Mama Mia's Pizzeria in Belle Isle - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

We loved eating here so much we dined at Mama Mia's twice while visiting Málaga. We the ordered the bruchetta, boloñesa, gnocci, carbanara, truffle pizza with mushrooms and La Primavera pizza. The owner was so sweet, accomidating snf funny, this place really does have a different atmosphere than a chain or fancy place. You have to eat here if you're in town.

Two slice of Pizza and a drink for 6.00

Born in new york best ny style pizza in orlando

Pizza it’s great love it, is wonderful very caring

Best slices this end of town. Simple, friendly and just great food. Give them a go. You won’t be sorry.

So far this is the best pizza here in orlando that i've tried and they are open till 1 am The price is reasonable, the food is outstanding and the music they play inside is always good. I order have cheese and half sausage, thank you for your services

If I could give this place less than 1 star. I would. This place is not authentic at all. GO TO ANTHONYS PIZZA INSTEAD!!!!!!. The wings were drenched in oil and seasoning and not at all what they looked like in the picture. The staff was so rude and presented very poor customer service when I called and told them how they served me a undercooked and frankly disgusting pizza. I paid 30$ for a cheese pizza and wings. This is the worst pizzeria ever. Don't even waste your time feeding your family with this pizza. I told the staff member on the phone my issue with the food I paid for, his response was "I could care less" " no one cares" " I don't care" then hung up on me. Honestly if y'all are reading this I hope y'all find Jesus. Because to treat people who paid for food from your establishment this way , is beyond poor customer service. It's really just flat out an unhappy soul. I will be reporting this to the BBB. My order was 8/19 around 6pm.

Horrible!!!! Pizza had no flavor and was under cooked ...if you're looking for a pizzeria and a real pizzeria go to Anthony pizza shop.

The atmosphere was tiny but definitely a mom and pop pizza shop the customer service was nice an Friendly! Pizza was 10/10 hot cheesy goodness wow!! Definitely have good specials

Pizza barely had any toppings and customer service was horrible. What happened to this place?

The wings,,,the Antipasto salad,,,,,🥰🔥

Small place with delicious pizza!!!

Greasiest pizza in town. We ordered a large pepperoni with mushrooms and extra cheese and the grease was ridiculous! I think that will be the last time we order from there. 🤢 NEVER AGAIN!

This place has always been good to me and my mom pizza is always amazing

Great pizza. Good prices. Staff very friendly. Highly recommend.

Great food, great pizza and done quickly so you can get on with your day!

Pizza is delicious. Pretty small place, limited seating. It's a take out pizzeria type vibe. Recommend ordering in advance and taking out to eat.

Update 2024: Still really good pizza! Ate it after 25 minutes and it was still crispy, cheesy and delicious. Our favorite. Edit: Loved this pizza!!!! The sauce was perfectly balanced. Not too sour, sweet or acidic. The cheeses was abundant and tasty. We ordered and waited. When it came out of the oven, you can smell it. SOOO good. I thought the crust was a little too big, but it was so tasty. There was definitely flavor in the dough. It is a far way from my home but I would get it again while in the area. Wish we were able to dine in, but it is very tiny. We have no pictures of our cheese pizza because we inhaled it sooo fast.

Come here just about everyday best pizza in town trust me

The best Pizza in town! Thank you for being awesome

Excellent service and delicious pizzas

My first time here, I’m walking into a finished conversation about how stereotyping black people is extremely beneficial, I went for a regular pizza deal but left with burnt pizza, and a cup full of ice with hardly any soda, I think it was Kyle who took my order, and boy… he mumbled under his breath multiple about how I asked for To go and ate in the Lobby. Like you gave me this box?? And now you’re crying under your breath. Crazy. The bald white cook could be heard talking about every racial slur you can think of, The burnt pizza I guess was a result of me coming in and asking for a regular meal deal, First time in Orlando and I’m sure gonna go some place else. I usually don’t make these post, but the absurdity that has happened today has make me want to “paint the town red” and say don’t go here, Unless you wanna be racially stereotyped.

The people here can be rude. And the crust is always dry… wish I had somewhere else to get wings. 2nd time they’re out of wings

Pizza is tasteless. The staff couldn't care less if you were there. Small seating area. You can do a lot better with the mass pizza makers than this place, and that's not saying much. Take your business to Stonefired; much better everything.

I'm a New Yorker and once I Found Mama Mia Pizzeria I literally don't go anywhere else on the contrary I wish they deliver in my area so I drive way too far to get this pizza for me absolutely worth it the service is amazing the establishment clean and comfortable Everytime I go sporadically at that they treat you like family big smiles great music bubbly personalities and to Be honest today on Mother's Day I'm waiting to noon for them to open cause I'm getting my niece a pie for Mother's Day extra cheese since the day I introduced her to this pizza she also doesn't go anywhere else this pizza is as close to home as it gets thank you guys keep up the amazing work Ms Blunt Orlando Fl

Fantastic and tasty! An Orlando staple. These guys are dedicated and they aren't chinzy with the ingrediances either.

I got the Bianca, it's was ok. I think the place is probably really good I'll just try something different next time I would recommend it.

Best pizza in town, I drive 25 min just to go there. Great prices, sweet staff, phenomenal pizza. Try it. It's worth it!!

It's great for quick, casual NYC style pizza. And it is fairly accurate, this is definitely not Domino's. It's really tasty, the pizza has thin crust, the sauce is good. I'm only giving it 4 stars because it's not the absolute best NY style pizza I've had down here. But if you just want some quick tasty food, it's perfect.

Amazing people,amazing pizza, great price,great customer service super professional I go there all the time since I work down the street as a diesel tech

Super friendly service with TRUE New York style pizza!! Ate inside for a date, super cozy atmosphere!

I’ve been dining in here for a few years The best place to eat after a long day at work and I’m too tired to cook. These guys know me by name and make me feel like apart of a family

The pizza is good, the place is not very nice but it is good for a good pizza

A boutique pizzeria with delicious slices of pizza and very friendly staff. A good choice for a quick snack.

Great pizza Great value for lunch specials Staff super helpful guys are very nice it

Best in town if it's not the best it's definitely better than the rest 😀

Great food staff were very helpful. Lunch special so good

The best pizza spot ever . Affordable and delicious.

Delicious. I stop in for the 2-slice special every time I am in the area.

Best pizza in Orlando 10/10 so good!

Very good pizza and pepperoni roll! Service is fast and great. Just wish they had more indoor seating.

Food, Service, and Restaurant are top notch. Definitely reminds me of New York . Wish they would have Zeppola & their 18" can be bigger. Great place !

Love this place! Calzone & Bianca pizza are the best.

Excellent pizza at this place and good service.

The best pizza me and my fiancé love it 😍 taste like NYC Pizza 🍕 ❤️❤️

Pizza was great. Much better than Chicago pizza, thank you!

Friendly fast and delicious They give off family business vibes super welcoming My son loves there pizza

The food and service were amazing! Recommend this place 100%

The pizza is great along with the owner and staff a good selection.

Nice little establishment with great pizza.

Please pack the chicken wings tight because dripping and the grease gets to ruin the clothes car seat etc

Got in line to order. People behind the counter just ignored us. Waited on other people. Place is tiny, May be ok for take out but we will never know. Left without ordering. Won't be back

Terrible costumer service! We were a group of nine people. The manager and the employees were refusing to make us fresh pizza. They literally said that it made no sense making two pizzas that were half cheese when they can re heat a cheese pizza that they had sitting there even after explaining that the pizzas are for different families. Then they refused to give us paper plates. They say that the plates were for carryout only. An employee with a nasty attitude gave us medal trays those that you bake pizza on and said that those are they plates for dining in. After I insisted and because I mentioned that I will cancel the order he brought one paper plate just for me. I went back inside and the manager refuse to give us more plates so after the hard time that they gave us placing the order and now this I end up canceling the entire order. The manager literally said he did not care. I replied happy new year and there's many places we can go to instead. This was our 1st and last visit there!

Amazing pizza and wings!! Staff was fantastic and friendly!

Phenomenal pizza and omg the brownies. Hands down top 3 favorite pizzas I've had in Florida

Ordered 3 calzones, and they did not disappoint. Soo good. I will be back and write a new review with photos. ☺️

Ordered 3 calzones, and they did not disappoint. Soo good. I will be back and write a new review with photos. ☺️

Is best in town and best prices. Always service with a smile and almost never closed

Ordered a slice cause I was STARVIN LOKE MARVIN. let me tell you. It blessed me HEAVEY. $2.98 for a slice of pepperoni... it was worth it this time around

Food is amazing. Great pizza n pricing and they don't skimp on the toppings. So glad we found this hidden gem. Wings are big n delicious as well. Great lil spot

Stopped for pizza with a child , we loved it

Had my 3-Pie order ready in 25 minutes! Will most definitely return.

Best pizza in town. My wife and I drive 35 minutes just to go eat there 😋

Se puede entender nadie se puede sentar afuera amenos que esté consumiendo, se puede entender que no hacen delivery hasta después de las 4, puedo entender que aunque esté a 10min de distancia no me van a llevar un delivery. Lo que no entiendo porque los empleados tienen que ser tan rudos y amargados. Solo faltaba que me invitaran a pelear solo porque estaba esperando un Uber fuera del local y solo faltaban 2min para que me recogieran. No es lo que se dice, es como se dice, tener empatía es de gratis.

Excellent!!! One of the best pizza in Orlando. Great customer service.

I’m a die hard pizza fan who travels for work. , this place ranks in top of my list A must do for lunch when I’m in Orlando. Awesome slices and friendly service at low prices. Lunch special 2 one topping slices and a drink for $5.99. Can’t be beat

Only reason they got a 4 in taste is my preference not liking thin crust but even so it was delicious

Was late went we went; past 9pm. We ordered a small Stromboli and i have to say that it was big! Both myself and my bf ate and were full. It was fresh and super yummy! I definitely recommend!!!

Small places always have the biggest flavors. Best thin slice pizza around!

Excelente comida, ordenamos el calzone large y fue más que suficiente para dos personas, viene relleno de mozarella y ricotta muyyy rico y le agregamos tocineta y jamón! Lo único que no me gustó es que no tuviesen sillas para niños fue un poco incómodo entretener a la bebe mientras comiamos! Pero volvería ya que el calzone es delicioso!

I’ve been coming to Mama Mia’s for some time now over the last 6 yrs. Usually I order delivery but occasionally I will dine in and grab a couple slices and a drink no problem but today was different. The guy behind the counter making the pizzas was really rude towards me. He had a problem with my Ms. Marvel Funko Pop shirt. “I will give you the two slices free if you burn that shirt right now.” At first I was caught off guard and didn’t know what to say but then I stood my ground against him. I asked if he just didn’t like brown superheroes as I was a Latino proud to support another hero of color. He backtracked and tried to say the comics he hated of her and how she was such a terrible character but I could care less of his opinion on the matter and tried to ignore him but he kept going on and on about it. This is the first time having such a bad experience there in person that I will never return again. If you’re local and want to support another pizza business I suggest Napoli on Semoran!!

This would have been my first experience with Mama’s pizza and I couldn’t even get to the meal . Terrible customer service , whoever they have answering the phones is not fit to take orders . He was very rude and disrespectful. I’m not sure what is going on in his life but I recommend he not take phone orders until he can be professional. Or at the very least know how to be kind & respectful. Sadly he held none of those credentials.

Pizza is great New York style. However I was disappointed today when I purchased 3 slices to go and the pepperoni slice had only 3 pieces of pepperoni other times it has 4-5 pieces. It looks like they are cutting back on the meats.

Was looking for a pizza spot that isn't a franchise and found mamá mia, surprisingly good, service and parking also good mine was take out, but you can eat in or outside they have tables also.

This little hidden location has amazing pizza. It’s one of the only locations my wife likes. They are fast and reasonably priced Definitely recommend getting the wings

We have lived in the area for 5 years and used to order Italian House for pizza. They recently closed down so we started looking for a new ‘go to’ pizza spot. Mama Mia’s exceeded all expectations when we ordered today. Food was perfect - pizza and wings were on point! Even the delivery driver was super friendly. Just all around great experience. Will be ordering again!

Had a great experience. We're from out of town and were looking for a pizzeria that was open late. They're open until midnight. Did not know what to expect, except for great reviews. They hitt a home run, better yet, a grand slam. If every pizzeria was like this, the world would be a better place. 😀👍 Pizza, wings, and service were 10/10!

Calzone 9.0 Pizza 8.0 Definitely will be back and there marinara sauce was a 9.5 I’m a sauce guy I had it on both

Place has been here forever. The Pie is excellent! Crispy bottom with the perfect doughyness remaining under the cheese. They offer a loyalty program. It's quick, dine in, or take out. Very cost effective too. One of 2 pizza spots in this area in my opinion. Gratsi!

Delicious pizza 🍕 😋 especially the Pizza Bianca 🍕

One of the best pizzas that I've had since moving to Florida in 2011

Acabo de mudarme a orlando y es el primer lugar donde como pizza y creo que será el último porque las pizzas son muy buenas y tiene muy buenos precios

Greasy tasty pie, good garlic cheese bread and a home feel from the crew.

Have been wanting to buy pizza here for some time as it is near the ice machine I use. You can smell it in the air and the smell alone makes you want to try it. Finally went in and bought their 2 slice special with drink. The next time I go it will definitely be a whole pizza. When you crave delicious pizza and by the way the prices could not be any cheaper try this place you will not be disappointed. 💕

Stromboli was very big - very tasty! Pizza crust was a little tough but tasted good. Garlic bread is just a hoagie roll that had garlic butter on it and toasted. Not worth $3.75. Menu was a little limited, but had what we needed to feed our family. Cute shop and employees were very friendly.

My wife showed me this place its the closet pizza to New York city pizza

Great pizza, great prices . Friendly staff , great service .

First time here. I ordered 2 slices of veggie pizza for takeout (mid afternoon on Saturday). No lines. Very short wait. It was done quickly. I paid around $8.50. Pizza tasted great! Nice flavor and veggies I like. A good veggie pizza is not easy to find. Compared to many restaurants, this one makes a nice slice of veggie pizza, which was impressive for a small pizza place like this. Thank you!

Great pizza! I consider myself picky when it comes to my pizza. They are my Go-To pizza place on this side of town. I’ve had the near by competition and this is for sure my spot. Good customer service too.

We love mushrooms, we love pizza, and we LOVE this place ESPECIALLY the people ❤️ Been coming for years and hope they never go anywhere. Must try the brownies, they are delicious!

Excelente servicio y la comida excelente

Love this place. Founded and run by a strong lady. A business that is about family and community.

Can't say enough about this pizza but I'm letting you know I'm not sharing delicious taste love it thank you.

A little over priced for an extra LG pizza

Kevin makes the best Calzone. Muscles makes the best Pizza. I love their pizzas well done. Order one that way and you'll thank me. Texture. Flavor. Crust. Cheese. All good choices.

I came form Miami and my friend talked about this place over and over. AMAZING pizza the Chicago is to die for ! And the attention is great !

Great hideaway for a quick lunch 😋

You'd get more if you happen to deliver to truck drivers. Truck drivers are what keeps food on the shelves and yet you denied not 1 but 6 truck drivers that I personally know.

Food was amazing well I order wings followed reviews family oriented business you can feel the love as I entered 🥰

Went to get a couple Slices Ended up ordering a whole another pizzand in 15 minutes without that wanted to give me a hard time about how my pizza wasn't ready. Good pizza but the owners in a****** Probably won't go back again just because of the owner I've been here 26 years in the same spot and I'm still a d*******