Desserts by Toffee to Go in Tampa - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I've been going here weekly since I moved here a year ago, and I love the place, love the deserts... but y'all raised the prices to $7 for a slice a cake recently which turned me around from this place. I understand inflation, but unfortunately I won't be going back here anymore... thanks for bringing great deserts to Tampa. You will always get 5 stars from me! Edit: I came back. and as always, amazing deserts, and friendliest prices in town. Other desert spots do no compare to this.

I have been a happy customer of this establishment for a few years. I recently had an issue with an order and they went above and beyond what would normally be expected to address it. As a result, I remain a loyal customer.

Yoders ice cream was great.. The peanut butter pie tasted like wax and wasn't good at all. Counter girl was chatting it up with her friend and texting and forgot to make two customers cappuccinos. Won't be back.

Toffee To Go is a gem! I had an incredible experience with their amazing service and delicious treats. I want to give a special shoutout to Alyssa, the pastry chef, who truly went above and beyond for me. I needed a last-minute custom cookie order for my bridal shower, and Alyssa made it happen with such grace and kindness. The cookies were not only gorgeous but also absolutely delectable. Her attention to detail and dedication to her craft are evident in every bite! 10/10 service and products.

Warmed Toffee bar topped w/ vanilla ice cream and toffee sauce was so good

I got matcha and samoa pie and my friend got smores bar and toffee nut latte. THIS IS THE BEST THING I EVER TASTED IN MY LIFE. Employees were so sweet too. Everything clean, welcoming environment, easy to understand. Thanks!!

I visited Toffee to go for the first time this week and was extremely happy with the experience. The ladies at the counter were super friendly and informative when giving suggestions and offering samples. I ended up getting the desserts and love them. You can tell the product is fresh and everything was super decadent. This will definitely be in my rotation of dessert spots and my experience here is why I love supporting local businesses

Something must have changed bc their shortbread toffee bar was not as good. Neither was the toffee cheesecake. :(

I ordered a piece of the toffee cheesecake with the toffee sauce through DoorDash. It was very good, though honestly not quite as creamy as I was expecting. I would try it again.

Awesome environment and delicious dessert. Their Oreo cream pie is my go to but their whole selection is amazing.

Delicious toffee. Great gift idea! Lots of sweet treats to choose from. Plenty of seating inside. Small parking lot on side of building- you can enter off the Main Street or around back.

Excellent! No room for improvement.

Initial visit, we were so pleased with the cheesecake. We tried the pumpkin(perfect texture, so creamy yet thick/full of flavor) and toffee cheesecakes(same airy texture, delicious). The richness lies in the savoriness. It's not just saturated with sugar. The crust was also delicious. Unfortunately, the service was mediocre. I asked the young lady what makes the triple peanut butter ice cream, and her response "It has a lot of peanut butter." Not very helpful. It all looked so good, so I asked what they recommended, and the response was, "Everything." The other staff member jumped in and recommended the toffee cheesecake. Recommend better communication with customers. Nice, clean decor/layout.

Some of the best desserts in the area. It has become our go-to location for dessert whenever we are in the area

After spending part of the day in Pinellas Park for the BBQ & Rodeo, we all felt the need for a "sweet" follow up. Sometimes the equivalent of throwing a dart at the GPS (aka Google Maps) lands on a real gem. Today was no exception. Nice location, plenty of parking, and a very clean place. Service was prompt and very friendly. We all opted for a variety of sweet treats and beverages. Everything was 100% perfect. Can't wait to come back for more when we are in the area.

don't laugh at me but im leaving 5 stars for the refreshing water by the door. after having a few my pieces of the sample toffee & 3 cups of the most refreshing water i have ever had i instantly became of fan. I personally love the milk chocolate toffee & my hubby love the white chocolate. the place is always supper clean & organized & the staff is very helpful with picking the perfect toffee to go.

I liked the outdoor patio and they closes late. Nice place to hang out with friends.

This is an outstanding bakery/ice-cream parlor. All of the ice-creams, cakes and cookies are fantastic. The owners and staff here are friendly and efficient. Relaxed atmosphere. Always a great experience at the Deserts by Toffee to Go. Go out of your way to come here.

We visit pretty frequently and they never disappoint! Their shortbread toffee bar is to die for!!

The bakery was closed when we arrived, but the owner was there watering the plants and doing some maintenance, he was very friendly and invited us in to buy what we wanted, the carrot cake was very moist and absolutely delicious!

Carrot cake one of the best!!! ever.

Stop reading reviews and just go. I went to buy a few things for my family as a treat — ended up spending a silly amount of money to purchase a silly amount of desserts but did not regret it in the slightest. Everything was mouthwateringly good. We had the toffee cheesecake, the New York cheesecake, the toffee cookie, the espresso chocolate chip cookie, and the s’mores bar. The best were definitely the toffee cheesecake, toffee cookie, and the espresso chocolate chip cookie. This is likely my new go-to place for specialty desserts, and especially if I want to surprise someone with a treat. Tons of options for a variety of taste preferences and they even have icecream and coffee! Reasonably priced for high quality desserts. Everything was oversized as well. Don’t settle for mediocre sweets! Go to Toffee To Go!

Great coffee, amazing toffee and desserts and a phenomenal staff. All of the employees are super friendly courteous and very professional. It is one of my favorite coffee/dessert spots. 8/21/23 Still Amazing. Great dessert 🎂🎂😋😋 and Phenomenal espresso drinks. Superb. 100 Stars ⭐✨⭐✨⭐✨⭐✨ it just keeps getting better

Like Janice would say from friends Oh My God!!!! This is my new favorite place to eat sweets like pie,Cakes, ice-cream and pies. I might be going overboard on this review but I believe this place pies are way better than cheese cake factory cheese cake. The place is very clean the ladies up front vert professional and nice. This place you better visit and have your self some pie you won’t regret it. I will end with W-O-W just WOW 🤩

Something for every sweet tooth.

Great coffee, ice cream, cake, cookies, and desserts! Cozy place to enjoy a sweet treat!

Omg it’s really the best deserts ever

This is the best toffee I've ever had! The peanut butter delight bar and cookies and cream pie are a must!! 15/10 recommend

There is nothing I can say that will convey the deliciousness of these tasty decadent treats. Everything here is wonderful. Pictured is the oatmeal cream, peanut butter pie and carrot cake.

I love your place , the counter people are always great , i like how we are greeted when we come through the door and thanked as we go out. I do miss Kim though . She is a beautiful hearted lady , when she said " welcome " you knew she meant it . Tell her Walter from Brooksville was asking for her , the guy with all the jokes.

Enjoyed coffee, American cheesecake, and chocolate cake.

Bussin on god on god no cap fam fax 📠📠📠

We ordered 3 different desserts. The chocolate mousse cake was ok, the key lime didn’t have that tart flavor and the cheesecake was not great.

Not bad but definitely underwhelming and we tried a variety of things.

Ok lets get the elephant out if the way. Their toffee isnt inexpensive by no means. That said, it is also some of the BEST toffee I have ever had. Splurge and give them a try, I promise you will not regret it.

Lovely calm spot that was great to grab a little something sweet.

One of our favorite dessert places.

Amazing and delicious desserts! The staff was very friendly too! Very highly recommended.

Muy lindo lugar y lo que comí muy rico es muy acogedor

some of the best toffee I've ever had... Soft in the middle, so fresh!

Can’t believe I am just now visiting this place, but we Stop by for some dessert of course and just fell in love. This dessert spot is modern and sleek AND the desserts are just delicious. I got the chocolate espresso cookie and toffee cheesecake for later.

Ordered online. Great service. I ordered the toffee assortment and was not disappointed. Heaven in a box!!!

Watched this place on a segment of Fox13 Tampa Bay this morning and thought I'd love to try their toffee, What do know my Partner came home with a beautiful gift box of your toffees that some one gifted her at her job today !!! NEVER TASTED ANYTHING SO GOOD!!!

Loved the service and serving portions here. They have indoor and outdoor seating options and a corner couch where you can just sit and chat while enjoying their delicious baked goods. Such cute and comfy establishment

As another reviewer said the coconut cake was extremely dry almost stale tasting. I did like the icing and the chocolate chip cookie was ok.

MUST COME! I highly recommend to come here for coffee and dessert. This place makes a great place to come bring your kids or even for a simple date night. The prices are great for the items. They have a great selection of cheesecakes, and regular slices of specialty cakes. Super delicious! They also have a variety selection of drinks from coffee to hot chocolate. On the side they have a selection of ice creams. They have outdoor and indoor seating. The place is small and cozy. While you wait for your food they have a table with free water and also free treats for our furry paw friends. They do hand out free samples of their toffee, taste with caution because it’s a for sure you will leave with it! The service is great and the staff is super friendly!! I highly recommend you come try this place out!

beautiful place! delicious deserts and great spot for coffee and relaxing. owner and staff are so helpful and friendly. definitely recommend anytime of the day

Excellent service and amazing desserts