The Florida Key Lime Pie Company in Cocoa Beach - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I am thoroughly impressed with this establishment—it truly captures the essence of Florida in one remarkable shop. The staff are exceptionally helpful and friendly, enhancing the entire experience with their welcoming attitude and attentiveness. On Saturdays and Sundays, they even feature a live alligator for photo opportunities, complete with staff-painting her nails, adding a unique and charming touch. Their selection of house-made ice cream flavors is outstanding, and the key lime pie is nothing short of extraordinary. Additionally, their key lime yogurt-covered pretzels, aptly named ‘Cocoa Beach Crack,’ are an absolute delight and highly recommended. The vast array of saltwater taffy is impressive, as is their extensive collection of hot sauces. They also offer a diverse selection of beers, all sourced from Florida breweries, and an exceptional range of jerky, from beef and alligator to python. This store is truly a gem for anyone seeking an authentic taste of the Florida experience.

The pie was very and the service was friendly.

Seems to be a lot of racism in the air. My family and I couldn’t seem to get any answers about products, but white guests who entered after us received all the information they needed plus more. Sad that we can’t do better now and days. I’ll pray for them.

Excellent place in Cocoa Beach. Always enjoy going there buying their macaroons, their key lime pie of course, and assortment of so many different beers. I highly recommend this little gem.

Super grumpy dude employee 🤯 wth (the large man) Fix yourself before working in a customer-facing role

Their key lime pie is a great balance between sweet and tart.

I looove key lime pie and was happy to see this cute shop across from Ron Jon's. It is beautiful inside...absolutely beautiful. I give this cute spot three stars because (1) the key lime pie was not to my liking and I didn't like its, (2) not many selection to choose from, and (3) the person who assisted us did not make us feel welcome at all. However, overall, it is a great stop if you are in the area. Plus they have a winery with many mouth watering flavors in galore to choose from. Plus, ice cream.

Came in at noon, service & food was great. Haley said Sweety the alligator would be there at 2pm. Until about 20min later, some grumpy obese employee was rather blunt in providing advice, and further asked to move my car, in order to make room for the incoming “Sweety”. I felt intimidated, clearly this gentleman wasn’t having a good day. Decided not to come back to see Sweety.

The people are super nice and treats you like family every time you are in the store, and have the best key lime pie and cheese cake 🎂 I have eaten. And the owner treats you like this every time you are in his store.

It was really good 😊 and the best pie ever 😋 and watching the laughing hyena Camel toe Harris 😭 is funny 🤣😂😭

Great pie and even better service! Friendly and welcoming very happy!!

So glad we visited this place during our Cocoa Beach trip. We tried the key lime pie, cookie dough cheesecake, chocolate truffle cheesecake, and the key lime covered pretzels (aka “cocoa beach crack”). All were absolutely amazing!! If you’re ever in the area you owe it to yourself to give them a try!

I bought 2 key lime pies and they were so sweet that they gave me 12 forks and plates so we could share the pies. Also ordered 12 icecreams which were all very good. I liked the pecan and matcha best. Blueberry bourban was too sweet for me. But all was really good and love they had 1 scoop for $4. Would not have gotten 12 ice creams if they were more expensive.

The pie and ice cream here are great!

Went here on the recommendation of the local police. The key lime pie is amazing

I thought the Key Lime Pie was good, they also had a selection of ice creams, sauces, and even local craft beer.

A special place that you have to visit... find curious flavors of different products: ice cream, beers, jams and more... KEY LIMEN in different presentations. Great attention and good prices!!!

Key lime pie was not good at all. For a place that's called the Florida Key Lime Pie Company, you'd think the Key lime pie would be the star. It's not. Tucked away in a small fridge in the back of the store. The pie tasted of battery acid. We tossed it in the trash.

I loved the collection of hot sauces! Good local options to take back to Indiana.

Unfortunately they don't have any kind of coffee to drink in the shop.

Their key lime pie is AMAZING! Perfect match between sweet and sour. It's so creamy and delicious. That was my go-to dessert... until now. I hate cheesecake. But after trying theirs, I bought 1 for the week at the beach and 6 to take home. The best cheesecake you will ever put in your mouth. The owner and staff is always so pleasant and friendly. Love these guys!!! It's one of the MUST SEE places every year, sometime twice a year, when we are in town. Again... I HATED cheesecake until i had theirs. I will ONLY have theirs and no one else's. Dont take my word. You gota try it if yourself.

Lots of local Florida candies, beer, wine, etc. Was hoping for more pie options, but overall a cute shop.

Cute store, everything is overpriced- the key lime pie they sell, mind you , at the key lime pie company, is quite possibly the worst key lime pie i’ve ever had in my life. Skip it.

Worst key lime pie ever. We ate one bite and tossed it in the trash. 4 of us tried it and could not believe how awful it was. Do not buy. Tourist trap

The best Taffy I've ever had and love the key lime pie also

The lady working there at about 4 was not very friendly. There is only a small selection of ice cream. It's a shame cuz the store is really cute. $3.95 for one small scoop of ice cream. I probably would have been a solid 4 stars if the staff was cheerful or peppy a bit. Seemed a little rude unfortunately.

We tried a few places for Key Lime pie. This was the very best.

This was the worst keylime pie I have ever tasted. I bought a whole pie because there was 4 of us that wanted keylime pie. All 4 of us had the same opinion it was so tart it was inedible!! I threw out the whole pie! I love a good keylime pie but this was horrible.

Love the pace they have so much to choose from a must go to place in cocobeach.

I’ve been coming here ever since I was little (all the way from Canada) and it’s always the best key lime pie in Florida :) Lovely little shop with the cutest pet alligator!! Already cant wait to come back.

Love the unique products! Great staff.

This is very much a tourist trap. I grew up here in Brevard County. And this was my first visit. The shop is cute as can be. The employees were friendly. My only complaint is there is a lack of prices on almost everything.

We came to try the Key Lime pie because of a YouTube review and was greatly disappointed. Was the worst one I’ve had. The frozen one at the grocery store is much better! The Cheesecake was better but not great.

Loved the young employees. Owner is a class act. Key Lime Truffles were awesome. Hot sauce selection is the best ever.

What an awesome little shop. Located right across the parking lot from Ron Jon's. Fun atmosphere and friendly staff. Key lime pie and ice cream...what more can you ask for? Beer and Hot sauce you say...They have that too with an amazing selection of hot sauces and local brew. Be sure to stop by on Saturday's and Sunday's to meet Wally, a real live alligator. I love the floor! Ps...not sure of Wally's real name, but worth checking out.

The Key Lime Pie was really good. My daughter and aunt & uncle all enjoyed it.

So so good! Can’t wait to go here every year we visit the area!

Got a Key Lime Pie for my family and it was not good. We all like key lime pie, and this was barely eddible... tasted spoiled and sour in the worst way. We threw most of it away. I have no idea how this tourist trap is rated so highly.

Sweetie was amazing and we had the pie which was made good and fresh before frozen because you could taste the tartness of the fresh limes

Picked up a couple of key lime pies and they were average. Not tangy enough for my taste. Had a couple of key lime and lemon macarons, and those were really good. Very enjoyable. Recommend the macarons all day, but I would not make my way to get some pies.

Key lime pie not nearly as good as it used to be.

The key lime pie is everything they say it is. Super delicious!! I read some reviews saying it’s too tart. Well, it is especially tart, but that’s what makes it great in my opinion! The key lime pie candies are also amazing. Super cool to see their pet alligator as well.

Whenever we travel to Florida, you have to get key lime pie right!? We happened to be over at Ron Jon and saw this little shop. We have visited the one in Key West so we decided to go over. I grabbed a piece of pie out of the cooler and then when I turn around, I see some cups on the ice cream counter. One had a picture of an elephant and the other a donkey. The purpose was to put money in them to vote - or their tips, not sure. Either way, this turned my stomach. I put that pie right back in the cooler. The girl heard me say I don’t want that now and she offered some other options to me. I didn’t tell her that the pie wasn’t the issue, I just said no thank you and walked out. Please, if you want to keep business, DO NOT bring your political views into it. I have left other establishments because of this. This country is already very divided and in turmoil over politics. Don’t make it worse!

We’re from about an hour away and were in the area. We saw this lil shop and thought to swing by to pick up a pie for dessert but they had literally just closed a few minutes before. They were leaving to lock up and gave us a free sample slice and it was so yummy - a perfect balance of tangy and sweet you want in a Key Lime pie. They really didn’t do have to do that and it was so kind of them to. I’m also pregnant and my husband says they saved him lol.

Husband and I drove in from Miami area (visiting from PA) just to say we were in The Keys. We saw this spot from the road, and ordered two slices to go. Our biggest mistake was not ordering a whole pie! We also got a bag of the little cookies and they were delicious, but the pie is a MUST. Best pie I’ve ever had in my life, I wish they sold online!

Cool tourist place with good true key lime pie. Check dates and times to meet Sweetie, the alligator. Didn't see anywhere to sit to enjoy our pie. Only 4 or 5 plastic chairs outside.

Wow……now that was definitely a Key Lime Pie. The first and second bites really hit you in the face, but in a good way.

The pie was delicious! I didn’t get to stay and eat there, but just from looking around a second I could tell it was a really nice space! Their key lime pie cookies are vegan!

Strange little shop. Legit smelled like a pet shop when we walked in. For being called the Key Lime Pie Company, their pie was not great. My friend didn't even finish hers! We also got ice cream and we're disappointed with that as well! Friend also didn't finish her ice cream. Total bummer experience.

Best Key Lime Pie! Come here every time we go to Coco. Right across the street from RonJons.

Tourist trap. Pie was just okay.

Nice tourist shop for good Key lime pie, local canned beer, and other snacks.

The owner was very accommodating and service was outstanding! Ice cream and key lime pie were delicious. Near Ron Jon's, very convenient.

ALWAYS VISIT HERE COMING AND GOING TO THE KEYS!

was very bummed about the pie. it was extremely tart and out of all 4 of us in the group who tried it, none of us liked it. we ended up throwing the whole thing away. highly recommend looking on the updated trip advisor if you really want the best key lime pie in brevard. oh, and having muzzled alligators outside isn’t cute.

I ate a slice of Key Lime Pie on site, it was delicious. the shop is very well presented and the staff friendly.

We stop here every time we come to cocoa beach. They have so many unique foods and drinks there! They have some home made key lime pie that is to die for! If you like key lime stuff, stop here!

Very cool. A must stop for tourists and locals alike. Wild ice cream flavors, delicious pie, local brews, hot sauce, and a taffy wall. 💕

5 stars for the store and the staff! Unfortunately I wasn't a fan of the main reason I stopped in - the key lime pie. It was way too tart and almost bitter, like they put a healthy amount of lime zest in the pie filling. Left an unpleasant taste on my tongue. Kind of a bummer, but I do appreciate the super nice staff.

Cute little shop with an interesting array of products. Bought a couplet off pieces of the Key Lime Pie. My sister loved it so much we went back the next day for her to purchase another slice. My husband and I did not care for it. Way too tart for me. It was very smooth and light though. The staff were all very nice though

I enjoyed the wide selection and friendly service

I am so disappointed. We came a long ways to try this pie. Expecting to grab a slice, sit doen and relax and enjoy it. Intead, got there and were directed to a refrigerator with a stack of slices. We were advised to get a whole pie and so we did. We said it was frozen and were assured it would thaw in 30 minutes. We asked for forks and 2 containers so we had "plates" to try this fantastic pie. 2 hours later and sitting in the 80 degree weather. Its still frozen. No cream on top or cute little lime slice. Just a frozen crust with filling. Not even the experience we were hoping for. I hope its good when we ever get to eat it. I have been reviewing Florida key lime pie for over 10 years. Not had this experience ever. Update. The pie was good. I like that it was not overly sweet. Worth picking some up if in the area.

This was my second visit to the Florida Key Lime Shop while here in Florida. As we were leaving we saw a alligator on display on the concrete and a women with a bullhorn telling people to pet the alligator as get your Key lime pie. Why would anyone think anyone endorse this abuse of any animal? Just laying there on the cement for hours. Will never return.

Everything we tried was good. We tried the key lime pie, chocolate pecan cheesecake, and cake batter ice cream.

Bought a key lime pie there today, it was so bitter. It tasted like they used the key lime peeling instead of the juice.

Purchased a key lime pie today, it was so bitter. Called the store and spoke to the manager/owner. The manager/0wner told me it was supposed to be bitter. Key lime pie is supposed to be tart not bitter!

The ice cream was decent but we went for the key lime pie. It was delicious! Crowd pleaser for sure! And we got to pet "Sweetie" the alligator

Amazing ice cream. Great key lime pie. Tons of other local flavors and goodies! Worth the stop

Friendly people and awesome food.

I will start by saying this was definitely an interesting shop. We came here looking for some dessert, but the store itself has an interesting variety of products including an assortment of craft beer, hot sauces, and more. Our only disappointment was that we came close to closing time and there wasn't much left for cake slices. That said, we had some cheesecake which was pretty good and of course the key lime pie which was excellent. This place is definitely worth stopping in to if that's what you're looking for. Be warned that there is only a small number of parking spaces for their customers directly in front of the store otherwise there is paid parking in a nearby lot, but the rates are not cheap.

Awesome key lime pie. Would of been 5 stars if owner had made key lime ice cream that he said he would twice and never did.

Went today and am so glad we did! Very personable manager, and the key lime pie is amazing! Thank you !!

Traditional and yummy Key Lime pie made with the slightly tart taste it’s supposed to have. One of the best I’ve ever had and it’s my favorite dessert. Lots of other treats including drinks, truffles, meat rubs and more.

I had a delicious piece of key lime pie and my sister had ice cream. Both were amazing. The shop had a wide variety of items and the also had a room with specialty beers.

Should not have a man outside with an alligator. It looks miserable. Should be in its natural environment. Not forced to have its mouth taped up & touched and pics taken.

Great local shop to find lots of taffy, a large variety of wines and beer, a wall of hot sauces, cool souvenirs, a unique offering of scoopable ice cream, and of course...Key Lime Pie! Stop by and meet the friendly and knowledgeable owner, Louie, who can tell you all about the store and the area. Right across from Ron Jon's, it's a must stop.

I recommend the Mango habanero ice cream! Not spicy, but has a nice heat to it. Big hot sauce selection. Key lime pie is more on the tart side from here.

Not quite the key lime pie taste we like. But it wasn't bad. They also have a ton of sauces, taffy and local made food items to check out.

I forgot to get a picture of my piece of Key Lime Pie - do take advice and let it thaw just a little. I adore the taste because I'm more of a tart and less of a sweet person when it comes to key lime pie. This shop offers more than just key lime, though. The sauce wall has a ton of options, and the jellies are expansive. They also offer taffies, jerky, local wines, and other local things. It's a pretty neat little shop, and if you're in the area, you don't need to skip it.

I have visited this store numerous times and they are amazing. The snacks are great and employees are great. They have items from local artists so local supporting local which is great.

Awesome florida souvenirs store if you’re visiting! Small but good selection of ice cream and different flavors of key lime pie! I recommend their key lime pie soda.

I waited to get home to taste my pie. Thus a slight delay in the review. Watch out Key West cuz this pie is the bomb. OUTSTANDING!

Best place for unique snacks and the best key lime pie in the area. Also have hundreds of different craft beers. Closes at 6pm so get there early.

Excellent tour and taste of pie, pretzel and yogurt.

Key Lime Pie was not at all what I expected as a traditional key lime pie. Did not care for it at all.

The best keylime pie dipped in chocolate I've ever had!!!! Very professional and clean shop! Thank you so much

Delicious key lime pie. Great samples and excellent customer service

The Key Lime Pie was really good. That tart smack at the end of a bite of good key lime did not disappoint. 👌 My husband had a slice of strawberry swirl pie. He thought it was OK. We also bought a bottle of hot sauce for a friend. They have several cans of different types of beer, beef jerky, candy, taffy, and ice cream. It's worth a trip. Right across from Ron Jon's by The Corner Tattoo.

It's a unique shop to get local products and products unique to FL. It definitely feels it is designed to cater to tourist. I don't think their Key Lime is that good. It's ok. I've had better from other places which is disappointing. At over $4 a slice I really do expect more. I won't go out of my way to visit but if I'm in the area I'd consider trying them again.

Had to try one key lime pie. Not to bad. Not overly sweeten. Nice sourish taste. Maybe a bit tart for some. Do not think it was real key limes otherwise it would be light lime green in color. The pie filling is a rich yellow in color. $4.50 nett per pie. Right adjacent the Ron Jon’s flagship store. On the left side from the main road Atlantic Blvd.

Key lime pie and cheesecakes are fantastic! A live gator is outside on Saturday and Sunday 2-6 PM. It's a short walk from the beach and Ron Jon's surf shop.

If you are at Ron Jons Surf Shop, you can come over to the key lime pie company, pet sweetie the alligator, bring home a pie for dinner, or an ice cream. Pie is very, very, very good. Ice cream is okay.

It's my favorite place for key lime pie and homemade ice cream.

Ok pie. Ok service. Asked about whipped cream for key lime pie. Was told their pie doesn't need it, in a rude way. Need to be friendlier and more welcoming to visitors... No thank you, come again... Visited again...still rude and unfriendly. Pie is a bit too tart, whipped cream could really make the pie more enjoyable.

The service was good and the key lime pie is very good. I would recommend to everyone.

What a cool place!! Aesthetically pleasing and such a variety of items! I specifically stopped in for a key lime pie, ended up with the 'Cocoa Beach Crack', a Key Lime Tortuga Rum cake and some cookies as well. The staff seemed a bit stressed, but I'm sure they're very busy.

By Far the bes tasting Key Lime Pie i have had.. not too sweet, but punchy tart that is satisfying ! the slice was $4.50 which was way better price than Key Largo's Key Lime Pie factory, prices.. if you are in this area this is a must try

Pretty neat little store to find a lot of local Florida treats. You can even find local Florida craft beers available for sale. However, many items in the store are not priced and you have to ask a worker how much some things are. I came in for a slice of pie but when I went outside to enjoy it, it was frozen solid. If you look closely at my photo, you can see the ice crystals on the top. This wasn't a huge deal, I suppose. About an hour later, it was mostly thawed and I did enjoy the very tart flavor. Based off the responses from the owner on other negative reviews, I'm expecting them to tell me that I'm wrong and that all items are priced and probably that I'm exaggerating about the solid state of my slice of pie. I can assure you however, that I'm just sharing my experience with you and have no reason to lie.

I’m a huge fan of key lime pie, this is hands down the best slice I’ve ever had.

We love this place! We come here every time we go to the beach. This time we were gifted a complimentary ice cream for this birthday girl! Thank you guys for always going above and beyond:)