Rehoboth Baking Co - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Lovely modern-rustic-styled restaurant that has a great variety of food. We got pasta, wings, and a couple styles of both pizza and salad. Everything we had was delicious and exceeded our expectations. They also have a good selection of alcoholic and soft drinks as well as a dozen-or-so options for those with a sweet tooth. Edit: They now serve breakfast and coffee! I got the ham, egg, and cheese English muffin sandwich and it is fantastic. They home-make the English muffin and I can honestly say it’s the best bread I’ve had for an English muffin. (They also sell the bread so I’m definitely grabbing some for family out of state 😅)

This was our first time here and we definitely will be back...Staff was so sweet and the food was amazing! The chicken primavera was perfect and the portions are huge. If I could give 10 stars I would

We have always enjoyed our meals here so when I decided to have my husband's birthday party catered I had just seen that Rehoboth Baking Co. caters so decided to give them a shot. I am a last minute party planner so only called the day before and was so happy when they said they could cater. A lot of people had to cancel last minute (it was also Father's Day so totally understandable) but the food was so good everyone had multiple serving and we didn't end up with as much leftover as I thought we would. Our family was so happy to have the leftovers (except our poor daughter who LOVED the Street Corn Dip but that was long gone). Last night was our last night of leftovers and we were so sad. Usually my husband won't even eat leftovers never mind 3 days in a row! I am never cooking for a party again. Rehoboth Baking Company is my caterer now!!

I can’t say enough good things about this restaurant. The service was great, the pizza is the best in the area, and the atmosphere is very chill. New favorite pizza spot in MA.

New fav place. Rarely disappointed.

Found a new morning working spot close to home! Such a hidden gem I almost don’t to leave a good review so I can keep it to myself. The ambience inside is so welcoming with a modern rustic interior design. The people were so nice and accommodating. I had the best ham, egg and cheese on an English muffin that must have been baked in house. Everything in that sandwich was made with love. Good coffee. Good music. Amazing restrooms. Outdoor seating. Glad I found this place!

Finally got the chance to stop into Rehoboth Baking Co. Since the bridge work coming home I usually take 118 out of the way a bit but a nice drive, but anyways I was in the area and they were almost closing up for the day. I asked if they were making pizza's still and told them it would be to go. I go the bar style pizza it was called the mama but it had roni, peppers, and some other delicious toppings. They also have other delicious treats available, will have to come another time. Bonus if your into baked bread this is your place, it all looked tasty. I'm all about a loaf of bread and some oil or butter.

Updated review from 5 to 2 stars I’ve been a customer since they were at the country store. At first it was great, and I’d come very often and promoted it to friends and online. But I’ve noticed the quality keeps going down hill. First it would something small like the cookie or cream puff being so overcooked it would be hard as a rock. Then the pizza would be almost burnt or barely any sauce despite a request for heavy sauce. Tonight, I figured I’d bring some friends as I wanted to sit outside. I was very specific about no peppers on my sandwich. Can’t do them. Got part way through the sandwich & saw the peppers… and a pepper seed. Really have to avoid them. So I gave the rest to the friends.I hate to do this to a place I once loved and went to every other week but that’s where we are at. I was a fan when it was just based out of the country store. I’m an even bigger fan now that they’ve opened the restaurant. Firstly, their pizza is divine. You can get 3 types of crust- bar pizza, New Haven, and Detroit. Each are wonderful and homemade. I also love the red sauce they make which can make or break a pizza; theirs is outstanding. Their sandwiches all come on their homemade bread & again, just delicious. If you have a sweet tooth, I highly recommend their desserts. My favorite is their bread pudding. There is always a steady stream of customers and I can see why. It’s a great place. Everyone who works there is very friendly!

For a baking company the baked goods really sucked, but the pizza was very good.

👍 Inviting atmosphere and delicious food! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

First time here! The 14 CBP (chicken, broccoli, and Parmesan pasta) As were the garlic wings and cheese pizza. Wasn’t disappointed at all. Will return again!

Very nice premium food excellent fresh fresh exciting

Their breakfast food was good. It was the toast that was actually my favorite because they make their bread fresh daily. The cinnamon bun was absolutely delicious and the cream on top was on point. Not too sweet, definitely homemade, and we enjoyed every bite. We will be going back to try their other bakery items and pizza.

The best pizza and pasta you can get anywhere, hands down! Ingredients are fresh. Would highly recommend.

Great fresh food - amazing “ Home cooked” specials and an amazing staff!

I love this spot. Their love for cooking really shows. If you follow them on Instagram, you'll find their specials, which can include a wide variety of different types of food. Stop in for their baked goods. Their cookies are the size of hub caps, and their English muffins are delicious. Pricing can be a little high, but it shows in the quality of the food.

Stopped by for a pizza on the way home (I ordered on the website, which was quick, easy and very user friendly!) I ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza on their thinnest crust, the new haven (they also have a bar style pizza and. Detroit style pizza, which I believe is like a pan or deep dish pizza). Delicious! Pepperoni was nice and spicy, they used fresh mushrooms, not canned. The crust was nice and light and crispy. A winner! Lots of topping choices, they also have other food offerings as well as a breakfast menu. Check out their website for full details and menus. They also offer breads and desserts!

Great Service! Food was very good. Had New Haven pizza, Mozzarella cheese and sauce and Porchetta and Broccoli sandwich.

Cozy spot, super nice staff, yummy treats, good coffee. Glad I made the trip and I'll definitely be back! Looking forward to using the outdoor seating on a warmer day. Thank you!

Friendly atmosphere, food is amazing.

Excellent pizza!!!!!! Bakery treats were also 10/10! Highly recommend!

Best scrambled eggs I've ever had. Probably farm fresh local eggs! Everything is so fresh. No table service but that's not a complaint just a heads-up. Once you order you wait for your name to be called to collect. Very friendly and warm atmosphere. Sticker shock but worth it!

I put in an order for takeout at 11:30 am. I received a voicemail saying they were turning over from breakfast to lunch and the order would be ready at noon. I arrived at noon and food wasn’t ready until 12:40. We were in the area to watch our daughter play a sports tournament and I missed half her game waiting in the restaurant. Then got the food and found my husband’s BLT had no bacon.

One of a kind local treasure. Everything is a 10/10 and artisan.

Local, fresh, homemade DELICIOUS food! Outstanding cinnamon rolls, breakfast sandwiches, pizza, sandwiches. Can’t go wrong with any item on the menu. Beautiful indoors with great decor too.

Great place for pizza and baked goods

Paul makes a hell of breakfast sandwich, let me tell you what. Everything you’d want it be on a homemade English muffin. But, now, can he make a biscuit….?!

Wonderful spot! So happy I finally found a place that sells real homemade sourdough loaves. They are delicious! I tried the pizza and desserts so far, both really good. Little on the pricey side but everything is homemade with good quality ingredients so its worth it! A must visit!

Enjoyed my visit. Clean, very friendly place. Enjoyed the Smash Burger Special. Soooo good. You can tell they live what they do. Everything tasted fresh. Will def go back. Decided to take home a fresh cookie. Huge cookie. Lol

Rehoboth Baking Company is hands down the best place in the area. When we found out this was opening and they had pizza we would’ve been so happy even if it was just decent, considering we live 5 minutes away and the food options in the area are awful. Decent is an understatement. This place is amazing. We have had everything from the different pizzas, (highly recommend the pepperoni bar pie) sandwiches, wings, etc. and all have been outstanding. When we found out they were doing breakfast too we almost couldn’t believe it. Just like the rest of the food all breakfast items we have tried are 10/10. Don’t skip out on the freshly baked bakery items too!

Dillyo pizza was mad great. Our table was slightly rocky/tippy. Did not try the espresso, but will next time. They don't have espresso martinis tho. Very nice people behind the counter. Thanks. See ya later. Edit 1.8.24 - The owner is illogical and rude. Won't be back. Edit 2.9.25. - I believe you didn't see my previous edit. My wife sent an email dec 28th. Would appreciate a response to that.

Finally found great pizza in this area! The New Haven style pizza is insanely good and the chicken parm sub was excellent. Highway recommend

First time trying the New location for Rehoboth Baking Co. Previous experience was at the old location and it did not go as well. I ordered ahead online this time and picked it up at 4pm. Very happy to see that it was ready to go when I got there. Went with a New Haven style Meat sweats without the meatball and an order of their garlic wings. The pizza was very good overall. A little light on toppings, a little greasy, not too bad. Wings were well seasoned. Not as garlicky as I hoped for. Still worth a try. Pizza gets a 7.8/10.

If you like a nice thick crust, the Detroit is your pie. We have been ordering from here and love their fresh made pies. The bakery items will make your mouth water. The fresh made breads, desserts and cookies....the cookies!!! So glad this place is within walking distance. Very friendly staff and cute dining area.

First time customer and had a wonderful experience. Pepperoni Pizza, Buffalo Pizza and dined in. Then had a takeout loaf of bread, soup and two desserts. Everything was amazing. No leftover pizza, came home and ate the bread and the desserts. My daughter, a12yo pepperoni pizza connoisseur, said it’s the best pepperoni pizza she’s ever had. Will be our new go-to spot!

Fantastic pizza. It's hard to find any other pizza to even compare to this around Attleboro/Rehoboth

Amazing pizza! Will be back very soon!

We first noticed Rehoboth Baking Co on Instagram and thought the food looked delicious. So we made the trek and we are very glad we did. Fantastic pizza. Great atmosphere. And the service was remarkably friendly. We ordered one pizza from each of the three crust styles and they were all wonderful. Perfect blend of chewy crispy crust. I normally don’t eat my crust but this time I couldn’t stop. The kids all had a great time as well and my son declared “this is the best cheese pizza ever”. We will be back.

The people there are all very nice. The food is delicious. But I ordered online a few hours early and set a pick up time for later in the day. When I showed up the restaurant was not busy. People came in after me and left before me. I waited 20 minutes past my pick up time for my food. And ps it was only 2 appetizers. Not a huge order. Kind of unacceptable

Great place, very friendly staff and amazing food!

1st visit here Had a Meatball sandwich . A little different from most. Maybe next time I ll try a Pizza. The fresh baked bread looked mighty fine.

Amazing place all around and don't forget dessert!

Ordered last night for the first time, my friend got a sandwich and I got a Cobb salad with chicken. ($20 for the salad) it was TINY and there were barely any chicken or toppings. Also, forgot the dressing. My friends sandwich was just okay, she also paid $20 for that! We decided we will give it one more chance and next time will try the pizza. Was really hoping this was going to be my new “go to” in town. Disappointing!

Everything I've ever gotten has been superb! I absolutely LOVE the English muffins! I stock up when I go and treat myself to the wonderful pastries.

Great place to eat,and the waiting pin was hilarious 😂 all the staff were very kind and there was a great environment highly recommend for family members

First let me start good, pizza was phenomenal! Wait.. long (1 hour for take out) Hours.. night only, more of a pizza joint then a full on bakery. I thought the pizza was overpriced for the size you get. Detroit style is $20 and has two slices, enough for 1!! That’s a huge disappointment and not worth another purchase. Sorry guys, great taste and I can deal with the wait and only ordering in evenings. But won’t recommend until you give more pie for the price

What a great spot! Delicious food, great service, and an awesome atmosphere, make sure to check it out!!

The staff were very friendly, the pizza was excellent (good amount of options on top of being able to choose from 3 different crusts), and the overall atmosphere was great. Definitely will be going back! 🍕 **don’t mind the bite taken out of the slice already, couldn’t help myself!🤣

Excellent pizza that beats competition anywhere near and with a pizzeria right down the street you know they’re good..

Great place. So glad they are open. Nice impressive pizza.

The north Rehoboth/ Attleboro area has been waiting a long time for some great pizza. Aside from delicious pizza (Bar pies, New Haven and Detroit Style), they have great sandwiches, desserts and baked goods.

The pizza is next level good. Everything made to order. The inside and back patio are a great vibe. Place is going to explode with popularity. The owner/bartender was the nicest guy and was so appreciative. Will be our new Friday spot.

All I can say is WOW. Hands down, the best Pizza I have ever had. It is evident that the finest ingredients are used.

I have tried this place a few times and so far everything has been AMAZING. Pizza, wings, ribs, whoopie pies, etc. I can't wait to try more! This is definitely a hidden gem that everyone needs to try!

Our first visit at the Baking co. Very friendly and inviting. We ordered rolls and cookies for Christmas and can't wait to try them. I tried the tiramisu and it was great. We will be back for sure. Glen A.

This is a little place for take out. It is out of a place that is a converted space next to the home (basically the back of a garage, but good lord don't let that stop you!) The most incredible things are created here. The pizza is to die for. The sauce and mix of cheeses alone are fantastic but then the dough that is the pizZA crust is so good, my mouth is watering just thinking of it. Desserts, and other things for the holidays too. If you go, you will NOT be disappointed! (Now I feel like I need to go!😉)

Hidden gem tucked in the back of a massive barn/garage in a residential neighborhood of Rehoboth. Food is fantastic - we have found our new pizza place. The crust was crisp but chewy in all the right ways. The cheese blend was perfect. Carry-out only, but when you visit, you will see that that is the point. All ingredients used were premium and fresh. The cookies are enormous and deliciously crispy around the edges and soft and chewy in the center. The owners are friendly and good for conversation while you wait. And trust me, it is worth the wait. I love the idea of Rehoboth Baking Company and am extremely glad that places like this exist. We will absolutely become regular customers.