Cookies by Sarah in Egypt Lake-Leto - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

We received so many compliments on these cookies! Thank you for the product that was the talk of the meeting.

So I see this lady has all 5 stars so unfortunately I have to be the 1st 1star. We started with a visit to the address listed on google and it turned out to be a home. So we called a little confused, called the number online and Sarah explained she was a home based business. We explained that we are from out of town and needed emergency help and gave her a quick run down of our issue, she was very understanding and advised just fill out an order form and she will get back with us asap. We did as requested on 06/17/24 we never heard anything back from her in any communication platform. We reached out today 06/21/24 several times with no response till finally she decided to text that she never received any order form. We sent her the order form showing it was clearly sent and her response was did we receive an invoice with credit card details. I explained why would I receive an invoice if no details was ever discussed. Her response to that was her assistant must have deleted our invoice because it did not meet her requirements so my response was how could that be when we explained our request and you was fine with it. So moral of this experience is Sarah was very unprofessional handling this issues and clearly needs to get back to whatever gave her 5stars before because she gave us the very opposite treatment from 5stars. I would not recommend this place at all

What a wonderful experience I had with Cookies by Sarah. From the ordering, to the immediate communication, to the easy pick-up,- that was outstanding. Seeing the bonus cookie, the design on the cookies, though, and then seeing the guests see the cookies- that was extraordinary! They were literally SO excited. Thank you for making this process so easy. As I mentioned, I am from out of town and I flew into TPA for a work event. I flew into TPA airport and in just about 15 minutes, I was there to pick up the cookies. My event was a hit and everyone was raving about the cookies- both in the design and in the taste!! I was sure to let them know that you were local(ish) (they are all in the Spring Hill area) so they can reach out to you with any cookie needs. PS (shhhh) (I even took one home for my cookie-lover boys to try and their eyes were wide with joy and they both said "mmmmm" at the taste.) Thanks again Sarah!

Sarah did an amazing job with individually packaged cookies for a Baby in Bloom theme shower!! Design was flawless and beautiful and cookies tasted great!! They were exactly as my daughter envisioned them. Would highly recommend!

Our cookies are absolutely beautiful & so delicious too! Thank you so much! Can’t wait to order again for our next event!

Beautiful, delicious and glamorous! Sarah did an incredible job with these cookies, they were a gift for my sister and she was absolutely obsessed! Would definitely recommend!

Cookies by Sarah are not only absolutely beautiful but also so incredibly delicious! She will take your vision and bring it to life for any special occasion! I have placed an order for a baby shower, several birthdays and now for my parents 50th wedding anniversary and have been over the top impressed every single time! You will LOVE these cookies, guaranteed!!

We absolutely love cookies by Sarah, The taste, quality and presentation are superior and perfect for every event. She is always on time with orders and amazes us each time.

Have ordered from Sarah twice. Her cookies are beautiful AND they taste amazing— truly the best of this kind of decorative cookie!

Sarah did such a good job on my bachelorette cookies I ordered!! Highly recommend her 🤍

Sarah did an unbelievably amazing job on my cookies! Booking was easy and communication and pick up were smooth. I couldn’t believe how gorgeous my cookies came out for my travel themed baby shower. Totally exceeded my expectations because she nailed every gorgeous detail! Not to mention they were absolutely delicious! So thankful and highly recommend!

Sarah is not only incredibly talented but the nicest person! I was stuck at the car dealership getting my car serviced when I was supposed to pick up the cookies for a grad party. She personally drove them to me at the dealership. Absolutely the best!

Wonderfully made cookies! Fast service for a bulk order. Highly recommend.

The cookies are absolutely stunning! I am so excited to have them displayed on the dessert table at my daughter's first birthday!!!

Cookies by Sarah, best cookies in the Tampa Bay area! The creativity of her cookies and quality is unmatched. My husband could not stop eating the Christmas cookies I brought home. Make sure you hide some for yourself because they will go fast!

I’m a direct descendant of the original Cookie Monster. I know a thing or two about what sets great cookies apart from the average ones. I normally just chomp on cookies one after another, barely chewing and swallowing most of them whole. Sarah’s cookies are far too delicious to treat with such disrespect. They’re as gorgeous as they are delicious! 11/10. Highly recommend.

Absolutely can’t recommend these cookies enough. Not only were they absolutely beautiful, they were soo good! Not hard and crumbly like normal decorative cookies- soft cookie and icing. I told her my dads favorite things and let her have creative freedom and she knocked it out of the park!