Jersey Mike's Subs in Lake Magdalene - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Kudos to the owner and management for hiring a terrific staff. I order from this location a couple of times a month when in Tampa and the staff is always super friendly and quick. Please let your employees know that they are doing a fabulous job representing you and the company.

Best sandwich shop in tampa florida. They are very fast and Have a great attitude while preparing your sandwich.

I ordered a regular sandwich and I’m pretty sure I got a much smaller sandwich than a regular and when received my sandwich there was so much corn mill on it that it was in chunks. The customer service is lacking as well, they should spend more time engaging with customers rather than themselves.

Excellent the perfect sandwich every time❤️

5-Star rating great quality and amazing experience every time , visiting Jersey Mikes :)

Great service , and atmosphere. A place where the subs will always be great

Great service , and atmosphere. A place where the subs will always be great

Amazing, 5 stars is beyond comprehension with Jersey Mikes subs, i highly recommend eating here. They know what i already want when i walk in.

I had a amazing experience at this location in particular, the atmosphere was estaic, felt like I was in a rave the energy was amazing

Amazing staff and great food fast

The staff have been amazing and the food is yummy!

great customer food and good sandwiches

The customer service was amazing, food was good as-well, felt clean ,and the employees are very attentive, over all great experience would definitely recommend.

Just went there and the staff are super friendly, and the food was soo good

Very clean, best subs ever, very friendly staff and they are very quick and efficient when it can to making your food

Amazing I love jersey mikes good food good service good atmosphere

Food good service good and very calm atmosphere

The food here is excellent, I have never had a better sandwich in my life. From the atmosphere, the AC, and the drinks, what's not to love about this place. I would rate it a 6 out of 5 if I could but there's no option to do so

I recently visited Jersey Mike's and was thoroughly impressed with my experience. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by friendly staff who made me feel welcome. The menu offered a wide variety of sub sandwiches, and I appreciated the fresh ingredients on display. I decided to try the "Original Italian" and was not disappointed. The meats and cheeses were sliced fresh to order, and the bread was perfectly soft yet sturdy enough to hold all the delicious fillings. The combination of flavors was outstanding, and the veggies were crisp and flavorful. What stood out the most was the attention to detail and the quality of the ingredients. It's clear that Jersey Mike's takes pride in providing a superior product compared to other sub shops. The service was quick, and the store was clean and well-maintained. Overall, my experience at Jersey Mike's was fantastic.

Atmosphere was very welcoming and the food was very good.

I love this location, it’s wonderful!

Quick service and excellent food all the time!!

Always friendly staff, clean store, fresh ingredients! Love coming by for lunch

The best cheesesteaks, and always great friendly service!!!

Best cheesesteak in town. Plus staff was very friendly!!

Jersey Mike's is my absolute favorite sub shop. The Big Kahuna is my favorite. Their food is so fresh and delicious!

We ran into some online issues for our order, however Manny and Marcus were amazing help and always make the best subs every time!

Online ordering was down and the guys working were super nice to get our order to us quickly. Highly recommended this place! Manny and Marcus have great customer service!

I freaking love jersey mikes, out of all the sub shops jersey mikes reigns supreme. Everyone here was super nice and my sub was delish

We love Jersey Mike’s!! Great food and nice people!! It is close to home too!

Friendly staff. Clean restaurant. Typical Jersey Mike's. I wish there was a place out front to lock up my bicycle when I visit, but I'm probably the only one.

Amazing place with some good sandwiches!

Always the best tasting sandwich and service at Jeresy Mike's!

Friendly staff and greet service

They make a great Sub fast for a good price. Always clean and great service! I eat there on average twice a week and I've never had a complaint. I give them a A+ rating.

I just stopped in and had the best turkey sandwich. Everything was so fresh! The restaurant was really clean and the staff was very friendly!

Brand new place with good food and great employees! Thanks for the meal

Love this place. Food is made fresh and always nice and clean. Staff is amazing and greets you right when you come in.

So delicious! They were super friendly and helpful, asked if we wanted to cut our sandwich in half since we said we were sharing. I've never tried the spicy pickle chips from Mrs Vickies and they were amazing. The chipotle cheddar sandwich was super good as well. We added jalapenos for that extra spice and we were sweating 😂. So good!

The employees are always friendly, the tables and restaurant are clean, bathroom is clean, and the playlist is nice. No complaints!

The "Big Kahuna" is where it's at! The rewards system here is one of the best they have and all you need is a phone number!

Clean store and friendly staff. Great experiences every time.

The best jersey mikes in town!!! Thank you guys? !!

Great service, sandwich was well prepared, and clean overall.

I recently discovered this place like a month ago. It's the best sub shop I have ever been too. The staff are so nice. The service is impeccable. I've seen them get slammed at this jersey mikes and always come out on top. The food is always cooked the best way, the Jersey way. I love coming here. Shoutout to everyone that works here! 11/10 stars.

I went to place my order, and as I was placing my order for one of the two sandwiches, an entitled woman attempted to order a sandwich while I was awaiting to order my second sandwich The troubling thing is that the person taking my order started processing the entitled womens order. While standing in front of the sandwich tech, I had to inform her I was not done, to which she took my second order. Then, in the most sarcastic voice said "Will there be anything else?" Then, just to make my jersy Mike's order complete, they got my sandwhich order toppings wrong.

Jessica & James were so friendly and made delicious sandwiches. Very clean inside as well. Definitely come to this location for a #7 & a #44. 🤌🏻

Always love ❤️ this fast-food place.

Awesome location. Awesome staff

Great service and customer service as well as food. Small portions for pricing but expensive for large portions

Great staff, service, and of course subs!

WRENNA and BECKY, are absolutely amazing. I came in 10min before closing running late from another appointment and stuck without a dinner option. Both ladies treated me very kindly and prepared the most amazing chicken Philly. The customer service theses ladies showed me is very rare Jersy Mike is lucky to have them both and I personally would like to say thank you. LaToya

Great fresh subs and quick friendly service!

The kids eat free deal was the best

Great subs and a nice place for a sub !!

We stopped in when we saw the sign that kids eat free on Sundays. We really enjoyed our subs! Wish they had a few more options for toppings (eg olives) but will definitely be coming back.

Good service and good customer service

Always friendly,clean, and fast!#great eat🫶

Every time I come to this location. I'm always greeted with a smile and hello. The service is top notch. And it's always a clean and inviting place. Love come here. By the way, the subs are pretty awesome too.

Food was hot and fresh employees were amazing and fast def coming back

I love how welcoming the store is, and the food is always amazing!

Great at helping with our order. Service is great!

Best location and the staff is fantastic and friendly!

Fresh,fresh,fresh!!! Being from Philadelphia and in food industry, I was amazed at how delicious our sandwiches were! The place is super clean with proper food handling. The veggies so fresh and meat sliced fresh per sandwich. Will definitely be back ! Customer service super friendly 🤩 Kim Spiwak is a true asset to this location 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

The Big Kahuna is the best!! Perfectly balanced with ingredients. Thank you for slicing in two and individually wrapping!

Very helpful with recommending sub, greeted at the door, and the sub is delicious.

Everytime I go very polite and great service and the cheesesteak sub is amazing

Always fast friendly service with a amazing staff. The store is always ways clean with the best food

This is the best location best service and always fresh !

Great service and flavorful subs.

Awesome service and solid sandwiches!

Friendly and fast staff and great food!

Always great! Friendly service!

It was really good! The customer service is beyond amazing, Lisette was awesome!

We love the service and the food. A family favorite for years.

Always come here to get subs. Great subs. Would also recommend door dashing them. They come very quick and always good

Friendly service Quick and delicious

Very fast and friendly service!

Good Sandwiches 3 sizes Check it out 😋

In and out with the best subs ever.

Jersey Mike's is by far better than Subway. This location had no line when we walked in. The service was friendly, and the Veggie sandwich very yummy.

Happy, smiling, helpful employees it was a pleasure visiting today and the sandwiches were great

Great service and great food! Kimberly was very kind!

Abi did an awesome job! She made sure my sandwich was perfect and even added extra pickles. The store is very clean (as well as the bathrooms). With only 2 people working they worked hard to push out a crowd of people quickly. Highly recommend this location.

The best Subs in the USA, they use high quality products and the customer service of the guys is great. Thank you Jersey Mike's.

Jersey Mike's is so delicious. At this location Jessica and lissette are super nice!

Nice, clean location. Staff was INCREDIBLE!

Always a great experience. I’m from jersey and Jersey Mikes stays quality. Staff is great here, not sure of her name but there is a girl who works here, petite with long dark and and some brown… I wish I asked her name bc every time I see her working she is so positive and nice and personable. I live closer to another jersey mikes but will take the extra 5 mins to drive to this location

Ordered via Uber Eats a giant sub and a regular sub with extra meat on rosemary bread. We got both on regular bread and no extra meat on the regular sub. I reached out to the store and they got back with me right away, apologized about the mix up and redid the order. Mistakes hapown; it's how they're handle that show if they care about good service or not and Stephen obviously does.

I have been coming into this Jersey Mike’s for some time. In the past 6 months, I have noticed some awesome changes in regard to the service and cleanliness of the dining area. My favorite JM in the area.

Restaurant is very clean and service was fast. Our food is always fresh and customer service is amazing at this location!

Great food great service all the time.

Great experience good food happy I came.

what a WONDERFUL customer service experience!!!! the owner humself helped us out! he made our samdwiches and was so kind and so sweet!! he was absolulety amazing! the food was really good!! the breads so softs! the place very neat and clean!! me and my husband talked to him and he told us he had twins also, very polite always and how attentive!!. will definitely come back! this is the way all services should be! May God bless this business!!

Fantastic customer service and delicious food. They hosted our JROTC and we’re the best! I’d definitely come back!

Came here for a sub bowl and it looks so good. Ladies here friendly and provided good customer service.

Went for a sub which some chips, and from the drink selection, to the personnel, to all parts of the establishment, had a great meal that was affordable

This is an awesome location! Delicious food and great, fast service. We love the rosemary parm bread and the Italian (Mike’s way!) is our go-to sandwich.

I think that Jersey Mike's is one of the best Sub shops in the country and especially the one at 14839 N Dale Mabry Highway in Tampa, FL. It is extremely clean inside and out - especially the rest rooms. The staff is fantastic, friendly and the service is quick and and efficient. The current owner, Stephen Hyotala is great as well. Looking forward to making this our Sub Shop of choice in the area.

We loooooove this location of Jersey Mikes! The staff are helpful & always a joy to see. The sandwiches are packed with goodness!