Stay Sweet Bakery & Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

First time there. Great service, great atmosphere. Will be back.

My husband and I absolutely love Stay Sweet!!! We eat there all the time! The grill food is amazing and the ice cream and desserts they offer are top tier! They even did our bride and groom cakes for our wedding! The staff there are so great and very friendly! They feel like family now! :D Absolutely recommend Stay Sweet to everyone I met!!!

I ordered a couple dozen cupcakes and cake pops for an event and our guest absolutely loved them. The banana pudding cupcakes actually had pudding and a sliced banana in the center of the cupcake. They have a large variety to choose from and I can vouch for the banana pudding, key lime, strawberry, and cookies & cream cupcakes all being yummy. I highly recommend Stay Sweet Bakery!!!

I told my husband to get me something sweet. He surprised me with some cookies and a cheesecake slice. I did like the cookies but there was a weird aftertaste. I did however really enjoyed the chocolate and vanilla cheesecake. Rich, creamy and decadent.

Searched for the best milkshake in Goldsboro, NC. Not disappointed! The owner was very gracious and the staff gave excellent service. We'll be back.

Great place for any age. Servers courteous and always smiling. Best homemade cake, cupcakes, cookies, and all flavors of dip ice cream. Highly recommended...

Love their ice cream and friendly service

Absolutely phenomenal every time we go! The kids love it! There is a wide variety of treats and grill food. The service will not disappoint either. I have never seen an employee or the owner without a smile. The sweets are wonderful, but my favorite is their pickle fries! This takes frying pickles to a different level 🤯 10/10 hands down!

Friendly staff, fun atmosphere and great food! Always a treat at STAY Sweet!

This is such a nice eatery and bakery, friendly staff, very good food, hang out as long as you want.

Very good grill type food and excellent desserts!! Highly recommend this restaurant!!!!!

I absolutely love this hole in the wall! The ice cream is delicious and I can't wait to stop back for the soup next! Plenty of toys for kids to play with, food to eat, and merchandise to wear. If you're on this side of town you have to stop in!

yummy ice cream! they have the Hershey tub flavors 😍 big scoops, good price, and nice service

Super fun place to bring kids. A little bit of everything to do. Great service!

Good ice cream/cookie dough. I tried both and asked the staff if they could put it in the same cup (I’m paying for both separately), and they told me they couldn’t. There’s no need to be so robotic, just help me out so I can enjoy two flavors at the same time! lol

I had the hot dog it was great except the chili was a bit sweet, guess for the kids and can get ice cream and other items for the sweet treat but not the chili, other than that the place was awesome the kids seem to enjoy it so that's nice, not many places welcome kids like they do many toys to play with!

Absolutely love this place! Our daughter loves all the toys and games to play there. Food is great!

The owners arw amazing, the other employees as well. They always have a wonderful selection of baked goodies. And the SOUP. The best!!!

Messed up my order then was very rude when I asked for the food to be replaced and done correctly

What's not to like about ice cream and sweets. Maybe the calories. Otherwise yum yum. They also have food. That day didn't have any but it did look good on other people's plate. Small area for kids to play. Unique idea in a restaurant.

Today, my family and I went to stay sweet. I had only been one other time, and I believe that was a few years ago. As soon as we walked in, we could feel the hospitality and it was so nice to feel like our kids were just as welcome! They have a whole section for the kids to play and have fun! As a mother to all boys, sometimes it’s hard to feel like my kids are welcome to places. But not here! It is so family oriented. Don’t even get me started on the actual treats themselves! The selection was amazing! Cupcakes, ice cream, cake pops & so so much more! This is definitely a place that we WILL be going back to and I’m confident we will make this a go to for our family for years to come!

This quaint local restaurant is kid friendly as well as gluten and dairy free friendly. The food is delicious and plentiful. You order at the counter and there is ample seating. I highly recommend this restaurant.

This hidden gem is worth finding . Located a bit in the country but worth the drive. The employees are always delightful , as are the treats and sweets. A nice environment that me and the family love going to regularly!

Honestly, places like this and people like this aren't the norm anymore. Every person working there was so warm and helpful! The food was delicious and creative. The atmosphere was welcoming and family friendly. We can't wait to go back!

Excellent selection and great kids area. Grill is good too!

We had a really nice experience. The food was good, quick and the desserts were delicious. We'll definitely be back.

What a great restaurant! They have places for the kids to play while you eat. They are excellent with gluten free and allergen options including vegan ice cream. If you nearby, you should give this place a try. The food will not disappoint!

Great family friendly stop! Loved their goodies.

What's not to love? Over 24 flavors of Hershey brand ice cream, incredible fresh cookies, cakes, cinnamon rolls, etc plus burgers, hot dogs, play area for the kids and plenty of seating

Love this place. Clean, great service.

Ice cream was a little pricey(almost $12 for 2 double dip waffle cones) and a tad soft for dipped ice cream. Food is excellent. Service was friendly.

Thank y'all so much for your service! EveryTHING IS ALWAYS DELICIOUS and FRESH!!! SOME OF THE BEST PEOPLE I KNOW❤️

Delicious food, friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere. What else could you ask for, love this place.

Fantastic service and good food & great ice cream. Very friendly staff!

Love this place for their whipped icing cupcakes and banna pudding ice cream. They are also kid friendly.

Great place to eat and get awesome ice cream! Great people.

Has a wonderful variety of cupcakes! Cupcakes are always perfection. Hard to choose between the cookies and cream and the mocha/vanilla cupcakes as a favorite so you should try both!

A hidden gem in Wayne County! My family and I stopped in for a sweet treat today. This is a lovely location that is extremely clean. The owners took time to chat with us and tell us the beautiful story behind this local business. I encourage you to go hear the story for yourself, as I am sure, you will be blessed. On this first trip of many, we had ice cream and a cupcake. They were both excellent. We look forward to returning soon.

This place is amazing! Placed an order for cakepops and dipped marshmallows for a baby shower last week. They were a hit at the shower. Also grabbed a BLT and hot chips for lunch, simply delicious. Highly recommend!

This was a very family friendly bakery and ice cream shop. They have such a large variety of goodies that are absolutely delicious! Plus this place is also a grill serving bugers, dogs, soup and sandwiches and more...we are definately going back. The prices were great. Food was made to order.

Great ice cream shop. Lots of selections and very kid friendly

Beautiful, clean, family environment. Food and desserts are superb!!! The customers very well taken care of and I will definitely be back in the very near future !!!!💜💜💜💜💜

Nice quiet ma and pa ice cream parlor. We found this gym over a year ago. To this day we enjoy bringing our children . To play with the toys while eating there meal and ice cream

Great food, ice cream and treats. Clean and very friendly.

I love this place. Cupcakes are delicious. Clean and bright. Friendly staff. I can’t wait to bring the grandkids. Reasonable prices.

Fantastic burgers! The strawberry cake is my favorite

Always great kids love to play with the toys there too

This place is always so lively and full of energy! Very welcoming. Best place for milkshakes. The bakery is always decorated according to holidays and seasons. Consider inside the store as EYE CANDY.

Chili is on point, great soups and desserts 🍨.

Best Gourmet Cupcakes and huge variety of ice cream flavors that make perfect milkshakes!!

Super friendly staff. I had hot dogs and French fries and soda. My family got Hershey ice cream. Great atmosphere. Glad we went.

Customer is always wonderful and the sweets are amazing 😋

Great food great people awesome service!! We love this place!!

Prices are way too high. Foods good but expensive for a small business.

They have great food the people are nice 👍

Great place to stop in after a hot summer day. Huge variety of flavors and the sweets are great! Perfect for the kids with plenty of room to play as well!

My favorite dessert shop to go to! Their burgers are the best!

First visit today with my girls, I thought it was neat, clean, and cozy. We ordered cupcakes and icecream. 2 scoops of ice cream were like 3 scoops. Decently priced, as well. I will be back to visit.

Loved it very very friendly staff and the ice cream was awesome I'll definitely be going back for sure

So many choices and they all look so good

Good hotdogs, soft buns, crispy onion rings & fresh fountain drinks. Good prices

Great ice cream shop with many flavors for cones and cups. Drinks, cookies, play area with toys and stuff for the smaller kids. Great young staff friendly and knowledgeable.

Great food. Burgers are delicious. Love the family feel. Ice cream and fresh cookies are amazing. My wife says the cupcakes 🧁 are some of the best.

we come here all the time, love it. great food wonderful people :)

Always a pleasure to get my sweet tooth fix from here

This place is so charming! Love the atmosphere. The workers are sooo nice and attentive! Cupcakes, ice cream, and cookies are always yummy here! I'm working my way around the menu. Banana split is next.

Ice cream is more expensive than anywhere else I have found.

Very nice place and friendly staff. Food is always excellent

Very nice non-chain, family-owned business. Burgers, hot dogs, chicken strips, sandwiches, ice-cream, and other American style dishes. Good quality and good prices. If you're hungry, go check it out. Freshly brewed ice tea !!

Great little ice cream shop! Their cupcakes are also really good.

The atmosphere was wonderful and the desserts were delicious. This was my first time and I will definitely be back. The strawberry Cupcake with strawberry icing was my favorite. I also tried the cotton candy ice cream.

Great sweets but don't forget their fantastic burgers. Hidden secret in Goldsboro but shouldn't be!

My daughter and I visited here at the beginning of the pandemic. I’m just now writing a review because we haven’t had any cupcakes to top theirs yet. My daughter has been raving about the brownie she had. We will be visiting again very soon, hopefully this weekend. The cupcakes are moist and delicious. I really enjoyed the maple bacon and strawberry. I’m going to give their cheeseburger a try as well. Friendly customer service. Definitely worth the try!

First, this is an excellent place to visit with children! I ordered cupcakes for my daughter to take to school for her birthday and they were Excellent! They looked perfect and they were exactly what I ordered and even more importantly ...they were so tasty! The cake was very moist! I will definitely come back here. Expectations exceeded.

Amazing food and great atmosphere. Madelyn was so sweet and helped me so much. Would come back for her alone!

Great food and service! Everything has been tasty so far, above what you might expect. Got a piece of cake to go with a moldy berry and next time I went back, I told them about it hoping for a free piece or at least a discount. Was not only informed that new procedures have been put in place to prevent that from happening, but they also comped my whole meal. Highly recommend

Love all the goodies and food! The staff are as nice as can be!

Having at&t to help in the parking lot and amazing ice cream..... bonus.

Amazing home baked goodies & Ice Cream! Super nice people.

Had lunch. Chicken salad sandwich with fries, it delicious! 👍❤️😁

Great food, a fun and friendly atmosphere, and my kids love to go there!!!

Love this place 😊 very kid-friendly...so many things to do for the kids! Ice cream was very delicious!! Will definitely be back soon 🧡

Folks are nice and servings are good, then there's the Hersheys ice cream!

Absolutely the sweetest owners. If you want a fresh, delicious cupcake or even something from the grill. COME HERE! You’re treated like family :)

Awesome service. Great ice cream. Kid friendly.

Just visiting from MA and stopped in with my daughter and granddaughters. This is a very nice place to stop for a great variety of ice cream and pastries, run by some very friendly folks.

Love the flavors of this place. Lots of flavors to choose from! Cant go wrong. Will definitely return!

Was a great experience great service and great ice cream will be back!!!!

Amazing customer service, delicious Hershey brand ice cream that was fresh and delicious with a wide variety of flavors, cones and toppings. Today was my first time going and I would definitely go back. I got a kid size and it was the perfect portion. Wonderful location and other gifts available for purchase. Not to mention right next door to a CashPoint free ATM and a Circle K.

Love this place. Great grill. Ice cream and Bakery is great. Huge selection. Dine in, take out, or drive thru. Your choice.

The food and customer service are impeccable in this place! Cute little stop.

Got a burger combo today. Was sooo good, and love that chili is an offered topping. Great price, great food, thanks!

Its a very nice place to get ice cream and they also have food and it is very good i would recommend this place to everyone and the staff is very friendly and nice

Best place in town for burgers and ice cream. I go here all the time. Goldsboro's hidden secret. If you are looking for a delicious burger this is the place! Their grill menu offers a lot of variety. French fries are so fresh and crispy each time! I love to treat myself to an ice cream cone afterwards.

Always great service......and ice cream!

Very clean, good selection of ice cream, people were nice and polite

This was my first time coming in and I wasn't disappointed.Excellent customer service and the food was great.Those cupcakes were like a taste of heaven.

Great food fixed to order and very courteous staff!

Great family owned place! Great food, service, and of course sweets!! We love this place ❤

They are so personable! Every time we go in, we are greeting with smiles and lots of love. We feel like we are the only ones there when they are talking to us. We have been going in ever since they opened and were so excited to see them expand and now have a grill. Their food is just as good as their sweets! We love that they have dairy free options as well as the option to take our food and sweets home. Our daughter always feels so welcome there the way they have it set up for children too. The atmosphere is all around happy.