Dimitris Pizzeria - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Went in for dinner, the food was great and so was the service

2 subs for $ 28 and they were ok. Chicken parm was dry and chicken tender sub was just thrown together. Quality is slipping lately

Split a pizza and antipasto, both were delicious!

We tried some wings and garlic knots tonight. We ordered ahead, but decided to sit on their deck to eat after seeing the atmosphere. Service was great. Food was fantastic. The owner even came out and checked to see how our food was. Bonus points for recognizing a Miami Dolphins fan on game day!!

Great menu options! Fantastic pizza. The chicken, bacon, barbque, ranch pizza, recommended by the ower as a customer facorite, got rave reviews! I'm anxious to try the gluten-free pizza.

Excellent service and fantastic food! Owner is a stand up guy and makes sure everything is right with your order.

This is great place to eat , drink and be merry. The atmosphere is welcoming, the people who work her are friendly and respectful. But let me say the owner Sam is a very amazing person will help anyone. The is the only place me and my son like to go other than Kostas. Keep up the amazing work everyone.

So many choices of pizza, if youre looking for just a slice, theres no less than 12 pizzas to choose from. Thin crust which is my favorite. Best pizza around

Great staff, great food! Just wish chicken wings were crispy when asked for xx crispy.

Awesome place for pizza!!! Quick and friendly service!!

If you do a Google search on the owner I bet you won't support this establishment.

this place is amazing i love it there Service is great and their kindness Hi

We heard about Dimitris from a friend so since it was a nice day and being off we decided to take a 2 1/2 hour road trip to try the great Dimitris. We'll we are here to tell you it is FANTASTIC. It was so good that we ordered extra to take home! CHERYL our waitress was also fantastic very friendly. The whole atmosphere is great and clean. How many pizza places do you go to where the owner whose name is "SAM" walks around and talks with every customer that came in. You didn't just feel like a customer, you felt like family! So wiould we drive 2 1/2 hours for Dimitris again? You bet your sweet *** we would. GUY FERRIO YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU ARE MISSING!!!!🥰

Large portions, large variety on menu, many specials every day, decent prices, very nice service and very clean.

Had Beer battered fish dinner with french fries and it was very good. Fish was fresh and meaty. Came with garlic knots and soup as special. Nice dinner to go to in Eldridge.

I was waiting to get pizza from here. I had heard really great things about it. My wife stopped once about 2 months ago for a slice at lunch and raved about all the selections. Today I finally ordered the $25 large specialty chicken wing pizza and a dozen mild wings. The pizza was not good at all I am sorry to say. It had very little flavor and it was very hard. The wings were average for $17 for a dozen traditional. We had carry out. They told us 20-25 minutes and we were there in 20. The pizza only had a ten minute ride home. It will be awhile before I try it again.

Great home cooking and comfort foods in addition to the great pizza!

Amazing pizza selection. Fast and friendly service. Will be back.

Had lots of food all was great.

Average pizza for the area. Got the deluxe pie. Crust was a bit soggy.

Some of the best I have ever had.. highly recommended..

The establishment's interior has an exeptional charm and character to it, and while tables are rather close to one another, the large open space makes every seat as good as the next. The food is also high quality, and if you have an issue with your food, they will try to have it remade for you immediately. Staff are very friendly and act respectfully.

Their philly cheese steak sub alone is worth the drive from Auburn !!

I eat there around 3 times a week. Food is very good. Service is top notch. You must stop in and try all the different options and specials they have there!

Always good food and service at Dimitri's!

Jennifer Adam’s is the best waitress ever omg it was packed she was the only waitress there and the food was delicious

Food was good and hot. Waitress was very nice. Service was fast.

Amazing service and outstanding food!! This place is top notch!!! A++++++!!!!

Best Pizza Around! Sammy is the Man!

Service was very efficient. My antipasto was very large , fresh & delicious! This visit to Dimitri’s was excellent as usual !!

Incredible pizza! Great service. A+ I’m from Arizona and this was exaaaactly what I wanted for Pizza when I got here.

sherry, the waitress is awesome

SCRATCH cooking at its best! Dimitri’s offers a great menu that has something for everyone. Highly recommend it! Great pizza. Riggies are awesome. You just can’t go wrong with anything!

Amazing place, incredible environment. The food is second to none! You must try the Louisiana wings !

Jen was our server today. She is always such a joy to deal with. I had a burger with fries and they both were fantastic. The fries are nice and crispy and the burger was perfectly cooked. Hubby had the dish sandwich and as always its was great. He loves the fish here. Stop in and see Jen and have a great meal

Food is excellent customer service excellent it's not just this pizza place it's every single place in Upstate New York when has it become more expensive to eat pizza for lunch in central New York than New York City I honestly don't care what you put on it charging 5 and 6.00 for a slice of pizza is highway robbery and I'm surprised that the local people still support it get a grip man $17.75 for two slices of pizza and two drinks is absolutely ridiculous never again not just you but every single other pizza place across Central New York you guys aren't putting gold on their it's cheap Frozen toppings it's almost not even pizza anymore when you can't see cheese or sauce and all these weird toppings on there like sriracha stick to the basics you're not in New York City you're in Elbridge I don't care what anybody says my guy

Look at the amount of bacon on this pizza! Yes it tasted as delicious as it looked. This place has the best pizza in Onondaga county. I drive 40 minutes round trip just to get it. They have a vast menu and many other good food items as well. I love their Reuben’s. The owner is always there when I go in, which is probably why the food quality is top notch. Highly recommend.

So we actually really like the food here BUT our order is WRONG every single time!! Today my wife went to pick up the pizzas and wings, got to the car and checked and the the order wasn’t even right AGAIN. Sammy took care of it, which he always does make it right but we usually have to plan on eating 2 hours after we order because it always has to be remade. So my wife got home with the corrected pizzas and we opened the wings and they werent even chargrilled which we paid extra for!! Totally done ordering here. The only thing that would keep us ordering would be if Sammy himself was making it for us.

Everything I have had is delicious. From pizza to fish dinners, meat loaf dinners, eggplant parm . Nothing has been bad. I get delivery a lot but also enjoy dining in.

Good prices, nice portions, great food!

Ordered late at night, ordered a garlic and chicken wing pizza, garlic base with chicken tossed in hotsauce. I’ve ordered it from a lot of places but they killed it amazing pizza here 10 out of 10 will be ordering my weird pizza here in the future! Was here in 30 mins surprised me tbh and the driver was nice and the food warm and crispy! I hope they add it to their menu or try it themselves cuz it slapped! Also noting they were nice on the phone while I tried my best to explain the pizza because it took me a second to find the words to Describe what I wanted.

Excellent dinner, 5 star review on their garlic knots.

Great family cafe and pizzeria!

This place was good! Seeing Cavi making pies instantly knew it was going to be great! Food amazing, service amazing! Glad I stopped. Highly recommend!

Very clean good people and good food

Totally AWESOME place. Owners and wait staff were fantastic even though it was packed . Every one was friendly and helpful.The scallops were sweet as they should be,hubby's 2 pc fried fish was really great and plenty,he ended up taking it home and air fried it the next day, potatoes were real mashed potatoes. They also use real butter. We will be going back real soon. I already love that place.❤️🍀

I can not say enough about this place. From the pizza, to the pasta, to the fish. It has something for everyone. Extremely spoiled to live across the road from it!

Order here almost all the time from work, everything is great everyone is so nice and helpful. Never any issues, food is always great specially the Cajun chicken charbroiled

Good pizza at a fair price Good service and clean tables

Excellent food, friendly and quick service, very attentive to the customers needs, very clean and nicely decorated. Great place to enjoy a quick meal or a more traditional home cooked meal,this is the place!!!

The pizza is among the best NY style in the Syracuse area. 4 slices and two sodas were $20, so the price is very reasonable. Worth visiting!

Great people good homemade food

The pizza was great. Staff was friendly and checked on us the perfect number of times. We will 100% go back. Even had nice placemats with local businesses on it.

Ground chicken parmesan sub wasn't my forte but the sliced pizza was awsome

We love the pizza at Dimitri's and always a large variety to choose from. We also love the people and atmosphere there. They treat you like family. Would not have pizza at any other place for pizza night .

Food was yummy! Service was great! Will be back in a few days!!

This place was a disaster on the night we visited. Not only did we sit 15 minutes before wait staff addressed us, our initial order was lost. I have eaten here 2 times before and the pizza was excellent. I encouraged family to come and try it out, to my own embarrassment. The 2nd order placed for us was incorrect and had to be sent back. The italian wedding soup arrived lukewarm and the ziti also was lukewarm. Staff was unable to keep up with the patrons, not sure if this was due to inexperience or being understaffed. I never received my drink order. In expanding their menu, I think they lost touch with what they did well, pizza. The crust/dough of the pizza is far different than it used to be, sadly thats what made me love it. It was still good but what made it stand out, wasn’t there on this trip. Ultimately, deciding to turn a pizza shop into a sit down dining experience is a liability for this place. They should have stuck to counter ordering and an order number. Having waitstaff doesn't make sense. Its the poor customer service and staff errors that has knocked the wind out of this pizza shops greatness. The Manager comped our dinner (which we felt bad about). Hopefully they can backtrack and re focus in what made them stand out.

Great place for a quick bite. Great pizza selection.

I'm not from this area and this is my 2nd time here. Ironically I previously posted how bad the service was about a year ago. Coming home from a job this evening with 12 ppl, business hours say it's still open, yet when I call to make an order they said they're closed.....half an hour before any listed closing time?! Then they tried to tell me 8:30, so why doesn't it say that not only online, but at your business? Yes, we were the group that stopped, looked at your hours, which we were early before this "closing time" then left. Anyone in the greater Auburn or camillus area, go to Rinaldo's. At least they care about their customers and business. 🤙

Best pizza and fish, very clean and very friendly staff!

We dined in for lunch at Dimitris Pizzeria and the food was stupendous! I had the Special: Spanish Rice and my friend had a Burger. The food and the service were both 5 stars

I've only been here twice but it is worth my 25 minute drive. The food has been excellent and the variety of dishes available is incredible. Additionally, the staff is super friendly, concerned about our experience, and can provide fun interactions. We had at least 3 different people, including the chef, ask us how everything tasted and was going. And our waitress had us laughing with her during both visits. Our group had the poppers appetizer, personalized calzone, Stromboli, and meatball sub - all declared delicious and all very large meals. While it is a basic restaurant interior, the food and personnel make it extra special for enjoying a meal out.

They failed the Liver&Onion Test. thin, dry and dusty. Funny, because it was good in Port Byron. Also cheapest take out containers. Ended up with a plastic bag full of sauce. The waitresses, however were wonderful

Best pizza in the land!!! Crust is awesome. Service is outstanding and friendly, but, big but, Fox News on tv

First time there, lots of selection. Everyone was super friendly, polite , and quick to greet us. Chicken Chipotle pizza was excellent! Buy the BBQ chicken pizza was amazing! It's probably the best I've had in years. Nice eating area inside, super clean, and for me, the weather was just right to hang out on the front deck and relax and eat. Thank you for making my first time at your establishment, such a Memorable one. Keep doing what your doing!

Sat outside on their deck on a beautiful October 19th. Excellent pizza. Had pepperoni and mushrooms. They use Fresh mushrooms. They have several kinds of pizza. By the slice or whole pie. Great spot for a quick lunch. Was riding through on my Harley. Lots of parking. Plenty of seating.

Great food , great price , Sam takes care of his customers 😀

This was a to-go order on a late Sunday afternoon. Pizza: Deluxe. This sounded good on the menu but it is truly overloaded (see the pic). They could use the same ingredients but less of them and still achieve a good tasting “supreme” style pizza that doesn’t feel like each slice is a 1lb floppy mess. Wings: medium. Barely cooked and hardly any sauce. These yellowish wings were unappealing. Also, even though they are big wings that doesn’t make ‘em better. Crispy and saucy is the way to go. I’ll try Dimitri’s again with just a cheese or one topping pizza, but no bone-in wings.

Always great food,, big menu, wonderful staff and the new restuarant is very nice with easy access!

Great pizza slices (pepperoni); Greek salad is fresh and delicious; meatballs are tasty

The food is great and the people are very friendly.

This was supposed to be a gyro. After waiting 40 minutes and getting home this is what I got. Not the first time something like this has happened, it will be the last. I ordered from here almost weekly and the food is normally good, just not always what I ordered. No more, hire competent people before you have to close your doors for good.

Absolutely Delicious Pizza, great service. Place is great, dine in or outside.

Not fine dinning but a fine place to dine

Very good food and always plenty on your plate.

Good food Fair prices Enjoyed seeing the staff and tom from the old portByron diner. Our breakfast was the tasty.

We have gotten pizza there plenty of times for pickup. The food is very good. Tonight I ordered delivery at 6:20. Called at 7:40, Wondering where the pizza was. Was told it would be there in about 10 minutes. It was not. I finally gave up and left for work. My son told me pizza didn't arrive until 8:20!!! I live less than 10 minutes from the restaurant. Food was lukewarm. Will never order delivery from there again.

It is jammed packed and filled with great food. I highly recommend the calzones. We eat here every week. Great atmosphere, plenty of parking.

Very good overall. Clean nice tasting food. Very nice staff. Will return for sure.

Went for breakfast. Nice variety and reasonably priced.

Great place to get some great food owner is a super nice guy always says hi and talks to you remembers your name best pizza place that’s ever been in our area, hands-down recommend this place to anybody.

Visited for breakfast which was served very timely. Coffee was filled several times without asking. Will definitely visit again to try something different.

Luke warm stuffed shells, way over priced side of meatballs, salad is extra $ and no garlic knots that come with the dinner. $60+ tip for a meal that should've cost $40. Combining with the old Port Byron Diner apparently was more than they could handle.

To expensive for the small amount ordered be sure to get the price first will not be ordering again

I stopped for breakfast with my medically complex child and we had the best waitress EVER and the food was delicious! I have never had a waitress show my daughter so much love. It warmed my heart and made my entire day. I wish I remembered her name but we will back to see you soon diner grandma ❤️ thank you so much for making us feel so welcomed!

Absolutely loved it. So many fantastic choices. Lunch was awesome. I ordered the special, goulash, and it was meaty, and sauce was delicious. It also came with soup and garlic bread. Soup was also delicious. Prices were great. Ordered a Stromboli to go. I was shocked and pleased when waitress brought out large pizza box and it took up the length of the box. It also weighed a lot. It was beautifully crispy and golden on outside yum. I can't wait to go back. So much I want to try. I saw others with beautiful salads, fish sandwiches, and French fry. Everything looked delicious.

Have one major rule, everything else is a non-starter if that fails. Do not charge a fee for seniors splitting meals, they leave better tips anyway!

Delish....Closest tasting to Long Island. Took me 7 years, but I'm a customer for good!

Need a separate take out/ pu line.

We went there this afternoon with friends. Will definitely go back. Food was excellent. Service was excellent.

Tasty large subs & fast service.

The food here is amazing and the staff were so friendly. Will defiantly be back. 🙂

My family and I love Dimitri’s! They’re a huge hit within the community so they’re very busy all throughout the day. That being said, we never have a very long wait for our food and it’s top quality every time! I’ve never had a bad meal there which is what keeps us coming back! We love all of the food, the pizza is amazing but I love the HUGE calzones, garlic knots, salads, apps, and eager to try their newest options breakfast-dinner!

Got slices for lunch and they were great. It was very busy but they were keeping up. Two slices and a drink for $8.99 Definitely will be back.

I travel all around central new york for work and try pizza from all over, Dimitri's is still by far the best I've had yet. Always my first choice!

Great people, amazing food, and quality service.

3 cheese slices and a drink for less than $10. Thin NY style, very tasty! 10/10 recommend

Sam went out of his way to make sure my food was perfect!

Absolutely amazing authentic pizza. Hubby stopped in for a quick slice snack on a long drive and oh my word the pizza was fantastic! If your driving by stop by your taste buds will thank you. I had a cheese slice my husband had 2 pepperoni slices, perfect crust.

We stopped by on the way home last night (unknowingly pretty much at closing 😱). Staff insisted on feeding us anyway. A gyro and eggplant parm sub were enjoyed. Apologies for any inconvenience but we’ll be back for sure!