Stevie Tomato's Sports Page in Cape Coral - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Never again will we go there. Ordered 2 “large” pizzas and garlic bread, when the food came out it was absolutely not what we expected. The garlic bread looked like it was was frozen and heated up in the microwave and the pizza looked like someone puked a bunch of red sauce on it. We talked to the manager “Nichole” to see if we could work something out and she absolutely was not willing to work with us. All together it was $55 and it was absolutely terrible.

Great specials, pizza and wings!! Service is the best around!

I went there one knight and ordered the weiner. They couldn't get me the weiner but said they could chop off two chicken breast's for me. Lilly was my server and she was the bell of the ball. She should win an Oscar. Bravo Stevie Tamatas!

This place has great food and drinks and a nice atmosphere. Just don’t go in the bathroom, there is a lot of graffiti about Stuttering John Melendez in there, not sure why.

Stopped by for lunch around 1pm on Saturday. Not busy at all. I ordered the Freek salad with lamb. Very tasty. My brother got wings and buffalo cauliflower. He said both were very good. The service could have been just a little bit faster I think. If you won't to hang around and watch sports...this is the place to go.

Versatile menu, where most can find something they’ll enjoy. We love the pizza and burgers and my partner can’t get enough of the fried pickles. The outdoor space is quite a pleasant atmosphere, with sports and live music playing all the time.

I come once a week thinking I’m going to have good food, but it’s always horrible. Burger was horrible this time the ribs tasted like dirt and they gave me old fries!!! So sick of this place! Oh and it’s hot inside!

My friends Bob, Mike, Log Cabin Larry, Julie E and I had a great time. The food, cleanliness (except for some graffiti in the bathroom), and service were great. The puddled chicken is to die for. I had to give the atmosphere a 2* because of some 5’4” drunk at the bar going on and on and on about how great he was, bragging about his workout routine, and dabbling in stocks. His actions were nefarious, and I would have asked him to leave. Lucky for us he left with his partner KB shortly after 8pm.My buddy Bob said it was 8pm it might have been 8:30pm. You never can tell. The comedian Don that was there for comedy and taxidermy tips killed. We will be back for sure.

Best chicken fingers in all my 75 years and could not have had a better server than Jonathan. Wish you had a location nearer to Venice!

Stevie Tomato's has a decent menu selection. Traditional bar food. They do have live music, which was nice. No wait time to get a table. Worth checking out.

Place was really hot inside. Flys everywhere. My waitress was in no hurry. Had to ask for silverware. Probably not coming back...

Horrid experience today flat beer and bland food. The bathroom lights almost caused a seizure I ended up going on the floor. Then I come here and 3 weeks ago someone complained about the lights. The filth was untold and the staff bragged about local celebrities that come by. This is a place for dumb drunks to hide from support enforcement.

Place is great. Was there about a month ago and there was some obnoxious old drunk in the men’s bathroom muttering to himself complaining about “Lady K”. It was weird. But other than that the service is great, food is good. Highly recommend.

People shouldn't give bad reviews who haven't been here.

I have no idea why there are so many positive reviews about the food from this place. Almost all of the food that we ordered had no seasoning and was under cooked. We LOVED Stevie’s that was in fort Myers. We thought we’d make the trip to this location because we missed the old Stevie’s so much. $100 on disgusting food. Complete disappointment. The atmosphere was fine though, very quiet in the afternoon, kind of disappointed I didn’t get to se the drunk dwarf the other reviewers mentioned.

I recently dined at Stevie Tomato's and had an absolutely delightful experience! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warm smiles and a welcoming atmosphere. The stars of the evening were Lilly and Bree, our fantastic servers. Lilly's attentiveness and Bree's cheerful demeanor made us feel right at home. They were both incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and provided excellent recommendations. Stevie Tomato's has definitely become my go-to spot for a great meal and outstanding service. Kudos to Lilly and Bree for making our night special. We can't wait to come back!

A group of 4 of us went for lunch. Service was horrible and we were the only ones in the dining room. We all ordered something different. I ordered the thin crust pizza. BIG mistake. The crust was a tasteless cracker. There was no flavor at all. If I closed my eyes while eating it, I couldn't tell you what was on it. There was probably sauce somewhere but it was tastless. The crust was some manufactured crust from a package. Yuck! Do not try to pass this off as Chicago pizza. That is an insult to Chicago. My husband had the fish and chips which were just ok. We won't be back

Been here several times. This visit I was bothered by flys around food and found a hair under my pizza on the platter. Some of lights in restroom are nonfunctional and have been that way for months. Manager here not managing very well.

Great Sports Bar. Wonderful service. Good pours. What more do you need to know?

Been here many times. The food is good. Prices are good. Staff is wonderful. The crowd varies depending on the night.

Sub par food, obnoxious staff, disgusting bathrooms

Bring Matt and bar bingo back!!! We were there every Tuesday with friends.

A excellent place for nice meal, And me up with friends.

Food & atmosphere were good but the service was very slow

The pizza is very good. Garlic bread is spot on. There was a 5’3 homeless man screaming he was on Howard Stern Show. Besides him with his pocket full of sharpies the place was great

Stopped in and had a beer. Nice place, nice staff. FSJ

The staff here was great. Food was delicious.

Been here a few times, it’s alright. But lately anytime I try to call, the manager Danny yells at me thinking I’m someone named Vinnie? I’m hoping to schedule an event for me and my husband’s radio show

The service and food is excellent, but some old guy who claimed to be from Howard Stern tried to spike my wife's drink. When confronted he challenged me to go outside, and then immediately jumped on his friend's bike to retreat.

John Melendez frequents here and writes graffiti on the walls and then blames innocent people online for it, the manager when asked about this was very angry and rude, avoid at all costs as John harasses patrons for drinks while declaring he's a celebrity

Terrible atmosphere. A drunk named John kept yelling about graffiti. It was really off-putting. Will never go back when this sawed off, inebriated reprobate is in the bar

My experience is strictly at the outside seating area. Food is pretty good, service has always been good. I’ve become a regular. Daytime weekly bartender is awesome

I loved the people and food was great. But I’ve also noticed this guy always holding a coors can, while yelling NOGA. Other than that it was great.

We were visiting from out of town for a softball tournament. We walked in for lunch with 17 people and were told no problem and were seated right away. Staff was very accommodating, our server McKayla J was on point and did an excellent job. The food was delicious and if in town again, we would definitely visit again.

The pizza is what I came for and it was really good. There was an older gentleman there, about 5’ tall who kept loudly proclaiming that he was a celebrity and my table should buy him Coors but, we ignored him like a Mariachi band and he moved to the next table. Fun place, get the pizza!

I want to eat here but some crazy old man who calls himself "Stuttering John" keeps yelling about how Stevie Tomato's has hoodlums vandalizing their men's bathroom. That worries me as a customer and I don't want to take my family to an establishment that either has a vandalizing problem or a senior citizen problem.

Stop letting Stuttering John into your restaurant. He has brought down and has eventually banned from every establishment he has ever been to. Do some research

Horrible experience. Graffiti in the bathroom with inappropriate language. Will never return again.

The manager an the staff are awesome the best kind attentive service is amazing great music an atmosphere

Ours in Fort Myers closed. Went to Cape Coral to this one. Great pizza & friendly service.

I had heard the food was good here, so my wife and I went to check it out, and it was very good. The service was fine also, but there was some guy who seemed to be very drunk, yelling over the live music saying he was a celebrity because he was a stutterer or something. He walked by our table, and he smelled like a homeless person. I don't think we will return. Update... I see the manager of this establishment has replied saying this never happened. Well, it did happen. I don't have any reason to make things up.

It's not their fault Stuttering John dragged them down into hell with him. They got good bar food, and drinks. Nice place to hang out.

Wow, after deciding I was going to write a review I read some of the recents and was shocked. This place has such a fun relaxing atmosphere to watch sports, the best live music in SWFL, and has delicious food and drinks. The service is amazing! I love the staff for having fun with their customers! They treat us like friends! Management has always been nothing but kind and very attentive to the needs of staff and customers. Definitely a must try!

This guy John told me he hangs out here because one of the girls that works there “Bree” is banging him. I figured I’d check it out . Some band Pipe Dreams was playing and they were horrible. They over serve people who were obviously already intoxicated . Food was pretty ok though .

To sum up the excelsior ecperience I had a the esrablishment known as ‘STEVIE TOMATOS’, I will have to borrow a quote from the famous Sun Tzu. “ What the ancients called a clever fighter is one who not only wins, but excels in winning with ease." Not only was the music, as the kids say, ‘bumpin’, but the service (Our server was Brie! (Not to be mistaken with the cheeze)) was indeed top noch. They were as busy as a tree blooms in the Autum, and yet despite that, everything they provided me and my hot asian wife was spectacular. Twas all done with ease! Like a bull fighter damces in the wring, they danced. And danced they did! I am very happy in my life, and provide for my hot asian wife very well. Thank you stevie tomater. “All that glitters is not gold, but Stevie tomor is really cool.” -William Shakespeer

When you have so much rudeness out of one place, I blame the management starts from the top

Amazing bartender Nikki and Nick and awesome manager Danni.

Food is great, service is great. I just wish the manager would relax a little. Stop acting like you're above what's happening. It's lame.

I come here quite frequently and the atmosphere is amazing, everyone’s extremely hospitable and very attentive, Bree, McKayla, Giana, Brandon, and Isa are the people you want to see!! The sweet and spicy bacon wings are to die for! Everyone’s been leaving some very hasty reviews lately due to stuttering John mentioning it in his podcast. It sickens me to see such an amazing establishment suffer based off of hate for one of their customers. I for one will most definitely be coming back!

Food was Good , Atmosphere great but when I went too the restroom I needed too use the closed door stall but there was a drunk older man in there throwing up so I waited , then he loudly asked if I knew what letter Carl started with I said C he said no the other Carl. I did not understand what he meant but when he came out he smelled like a urinal , he had greasy hair and and misbuttoned shirt he left the restroom without washing his hands but he also left his sharpie in the toilet. I think he tried too flush it idk.

It was good but I was under the impression that IT WAS A BARBECUE RESTAURANT!

Flew in from Utica for a GQP convention and luckily ST was walking distance from my hotel. Food and staff were excellent(hi Bree!). I was even fortunate enough to catch an Islanders game while I was there! The other guy at the bar was also from upstate NY so that was fun, at least at first. He seemed worryingly inebriated for a 3:30 puck drop and when I mentioned that our forwards seemed slow transitioning from defense to offense he told me to "stop talking about my kids!" Maybe his son is on the team? Because he also talked about being famous but no one seemed to know why exactly. Idk perhaps it's just an Albany expression.

Stopped by with family for a late dinner. Food was better than expected. Service was great. Only ding was a guy who decided to tell everyone he is a celebrity, kept telling everyone that would listen the difference between their, there and they’re. He must of been drunk cause he would try to “make a basket” with his empty coors light cans. Either way great restraunt

I was initially hesitant to go in because there was a big group of Harley’s out front. My dad was an Army Major and my mom is overweight and they have PTSD from loud noises. Luckily the Harleys were all very quiet. They must not be manly men. Very good establishment.

I stopped in last weekend while I was in town for the Mensa convention. I had wings and beers and they were great. Only issue I had was this drunk guy kept talking to himself and yelling out about someone named lady K. When I realized who he was it was Stuttering John who was fired from the Howard Stern show. He is a shell of a man he use to be. He was angry and being rude to other customers. Anyways besides him I had a great time.

The food was amazing and the waitress was a delight. I love the place and next time i am in the area (probably a year from now), I’ll revisit. I had once incident there that isnt the staff’s fault. A 4’8” guy who looked like a drunk leprechaun and smelled like Coors Lite confronted me when i went to the bathroom. He accused me of working for “Lady K” or something before rambling about Door Dash and Rooms to Go. It was quite odd.

I'm giving "Stevie Tomato's" the ratings I am based on reputation. Was planning on going with a group of eight other folks. A nice, pleasant Easter Brunch, my treat!! But my cousin went to Florida three days before: an "advance scout", if you will. She texted me this past Thursday night that she was in ST for all of just five minutes!! While trying to quietly enjoy her shot 'n brewski, some bum-looking little-person kept screaming & yelling about "showing Carla with bathroom graffitti" or some such .... My cousin tried turning her back to all the commotion but it just kept coming. She says he was ranting about 40-pound saddlebags of Coors Lite attached to some *other* guy named "Harry Davison" or whoever. I really couldn't understand what my cousin was on about. All I *do* know is that the world is dangerously crazy these days. I thought a nice, quiet watering-hole, ON EASTER, would be a break from the madness. But now after hearing about the sort of clientele ST allows in their establishment on a random Thursday evening, goodness only knows what sort of unclean street slime might slither in on a major holiday .... Like I say: was planning a nice Easter Weekend with eight other heavily-tipping friends/relatives. Thank heavens my cousin warned me ....

Great food and fun atmosphere. We will definately put this in our rotation. Looking forward to catching one of the games there again today.

They allow some drunk dwarf to yell during live music. He must be a Vikings fan because he yells SKOL when he drinks his Coors. Food and service was great though.

Had to go two stars for atmosphere because of this Guy from the Howard Stern show who drinks (gets hammered) and is really loud. When Stuttering John Melendez stops drinking until drunk and being really loud, I won't go back!! This loser actually wrote on the bathroom wall to get others banned. One bad apple can spoil the whole bunch!!!

I am a new resident to Cape Coral and ST's come up first on my pub and grub search. I found the food to be very good, and the bar staff and crew were well cool and attentive. But, I will never hang out atthis place again. There was one very drunk individual amongst the other easy going bar patrons, this one man was extremely loud and very vulgar with his language. Apparently he is some entertainer from the radio, the Howard Stern show, John the stutter was his name. A few of us at the bar left because of this man. I can't imagine a true bar owner would allow this ridiculous person into the establishment.

I was initially hesitant to step foot in this place due to the biker gang parked up outside. They were in good spirits but were unfortunately laughing at a 'little person/dwarf who I can only assume is the town drunk/village idiot. The little guy was drooling and spitting as he shouted and ranted... He seemed to think he was part of the biker gang because he was shouting "come on guys we're gonna teach Carla a lesson" (This is where I lost all sympathy for this angry little man)... One of the bikers laughed and said "don't you mean substitute-teach Carla a lesson?"... Must be some kind of inside joke. Upon entering the establishment I learned that everyone inside knew the little fella and nobody liked him. NOBODY. So, great place, great patrons (even the biker gang), just watch out for that angry little alcoholic dwarf.

The food here is absolutely amazing the service is amazing everyone is so quick and nice to each other they keep the place very clean I love it here

Stevie tomatoes is a great establishment. Kris, Bree, Giana, McKayla, and Jonathon are the best servers ever. They always take care of me and make me feel at home! 10/10 stop by and check it out.

stevie tomatoes is my favorite sports bar in the area! i’ve been coming here for years and i always get great service and the food is fantastic - my personal favorite is the pizza & wings!

Nick, Nikki and Nicolle are the best! Food and service is always amazing!

Food and service was great. The screaming, delusional drunk, screaming about bathroom graffiti, only added to the atmosphere.

The food and service was great. Even the bathroom was easy to graffiti. FSJ FKB

Place is great! One negative is this disgusting, drunken loser that hangs out there. This buffoon, "Slobbering" John, has even gone so far as to vandalize their property in an attempt to frame his enemies and drum up content for his YouTube "show". Give this lowlife a wide berth - you'll be glad you did. His poor hygiene will make you lose your appetite.

Great place. Great food. Great service. But 1 of the regulars, a drunk midget who smelled like shut, kept telling me he was famous and his name was stuttering john. Guy was repulsive.

The staff was very pleasant and professional. The food was delicious. The Dr. Pepper slaps, 10/10. Some red faced stuttering slob was yelling at the bar and later was writing on the walls in the bathroom. Very strange behavior. Strong odor. Please keep an eye out for him. I'm sure the staff knows how difficult he can be.

This seems like an awesome place with amazing food but you might want to tell Stuttering John Melendez to stop talking about this place on his YouTube stream. He has many many people that don’t like him. Don’t cross him because he will definitely tell people to send in bad reviews. I wish you and your establishment nothing but great success.

What a dump. The ribs had to be cut with a steak knife

The food and service here was good! I found the dining room and the bathroom stalls to be particularly clean and wonderful! The only criticism I would have to say is the atmosphere was a little suspect. I kept getting this odd feeling about a short, definitely intoxicated man. I think I heard his name was John, whatever it was, he was VERY drunk and obnoxious. It’s a little disconcerting he wasn’t removed for how drunk and obnoxious he was but I trust the owner will do away with pests like that in the future. Great food though!

Great place, but when my wife and I visited, we were bothered by a drunken slob who called himself "stuttering john". This guy was about 4'9 and obese. The drunk kept screaming and dribbling as he told everyone that he was famous. Ruined the evening.

Just enjoyed an excellent lunch. Food was wonderful but above all was the service we received. Our server Chris was outstanding. He was on top of everything. Thank you Chris for a excellent lunch.

Didn't eat there this time but sat outside at the bar and listened to the live music. It was great! The food looked very good too!

Had a great Friday night pizza dinner with friends and family visiting Florida... 🍕😋👌🏻Live music, outdoor seating and booth bar atmosphere! 🍻

Server Cindy was awesome. Food is great and all football games available on TV.

Me and my wife and family went on Super Bowl day. We had fun I came in 2nd Pl., Buffalo wings, eating contest what exciting. All in all we had a great time nice place to go we will definitely come back another day.

Nikki and Chris great Combo The atmosphere at Stevies is already great, but Nikki's exceptional service takes it to the next level. She ensured that every customer felt valued and well taken care of, creating a positive and inviting environment. And let's talk about Chris and the trivia nights – absolutely brilliant! Chris adds a perfect dose of entertainment and excitement to the evenings. His trivia questions are engaging and challenging, making the atmosphere lively and fun. Whether you're a trivia enthusiast or a casual participant, Chris knows how to keep the energy high and the competition friendly. If you haven't experienced the magic of Nikki's cocktails and Chris's trivia nights at Stevies, you're missing out. Head over there for a night of unforgettable fun – you won't be disappointed! Cheers to Nikki and Chris for making Stevies the ultimate hotspot in town! 🍸🎉

My family and I come here every Wednesday for music trivia. The food is great, service is AMAZING Nikki is the best server I’ve had in years. The host for the trivia does a wonderful job to create a fun friendly environment. Will continue to come here every week!

Great food, we order a 16 inch thin crust it was delicious. The garlic bread was amazing. The service was exellent and fast. Outside the have live music for those who want to have a drink and hear good music from local artists.

Bar and Grill atmosphere. Waitress was great! Average prices. Bar food. Chicken wings were really good. Buffalo was nice and hot and tasty.

Bought food and drinks there.. Best thing is free bingo Tuesday night 6:30 to 8:30

Monday night burger specail was excellant! We will come back!

Fried fish is awesome. Haddock big flakey white fish.

So we finally decided to stop in and check out Stevie's tomatoes sports bar after being seated it took a couple of minutes for Riley to even come over and take our order We ordered an appetizer and drinks after waiting a while again or drinks came out plus our order of fried pickles which were very greasy there was so much grease on the bottom that we couldn't even finish them No plates to put the pickles on the sauce was really good spicy which was good, then we said and wait on our food I got the apple wood bacon burger which was good a little dry had to wait on mayonnaise but ate half of it was really good baked beans were really good My husband ordered the pizza and he pretty much ate the whole thing It was a thin crust 12-in It was good as well but when we typically go out we focus on the service We focus on customer service We focus on how long it takes to get certain courses sent to us drink orders and also about coming and checking on us Michaela had stopped by several times to check on us and bring us plates bring us boxes so service was the big issue coming to Stevie's tomatoes we will talk it over and decide if we want to return.

Went to this location for a charity event and will certainly return. The service was outstanding!! The wait staff was slammed with people and was up to the task. Breanna was very attentive despite being busy.

They burnt the first pizza. the second pizza wasn't cooked enough, but when I took it home and reheated it in the pan, it was great. Service, not so good, the young man we had never cleared our table. Dishes were still left on the table when we walked out and they were not even busy. But he was a good Talker.

Get place to go. Excellent service, Dani and her staff are awesome. The food was great. If you looking to catch a game or checking out the entertainment on the patio, always a amazing time.

Sports bar with lots of t.v.s.... if you are looking for a place just to have drinks and watch the game this would be a decent go to. As far as food goes I had their chicken Cobb salad. Ingredients were not fresh, for the bacon they use bacon bits. Pretzel appetizer was mediocre at best. Wings were average.

Decent food (skirt steak), ok for a sports bar, if that's what you want.

Lots of fun on music trivia night. The waitress there (wish I could remember her name) needs a bonus. On just our second visit, she remembered what our drink order was exactly from a week prior. She deserves a huge bonus and is the best thing about this location. The fajitas are great as well!

A bar grill. The chicken tenders and pulled pork were great!

Great staff, great food. Always a good time.

Nick, the bartender, is great. Always ready to serve us our favorite drinks. Live music 🎶 is nice.

We took friends to see Deb and the Dynamics and cocktails. Had a great time. We will definitely return.

Great pub fare. Portions are huge.

I should have taken a pic of the food here. Had a Chicago style thin Cristina pizza (ask for it to be sliced normal if you don't like middle pieces) and wings. Both were phenomenal‼️👊