Pie In the Sky - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

We ordered a steak pizza and it was delicious and we had leftovers to eat for dinner later today. Next time we are in Lancaster we'll be back.

PITS is our go to. Same proximity as Two Cousins, Slice of Brooklyn, Vinnys, Pasquales but their prices are better, they are super friendly, and run a clean tight ship. Thanks for always being there for Pizza Wings & Cheesesteaks.

I’ve gone here a few times with my mom and my kids. Today we enjoyed pizza and chicken tenders. My oldest does not usually like pizza , however she said today that this is the BEST pizza ever. I have to agree that the food here is so incredibly good! Everything we have ever had here has been delicious. It’s a great place to sit and have a meal either as a family or alone. They are so kind and great with everything we needed or asked.

We come here for the ice cream. Raspberry soft serve. Yummy

Great people great service and great food

I really like this place. I get cheese steak hoagie which is delicious 😋. They are friendly fast and efficient. They are 1 of 2 pizza shops that I go to.

I been going here since I was 6 years old with my dad. Im 19 now I still go . Great food and if there’s a problem they fix it . Honest place quick and good

This was our first time trying Pie in Sky upon google reviews. I was skeptical and concerned since a number of the reviews on other platforms said that the food was not cooked fully and items were soggy. However, my boyfriend kept saying “it’s likely a spoof, one time thing. When I order, I’ll let them know to cook our pizza a little longer just in case.” We just picked up both pizzas, wings, and fries and I’m appalled by what we got. Our pizzas are not done and ,by not done, I mean there is soft dough in the middle that is not cooked at all! My boyfriend, who is a foodie and way more forgiving than I am, even went and said “I can’t eat this either. Let’s see if we can cook them further in the oven.” Currently, we are cooking both pizzas in the oven. If I wanted to cook my own food, I would have cooked at home. The fries are in the air fryer as they were also not cooked, not seasoned, and tasted like frozen cardboard. The wings we are debating throwing out as they are still pink/raw in the middle. I understand that sometimes things are a little “under done” but this is bad on all levels where nothing was cooked even remotely close to being done. I’m only eating 3 stars for atmosphere and service since my boyfriend relayed everyone was nice and it seemed like a fairly good establishment. I wish I could say we will try them again but this was incredibly disappointing on all fronts with the food that there is nothing redeeming to bring us back.

My order of the shrimp basket was horrible my fries were still frozen and the shrimp was over cooked that I could barely bite it without thinking I was going to break a tooth I would of returned my food but by the time I got it home the place was closed

Food is very good and good prices

Their Strombolis are massive. Really good and shareable.

Family favorite for years. Great food and the entire staff is always going above and beyond to make it a memorable experience for my kids!!!

Excellent find, wonderful food!!! Especially for takeout... 😁 🍕🥤 🤤 👍👌🤙

Great food best pizza in my opinion

Good food great customer service

Garlic knots were delicious and the cheese square pizza is HUGE!

Great food. I mean… GREAT. Staff is very nice. Had our order done quickly and cooked perfectly.

Get the salad and a pepperoni pie.

The meat lovers deep dish is so good they never disappoint

Order here for the very first time traveling around lancaster and was lucky to come upon this great Italian restaurant! We ordered pizza and a calzon it was amazing, so delicious it's a good distance away but so worth it❣️❣️Best Pizza I have had here in PA and I have been here since 1972❣️ Looking forward to trying many more delicious foods they prepare! Hoping they make a true antipasta salad have not had a good one since leaving New York other then making my own😍❤️❣️

What can I say that most others already know. We do order take out from time to time when we're in the area,delicious!! Thank you till next time take care.

the hawaiian pizza is just alright but everything else is absolutely delicious i come here all the time now after work

A great experience very good quality tasting the best thin-crust new york-style pizza at its finest in Lancaster

We love their pizza especially with sausage which is SLICED!!!!! Sooo much better than ground pieces!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️

I cannot say enough good about these guys. Everything is priced competitively with other pizza shops but, their quality and taste excel! The owners/workers are personable and friendly. Any time we want to order food they are at the top of my list!

Great place to order pizza wings and subs, I have been ordering from here for many years now. Thank you

La mejor pizzería sin duda de Lancaster

Had a sausage and onion pizza. Was good but could have used a little more sauce. I dont enjoy a real thin crust. But there's is perfect.

Tired seem everything I go here they screw my order up ask for sub with extra fried onions mayo lettuce they put tomatoes and raw onion another sub lettuce tomatoes mayo they add onions done complaining about screwing up the order cause they don't care

The food is great and friendly service

We love their pizza--Best around!

Very good pizza! Employees are very friendly except the guy with the mets hat! Haha! Joking! They were all great. THANK YOU!

Love this place. Everything I have ever had has been wonderful. Definitely recommend

Delicious Pizza and Subs! Always friendly staff members and quick service. We're happy they're so close by!

Excellent pizza and sandwiches.

Ok place but disappointed in the lack of a lunch special menu. The amount of mushrooms on my slice was overwhelming, can’t believe I’m saying that because I love mushrooms. Staff was not very friendly and a bit loud, so overall a mixed bag at best. Food/Menu: 3.5 Atmosphere: 2.8 Pricing/Value: 4.8

Love, love, love this place. Friendly and more importantly the food is great.

Found this place about 7 years ago next to my mother's neighborhood. Staff is great, food is good and very reasonably priced.

We ordered food didn't get a regular steak sandwich sauce and onions.we would have ate there but we were told that they were going to be closing soon so we got it to go when we got home 20 minutes away I discovered that their was cheese on my steak.i can not have milk products. The magic marker clearly said regular steak no cheese. Make sure you check your food. This could have been a disaster. R.P.S.

The food tastes great and was a very good meal for the price. I left feeling completely full! Everyone working there was very nice. Didn't have to wait very long to get the food either. Would recommend!

My wife and I think they are great!!

Great food and fast service. I order often from here for lunch and never have any complaints and food is always good.

Day after Christmas stopped for a pie. Got the special pizza. Very fresh and all the toppings were delicious. I also love their shop in Strasburg. Excellent chef salad. The owners are really friendly and will make your food your way if you ask, like I do. ;)

I had the sausage pizza is great!!!!

Great place to get ur delicious pizza here there wings are great and I love there onion rings 😊😊😊😊😊😊

My wife and I both wish we had tried years sooner than we did. Excellent pizza every time!

Best pizza and wings I ever had

Good pizza and cheesesteaks. Always pretty fast. Very nice staff.

I’ve passed this place a few times and finally decided to give it a try. It’s hard to beat a place that puts out a solid product for a cheap price. For under $25, we got a dozen garlic knots, a one-topping slice of pizza and a foot long sub with three types of meat. The knots were generously doused in butter, garlic and topped with parm cheese. The sub also lasted two meals for me. Check this place out.

Had not been there for awhile. Staff friendly, pizza was very good with plenty of toppings.

This restaurant is great! I've been here so many times and can say with confidence that this is one of my favorite restaurants in the area. The food is delicious and tasty, and their pizza is just amazing (the best pizza I have ever eat). Customer service is on top.

Great food & the prices are right

Great place to eat, clean great food & family owned & family operated

Great pizza at reasonable cost.

the service was good and the pizza was delicious

The owner is super friendly and will make you feel like family! The pizza and italian cuisine are authentic and delicious 😋

Was recommended this place by a friend at work and wow, what a suggestion! The people were super friendly and the food was amazing! We will be back next time we are in the area!

Excellent tuna sub. Pizza delicious! Will be trying other stuff.

Most disgusting ever. Always good but this is awful n a rip off. Thinking make it right an costs or we are done

My place to go. They are like family to us and know what we want every time we go. Great people.

Very friendly.. food is great, especially the garlic knots!!!!

The Sicilian pizza is terrific. The boneless bar-b-que wings are great; smoky and not too sweet. Fast, friendly service too.

After reading all the great reviews, I was surprised to find this pizza is mediocre at best. If you like cardboard crust covered with lots of toppings, this is the place for you. I like a good crust, however, and this is not even close to being good. Like I said , it’s like cardboard. Will not order pizza from here again. I am interested in trying their other items, however.

One of the best cheesesteaks I’ve had in a long time. And it was cheap too.

BEST PIZZA IN LANCASTER !!!! FINALLY FOUND IT.... MY FAV USE TO BE VINNYS BUT HE RETIRED AND THE PIZZA IS NOT THE SAME AT ALL.....

Good service and good food buffalo chicken cheese steak.

This place seriously has the best Pizza we have ever had! The wings and mozz sticks were also super tasty! Will definitely come back

Got a buffalo chicken cheese steak & a cheeseburger sub. Very satisfied.

Cheese stake was good fries also good over all good food .

This is a hole in the wall with good guys making NY pies! Hearing a New York accent in Lancaster is funny, but you will enjoy good food and good conversation. Not a place you go for atmosphere, but one you should visit if you want a good pie.

Very nice atmosphere, extremely busy... Good customer service.Good food !!

This place is legit New York style pizza...a rarity in Lancaster County. Amazeballs is all I have to say.

Vert clean place, friendly staff and good prices.

The food is all around extraordinary! My personal favorite is the Sicilian pizza

The kindest group of guys and easily the best pizza in all of Lancaster!

Great service, and the staff is friendly, as well as helpful

Great service and food. Keep it up.

Always delicious food and great service. We are regulars here.

Thank you for stuffing us !! Great quick food.

Always a great meal. Owner is real cool! Always busy but always engages. One of our favs.

Pie in the sky was great; food was delicious and Julio corrected doordash's wrong. Looking forward to trying them with the right order next time! We most appreciated the high quality customer service from Julio.

The Sicilian is phenomenal. Thick and heavy crust. Delicious cheese. Mmmmmmmm ... I like sausage and sweet peppers as toppings, but plain cheese is great as well.

There food is excellent! Best cheesesteak..

Food amazing, like ALWAYS! Such good customer service. A FAVE LITTLE SPOT TO GO!

Very good pizza at good prices.

Always outstanding food and quick service

Food is very good, cheesesteaks were great but ham and cheese stromboli fell apart a little too much. It was still delicious though! Staff were friendly as well.

Food there has enormous flavor like a true pizzeria like I used to visit when I was young

Absolutely love this little local pizza/sub shop behind the Turkey Hill on Lampeter Rd. Extensive menu with a few dine-in tables. They are great and fast!!

Pizza was pretty good. Not great, not bad. Seemed to be better a few years ago.

Great pizza and great people! Recommend everything pizza, white pizza with broccoli or classic cheese pizza. Come for the pizza and come back for the great family atmosphere.

We have been eating here for at least 10 years. Fabulous food, friendly staff and fair prices.

Love watching them prepare the food. Always seen to have a smile on there faces... love the PIZZA

These guys are great! Hard working and very consistant great food. 👍

Very friendly staff. Excellent food. But pricey

Great service, GREAT PEOPLE Their Meatlovers pizza is DELICIOUS

Food is well prepared and tasty. Nice menu. Workers are pleasant.

Always a good experience anytime I go there.

This is by far one of the best family run pizza shops in Lancaster county. the food is much like any other pizza place, but the staff make you feel like family. And there is just a ton of love felt when you open those doors.

Great prices and great quality food!