Geo’s Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Excellent food and service, very clean place

Perfection! Great staff ! Great food! Great deals!

Pizza is delicious! Crisp dough and the ingredients are fresh. Grandma pie and Bacon chicken ranch are our favorite.

Everytime we order from them the food is amazing, everyone there is so nice. Tell my friends about this place ALL the time. They really care about their customers and their food. From the pizza and Stromboli to chicken franchise everything is amazing.

I ordered a Large pizza with sausage the other day to go. It was absolutely mouthwatering & ohhh sooooo good!!!! I'll def will be back & will recommend your pizza to my family & friends. 😊 ❤️

Ordered from Geos tonight and the food was absolutely delicious. We got a large plain pizza, Cheesburger with fries and chicken tenders and fries and everything was cool perfectly. The cheeseburger was the best though will deff be ordering from again. Thank you guys so much!!

I ordered a pizza delivery tonight. I’ve moved here to Farmingdale and have passed Gio pizza for years !! However Tonight I wanted y To order a pizza and have it delivered . It came promptly very hot and also delicious. I’ll be using Gio Pizza again. It’s the best pizza I’ve had since I moved to New Jersey. I give them a 10 stars

Tried the personal pizza and it was great. Thank you for the recommendation!

The best pizza and garlic knots I've had! Will definitely be back ❤️

Good pizza especially the grandma's pie. Pleasant greeting upon arrival. Nice atmosphere but very small inside .

BEST KEPT SECRET !!! GEO'S PIZZA IS A LEGENDARY HOLE IN THE WALL, FLAVOR WAS AMAZING; 10 STARS !!!!!

My boyfriend and I found this cozy little place yesterday so we took a drive. The people are so friendly, the service was wonderful and the food was AMAZING!!!! I've ordered my white pizza dozens of times from different pizzerias but this place is high high up at the top of my list. #1 in my book, not to mention when you choose to sit outside, you're surrounded by beautiful plants, flowers and colorful birds. I urge you to go and try the food here, I promise, you will not be disappointed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Our family's favorite spot for pepperoni pizza and wings, so of course we try to stop by a few times a month. It's always so good and always get great service here. We live on NWS Earle military base, and they deliver to the front gate, which is also a plus!

The food is excellent. The Italian hotdogs are out of this world.

Very good thin crust pizza and chicken wings. I highly recommend it. Gracias por el servicio GEO 😃

Love the food & the people. They make me feel like family & that's awesome.

I discovered Geo's during Covid when they operated out of Our House and followed them when they moved to their new location. I have ordered MANY items off their menu and Geo always makes me things that I request that are not on the menu. They have catered graduations and Christmas parties for my family as well. My family favorites are vodka chicken pizza, BBQ chicken pizza, Chicken parm, meatballs, penne vodka, apple chicken salad and garlic knots. They know us by name and are the nicest people. You will not be disappointed.

It looked really nice from outside in the parking lot while I was broke down on my motorcycle.

Very friendly staff, a small and quiet restaurant with a lovely outside garden with tables for dinning. They were fast and prompt with my large plain pie. The cost was reasonable for a large and 2 cans of soda was less then $20.00. This was my first time ordering and wanted to start basic. The pizza was delicious! The crust was crisp yet not hard, the sauce on the pie left fragrances of Basil and Garlic, telling me this was a homemade sauce. The cheese left no puddle of grease, a sign that they are using quality cheese. I am looking forward to going back and trying something from the main menu. If in the area I would definitely recommend stopping by for a slice.

If you are looking for a place to have a good meal or pizza then this might be the place for you.... but if you are looking for a place to eat that will excite your taste buds and knock you out of your chair then this is definitely the place to eat. Great food and excellent customer service paired with reasonable prices make this a top choice in places to get your next meal. I have had the cheeseburgers and the taco salad and both a personal pan pizza and pizza slices.... every item has been carefully prepared and as if that were not enough you can even take it outside and sit in their outside dining area. Going here is a win-win situation and I have never been disappointed.Now you’ll have to excuse me as I need to prepare to go to Geo’s for dinner. GEO’S THE ONLY PLACE TO EAT IN FARMINGDALE!!!!!!!!!!!!

Very close to my house. Let them know what you want and then enjoy. Don't forget the amazing cheesecake for later. Thanks folks just what the doctor ordered.

The owner, Geo, makes all of his items with special care. Nice convo while preparing my item and I can sense lots of passion and integrity as he dishes out the best possible food. 👍🏽👍🏽

Just had the lunch special.. 2 Slices and a Dr Pepper... awesome place.. you got to stop in if your near the area!

Just discovered this little gem a few weeks ago and I can review what I had. Pizza Margherita - Perfect! (Cheese, crust, sauce - 5 starts +) Plain Cheese - Five Stars! (love the sauce, cheese and perfect crust) Meatball sub - Delicious!

Everything is great and cooked with great care for detail!!!

My brother Sean told us about this place, so we decided to try it....eating the pizza right now! Very good 👍. Nice and thin crust, great flavor.

Geo is the best, great food , great price. Extremely friendly, they treat u like family even down to the delivery guy. I’ll eat nowhere else💯💯. Everyone go!!!!

Excellent service and pizzas, as always! Looking forward to trying more!

Had meatball pizza it was delicious! And the customer service was Amazing! Thank you!

Best pizza in Farmingdale area! Carry on Geo!!

Your photos are of another restaurant, inside and out. You need to have them removed.

Ww stopped here on the way home from the beach and the pizza and garlic knots were delicious!! We will definitely have to stop here again when we're in the area. Everything was so fresh!! The Chicken Vodka pizza was amazing!!

Excellent vegan pies and garlic knots, request upon order. Fantastic- 6 ingredient dough, flavor, overall food and service- great people. Look forward to future vegan options! Much love! **Part 2- pic attachment** Fantastic!! 👏👏

They started up during COVID out of Our House and were the absolute best! They moved and now we are technically listed as out of their delivery area. We were so disappointed. When I called to see if they would still deliver to us, I was told “absolutely!” They know us by name, they gave us a Christmas card, and we’re always treated like family. They know our name, and our dog’s name. They go above and beyond for their customers, and treat us all like family. They have the best pizza we have had locally and we enjoy everything we have ever had from them. I can’t say enough great things about Geo’s!

Geo’s is a hidden gem and has not only the best pizza in the area, but the best Italian food period. The owner is a great guy and really cares about his food and each and everyone of his customers. Incredible food and wonderful friendly service—what more can you ask for? My new go to and it will be yours too!

My absolute favorite food is eggplant and I try it whenever I go to a new restaurant. Our office at Allison Pest Control ordered lunch from Geo yesterday and I got the eggplant and it was excellent! The taste was a nice grilled flavor with a little crunch around the edges. We all ordered some type of pasta, some with shrimp and fettucine alfredo. We are very happy to have a great go- to place in our area. We will definitely order from here again.

The food speaks for itself man you just have to go try it.

The food is consistently good, never sloppy and always made with care. You can tell that they take pride in providing their customers with good food. They are also very friendly and pleasant. I really cant say enough good things about them.

Our new go-to pizza spot, thin crust pizza, very consistent, and a friendly staff! Highly recommend

The food at Oh Geo's is OUTRAGEOUSLY DELICIOUS!!! I was born and raised in NY.. the real NY... And trying to find a pizzaria nearby that has food that tastes the same (or in your guys case, better), has been a test for us living in Howell for 6 years... Everything we ordered was phenomenal! The portions were on point, the pizza was delicious with the right amount of crisp... I mean you guys blew us away. I know it doesn't seem like much, but you truly make delicious home cooked food. And the beautiful young lady that delivered that was talking to my son about his birthday was so so so sweet to our boy. It made him feel special that she cared enough to ask how old he was turning and to talk to him about the 2nd most exciting day for him! I am SO GLAD I went back to my post to show my sign of sadness that I couldn't order online, only to be told to call and order. Thank you for filling our tummies with lots of yummies❤️❤️❤️❤️😋😋😋😋😋😋 10 out of 10 will order again...and again... And again...