Mikey's Pizza-Ria in Kissimmee - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Food was good until they decided to just give slop no one orders tuna fish on top of a salad. Will not return

We drive from lakeland to kissimmee to eat this pizza and to us it is always worth the drive. LOVE THIS PIZZA!!!!

Delicious, as always. Highly recommend.

everything is great at Mickeys pizzeria

RIGHT NOW I THINK THAT'S PLACE HAVE NEW ADMINISTRATION AND THAT IS GOOD BECAUSE THE FOOD IS BETTER ATTENTION TO THE CLIENT IS MUCH BETTER...SO I GO GIVE YOU GUYS ONE BREAK .....BECAUSE I LIKE WHAT I SEE TODAY APRIL 23 2023....I recommend a 100%...is a little expensive I don't go to lie but u paid for a good dinner... promess love ittt

Prices are to high compared to other pizzerias

I’ve ordered from here in the past, and this is not the first time they mess up in a large order (7people, 10items) (seems to be their weakness). We were missing food (1slice/1coke — maybe the driver had a snack..? or the restaurant forgot..?), so one person from the group could not eat at all. The person is vegetarian and all other orders had meat, so we couldn’t even share! One of the calzones was burned with charred/black edges/spots. And the marinara sauce that is supposed to come with each individual calzone/Stromboli order was put into one large container without advising. Just because it’s being ordered from the same place does not mean it will be a shared order (especially when we went as far as to include the name for each order in the notes). We were also not provided with any plates/napkins/utensils, even though it was asked for in the order. This was a terrible experience. Each of these things has occurred singularly on different orders, but this time takes the cake (or the slice that we never received but paid for…). I will be escalating this further…. If they don’t make this right, we will unfortunately not be ordering from here anymore. The pizza/calzones/strombolis are usually delicious, but the quality of the orders has gone down the drain. From pricing inconsistencies (their website vs their flyers vs delivery services) to having something wrong with practically every order… I am not sure this place is in the game of large orders (more than 2-3 items). And that’s the main experience expectation with an online delivery: presentation and accuracy. So disappointing… I am available for consulting needs, should this business desire to improve. I am also not above a comeback! If they make this right, I will update this review. So far.. the driver does not reply…. #itybityreviewsandconsulting #itybityreviews #itybityconsulting

This place is a ripoff The food is alright but THE PRICE is just horrible theres is no way i get charged $22.30 for 4 sliced of pepperoni

Came here for a takeout pizza and it was the most delicious pizza ever!! Service was fab too! 😊

Dont order on there link for delievery they will cancel your order 1 hour after you order and say they were closed also they kept my money no refund 2 hours later

I like the thin and crispy pie.

Mikey's never disappoints 👍🏽💯 I would post a picture but the pizza was gone before i even thought about taking a picture! #Thebestpizza

For over 20 years. The pizza still the same! Fire 🔥 💯

Good nyc style looking pizza but the only issue is that the bread(dough) part is to thin it was like eating a thin crust pizza ,which isn’t bad but I wanted more bread part.other then that it was good.

Staff is nice that makes me wonder if high ratings is based on that because the pizza itself is honestly mid. Sure they got the NY style right but eh. It’s hit or miss, I wouldn’t pay for it again and there’s better pizzerias to get from. It’s average - slightly below average pizza. Place is extremely clean though and welcoming.

I took my parents and my boy there weeks ago. It was the best pizza I ever had. So fresh and so well baked. The service was so kind and nice. They gave my mom a free bottle of room temperature water since she needs to have her pills. I love everything about this small local pizza store! Oh their Salads are so fresh and in big portions too! Must go back again if we visit Florida! Thank you 💞

OMG the pizza took me back to New York. My kids always enjoy the pizza service. And the smell of the pizza cooking is yummy. I don't care what people say on the negative reviews . This pizza is very great 👍👍👍🍕🍕

Great pizza! Garlic knots weren't bad either!!

EXCELLENT SERVICE EXCELLENT FOOD GREAT STAFF 👍👍👍

Order pizza..it was terrible also they gave us our food and closed up before we realized the order was not correct

Is nice and the place is clean, plus the workers are very polite

Best pizza by far, small but friendly place to eat in. The pizza was well prepared and delicious and the chicken wings yummy

Doesn't get better than Mikey's!

A Pesaro de uqe es un lugar pequeño Las Pizza son espectacular llevo mas de 15 años comprando sus Pizzas y calzones y no Los cambio por otros

Nice place to expensive buy is ok the dinner is good

Excellent Pizza great flavor. I love how the pizza sauce has little chunks of tomato.

I ordered a calzone and it’s not what I expected the mozzarella cheese wasn’t even melted not good after paying $25

I googled “best pizza near me” and this place popped up - and the ratings didn’t lie. Great pizza, subs, and salads. VERY easy online ordering with delivery tracking. Highly recommend for vacationers!

The experience was great, really quick delivery

First time ordering and trying to find a good Pizzeria, well I found it. Great pizza, and fast delivery. Am ordering from Mikey's from now on.

I love their pizza the only place I know that taste like real New York pizza I travel from Winter Haven to Kissimmee just for their special

Easy and way more than we expected but taste delicious

Had garlic, onion and bacon Large Calzone and it was great. Meatball sub was toasted as requested and delicious. Delivered on time and food was still hot.

Best Pizza Place in Kissimmee! Long time neighborhood favorite!

Came here for a quick lunch and have always been intrigued trying it for years now. Had their 2 slice and a drink special. Their pizza is pretty good..not too oily and has a great taste. It's a small restaurant with very little seating so it's best to maybe do take out.

Went had their pizza today it was awful had their pizza before Todays pizza was dry and it was super thin and hard nothing like it was before Most be new owners

My go to pizza spot in Kissimmee! Been around forever and so good!

The pizza was good, staff needs to take an ethics class. There attitude really sucks.

Yummy Pizza! Good pizza starts with the crust for me. Its not thick at all and has a nice baked crunch.

I'm from Philly and this is the best pizza in kissimmee as close as I can get it here

I wonder how they have good pizza or get the orders right all they all do in there is smoke pot in the back all day and night it’s a wonder they have any brains at all.

Best Pizza in Kissimmee. Lunch special customer since 2013.

Best pizza in town. I try to find the best being from New York. It's a toss up between here and Bronx pizza on Hoffner.

Called at 8:30 to put in a order was told by staff they closed at 8:30………..SAD! I see 9pm in google search of their business hours . SAD!

Just ordered the party pizza today 4/03/22 at 4:14pm! Called and the young lady is very rude first of all. Ordered a PEPPERONI pizza waited at a meet up point and when I got home it was a cheese pizza. Called to let them know that one, my pizza was cold and two, it was not a pepperoni pizza which I ordered just plain cheese. Danny was very rude and hung up on me. The pizza here used to be amazing and the ones working have no good customer service, they shouldn’t be working where they have contact with people. It’s been 10 years ordering here and I get treated like this?! Paying $40 for a pizza that wasn’t what I ordered. Smh.

The young female cashier with glasses was incredibly rude to the point where I was in disbelief and feel bad for the business owners because the pizza that we ordered was SLAMMIN! Not my first time at Mickeys and they never disappoint (food wise) and we always had a great experience with the previous cashier (not sure if she still works here but she is missed). To summarize the pizza is top tier but the service not so much.

Great little spot for a slice and a coke.

Love their pizza and their 2 slice with a drink special😋

Slice of pizza and garlic knots aways hit the spot thin and crispy

Food is tasty, wings, pizza excellent

The large veggie pizza is great for the price $23.00

Excellent! Sauce is not sweet and the wings are small and crispy how I like it!

I love their pizza it’s the best here in Kissimmee

Best NY style pizza and by the slice as well in Kissimmee Florida.Reccomend highly

Everytime I have a Doctors appointment. I go eat there weekly. Great pizza.

Good pizza reminds me of back home in the Bx

They have the great pizza in Kissimmee area. New York ..

Ellos preparan una pizza 🍕 muy buena😔pero me quitaron el trabajo de drivers sin ninguna esplicacion😞👊

The pizza was definitely good, New York style. They do not practice adecuate sanitization. The tops of condiments on the table were handled by server and tables were not sanitized.

If you are looking for the best New York style pizza in central Florida you have found it. A perfect balance of sauce cheese and thin crispy crust. The taste is off the chain!!! Great customer service and a variety of delicious lunch specials. The best hidden Pizza spot In Kissimmee.

Expected a lil more flavor and sauce on the pizza slice

The pizza was good i bought one pizza and i fell in love with it im going to meet her folks next saturday wish me luck.

Veggie pizza was delicious it taste like real Italian pizza from new york prices are affordable will recommend

Great pizza 🍕 and great service 👍

Gotta love them !!! 23 years later and still the best pizza in Town!!!!

Excellent thin crust pizza ! Best in town

Real great Italian pizza great service as well.

Always Great pizza !! And a Great time with my grandkids. 🙂

Excellent food and great service this is one of the cleanest restaurants ive seen all and all mikeys get a 110%

I really love their food. Im dissapoin that they changed stuff so much.

This is an Amazing little spot to eat. Great lunch special everyday. The staff is friendly and the food freshly made. Don't let the size of the place fool you. You will be amazed.

My first time eating from here and I have to say I am very satisfied with my food, it was very good. They had a great customer service skills. The place was clean. I'm just very impressed with this hidden gem that I found.

Mikey's Pizza-Ria has been supporting our Teacher Appreciation Week for the last 2 years. I am so grateful that even throughout this last year, they were able to sponsor an awesome luncheon for our staff. The best PASTA in TOWN, yes I said it BEST IN TOWN. Garlic knots, drenched in garlic sauce are to die for. Super friendly staff and great establishment. THANK YOU for all you do!!!

La mejor pizza en fl hace 19 año que fui por primera vez y aun sigue siendo igualita, ricaaaaaa

Fantastic NY Style Pizza. Their wings have Fantastic flavor.

The best NYC style Best Cheese STAKE

Everyone is friendly and the pizza is amazing . Moved from Kissimmee to Tampa and there is nothing that beats this pizza place ! Wings are amazing!!!!! Old town was packed and no social distancing so me and the family came for Mikeys

Always great pizza. We drive from lakeland just to eat here.

Love this pizza place. The crust is delicious the mozzarella cheese is authentic the sauce isn't acidic taste. The staff is always attentive.

Pizza is great just the way I like it.

Really loved being back here. I use to go when I was younger and it's been about 15 years since being back and it's still amazing as ever.

I ordered the large calzone with everything on it bigger than I thought it would be and it was good I would be back

By far, the best pizza I’ve had in a long time.

Never disappoints! I've been eating there since I was a child. Over 20+ years

Great place, great pizza and great pasta...the service excellent!!

The pizza is delicious and the customer service is great!

Ordered an XL cheese. Perfect as always. Delicious and ready right on time. Great value❤❤

Pizza is great. Place needs to be spruced up and cleaned

The pizza is delicious! The service is great!

Amazing pizza and good food..!!

The best pizza in Kissimmee and 192 the best pasta best sandwiches I love it the staff beautiful thank you for everything and thank you for your service can men anyone that loves pizza and love sandwiches go over there to Mike's

We are never disappointed with the quality of the food here.

Great pizza and the people here were professional.

The best pizza I've ever had in Florida

As a New Yorker this is the closest thing to the real deal that I've tasted down here in Florida! The staff remember you and are very helpful and friendly!! The size and quality are totally worth the price!!! One of the most important things for me is that the consistency of the product stays the same!! Love it!!!

Authentic taste. Very delicious

Never disappoints, best in town especially for the price!

Best pizza around I don't know how people can eat card board pisa from Pizza Hut Domino's or even Little Caesars but the pisa is still mediocre nothing like New York

The pizza is always consistent.

Great service. Huge Pizza slices🤗❤️