Scott's Deli in Holmes Beach - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great Food and Fast Delivery! I got my food in just under 30 minutes. The food was great :) 10/10 Recommend.

My son has carried a Scott’s Deli reward card around for 3 years, which was his last time on the island. The reward card was for Buy 9 sandwiches and get the tenth free. Three years ago he purchased 5 sandwiches, leaving 4 more sandwiches to purchase to get a free sub. We ordered many sandwiches this year, totaling over $140.00. When he presented the card to the woman helping him she said she would have to check with Scott himself to see if he would honor the card. She checked with him and was told his reply was, “It’s no longer number of sandwiches purchased, but number of visits. You would get a stamp for each visit.” They would not honor the reward card. I think them giving us one free $12.00 sub would be way less costly to them than the money they will be losing from us and everyone I tell about the very poor customer service. We can pay for the sub, that’s not the point. Reward cards are fun, especially if they are from a favorite vacation destination. We vacation on AMi every single July. Trust me, Scott’s Deli will NEVER get another cent from us. I would urge everyone to avoid Scott’s Deli and not reward his horrible customer service!!

Great little deli that serves delicious sandwiches loaded up!

Scott was amazing great food been here a week and this was my first fulfilling meal.

We ordered lunch for about family, and Scott’s Deli delivered right to us on the beach! It was such a great option for lunch on our last day of vacation because we had depleted our fridge supply in order to check out. The food from Scott’s was delicious and fresh and amazing!

Complete rip off. $12.95 for a mediocre sandwich. Comes with nothing. Do yourself a favor and eat at any sandwich chain to save 50%. Quality will be the same.

I should have taken a picture! Scott's Deli was recommended to us when we came last November, and we stopped in several times. Here again in July, and they are just as good. The street taco's are excellent!

We had 7 girls come to Scott’s Deli as soon as they opened. They were super friendly and got our food out fast. That was the BEST bacon, egg & cheese bagel I have ever had. Several others got Avacado sandwiches and the Avacado was to die for! Highly recommend!!

What a great little deli! This place is a hidden gem. The menu is has breakfast sandwiches, regular deli sandwiches, salads and tacos. Our group ordered the club, turkey and avocado, the Italian, potato salad, Miss Vicky’s spicy dill pickle chips and a tropical smoothie. The portions are large. The sandwiches were all delicious. The potato salad was also very good. The smoothie was yummy. Definitely recommend this place.

I ordered a BLT, something simple because I'm traveling, and honest to God it was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had in my whole life. I wolfed it down too quickly to take a Pic of it but perfect ratio of ingredients and everything was fresh and yummy and crisp. Also got the Strawberry Mango popsicle which I enjoyed as a dessert afterwards as well

Best sandwiches EVER!!!!! Totally unexpected! After eating the best sandwich of my life, my expectations were high for the homemade snickers, but was let down. Don’t bother with the snickers and you’ll be golden.

Hot Beef! Awesome!! Thank you!!!

Best sandwich I’ve ever had!! Super fresh ingredients with great taste! Slammed full of meat and toppings. It’s a MUST

Could not have been more pleased about Scott’s Deli! It was my first visit to Anna Maria Island and was enjoying the beach too much to venture out for food. I called Scott’s and the customer service over the phone was incredibly friendly and helpful! I ordered a custom wrap, chips, pasta salad, drink, 2 tacos (for later that night), and a slice of key lime. The delivery right to my hotel was fast and friendly! It was such a great service to be able to enjoy their food right on the beach! The food was excellent! Fresh and delicious! Thank you for helping to make my first visit to AMI so memorable!

I have eaten there twice. Both were really good. One time was a Cuban sandwitch. The other was recommended by casher and was really good.

We were in the area on vacation and decided to stop in. I am so glad we did! The sandwiches were some of the best I have ever had! The atmosphere was really cool. The service was fast and friendly. The perfect place to stop for a quick bite when visiting the beach. I can't wait to come back!

Cool little sandwich spot as we came down to AMI! Great Cuban sandwich as well!

Bahn mi wrap and pastrami sandwich were so good! Excellent service to the beach!

We have gone to the island for years and am so glad we found this place. We got the turkey and bacon avacado sandwich and it was absolutely delicious! We will be back! Dont miss this place! Great service and great food!

This is the best place for lunch on AMI. The Korean pork tacos are so delicious. They have great sandwiches as well and they often have good dessert bars.

I have been raving about the sandwiches from Scotts deli delivered to beach. We have ordered many times and loved. We tried to order 10 sandwiches but was told they don't deliver past cortez Bridge. We even said we would meet closer but said no real bummer ! You have lost our buisness .

The "Coquina" is probably the best sandwich I have ever had. 11/10

I tell you what for a little sandwich shop on the island this place blew my tastebuds out the water. Friendly staff, fantastic sandwiches serviced to us in about 5-8 minutes after ordering. Supposedly they mentioned they will deliver to you on the beach if you order delivery which is pretty neat but we just did carry out

2024 Update: Just another fantastic meal from Scott's Deli. Rode the bicycle to pick up two sandwiches, great pasta salad and two fantastic desserts. This is one of those places that ALWAYS requires a visit when we are on AMI. Should probably try something new but the pastrami is just so good. Not from NY so I might not be a legit judge for NY Pastrami but I think it is a great sandwich. This was our second time trying Scott's. It had been a year and my wife tried her first bit of pastrami at Scott's on our first visit. She didn't want a whole pastrami sandwich so went with the Cuban. I am a Cuban sandwich fan and thought she might not like it since she typically doesn't like pork roast or chops. I'm used to thicker slices of roasted pork on a Cuban but the thin slices along with other ingredients had her commenting that she liked THIS pork even though she would still not want a pork chop anytime soon. My NY Pastrami was wonderful. And two small orders of pasta salad were a nice touch. My wife really likes the pasta salad as it does not have onions which really affects her stomach. Even in a tiny sized deli container there were halved cherry tomatoes included. A nice touch for such an overlooked side dish. And the best part was we didn't even get up from our beach chair. Called it in and put a tip on the card so when the sandwiches were delivered, there was no business to handle in the sand. Just make room on the lounge chair and start enjoying the food. Since then we plan out how many days relaxing on the beach during lunch and which day we order Scott's.

Excellent little sandwich shop had it early one afternoon on vacation, food was great ready fast staff was friendly.

Very impressed with the quality of the ingredients used, and the care taken is preparing the food. Pricing is reasonable. This may be the best overall 'value' on the island. The menu is packed with great options, but don't make your decision too quickly as you scroll down. The street tacos at the end are amazing. It is so nice to have an option like this on AMI, where the food quality of so many restaurants has plummeted while the prices have soared. It is obvious that the folks at Scott's care about the flavor, quality, and presentation of their product. 5 stars!

The sandwich was good but not mind blowing. I think because it was hyped up so much to me, I was expecting something different. But, it was tasty and hit the spot after an afternoon in the sun. Delivery to the beach is a huge bonus.

Great sandwich spot with unique menu. Better than the national shops. Had the NY style pastrami and it was great! Buffalo chicken wrap was chicken salad style as opposed to deep fried.

Scott’s Deli is hands down the greatest establishment to ever exist on Anna Maria island, I ate there almost daily when I worked on the island and NEVER had a bad experience, the service is impeccable, the staff is literally the best group of humans I’ve ever met and Scott himself is the greatest of all time, he makes the best food ever! I recently moved to New York and still have yet to find a sandwich that tops Scott’s Deli!

Everything was very good ..No pickles are served there? Pickles usually are served or offered with most deli sandwiches

Always have an excellent experience when I stop in to get lunch while on my lunch break! Never disappointed

Beyond delicious, all the sandwiches are super tasty, can’t go wrong with any of them. Owners are great, can’t say enough nice things. Please stop by when you’re on the island, you won’t regret it.

Excellent service. Looking for a guy who offered a stranger a home when needed.me.ty if ur there.im coming to thank you personally

Small deli. Bought a coke and a water.

Absolutely delicious and fresh sandwiches. Service was fast and staff was very friendly!

Pleasantly surprised to find an amazing deli in AMI. Was so good we came back for seconds. People were very friendly, carry out order was timely, and food was amazing. The dessert were unique and good also! Highly recommend Scott’s and will be coming back next year!

We had the Pineapple taco special and a steak philly sub. Both were delish! Fresh ingredients, and perfectly prepared. They said the pineapple salsa was incredible, and indeed it was.

My husband LOVES their Chicago dog

Great sandwiches, unique menu items. 10 person group.

Amazing food and choices! Loves everything I have tried! The key lime pie was amazing and the kitchen sink cookie was huge!

Ordered a cheesecake (Chocolate/Vanilla) swirl and it was sooo good and very reasonable. A real treat for Thanksgiving. Also their individual treats eg Brownies, etc are amazing. Make sure you stop and support this great business.

We've been on Anna Maria Island for two weeks and had lunch three times at Scotts Deli. The food is so fresh and delicious we just couldn't resist it. We had the hot tacos, the korean and banh mi style both of which are so flavoursome with so much meat in each one it was a struggle to finish them We also had the chicken Banh Mi wrap and again it was so lovely and fresh and packed full of meat. The home made key lime pie was to die for, I've of the best I've had in Florida. We would highly recommend this place and the staff are so friendly too. Best food we've had on the Island.

We really wanted to love this place! The service was aloof, the staff has their own tv and was watching a show? Never seen that before, and they seemed much more intent on socializing than guest service. The sandwich was good, not the huge pics we've seen on other reviews. I made the mistake of using the bathroom, which is filthy, and had to walk past a mop room that was also filthy. Restaurants that don't keep their bathrooms clean, I just don't get. It appeared to be a ship without a captain.

I had the NY Pastrami. I think scott need to go to ny and have a Pastrami sandwich. It was the most tasteless thing i ever had.

By far the best sandwich shop we have visited. Plenty of food, the taste is great. We stop every visit.

Had the coquina. Best sandwich ever. Our whole family loved their sandwiches. Quick service at a hidden gem.

Wow very good ,Create your own or off the Menu wide selection sandwichs and Tacos or Hot dogs you won't be disappointed my opinion.

Fantastic food at a great price and super friendly staff

This place was awesome! The sandwich was really tasty. I was very happy with this last-minute stop for food!

Called in an order for pick up, was told 10-15 minutes. Arrived 15 minutes after calling, then stood and waited for 15 minutes for them to make my order. Then they forgot 1 of my 5 items which fortunately I caught before driving away. Also it's overpriced for the portions.

Amazing food!!! Everything we got was so delicious especially the Korean tacos. So glad we found this recommendation!

Delicious and fresh sandwiches—loved the selection here. Very friendly service. Highly recommend.

Scott’s deli is super legit. The roast beef sandwich is ridiculously good and a few the other sandwiches. I’ve had there have been just as tasty. I always end up back at the roast beef sandwich though. It is so so good. This place is a staple on the island. Definitely check it out if you’re in the area.

We ordered sandwiches to be delivered to the beach two days in a row, and both days they couldn’t have been more delicious!! Everyone should get Scott’s Deli while in AMI, you will not be disappointed!!!

We ordered sandwiches from the beach, and they delivered them right to where we were sitting! Sandwiches were really good and had plenty of meat and veggies! 10/10

Absolutely delicious club sammich

This place has the BEST deli sandwiches!!! I've tried several and have loved them all, but my absolute favourite is the Coquina - it's got the perfect blend of savoury and sweet, I've never had anything quite like it! I've also tried the Roast Beef Melt, the Cuban and the BBQ Beef sandwiches - all to die for. The tacos and desserts are also fantastic - super fresh and you get great portions. The cheesecakes are some of the best I've had (better than many bakeries out there!!!). I'd highly recommend Scott's Deli to anyone looking for a super tasty lunch on the island - AND they deliver to the beach!

The sandwiches are out of this world!! Well worth it.. Delicious!!

Update: 8 months later- still one of my favorite lunch spots. Literally everything is so good. I'm a local manatee county resident and I work on Anna Maria. This food is top tier. You can eat it for lunch and it actually replenishes your energy rather than slowing you down. The bbq turkey ranch wrap is incredible. Definitely my lunch break spot.

Don’t skip getting a sandwich here while on AMI. So dang good.

OMG...I couldn't say enough about the flavor of the food here. The service is so friendly with a hometown feel. I would eat here everyday if I could.

We ordered Scott’s Deli for a lunchtime party with friends and it was an absolute hit! We were hosting old friends and wanted to have time to relax while eating good food, and Scott’s made it a breeze. I called them and asked for an assortment of their most popular sandwiches and they were all great with quality ingredients. The delivery arrived on time, too.

Tiniest and most over priced gluten free sandwich I’ve ever eaten…$16.50 for hardly a meal. The picture is half the sandwich. I’m sure if you’re getting regular bread it’s more worthwhile…

Awesome sandwiches, delivered to us on the beach!

I got the Manatee Muffaletta, and it was incredible! It's definitely a hidden gem that everyone should go to.

Fantastic food, and incredibly friendly staff. Definitely worth the visit.

I wish we knew about this place when we first got here! Great food, lovely outdoor area, especially if you have a baby. I’d highly recommend!

Great Italian sub. Brought quickly to the beach. Highly recommend

This place is the realio dealio. Bomb tacos? Check. Amazing sandwhiches? Check. Yummy wraps? Check. Fast and friendly service? CHECK. Literally anything you get from here will be great, the prices are reasonable for the amount of food you get, and they'll serve you with a smile. Don't leave the island without trying Scott's!

Best sandwiches on the island. Staff is super friendly. Scott's pies are out of this world

Hands down Best Philly! Added Jalapeno and best I've had!

Very good variety, great food, and a 15 second walk from my office!!

The BBQ beef is fantastic. I don’t know how you could give this place a bad review. Will 100% be back again when I’m on Anna Maria!

This deli is amazing. Everything I’ve ordered from here is great. My favorite sandwich is the HB Italian beef which I really recommend you try.

FedEx approved 👍 roast beef melt was one of the most flavorful sandwiches I’ve ever had.

Holy freaking WOW. I'm a sandwich connoisseur and holy f- bombs these are next level amazing. I couldn't get enough. There Royale and the Coquina are bonkers. Awesome friendly and appreciative staff too. I was fema Hurricane Ian clean up crew. Thank you!!

Friendly staff. Great Italian sandwich! Highly recommend.

Out here getting power restored and just as we were starving these amazing people made our day with some delicious sandwiches water and chips #thankyou #scottsdeli Great food and even better people. #GodBless

We had friends come to the island halfway through our vacation. They had never been there. I called very early to set up delivery and let me say.. They were there right on the dot.. Not a minute late. The food was delicious 😋. We will order again and again

Good food. A little pricey but you do get a lot of food for your money.

Das Steak and Egg Sandwitch war der Hammer. Besitzerin ist auch total nett gewesen. Auf jeden Fall einen Besuch wert.

Tacos were great! Delivered straight to our hotel!

Best meal on AMI The food is absolutely fantastic, the AMI Philly Steak sandwich is one of the finest made cheesesteaks I have ever tried. Excellent service and a great atmosphere.

Had the best vegetarian sandwich! The ingredients were super fresh and the bread tasted homemade. It's nice to know there's somewhere to get a good veggie sandwich that's not Publix. The service was fast and friendly! Can't wait to try their breakfast sandwiches.

Very refreshing cold and hot sandwich would recommend to anyone

New location - good sandwiches!

Scotts is a must stop while on the island. This is the only food I've had during my stay that I genuinely left satisfied after eating. The food was delicious and filling. The best Cuban Ive had. And the cheesecake was next level. The crust was perfect. Next time I'm on the island Scotts gets my lunch money all week!

Amazing roast beef melt and philly. this place is definitely worth looking at.

Recommended by local marina tour guide and WOW! The food was outstanding, full of flavor and tasteful balance.

Great tasting food just perfect

Good subs if you’re not that hungry, just a few pieces of meat in the sub- I guess the reason could be the supply and demand, since other reviews are good. Overpriced

Awesome quality local deli, soooo good! And the smoothies are deliciously refreshing too!!

The Club sandwich is stacked high with meat.

Mandy was extremely patient, friendly, and understanding when placing a difficult 7 sandwich order for delivery to the beach. Great customer service!

This place was really good! They have great gluten-free options as well as some other healthier and even vegan choices. They’re really unique with their sandwiches and everything was very tasty!

Came back at least 5 more times on our one week trip. Eggless during breakfast and Coquina for lunch (or breakfast) are must trys and BBQ pork/philly are also great!

Excellent Italian sandwich with alot of meat and ingredients. The chicken street tacos are also delicious! We are planning on trying something from the breakfast menu tomorrow morning.

Amazing sandwiches and friendly staff! Can't wait to come back.

First time here. As some have said, a bit obscure location. But certainly worth finding Scott's. I'm a big fan of Poppo's on Pine Ave but these street tacos are amazing. Got out grocery store salsa to add but when I tasted mine, I realized that the taste and sauce they crafted would be diminished by adding anything. Better get to this place before the feeding frenzy on AMI makes it impossible to get in!

We had Scottis deli do a taco bar for our family who was visiting from Maine. The service and quality of the food was 10 out of 10. This is the second time I’ve had catering done by Scott and his team. I highly recommend them.