I LOVE NY PIZZA in Orlando - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I always get the 2 slice special. Been coming here for years. Its always great and the kids love it too. They are always friendly and service is great.

On top of really bad pizza that doesn't come anywhere near NY style .... the service was bad too. Asking for a simple credit was rocket science for the cashier smh.

WOW! This place is a hidden gem for real New York food. I got a calzone and stromboli and it was one of the best I have had. This service was quick and the ladies in the front are nice. This is the real deal…

Pizza, ziti and raviolis all cold.

Best pizza and chicken wings in town, is a must if you like real NY style pizza!!! Bread and sauce is made from scratch, Roxy has always been amazing at customer service and def we love this spot, stopped ordering at Papa John's nothing compare to this spot!!!!

This New York pizza place is amazing!!!! The pizza is so tasty!! Costumer service is very welcoming and friendly.

I have to take back everything I said about american/NY pizza. Wow, I am impressed. You may try to offer classic Italian toppings though...

Ny PIZZA ??? Where ? How ??? Coming from someone who was born and raised in the Bronx I’m going to be very judgmental when it comes to a pizza shop that claims they are like NY slice. Flavor is not good . I ordered a pepperoni pizza and look at how cheap they are with their toppings!! Do not order toppings . I might as well got a cheese slice . Then you say something and the lady in the front said. “ oh that’s how we do it “ okay no problem . If you want to waste your money .. then this is the pizza store for you. If I can do 0 stars I would

My wife was born in Brooklyn. We go to NYC frequently enough to be able to discern good NY pizza from great NY pizza. This place, this perfect little hidden gem of a place, has GREAT NY PIZZA. It is exactly what I'm looking for, and the smell, heck, the FEEL of the joint takes me right back to the best spots throughout NYC that I've visited. You ever walk into a restaurant and just know it's going to be awesome? That was the vibe here. Excellent specials, we did two slices and a drink for under $9. Both came out hot, melty cheese, loaded with toppings, and the most sincerely perfectly cooked crust I've had in years. Listen, you want a great pie and you're on your way in or out of Orlando? Pop in here. You will have zero regrets.

The best pizza parlor in FL. Everything they make is awesome. Had there cheese steak pizza today. As always it was great. On top of that the prices can't be beat.

Absolutely love this place, perfect size for a pizza parlor. The pizza is the best I've had personally. I recommend it to everybody I know who likes pizza. The slices are a good size and not overly greasy. If your looking for a new pizza place I Definitely recommend checking this place out you won't be dissapointed.

I come to this place every time I'm in Orlando for work or pleasure, love the pizza, I get a large for myself.. The people are also really nice.

Everything was delicious & fresh I love this pizza spot!

Employees are very friendly. I Love they are a pet friendly restaurant because we can take our Sophie (Yorkshire Terrier) with us.

THE ORGANIC SAUCE AND THE THIN DOUGH IS EXCELLENT. CONGRATULATIONS TO THE PIZZER. THANK YOU !!! I WOULD RECOMMEND IT A THOUSAND TIMES!!!

Its an amazing experience at I Love NY Pizza, the Pizza is the best around with unbeatable prices. The pizza is always amazing and hits the spot every time. Skip the other pizza joints this is the only one you need.

Let me say for the record, the most absolutely spectacular calzone I’ve ever had. It’s so good, I’m home and went to my local joint to get one and got reminded of how I miss this restaurant. Don’t miss out on the chance at one of the most fluffiest but yet crispiest bread, most flavorful and delicious combo of cheese, meats, spices and herbs you’ll ever put into your mouth.

I don’t think anyone understands what ny style pie is or buffalo wings?!?!?! They hit the mark! They aren’t here to coddle you like it’s a date night. This is real

Man O man, were on vacation from Chicago and my son had a craving for pizza, im thinkn we werent gonna find any good pizza joints. Well im glad my son had that crave because the food and service were amazing. Im pretty picky. The pizza was 100/10 The chicken philly was🤌🏾 chefs kiss. I’ll recommend this place to anyone coming to Orlando. Thank you to all the cooks and servers we appreciate you and we will be back❣️

Pizza was delicious, stopped in on a business trip, pleasantly surprised

I love this place this remind me of New York and they have the best pizza ever

Home away from home I love my visit. From the Bronx NY here for the weekend visiting nephews and nieces and sis in law not one unsatisfied customer we all leaving full. The pizza pie was excellent and buffalo wings were just how I like them. All around the table we will be back and inform those on our Facebook. Wishing many more years of this great Pizza

The NY style pizza is amazing!! It has great service and they are really nice! 🥰

It was amazing! The pizza and the Buffalo wings were the best part and the owner was very nice to us this place was the best.

I love everything about this place, there pizza reminds me of New York.

Went there for lunch and ordered a sausage sub only thing is that the sausage used was more of a crumbled pieces that did not even equal a half of sausage link. We ordered pizza half cheese wanted the other half with sausage peppers onion olives tomatoes and spinach and got something totally different when we asked the woman she said you asked for deluxe. She told us the deluxe had all of that and pepperoni then told us that’s what we ordered when she is the one that said deluxe had all of that so we said ok. No attempt to fix the problem. I refused the sausage sub and asked for a refund let’s see if that even happens. Have been here many times and never encountered a problem. Prices went up and quality went down hill. They have just lost a faithful customer won’t be visiting this establishment any longer.

This was an unassuming place. Something you should not pass up. Excellent pizza. Great service. My picky cheese pizza kid ate every last bite.

Fresh. Authentic, super affordable and an overall cool little spot Love the Memorabilia !

This is true NYC flavor. Prices are affordable and plates are filled. My favorite is their Lasagna Pizza. They also make killer salads and tasty wings.

This is a late review. I visited I Love NY Pizza on 10-18-2020 and got a half steak and cheese, half veggie pizza....delicious!

Loved it would definitely eat there again!

Great pizza and service. My family and I are visiting from the Atlanta area and this was our only pizza stop on our trip. Food was very good, service was excellent, and we will definitely be back on our next trip to the Orlando area

One of the very best pizza places I've ever been to.🍕🤤 Fresh, quality ingredients for sure. You can tell by the good cheese they use. 😋 The pizza sauce is amazing and doesn't give you heart burn. The topping sprinkles on the table makes it a total plus. I ❤️ NY Pizza!

Best pizza around an wings as well..

We decided to take my daughter for pizza and we’ve been here 8 times already and this spot is a good spot for pizza but yesterday was the last time I will be attending this location I asked the old man the owner for two to go boxes because we all don’t share the same household and my daughter wanted to take her slice of pizza home and the other person who paid for the pizza wanted to take their pizza home. So I asked him and he rudely said no because it’s only one pizza. He’s so stingy and trying to save an extra buck when the to go box doesn’t even cost that much considering you bulk your to go boxes right. I didn’t even bother explaining to him since he was so rude about it. Enjoy your to go boxes. And your awful mindset and rudeness.

Staff is very nice and hospitable. Food is great. My daughter fell in love with the pizza now we come here every other day.

Food was amazing, crust crunchy and cheese stringy, doesn’t get much better than that in my opinion. i’d come back and back again!

Pizza & wings! You can’t go wrong. This was my second time dining here and it was still as good as the first. Thin crunchy crust, generous toppings and the wings had a good fry and sauce ratio to have a good crunch as well.

Good pizza and priced very reasonable.

I really love the pizza from here, it tastes very authentic to the pizza that I've had from New York. The owner here is so nice and welcoming. They also have great deal from time to time and their delivery service is really good.

We’ve been coming here a little over a year. It doesn’t matter how busy Saturday nights are, our Pizza Deserves at least 10 stars! I’m sorry but this Treasure of a taste of authentic NY Pizza is EXCELLENT. EVERY TIME we come in. It’s Definitely my Happy Place. All The Staff is very Warm and Welcoming, Ask for the Pizza Whisperer to make it!

Great service and Delicious Pizza. Definitely a must try if your in town

Enjoyed dinner with my family today. We loved the food and atmosphere!

I ordered the lasagna pizza and WOW so good!!! The environment and service were great as well. Definitely coming back❤️

Great food, good prices, fresh ingredients. Don't order through door dash or Uber eats. It will be way more expensive. Give them a call, they always have good deals. Two slices and a drink for about $10 with tax. Wings are crispy, and pizza is always fresh!

Why have a phone if you aren’t going to answer.

Owner is there always. Nice guy, and awesome pizza and food. 2 slices and a drink for under 10 bucks and the Hawaiian pizza is crazy good.

Great pizza. Owner is a extremely nice. Came to our table and chatted with us. Great guy. Great staff great food. A little mom and pop chill spot

Roxy was very pleasant she’s awesome Love the food too

Has to my favorite pizza place out there in Central Florida. I go there with my friends and love it every single time, employees are nice and the food is amazing. I always take home myself a full pie for my family because of how good it is.

Roxy provided excellent service, awesome atmosphere and great food!

Pizza and garlic knots are delicious. Probably the best pizza I've had in central Florida.

Great food, and good lunch deal.

Pizza was incorrect. Called the restaurant and the person who answered could care less. Didn't apologize or try to resolve the problem. Just said you'll probably get a credit. I got a $4 store credit which I won't use cause they have lost my business. All you had to do was apologize. Bye

Best pizza in Orlando! Authentic NY style

Owner is friendly. His workers need to smile a little more. Pizza was thick and flavorful. Pizza needs a little more cheese but with extra ingredients was good. Prices went up but so does everything. Pizza alone not oily enough but helped with pepperoni. It is worth 2 topping slices with soda for $8.25 used to be $7 then $7.25 then $7.75 but now $8.25 plus tax. I won't pay more than $5 per slice with tax and soda and sadly the price is quickly reaching my upper limits. Great location and parking. I recommend to stop in. Not bad for Florida Pizza.

Great place with nice people! I had the lunch special, which is a good deal. I’ll definitely come back.

Luisa, la dueña de la pizzería, su clase y excelente servicio vale las 5 estrellas

HANDS DOWN THE BEST NEW YORK PIZZA IN FLORIDA! They make everything on the menu to perfection. I go there everyday after work and get 2 slices and a drink for less than $10. Big slices, extra crispy and they have different flavors for all slices. I will be back everyday for more!

This is Definitely some of the Best Pizza in Orlando. If Willy is working ask Him to Make your Pie! You will not be Disappointed. Thoroughly Enjoyed our Dining Experience. We Enjoyed Every bite of our Deluxe Pizza and even the next day leftovers was Delicious. Can’t wait to return. I can taste it!….. I can’t remember our servers name but I’m gonna call her Mom. She was a Breath of fresh Air and so nice we felt like family. I probably could eat Willies pizza 7 days a week. Thank you Willie and Thank you Mom. See you soon!

Love the pizza here. They have Jamaican Patties too.

2023 UPDATE. Still amazing cheese pizza. Thin, perfectly balanced sauce with right amount of quality cheese. Garlic knots. Not sure about other things. Did go go up in price for XL $$$ Atmosphere can get loud, but reminds me of old school pizza place up north. With jars of seasoning and wooden booth. Help yourself to the soda. ORIGINAL: Tasty pizza that reminds me of a slice I can buy in NY. Thin, not too much sauce and cheese. Perfect texture and taste. We also love the spinach calzone and stromboli. We have had both. Garlic knots are delicious with that red sauce. I prefer mine with more garlic, but that's just me. I walk in , order my pizza and walk around the plaza until it's ready. Everyone is nice and service was good. Definitely not the same experience as some below have described. This place works for me and my family because it's so reminiscent of what we are used to from NY. UPDATE: Still the best pizza for us outside of Queens, NY. Cheese is tasty, still on the thin side but no oil or grease. Heats up in the oven perfectly. Really need to try other flavors. But kids only like cheese. :( Update 6 2020. We love NY pizza! We tried a few diff places and still come back here. We actually started using the delivery (6 times) and have had no issues at all, they are totally on point.

Best pizza you can get in Orlando for a great price

Great food. Homemade ravioli was amazing.

Lugar super interesante, las fotografías y la decoración con temas deportivos, las pizzas riquísimas, la atención de sus dueños es súper amable. La recomiendo cien por ciento. Super interesting place, the photographs and the decoration with sports themes, the delicious pizzas, the attention of its owners is super friendly. I recommend it one hundred percent.

Good pizza and wings . Iam customer for more of 10 years here but for the last month the customer service is to bad. The daughter for the owner is so rude and bad actitud . She have take better care os customer. Robert hope yo take care of this. Or maybe customer have to go other place.

Went today with my husband and we had the large pizza with pepperoni special and 10 wings . The wings were garlic flavor and crispy and we really enjoyed them . Same with the pizza - the lady at counter today was adorable and showed amazing customer service . Keep her there if you can and treat her well . She spoke volumes for the place today . She brought us some garlic knots while we waited which were perfection today .

Im from NJ...I went here with a friend who lives here...Definitely close to Jersey pizza...I would recommend it...

Definitely a slice worth bragging about.. closest slice I found compared to anything like no other. If the cheese pizza was delicious imagine what other wonders this place creates. Definitely a slice worth buying. Give it a go

Such a nice place. The food there is great and I love all the workers, they’re all super nice! Definitely my favorite pizza place. I would recommend to anybody who is looking for real good NYC pizza

This was my first visit and I was so pleased with the food, service , and atmosphere. I ordered a philly cheesesteak sub and an antipasta salad . Both were incredible ! The philly cheesesteak was perfect and the salad was super fresh and the portions were large . I look forward to returning and trying out the pizza and other items from the menu . Definitely a Gem in Orlando and worth a try . I will will back :)

The pizza and calzone are absolutely amazing. The delivery service so efficient too. Our family loved

I am late with my second review, but I have to let everyone know that this place is awesome!! The manager is not only bilingual but better to say, Trilingual! She also knows ASL!! I witnessed a customer who had a situation with her order and Lord and behold the manager was incredibly attentive to her and was able to communicate with her through ASL!! What an incredible thing to witness !! Again, it gets better every time I come in here!! I ordered the homemade meatballs sub, which was awesome!!!

Food is absolutely amazing here, rio ranch pizza is fire !! As well as the plain cheese. I’ve branched off and tried the pasta calzone Stromboli and garlic knots as well and I can say I have literally never been disappointed. Roxy’s customer service is definitely what keeps me coming back. She is definitely the face of this place & she locked me in as a frequent customer after the first day. I’ve never wanted to keep talking to someone while they’re working before!! She really cares about her customers 🤍🤍

Great pizza and price. People are also super nice.

Very tasty NY style pizza with lots of toppings. The garlic knots are very good. The 2 slice w drink lunch special is a great deal. Definitely recommend.

While in the area, we decided on a pizza place for dinner. Upon arrival, we found no one here -- hmmm.... We were shocked by the overpriced menu so we all (our family and friends) to split food to help with the cost. We did order the garlic knots and they were very good!! We all loved them. We ordered our pizzas and most of us split ours. The pizza was good -- I mean, it wasn't NY, per se, but it was good. They have priced this pizza as if it would be the best pizza your lips have ever touched but no, it wasn't. The prices were at $25+ for a pizza -- just way too much!! A big downfall -- the people working here know limited English so it was difficult to get answers to our questions. Very disappointing! Not Italian, but Mexican and it's very frustrating to be unable to communicate in an American/Italian Restaurant with a language barrier. Will not be back here!

We decided to take another slice from this place. One thing we agreed on was the great taste of the pizza. A perfect bonus to the food was the great and friendly service we recieved. Food took us back to Brooklyn style pizza feel. I did have to update my former post which brings great testimony that all things can change.

This is the real deal great pizza 🍕 and service you have to try it. Thanks for a slice of NY in Orlando 😎

Good pizza , ordered it to go. Waited about 20mins for my order. They seem to be popular as there was a lot of traffic coming in and out.

Got sick after ordering the chicken alfredo last night. Was only thing I ate all day so had to be it.

Went to the restaurant for the 1st time. 5 people were ahead of me all take out. Everyone was seated at the table waiting on their food. They brought their food out to the table and gave it to them and they left. They even brought a single slice of pizza out to the young lady gave it to her and she left. I was the 6 person waiting and seated at the table waiting on my food .When my pizza was ready instead of the girl bringing my pizza out to my table she motion for me to come to the counter and get it. I just felt some type away . Instantly I felt like wow!!!!I'm a black person. And I was the only black person in there at the time waiting for my food. I'm kinda taken aback!😤And I won't be back.!!!👎🏾Pizza was ok.

Very good pizza will definitely hear again

This place slaps. Like, yeah, I guess I can get some mcnuggets for $7 or I could have two slices of awesome pizza and a drink. Can't beat it. Great variety too!

Very rude lady at the front. Refused to remake my order knowing they messed it up. Please make sure you check your order before stepping out.

This place is a complete sham!!! They upcharge for everything and are sneaky about it! They charged me $2 because they didn’t have the right box size. How is that my problem

This place has the best pizza we have tried so far! It’s just like our pizzaria back in the Bronx

Used to come here everyday but their service has really gone down hill. Place is too messy and it seems like it needs more people to be able to run efficiently. The last straw was making a phone order, waiting the 30 mins that they said I show up and apparently the young girl in the front can’t find the order?! They then asked me if I wanted to buy the 3Xl pizza that they had on the display window. I called cause I wanted a fresh piece made. Not no reheated cheese pizza. Place is trash now days. From going everyday to never hitting that spot up again.

Delicious pizza, subs, and pasta. We will definitely order again.

Everything is great about that restaurant 😊

Oh how I'm Not disappointed....sorry that I stayed away sooo long!!💜

The food here is fantastic. I gotta calzone and some fried ravioli's and forget about it the best I've had in a long long time. The service was fantastic as well very nice And made me feel important. If anybody gives this place a bad review, they were just having a bad day . It was delicious, and the people were very nice. I had to call them to tell them personally how much I enjoyed it.

Second visit and both ones are wasting time… too much time waiting for food.

Food was delicious and great customer service

Great Experience with Awesome Service and Outstanding Staff... Food was Excellent!!

I myself am from NYC. I have fond memories of going to Yankees Pizza in the Bronx when we visited my grandparents every weekend. This place is the closest I've come in Florida to reliving that experience. And it's become a weekend tradition for my daughter and I. The pizza is the best I've had and closest to what I remember in The Bronx. The staff is all wonderful, friendly, courteous and treat you like family. Wonderful family atmosphere.

Service is top notch. If you want a place that feels like your local neighborhood I recommend this establishment. Luisa’s service was beyond standard. I’m definitely coming back!!! I’m all about the service

Best Pizza around, period! Awesome owner and the New York style crust, Forget about it...... Delicious. Try the Rio Ranch pizza , but leave some for me.

Great NY style Pizza. Vegetarians have options. Primavera is great. Friendly servics. 2 slices and a drink is 7 bucks. Lots of baseball pics on wall.

I places my order and went and sat down and people who came in after me were served before me and I went and told the owner and he just didn't care and had a nasty attitude about it I guess he just don't like serving black people because all the people that where in that restaurant who got there food before me were white he gave me my money back and said with a nasty attitude I don't need you or your money