very reasonable.

Very solid place. 👌 but man plan for a wait.

Best food ever! Reasonably priced!

Awesome and friendly bartenders. Exceptional service and yummy food!

They sat us at the table, next to the patrons. Loud , people pushing shoving. It was awful. Steaks were raw. Sent back twice, still raw. Potatoes hard as rocks. Just gave us money back. That wasn't the point. My point was to let them know how bad it really was. Waitress was rude.

I took my daughter there for her birthday and we both had a very wonderful and relaxing time with each other over a very good meal.

Very good food, excellent service. First time there.

Best place on the East shore of Lake Winnebago!!

We went on Friday and everyone in our party had fish. Some had tuna, some haddock and some perch. All were excellent. Wait staff was attentive and accurate. It's a smaller di ni g room so was a bit loud. This didn't interfere with the experience. Will definitely go back.

Great food. Excellent steak. Everyone was genuinely friendly that worked there.

Had our first family meal out in months. The staff was very accommodating and our meal was amazing! 8/9/23 Had a birthday dinner here. They were so kind. Even brought my husband's cake out with candles on 😊

A wonderful drive with friends to enjoy exquisite food. Strawberry soup was sweet, creamy delight.

Cedar Lodge has awesome food and service. I would highly recommend reservations. The place is a bit small but they are highly efficient in serving customers. I love eating there and I ‘m never disappointed. The prices are very reasonable.

Great place to eat and visit with great friends. And mother's Birthday

I eat out a lot and appreciate the finer establishments - this is one of my favorite restaurants in Wisconsin. Fish, steak, prawns, strawberry soup, cole slaw are all incredible. The staff is consistently exceptional. Worth the drive from wherever you are in eastern WI !

Ok, so, yes i work here but i want to share. Kellen (the boss) is the nicest boss ive ever met. she treat’s customers so well and always puts her workers before herself. and in the kitchen we always make sure to keep things clean and keep dishes sanitary for customers. the chefs are also full of joy and love joking around but not when it comes to cooking. they always do things to perfection. the bar and menu have a large variety of things so you will never be disappointed.

Went with a group of 16 and they were able to accommodate us later in the evening at two separate tables. Food and service are excellent as usual.

Stopped in for a beer and breakfast while out biking. Loved the patio seating

This is absolutely the best supper club in the area. While this is a smaller restaurant, they are extremely efficient in turning the tables over. The wait staff are great and professional You will start your meal with a warm fritter followed by a soup and then a salad. The food is always great. Tonight we had prime rib and it was perfect. They do take reservations and I would recommend that you make them. If you come by boat, they will even pick you up. It’s a special treat ever time we dine here.

Not easy to get table on weekends. Need big appetite to eat the amount of food they serving....Excellent prime rib. Great bar.

Best food , cocktails, and service around.. We love this place!