Oak Leaf Cafe & Bakery Penn Yan - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Food is great, but the waiting line is too long.

Great store with many fresh products and local herbs and spices.

Lovely place for lunch and a quick shopping trip. Nice salads and wraps.

I would give 6 stars if we could. Love Oak Leaf cafe food, staff and atmosphere! Best in the Finger Lakes.

Best breakfast in the finger lakes region! Coffee is amazing! All of the staff are so kind and helpful!!!! Love Love Love the fry pies and the market!!! Everything we order is delicious!!! It’s truly our favorite place! We’re from Lancaster County, PA and certainly, it reminds us of home!!! Oh! And love the gift section!!! Best place to buy beautiful & unique gifts!!!!🩷

Love it . Had zucchini panini and my husband had bacon egg cheese . Delicious thank you coffee was amazing too .

We enjoy coming here to shop and possibly eat.

Friendly service and big portions for lunch. The tastiest oak milk latte's around! We make sure to come here whenever we're in the area.

One of our favorite go-to places in PY. Always good food and great people!

The hot chocolate was amazing! It was a perfect temperature and was so creamy. The whip cream just made it even better. The French toast had cinnamon, blueberries, and whip cream. The plate also came with real maple. AMAZING!!! The staff is very friendly. They listened great with the kids and were friendly overall. The bathroom was very clean. I highly recommend this place!

Have been going to Oak Hill for decades, always wonderful!!!

All very tasty and they have a wonderful atmosphere. Always seems there is something small that makes having lunch better each time we go!!! Give it a try!!!

Always delicious and reasonably priced.

Fast service!👌 Pulled pork panini was excellent!👌

Great food in a casual atmosphere. Handy for lunch after shopping.

Good food and relatively timely service for the amount of people on a Saturday!

Stellar breakfast or lunch spot. Great specials and coffee drinks. Real food made with fresh ingredients.

Love the food, people and atmosphere. Terrific store. The Seneca Sunrise sandwich is simply, The Best.

Love this place. Great family atmosphere

They could use some more space in the cafe, but I had the special that day, bacon raspberry grilled cheese, and it's now one of my favorite things I've ever tried. I personally didn't like the beef and vegetable soup however. It held more of a bean soup profile. The iced Chai Lattes are amazing as well, normally I'd drink them hot but I recommend getting one here on ice.

Got the turkey pesto panini, it was delicious!

I have had trouble with gift cards for a couple years there but food and service is very good

Had Buffalo Chicken wrap. It's very good. Not too spicy, yet there's enough spicy there so the sandwich is not bland.

Soup, sandwich, salad, coffee or tea. Squash soup, so tasty with bacon crumble on top. Get the hand pies!

Came all the way to Seneca from Cambridge UK for a holiday, and I'd definitely come back. Good food, good price and great shop!

Friendly, inexpensive, delicious - what more can you ask for?

Very good food, clean and friendly atmosphere.

Everytime I visit Watkins Glenn I always start my day at Oak Leaf Cafe. The food and coffee is absolutely exquisite. A must have. I always feel like I am being transported into a world created by Tolkien himself.

Great little grocery store and cafe. I frequently stop here when in the area. Normally it's a great experience and I enjoy the Cafe immensely. This time, they really screwed up my order. Gave my wife a chicken wrap, but they didn't even put my chicken wing wrap on the order. The Mocha Javas, which is the main reason I go there, had large chunks of ice and the straws were too small to suck the Java out. I'll probably stop again, but if it's the same ....... it'll be the last time.

Great place for lunch. Delicious Panini's.

Very clean place with friendly staff and good food.

Highly recommend!!! Love the zucchini panini and we tried the zucchini chowder soup ☺️ plus my husband enjoyed his mocha java!

Stopped in for breakfast while camping in Keuka State Park. Amazing fruit smoothies, the raspberry was delicious! Even stopped in again for breakfast the next day for an amazing blueberries and cream latte and French toast for breakfast, as well as a zucchini Panini to go for lunch later in the day. 10/10 Cafe! Great service and lovely atmosphere! Presentation of dishes is also very pretty, even when you order to-go!

Hey nice cafe, had maybe the best BLT sandwich I have had in quite some time, and in the summer, they have a good chicken BBQ

A nice out of the way breakfast and lunch spot. Food was good but meats were bland.

A very quaint cafe and bake shop with a very not so quaint , quite amazing grocery store attached. Food at the cafe was great. Staff were wonderful and the atmosphere was pleasant. Would come back again .

I LOVE it here :) Best coffee in town. The girls are lovely. They are polite, knowledgeable and work really hard! It's always clean and inviting. Good prices. Happy customer here !

Delicious food. Ham & potatoe chowder is so good. Chicken salad sandwich was perfection. Enjoyed the store. Bought alot of goodies. Going to get back there more often.

Honey lavender latte was delicious

We occasionally come to Oak Leaf and order from the menu….. they have a short menu, but it’s the right amount to choose from. I love their Paninis, especially the deli chicken with pesto, hmmmm good. Their homemade soups are also highly recommended. Try to avoid Saturdays as it’s very crowded with “The Lake” crowd. and tourists.🙃

GREAT FOOD. GREAT SERVICE. GREAT PEOPLE.

Very good breakfast choice in the area.

This little store and cafe is always a delightful experience! It’s wildly popular for good reason, always clean and bright and busy! It’s located just a few miles outside of Penn Yan and if you’re going to the Windmill it’s right on your way. The food from the cafe is wonderful, I’m partial to the paninis!

Large variety of fresh baked goods, and Large selection of all types of processed foods. Deli was good 👍. Only a few choices to pick from. Definitely worth a look.

Great spot for breakfast or lunch

It was definitely worth the try,the service and food were really good. Will be going back again soon.

My wife, daughter and I dined in with picky snacks from general store and a fry pie from the bakery, which was the BEST baked good I have ever had. Absolutely delicious. Well done. Very kid friendly which is a must with having a 14 month old.

Good food and service, nice decor. Highly recommend.

Fresh food at a reasonable price and excellent service!

Best place for lunch and breakfast, my favorite! Shopping here is an experience in itself…

Great selection of local produce and prepared foods.

Great food and great atmosphere!

Great grocery store and the food at the Cafe is amazing 👏

Everything was good at the time of our visit

They're subs are out of this world. Fresh homemade. Delicious.