Manhattan City Pizza in West Lealman - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The pizzas are excellent at this place.

Got a cheese and a Florentine pizza. One of the best I’ve had in the area! Crust is perfect!!

Great place unfortunately bad location for owner. I only had 6 knots and two slices of pepperoni and the knots were perfect and the pizza was great. So glad I found this place on my lunch break for anyone looking for good food this place is it. I’m debating driving from Ruskin just to get pies from now on. Definitely a hidden gem. Not a lot of seating but good people and great food how can you go wrong..

Pre-ordered a pizza for a later time to be delivered to Five Towns 1/2 mile away. 45 minutes passed the delivery time the driver arrives and said that he couldn't find the building and told me that he tried to call me and acted like it was my fault. Hands me a cold pizza like it was nothing and drove away. Get a GPS.

As a New Yorker I’d say this is the closest thing I’ve tasted to real NY pizza and wings outside of NY. The owner is always so friendly and helpful. Never waited more than 10 minutes for food I’ve ordered.

Hands down , one of only 2 hidden gems , when it comes to excellent up north style pizza , in St. Pete. Perfect crust , perfect ratio of sauce , cheese , and toppings . I eat at Manhattan pizza 3 times a week . To top it all off , the owner / operator is an excellent person , friendly , courteous , and cares very much about his product , and customers. A+++ I got the 20" pizza , with pepperoni , exquisite !! Thank You Eddie 🍕

First time customer. My wife and I have been batting zero on pizza places....we hit the jackpot tonight. Eddie....the owner was fantastic. As my pizza as cooking he engaged in conversation and made feel as if we grew up together.....and he didn't have to do that. We talked food and how important it is to put the love into your cooking. And of course the pizza was absolutely delicious. Cooked to perfection and very flavorful! Eddie....my friend....my Brother....thank you for keeping it real and serving food with class and love. I've seen some not so kind reviews about your establishment and I totally disagree with them all. To everyone out there.....stop by....give Manhattan Pizza a chance. I really believe you'll not only enjoy.....but it will become a place you'd love to come back to. Not only has this become our No. 1 pizza choice.....it's officially our only one. See you again soon Eddie.

My son Thomas, turned me on to this place. The owner Eddie is a great guy and he makes a great pie. Reminds me of back home. Perfect crust, mild sauce, and quality cheese. Not to mention, he gets em done in about 15 minutes. I'm now a regular.

The works pizza was delicious, efficient, family, friendly service. Very good Antipasto salad & garlic knots. Will definitely return 😀🍕

I'm a NY-er of 25 years that moved down 7 years ago. It's been a search for pizza that has similar taste and consistency and crunch from home. We drive over to Seminole for this pizza. It's no frills, but delicious and doesn't break the bank. It's in our top 5 of pizzas in Pinellas. The owners are awesome and treat us like family.

This place is sooooo good!! Great customer service as well!

BEST PIZZA EVER!!! I was so surprised with the quality and price.

Eddie and I had a great conversation about pizza and life. He went above and beyond any one could have for pizza in Florida. Definitely reminded me of the pizza I grew up with up north. Great family, with even better values. Would recommend 10/10

Love the pizza it's so thin and delicious 😋

Went there for dinner last night and it was honestly home of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The service was excellent as well. Highly recommend!

2nd time grabbing takeout! Chick parm sandwich n fries! Yum. Calzone,Stromboli! Mmmm!

We have been vacationing here for years. I wish I knew about this place before. The pizza is fantastic! The people are great. Eat here!

I can only recommend family owned pizza joint....kitchen is clean, Restaurant is clean, clean restroom. Keeps the slice and pie simple...honestly no non sense pizza spot. Delivery available

The food was fresh, delicious and the pizza crust was amazing!! We had a large cheese and a chicken parm hero, we'll definitely be back!

This place was just okay. The garlic knots were nothing special. The pizza was average. The quality of the chicken wings were below average. I ordered sweet habanero sauce on my wings and I was given Publix Mango Habanero dipping sauce and 10 of the wings were plain. Remove the sauce choice from your online ordering if it can't be provided. The prior owners had a much better product.

Everyone was super nice food great keep it up💪💪

I ordered their cheese pizza and a salad very generous portions in the salad excellent fresh ingredients and the pizza was out of this world not greasy handmade crust completely delicious.

I stopped into the new Manhattan Pizza at the old Manhattan City Pizza location, new menu ,new interior layout, below standard across the board .

Pizza reminded me of a frozen one uou buy at store. Absolutely a huge disappointment.

Excellent pizza! Very happy to have found this place when nearby for work. Thin crust just how I like it, BIG slices, great flavor, zero flop, and the owner was so friendly! Inside is spotless clean, he has great attention to detail. I will definitely recommend this place to my clients and friends who live nearby!

Great food and prices it's a new Family favorite.

We just moved to the area and this place hand's down has the BEST Pizza and subs. Everything was fresh and was delicious.

Been going here since i moved and love this place! Super nice guy, place is clean and always a good pie! They also added a 28” pizza and if you cant tell. Totally worth it

Cute little pizza shop! Very clean, very friendly, and very tasty!

Great food and really nice people. Will definitely be back when we come back to town.

Very good thin and crispy pizza and the place is always very clean.

best pizza of I’ve had in the Tyrone area! great place to go with friends, family, or even yourself:)

Jalapeno relish is not Jalapeno for pizza. that was awful should come with a warning

Big menu, family owned, great service and great food. Small spot in a plaza

If I could rate this place more than 5 stars I would. Coming from the perspective that I grew up eating authentic NYC pizza in Long Island year after year, it’s easy to say I am picky over pizza. Manhattan city pizza has the BEST and most authentic pizza I’ve found outside of NY!! Crispiest thin crust with great flavor and definition of quality flavor in simple ingredients. The prices across the board is beyond reasonable for taste and serving size. Best part, the owner is the kindest man, remembers his customers by name, takes pride in his food and creates an amazing atmosphere! Could not ask for more, thank you for EVERYTHING! Don’t hesitate to order from this restaurant!

Clean place, nice stuff, quick service

I have ordered delivery three times and each time it has been consistent. NY style pizza, flavorful pepperoni pizza. Garlic knots have been pretty decent also. I’m try the wings soon.

I finally found my new go-to pizza place! I cannot believe it took me so long to try this place! The online ordering was a breeze, it was ready for pick up in less than 15 minutes and upon entering the restaurant was clean and very inviting! My two pizzas were hot, with a perfect crispy crust! I will definitely be back!

Yummy tender crispy crust and a true white pizza 🍕 😋 👌 don't hesitate just order!

I ordered a Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Bruschetta appetizer! My new go to Pizza place! Tastes just like NY style pizza.

Ordered a pizza and garlic knots to go and it was good.

I love Manhattan Pizza. They are always there to make your order perfect. We just ordered today. Service was great. Food is delicious. I won't go anywhere else. I ordered a Philly cheesesteak with fries the best I've ever eaten. Kudos to you Manhattan Pizza

Best Pizza, wings, and Owners Eddie!!! 10/10 eat here more than anywhere else!!!

This pizza was disgusting... never ever again

Pulled in for a couple of slices. Always looking for another good pizza. Owner at the front was super nice and appreciative of the business. Had to wait a few minutes for a fresh pie. Appearance of the slice was perfect. Crust good flavor, nice crunch and perfect thickness. Sauce was.mild and had a good flavor. I'll be back for more.

Very good pizza. Very good service. And they deliver within a 5 mi radius of their location. They're mostly delivery and takeout, but they do have several tables.

This restaurant may be small, but it has a fully loaded menu. I am not a big Italian food eater, but I will say the reg pizza 🍕 they offer was most delicious. I grabbed a slice and a menu. I look forward to trying some other goodies in the near future. The eggplant parm sub and white pizza with ricotta sound delicious. I am most pleased I ate here!

The guy running this super sweet..good portion..outstanding sauce and flavor

Best pizza in the city! So light and crispy. I’m hooked!

So far probably the best Pizza I had in Florida ! The Pizza was delicious when we ordered it well done and and we ate it here on the spot. Also the Salad was very fresh and tasty. Incredible fast Service so I have to give them across all 5 stars ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ✨ 🌟

Delicious, Delicious Pizza ! The most delicious pizza I ever ate in St.Pete ! The salad is very fresh too ! I highly recommend this place if you are looking for NY style pizza !

Ordered 2 plain slices came with a free drink of choice .It was like having 4 slices in total and for the price you can’t beat it ! Quality pizza man at the counter was awesome and very kind

Great place, good food, pasta was delicious and the pizza on point. Service was awesome.

The contrast between this establishment's Google reviews, and the actual product we received, was to say the least, startling. This pizza reminded us of the Chef Boyardee kits we made as children. Stiff/dry cardboard crust, unseasoned/bland tomato sauce, and the pepperoni and sausage slices present, were few and far between. Perhaps they invest more in SEO than thet do ingredients? This experience solidifies my theory that some people love all pizza, even bad pizza.

Really good pizza, friendly staff, clean restaurant. What else could you ask for? 5/5

Delicious pizza!! My husband said is the best pizza he ever had. Very clean. You can see them preparing your food. The gentleman that attended us and also prepared the pizza seems to be like the owner it was very nice and helpful. 100% recommended.

Just stopped by today and had a great experience. Loved the cheese pizza by the slice and the garlic knots. Highly recommend!

Ordered from Mahatten Pizza tonite..delivery was quick. Food was hot but terrible…Pizza had no taste / onion rings were frozen then microwaved…. Won’t be back.

This is the best pizza in the state of Florida. I always get great service and great food. I come two times a month and I'm never disappointed.

Tried this place for the first time and it was excellent. The Mediterranean pizza is delicious, the wings were hot, fresh and meaty. Also had the Bruschetta and it was very good as well. Highly recommend if you are looking for really good pizza, wings and more. Give them a try, you won't be disappointed!

Okay WOW! Finally, excellent pizza! The crust was perfectly cooked and the toppings were in perfect balance. I highly recommend this establishment.

I was impressed with the chewy crust. The wings were cooked perfectly & I'd like to try some other sauces they have some interesting options. 😋

I used to get my pizza here most Friday night and the last 4 times the pizza has been horrible. I ordered a Cheeseburge with Fries one night and it was really good however I ordered it again a couple of weeks later and the fries were so soggy and the bun was stale. Needless to say I will be finding some place else to get pizza from.

I stumbled on to this pizza shop by accident. It's actually pretty close to my family's home so that's a bonus, and they deliver so that much better. Now I have a few pizza shops that are around my home and we've tried them all. This place is hands down the best we've had around here. My family is old school Sicilian and I grew up with my grandmother Nona making pizza every year for new years eve, this pizza is so very close to my Nona's pizza it's scary good. Ironically they call it the grandma's pizza and it's delicious. Now the grandma's pizza is not as thick as a traditional Sicilian pizza but it's still square. The dough is not bready but it's got a little chew. It's thin and crispy but thicker than a standard hand toss pizza. It's like the best of Both Worlds when it comes to the grandma Pizza, it's like if the Sicilian pizza and hand tossed Pizza made a pizza baby this would be what came of it. Which is exactly the type of pizza my Nona made. Now that's just the dough. The sauce on the pizza was just as good. The sauce was fresh and flavorful as if my Nona jar packed all the fresh tomatoes for the year. The sauce tastes homemade with all natural flavors and sweetness of fresh tomatoes that were cooked down as if Nona herself had cooked the sauce all day for Sunday gravy. They even use fresh mozzarella for the cheese on top. I hate whenever pizza places use the fake cheese that makes everything greasy or rubbery. This place uses the real whole milk cheese that has a perfect cheese pull as their shredded cheese and fresh mozzarella balls that sit in water made fresh daily. I know this review seems long but it's because our family has been looking for great pizza for a long time that's close to our home, and when you finally find it then you really want to tell everyone. Well this is that pizza and it will now be our new favorite place to get pizza. Oddly enough we even got the Caprese salad which is just fresh mozzarella with tomatoes and basil and olive oil with balsamic, it's one of my dad's favorites. But even with that simple salad, that was even delicious. I knew it was good because my dad wanted all the rest of it and didn't want to share. But honestly it really was delicious and that's why it's a long review. I'd post a picture with this review but we all tore into it so quickly because it was just that good that there wasn't enough to take pictures.

Found my new pizza joint, fantastic NY style pizza!

This place is amazing! The food is fresh and served to order! Delicioso! The owner works hard to exceed expectations. My daughter asked him if he had gluten free pasta, he said "No, but I can get some next door at Publix, what would you like?!?" That impressed me. They deliver, too, for only a $2.00 delivery fee. No up charge for gluten free pizza crust. I am ecstatic; we have definitely found our favorite italian in St. Pete! Awesomeness!

The pizza is really good and the owner is very nice. I am from the Philadelphia so I am very critical of pizza in Florida. This is my favorite pizza place in St Pete

We like your food and service. We will be back soon.

My friend took me after having tried their pizza at a work event and loved it. It's a tiny little spot in the far end of the plaza. It's definitely a hidden gem! The thin crust was crispy and had a perfect ratio of sauce to cheese and toppings. The crust was light and crispy, not overly doughy. Absolutely delicious! We consider this pizza on the level of Toby's, which, as you locals know, is very high praise. You can eat in, though it's not a traditional restaurant per se. We decided to eat there and the owner was so kind, nice, and appreciative of our business. The place was so clean and clearly well taken care of. They actually have a large menu, even daily homemade soups! We will be back and soon!

Great pizza! Perfectly cooked and it tastes delicious. Definitely give it a try!

Love this pizza place first time trying it today I was looking for a good NY style pizza place and I found it for sure I will be ordering again the service is great the food is great definitely recommend if you’re looking for a REAL pizza place 👍👍👍

I love their pizza. Especially the Sicilian.

Had wings and 16 in pizza both were really good, pizza ingredients were fresh and made to order, wings had good flavor as well, definitely will go back to check out other menu items, gentleman behind counter wad friendly and seemed be on top of everything

Just had the freshest, most authentic tasting pizza called grandmas. The sauce was tasty. The owner was the sweetest, sincerest, humble gentleman. I will most definitely return. 5 stars.A must try

The best pizza that you can find, Eddy is from ny so he really knows the Ny style pizza. Thanks and will be back for sure 10/10

I haven’t eat pizza like this in a while , Manhattan pizza was the best , great pizza , great food , great service , everything about this place was great , I highly recommend this place , very happy , thank you ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Extremely welcoming customer service. Pizza was best I have had in a long time in the west St. Pete area. Dough was thin and crispy without being crunchy. Got eggplant on our pizza and they cut and bread each piece individually. Manhattan knows their pizza. Looking forward to our next visit!

We ordered a customized pizza due to dietary needs and the service was excellent. My husband was asked very specific questions to make sure everything was to our liking. The pizza was so flavorful and extra crispy just they way we like it! Our son loved his pizza too. It’s our new favorite pizza place with excellent service and delicious food.

Just WOW!!! Tried this placed after it was recommended by a neighbor and it exceeded expectations. The best pizza I've had in a long time. Cooked perfectly. I will be back.