Sugar Creek Foods - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Lots of good food and malted milk balls with no waxy coating!

Friendly folks, Lots of unique and hard to find spices. They have also started selling hot coffee sub's.

Stop here whenever I'm working down in Penn Yan. Great store with very nice people. The selection is very good absolutely love stopping here and I highly recommend it if you are in the area.

The people here are very nice and have a good selection!

Great merchandise and wonderful service.

Very nice country grocery store with some "extras".

Best ham & cheese sub I've ever had! All the ingredients were so fresh, and the bread tasted like it was right out of the oven.

It's nice to have a place to shop at on this side of town that carries some organic items. Owners are real friendly.

Prices of fair that's a good place to go the people are friendly

Neat little store but not much variety

Excellent selection, quality, and prices.

Owner is very friendly, sub ingredients are fresh and delicious, and great selection in goods. Highly recommend.

Lovely small store, great spices, cold cuts , milk, bread, snacks, ice cream, dried beans, eggs, and best of all not crowded. Very friendly service.

We love this store. Kind and helpful people, a good selection, and attractive prices. Well worth the drive from Pittsford, NY!

Good lunch meat and sub prices, convenient little store.

Excellent store! They have all you'd expect from a dry goods standpoint. The prices are extremely competitive and the service is solid. They are willing and able to place custom orders to fit your needs concerning quantity as well. Thanks Sugar Creek!

Nice store.great subs and friendly people.thanks for ordering special products for us

Very friendly and accommodating.

Everyone who works there are very helpful. Luke has a great variety of products. Deli meats and cheeses are fresh and always well priced.Fresh made to order Hoagies are less than $4.00. Also has fresh ground peanut butter in two varieties. We're always very pleased to shop there.

Always great prices and great service with a smile! their sub sandwiches are fantastic as is all of their deli products. Wonderful selection of bulk food products and homeopathic supplies

I love this store, it has grown in the last 5 years. The family that runs it are very friendly, outgoing and helpful. They have books, bulk items, deli counter, shelves of food, refrigerator items, fresh eggs, cheese, health section, freshly made soap and Pepsi products. The sub sandwiches are delicious and they have the best smoked ham hocks I have ever seen (and I’ve looked for them for years in several places). I look forward to going back!

Awesome bulk food store run by a great Mennonite family.

Small selection of products but decently priced

Staff is always so very helpful. The subs there are amazingly delicious. The deli meats are always fresh and very tasty. I find the prices are very good.