Mary's Diner and Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Excellent for breakfast and lunch, a little bit of a wait, a busy place, and excellent service.

Here’s a great diner we hit on the way to go play McConnelsville country club. The staff was super friendly, the coffee was hot and frankly I had the best bacon I ever had ever had. At 9 on a Sunday it started getting pretty busy, so obviously this is a popular local joint. Swing by if you’re in the area, you won’t be disappointed.

One question, why have I not stopped here before? From the welcoming smiles to the delicious looking menu to the amazing food. We had a Belgium waffle, stuffed french toast and omelet. All were so delicious and filling! We will he back soon!!

Friendly fast service, good food. Family atmosphere, highly recommend.

this was the best diner experience we have had since we could remember. we were visiting the area from PA and came across the place. We have a 7 and a 5 year old and Despicable Me was on the TV when we walked in so we suddenly relaxed a little knowing it was so kid friendly. Our server was outstanding. She was bubbly, she was efficient, she was personable. It was better service in this small town back road diner for breakfast than we've received in any style restaurant, including fine dining here in Pittsburgh for a long time. We were blown away. The food was perfect. The sear on that corn beef hash was killer. The whole package was such a treat.

Meh . . . tried the sausage gravy and biscuits, sausage was way too spicy to be a breakfast item :-(

First time here for the two of us. We stopped by for breakfast on a weekday. Mary’s Diner is a hidden gem that I never knew existed. Breakfast was great, with generous portions. The server (owner?) was excellent and quick! The diner has both booths and bar stools. If there is ever a waiting time, I doubt anyone would have to wait for too long with the fast service they have. I would highly recommend this diner!

Great experience. Easy in and out service. Great food for the price, especially the pancakes.

Great food! Love this place. Everyone is so nice too.

Great food great service and still has the small town feel

Talk about "off the beaten path", this place is pretty remote. If we stayed on the main roads we never would have stopped here. I'm really glad we didn't stay on the main Rd! Very unassuming from the street. Inside is a quaint modern diner that has an old established feel. I loved everything about it. Our waiter was fast and efficient, brought menus and took our drink orders almost as soon as we sat down. He waited until we were ready and once we set our menus down appeared and took our orders. My breakfast guests had traditional eggs toast and meat breakfast. I opted for the Giambatta, an Italian version of what is called garbage plate in many diners. It tasted nearly identical to the dish my grandfather would cook decades ago. As a kid, we pronounced it Gham-bot, I was surprised to see it on the menu. Let me just say IT WAS GREAT! made even better by being delivered HOT from the kitchen. This ranks as one of the best breakfasts I've had on the road in years Hats off to the folks at Mary's. One meal and I realized how you could be a success with such a remote location. Good job, I'll be back🙂

Was a very pleasant breakfast. I beat the rush though.. Food was great, as you hope to find in a diner.. Service was very good as well. Will be going back.

Service and food were excellent, definitely will be stopping by again

Great food, clean establishment!

Great service here. order was completely correct, food tasted amazing and was warm, even with lots of peoples. One time went here with only one guy serving and like 8 tables and somehow this guy waited and brought all the food to every table at a pretty reasonable time. Order was completely correct too. Great place great service

3 of stopped in for breakfast. The moron there prompted us to sit at the counter. We don't want to sit at the counter. 2 tables available. You don't tell customers where they can and can not sit. Poor business management. 😢 lost my entire family's business. Bye bye stupid

Cute, clean diner with vintage items on display. Food was delicious and reasonably-priced.

Great diner. We love diners and this one is at the top of our list.

Great breakfast food! I've been a handful of times and never left disappointed. Very good food for a very reasonable cost.

Good food, cooked as asked, pleasant, personable, efficient waiter.

Staff was amazing and friendly! Food was superb. Highlight of our 3 day trip,so much, we went back again and again!

Man I haven't been in years, best breakfast in the tri town area! I will be back on my next journey back to NY

My family enjoys having a great breakfast when we are up to camp. We love this diner

Great food, beautiful surroundings and friendly staff! Perfect.

Cute little restaurant out of town.

The garbage plate is everything you could ever want. Great for after a night of too much drinky. And the banana bread French toast is literally heaven. Great service and incredible food.

Love Mary's it's hard for me to recommend because it depends on what I feel like eating haven't had anything I didn't like

The food is amazing! The staff is very friendly!

Great food at a great price! Friendly service in a clean and inviting atmosphere.

Food good, service good, prices could be a little less.

My absolute favorite diner. 😍 Try the hash and eggs. The French toast is like dessert.

The service was excellent! Our server, Diane was absolutely welcoming and kind. We had a wonderful experience at our first visit to metro diner!! Will definitely be going again soon!! By the way the waffles are EVERYTHING

Small place but usually a table avaliable, plenty of parking. Cute retro vibe

Great place for a great breakfast

Clean & nice but my omelet was terribly burned cheese melted on top. Omelets are made with cheese in the middle. Prices a little high for what your getting. We won't be returning as the wait for a replacement omelet while my hubby ate & all done when I got to eat. It would have been a nice gesture to have lowered the price of omelet on our bill

Delicious breakfast wonderful place!!!

This is my new favorite breakfast spot. Food was so good and our waitress was amazing. We didn't get rushed, the coffee kept coming and the entire atmosphere was wonderful.

So friendly , food amazing , prices are great. Next time we are in the area will definitely go back.

Adorable little diner with good food and friendly staff. Well worth a stop. They have breakfast and lunch items.

Food was excellent. It's out of the way but worth the trip. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is they did not take credit cards.

Nice little place right off Sylvan Beach at Oneida Lake. Stopped in for breakfast and it was solid.

Very clean good food and awesome staff

Food was amazing service was great, will definitely go back, would recommend going! Well we went back same great service and same great food!!

We've only been here twice but it's been a great experience both times. Reasonable prices, great customer service, and great food.

It was a girl's breakfast out from camp. Mary's is a cute and very clean diner. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The food was excellent. We will definitely be returning.

Food is good and service is excellent. It's my go to place for sylvan Beach

Cute little place. Very friendly staff, food is good and prices are average

Great food great price. Quiet with great service

Quaint little place of the beaten path, but his breakfast. Very clean diner!

Very clean little diner. Good breakfast, and good service!

Good food and service Friendly service