Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Horizon West - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The best workers here tai is amazing at what she does the ice cream was amazing and her service was great!

No shade, when is hot your ice cream will melt. Try the Bahama freeze. Is so good.

The mango ice cream was very refreshing, recommend trying it with the chocolate serve

Wow I’ve never had a Gelati my gosh it is amazing! So good! We got it delivered and it wasn’t melted and tasted perfect! As a first timer they recommended the strawberry ice with vanilla ice cream and it was perfect!

Very good ice cream. Enjoyed sitting outside and eating it.

I was waiting outside for 10 minutes at 9:50 and no one was there I was knocking at the door and know one answered so I saw a worker outside and I asked her if she can serve us and she said yes cause we have been there for so long she goes inside and there’s a different lady saying “NO WE’RE CLOSED “ and me and my family told her how long we were there for she said “I have been looking at the cameras and I didn’t see anyone” if she was inside she would have heard us. I wish I could leave a good review

Blonde girl was very rude, I am a regular customer at this location, and she was making a lot of noise, giving off rude attitude to me

a great little spot !! the service is always great, and there is usually seating available around the corner! i recommend the s’mores flavorite

Elizabeth and mom here!! We love Jeremiah’s we come whenever we can! :D

Great staff and good food. Be sure to sample a couple things.

Best Italian ice and I always get a nice customer service, the employees are very kind. I definitely love this place.

My go to dessert place whenever I am on the road in the area. Great flavors and always refreshing on a hot day in Florida.

It's was amazing they are nice people give u 3 samples there wonderful I can't stop going there cause its amazing

Nice treat for this summer heat

Best ice-cream ever!! hands down... Also, great friendly staff!!!

Las princesas que allí trabajan son muy cariñosas en su atención y sobre todo mucha paciencia con el cliente...me encanta visitar donde la atención es maravillosa... todas muy lindas.

Amazing as always! We have been to several locations, and it's always great to see how friendly the staff is. They seem to always enjoy the interactions, and the Italian Ice is always consistently delicious. Prices are great, too! Two people can get plenty to dessert on for under 10 bucks

Update 3/9/2023 Jeremiah’s is great, as usual! My daughter had a coupon for a free small item that she received from school so of course we had to go! It’s always a pleasant experience as their customer service is top notch. I was curious to try the sugar free tangerine flavor and was gladly given a sample. It wasn’t for me so I ordered my usual strawberry and my daughter got mango gelati with chocolate and vanilla swirl. It was a great way to get the weekend started! Of course, we attended a fundraising event at the Orlando Science center and they were there too! Love that they give back to the community and enjoying Jeremiah’s twice in less than a week?! Yes, Please! —————————————————————————— Jeremiah’s is the perfect treat on a hot Florida day! The small is the perfect size when you want something sweet but don’t want to spoil your dinner! There is ample seating because it doesn’t take long to finish. Our family enjoyed the ice and the gelati today (strawberry & vanilla, orange & vanilla, and blueberry Italian ice). So Good!

Delicious, reasonably priced, and excellent service. Options for every palate.

DELICIOUS Ice cream, reasonably priced, and great service. Addy was extremely helpful and kind.

Tried a new combo tonight; mango, cake batter, and swirl. Sooooo delish!

Me encanta los helados, solo que el lugar es pequeño y por lo general no puedes comer allí, hay pocas mesas

Love the fact you can sample before you commit! Great flavors! Great friendly staff. Thank you!

Cotton candy is my favorite! Good price Clean place

Most of the time, this location is a hit. Yesterday...not so much. There's a male employee who just literally throws your order into the bag and out the window with a "you're bothering me" vibe. Other than that jerk, it's great!

Totally satisfied my pregnant belly...

This place is awesome. I grew up in eastern PA, and we had "water ice" everywhere. This is the closest I've found to "real" Italian ice. Big fan here.

💥Always good....@hometownselects on any social media

Best Italian Ice in Winter Garden !

Service is always friendly and fast, every flavor is delicious

I went there once now I go every day 😊 My 4 year old loves it there! They're very friendly and professional.

Wonderful flavors and reasonably priced

So good! We recommend the Salted Caramel Italian Ice!

Best Italian ice and soft serve. Great selection of flavors. Busy, but the line moved quickly and employees was pleasant.

The size small always seems to shock people, but it's actually just the right amount. My experience with Jeremiah's Italian Ice has been great every visit. I will come here again.

We love, love Jeremiah’s gelatis, which is a combination of Italian ice and soft serve ice cream! There is a huge variety of Italian ice flavors you can choose from and they have vanilla and chocolate soft serve. It has a nice outdoor seating area and we had great service. If you’re looking for something other than regular ice cream this is a nice change of pace. There is one opening up in the Atlanta area tomorrow (September 7th).

They have different flavors, I loved the cookies and cream with horchata

Kids love it. App has great specials and deals

I love their Gelatis! Root Beer and Vanilla for that delicious frozen root beer float! Try it out!