Mystic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes in Pelican Marsh - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I just had one brought to me Wow, what a delight🤩Can’t wait to have an other one and meet the makers of that simple and delicious food

So disappointed! We loved the lobster rolls from Mystic in the past, but today's sandwiches were a huge disappointment! They had literally half the lobster as previous times, maybe 4 bites, but of course, still $25 a sandwich, so for 2 sandwiches and a tip, well over $50+ for 2 tiny sandwiches. My son even had a picture of a previous sandwich from there, he loved it, and this was half of that! Nothing good lasts.

Delicious BLT Lobster Roll and really yummy coleslaw!

So delicious!! I have the lobster Mac ‘n Cheese with snow crab. It was outstanding with a generous portion of lobster and crab. Highly recommend.

Don’t let the casual atmosphere fool you…AMAZING lobster rolls!🦞 Some of the best my husband and I have ever had. All of the ingredients were very fresh and the coleslaw was yummy. Don’t miss out on Mystic.

Great service and food! Healthy amount of lobster. Sauces on the Deep South were fantastic!

absolutely unbelievable. The pieces of lobster were huge and flavorful. I got the snow crab and lobster mixed roll. It'll be hard to go back to just lobster after that. Service was fantastic as well

Very casual space, but cute. Lobster is legit. As a New Englander I was skeptical but the lobster quesadilla was incredible.

Lobster Roll was fantastic! Service was top notch. Helped us to decide on a selection and was patient with our toddler and helped to accommodate her allergies.

Lalit was amazing, very kind and made our food amazing

Absolutely the best lobster roll! Full of large pieces of fresh lobster, not overly dressed. We will be back!

The experience was very positive with great food and service.

Food was amazing!! I got the Connecticut Roll and it was very flavorful! Definitely recommend trying this place out you will not regret it.

Best lobster roll in Naples. Get the Yukon golds (garlic) too!

Ordered Connecticut lobster roll & clam chowder. Service was wonderful soup came out hot and creamy lobster roll was full of lobster.

Amazing little gem of place- New England in Naples… go for the Mighty roll and add on the Yukon gold potatoes! Worth the money!!

Great roll! Definitely pricey, but also good quality, friendly staff. The lights inside were a bit bright for my tastes, but the outside patio is perfect.

The best lobster roll I ever had ...

Excellent lobster rolls! Even got to try a generous sample of snow crab which was also delicious. Nice place.

The lobster rolls were AMAZING. Nice big chunks of lobster perfectly cooked. There are many different types but we went with the Maine Lobster Roll. Simple and delicious. The Yukon Gold potatoes spilled with Old Bay were delicious. Not to mention the Cole slaw. Yummmmm!!! We will be back! Also Lalit, our server, was helpful and kind. With a big smile on his face. Very pleasant. What a find.

Excellent lobster rolls. Fresh lobster every time. I will be back

Great food! A little pricey for lunch but you should know that if lobster is involved. Wonderful lobster bisque too.

From someone who has lived in the Northeast and has tasted the best lobster rolls, this place is EXCELLENT!!! The lobster texture and flavor was great!!! The lobster bisque and potatoes were delicious as well. If you are craving lobster rolls & superb service, this is the place to go!

Had the Connecticut Roll. Plenty of lobster to go around!

Great place, friendly, lobster is cooked to perfection.

First time here. Happened to be in the area and stumbled across Mystic Lobster Roll Co. I am a huge lobster roll lover so I was super excited to try. First impression, the location is in a great area, the place itself is very clean and organized. The two gentlemen greeted us upon walking in the door and explained the menu and asked if we had questions. They also offered a few suggestions of their most popular items. My husband and I both got the Connecticut lobster roll. It comes with a pickle and coleslaw. The entire meal was phenomenal! The lobster was juicy and thick, full of flavor and tasty! The coleslaw is sweet with robust flavor. It did not disappoint!!! Definitely recommend stopping in. They have full menu and something for everyone! Give it a try!

Awesome roles. Just like back in Boston.

Lobster rolls and service were great!

Food was excellent and Lalit provided great friendly service.

I loved the chicken quesadilla. They were a 5 out of 5

We have enjoyed the lobster at this location on several occasions. The server is engaging and attentive. The Lobster is outstanding.

There is a wide selection of lobster rolls. The lobster rolls are on another level. Easily the best ones I have ever had. 10/10

Tried a Maine roll and a Connecticut. Both excellent. Lalit, our host was very personable and efficient.

Clean. Very friendly, & nice service. Delicious lobster!

Just had awesome lobster roll lunch! And lobster bisque! I definitely reminds me of my days when I was living in CT! Authentic!

Great find and delicious! Lalit was wonderfully helpful when I could not decide what to have. Some of the best fresh Maine Lobster and Snow crab I’ve had here in the last 4 years! I’ll be back!

Excellent place. I had the BLT Lobster Tacos and they were awesome. Highly recommend.

Love the creative take on lobster rolls and even got some snow crab!

We became regulars at the Vanderbuilt, Naples location very quickly. Lalit always prepares our order with care and is always very cheerful. You'll become regulars too after just one visit!

great customer service both times we’ve went, super attentive and very polite!

Absolutely fantastic! If you're not in Bangor Maine this is the place to get the lobster rolls!

Ample lobster on great buns! Will be retuning

Amazing food & Very friendly staff!

Very fresh and delicious lobster!

Lalit was a awesome server and the food was amazing as always.

The first thing you notice is the how bright and clean it is! We had the Mighty Connecticut roll and lobster Mac & Cheese. All was out of this world delish! Pricey, but worth it every once in awhile! It is lobster after all and sadly I was not in New England. Happy to have such a great spot in my hometown! 🦞

Laiat was very friendly! Lobster was delicious!!!!!

Lalit were very nice to me , even I ordered almost before closing time ) and food was just Outstanding and Soul Food! Thank You

Excellent lobster roll…best we’ve found in Naples, Bonita and surrounding area.

Really good lobster rolls, I highly recommend!

Great Food and Excellent Service

Authentic Maine Lobster roll. Price reflects the quality as it was terrific. Quantity is a little sparce but happy hour from 3-5 daily makes it an affordable treat. Awesome young man that runs the little eatery serves up delicious seafood and cold Stella's with good vibes. Two thumbs up!

My wife and I tried the lobster rolls and were not disappointed. The servings were generous and had outstanding freshness and taste. Our server explained that the lobster is flown in daily from Maine. The outside tables are definitely the best choice, quiet and with a pleasant view. Try it, you will not be disappointed

Absolutely delicious ! And so quick. One of my favorite places to stop on my lunch to get quick and delicious food.

Delicious food that tastes very high quality.

Very delicious lobster rolls and lobster bisque, and the staff are always so kind and accommodating. The food is amazing so we always come back for lunch or dinner! Definitely check this place out if you love lobster rolls or just lobster in general.

Best food I have ever tried. Accilent customer service. I would recommend to try it.

I came here to eat before flying back home to Chicago. Lilith (I think was his name) was very accommodating to my questions about the menu. I ended up ordering the Connecticut lobster roll, and my boyfriend had the Southern lobster roll I believe it was called (came with Jalapenos and jalapeño aioli) we both enjoyed our meals, and id say the lobster was pretty good quality. I’d go here again if I lived here!

Highly recommended !! Good service and on top of that quality of food. Amazing, I will definately come back.

The rolls are packed with lobster. Lalit was so helpful and friendly. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for a delicious lobster roll!

Delicious lobster roll, for the first day of lent! Lalit our waiter, was very helpful explaining the menu. I truly recommend eating here… 🦞

I'm from New England so very fussy about lobster rolls. This place is the real deal! The staff is very efficient and pleasant. The prices are reasonable. It's not really an easy- in place although there are a few tables. If you like lobster, you don't need to look anywhere else.

Our first time here at Mystic Lobster Roll , the service and food quality is great. Rishi was very happy to help us with specials We will definitely be back

Best lobster roll I've had down here. Fresh Maine lobster daily, great buttered bun overflowing with delicious lobster meat.

My husband and I tried this today and we were not disappointed! Delicious rolls with good portions of lobster chunks, good service, neat location! Definitely recommend

Food is really good, and the ambiance here is always inviting and comfortable.

Awesome place and great lobster rolls! Lots of creative options, excited to try others! 👍

Hands down the best lobster rolls in town. Not one of the many that put some sort of seafood salad on a hotdog bun. Actual tender chunks of Maine lobster. Friendly service and very clean. We will be back!

My husband and I recently had the pleasure of eating here for the first time. It was delicious and the service was amazing. Our lobster rolls were made fresh. The staff was pleasant, the restaurant was neat and clean inside, and there was a cozy relaxed vibe. I can’t wait to go back and try the Lobster Mac & Cheese.

I absolutely comming there. The service is great, along with the food. I will always be a returning customer!

Nice little shop serving delicious lobster rolls !! Friendly staff, cold Narragansett Lager, can't go wrong !!

Really excellent food, and the gentleman behind the counter is very kind

Food is great! In for a quick lunch.

The best Lobster Roll in Naples. The kindest server, Lilly was his name he made me feel welcome and made sure I was taken care of. 10 stars if I could 🫶🏽

Fair priced lobster rolls made with care! Treat yourself and plan a visit.

Best lobster rolls in town. Try them out.

My husband and I ordered a couple different rolls because they looked so interesting and good and they did not disappoint! The added flavors really took the lobster to the next level. My favorite was the Hawaiian roll. The staff was very helpful and friendly too. Will definitely be back!

I recently had the pleasure of enjoying another delicious lunch at Mystic Lobster Roll Co, located in the beautiful Vanderbilt Shoppes on Vanderbilt Road. This hidden gem captures the fun and vibrant northeastern style with its charming decor that instantly transports you to the coast of Maine. The interior design is a great mix of cozy and warm, creating a friendly and inviting atmosphere. Right from the moment I stepped inside, I could tell that Mystic Lobster Roll Co pays meticulous attention to detail. The interior design is perfect, with clean lines and thoughtful touches that enhance the dining experience. The restaurant exudes a clean and friendly ambiance that instantly puts you at ease. What truly sets Mystic Lobster Roll Co apart is their commitment to doing one thing exceptionally well. Their menu features a variety of styles of lobster rolls, allowing guests to choose their preferred flavor profile. As someone who appreciates restaurants that focus on a specific specialty, I was impressed by their dedication to delivering the best lobster rolls in town. One of my go-to rolls at Mystic Lobster Roll Co is the Connecticut-style roll, served warm with butter. This classic roll never disappoints. The lobster meat is incredibly flavorful and of exceptional quality. It perfectly complements the roll, which is warm, buttered, and lightly toasted. The combination of fresh, soft bread and luscious lobster creates a mouthwatering experience that keeps me coming back for more. Each roll at Mystic Lobster Roll Co is served with a side of cole slaw and a pickle spear. The cole slaw is a refreshing delight, with a bright and fresh flavor that is neither too wet nor too sweet. It complements the richness of the lobster roll wonderfully. The pickle spear, with its crispness and dill seasoning, provides the perfect balance of tanginess and crunch. To accompany your meal, Mystic Lobster Roll Co offers a selection of local brews, domestic beers, and soft drinks. Whether you prefer a cold beer or a refreshing beverage, they have you covered. Additionally, they provide catering services, ensuring that the scrumptious flavors of their lobster rolls can be enjoyed at any event or gathering. Overall, I highly recommend Mystic Lobster Roll Co for a fantastic quick and easy lobster roll lunch. The combination of their delicious lobster rolls, attention to detail, and friendly atmosphere make it a top-notch dining destination. Don't miss out on this hidden gem in Naples.

Lobster is very dry and tasteless. Does not taste fresh at all. It’s as expensive as other nearby places that do serve fresh tasting lobster. We gave it 3 chances and each experience was bad. Would not waste our money again, rather have pizza. Which is also dry and tasteless until you add the toppings! BTW is not the owners fault but rather the fault of the Mystic franchise and how they are shipping their lobster meat to their individual franchise owners.

I tried “Mystic lobster” for the first time yesterday. I ordered the gf lobster roll and absolutely loved every bite! The sandwich was overflowing with excellent lobster and the gf roll was one of the best I’ve ever had! The accompanying cold slaw and pickle were excellent and complimented the meal nicely! Definitely looking forward to my next visit!!

Just try it once and YOU WILL CRAVE IT!!! So good and such friendly service!!! YUM!!!

Great beer, great lobster, amazing service!

I found myself at The Shoppes at Vanderbilt around lunch time and I couldn’t resist the chance to have a lobster roll. I’m from Rhode Island. Lobster rolls are a staple during the summer. Well, Mystic Lobster produces an exception lobster roll. It made me feel like I was in Narragansett, RI on a hot August day. Thank you.

The food is absolutely fabulous. It was the best clam chowder I’ve ever had and the lobster roll was perfect. I can’t recommend it enough!

Excellent service , great rolls , hearty portions

My husband and I have eaten here shortly after there grand opening. We were attracted to the surf and turf which by the way were very tasty but we ended up ordering an order of sliders and lobster Mac and cheese because we were still hungry. Yesterday we went in and decided to order the Mighty rolls that were supposed to be an additional 50% lobster!! That was not the case… it was the same about of lobster as before with a small half of the lobster claw on top! We were so disappointed and felt robbed! 77 for the same amount of lobster!!! We were hungry when we left and went to eat elsewhere!! We won’t be back!!

Fantastic quality of lobster, one of the freshest places I’ve eaten at in Naples. And I’ve eaten at quite a few. I’m from Maine and they definitely do us justice!

The restaurant is so clean and polished! That’s the first thing I always look at when entering any restaurant I’m about to eat in. The service was great. Everyone who works there is so friendly and helpful! Now on to the good stuff…. I ordered the Italian Roll lobster roll and of course I made it a mighty (50% more lobster) it was delicious!! I ordered the combo so I got some chips and a water with it as well. PERFECT lunch. The lobster is incredible. Great quality. If you’re looking for a satisfying lobster roll this is the place!

Rolls taste very good! But the portion is too small. I’m a light eater. But paying over $20 for lunch, I’m still hungry.

So good! Everything was fresh, and tasted amazing! I ordered the Italian Roll! If I visit Naples again, would likely return

Love lobster so anxious to try mystic lobster. Very lacking in seating comfort and ambience. Lobster in the roll was good but overall not as good as expected and not attractively presented. Wine available made meal very overpriced. Disappointed.

Good lobster 🦞. I would have given 5 stars till I got the bill .. and they added a $10 charge for using a debt card .. before they even knew I was using one … lol … bring cash. …

Excellent lobster rolls and the lobster bisque was just phenomenal!!!

Excellent lobster roll and customer service!

Just a dynamite place. Great food, excellent service w a smile. Will visit again.

In my experience with lobster, flavor wasn’t good. The price was absurd I paid $64 for a pound of Lobster and for this two things I paid $49 with a bottle of lemonade. I don’t know about you. But I think people are abusing with prices. You decided. For high price I don’t recommend this place. Neither for the flavor.

Samantha the manager was stellar. She worked hard to make sure our order was done correctly and when Door Dash didn’t work, she drove it to us herself! Amazing customer service! The food was fantastic and the key lime pie was wonderful. We will definitely be coming back.

Lobster is good but at $20 on a small, cold bun it’s not a place I will visit a lot. The serving was so small I was still hungry after eating it and the coleslaw was tiny. Just not worth the money.

I was excited to try this new place and it did not disappoint! I had to try one of their specialty rolls, The King Louis XIII; fresh lobster, fresh mozzarella, razor thin prosciutto and truffle aioli. Along with it I had lobster bisque 🦞. So delicious and I can't wait to get back to try another!

I’ve been a couple times now and both times the food and service was fantastic. I got the Connecticut then BLT rolls both of which were phenomenal and looked exactly like the pictures. Would certainly recommend and will continue to go.