Upper Crust Pizza in Key Largo - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The best pizza in the south of florida

Ordered take out delivery. Food was fine. Delivery lady called us to come to parking lot to get our order because she could not get into hotel, even though we had other delivery people get in fine. Lazy pure and simple delivery person.

The seafood pizza is amazing delicious, I didn't eat 3 slices pizzas for very long time ,that's how good it is.

Best pizza in the entire keys. Bayside restaurant in islamorada is cheaper but not as good of a crust recipe. Upper Crust is THE best!!!

This place alone put a smile on my face best service from Beth a nice place to be but the pasta and other food is good

Nice place, David and Martina (Czechs 👍) created a Pizzeria at this place with excellent homemade crispy pizza, homemade bread, Pilsen beer... thank you, good luck. Greetings from "Kladeňáci"

Simply Wow. They had amazing beer selection. Multiple really good and fresh double IPAs. Chimay blue Belgian ale. Amazing pizzas and stromboli. Great soup and pasta. The hostess/owner was super nice. And the young ladies serving were very helpful like they ran the place. Amazingly the patrons were super nice. One person helped us with the menu and what to get. We even took some Chimay glasses from there. We came back the very next evening. The best part saw Sydney McLaughlin break the world record live in US Olympic trials. And my friends son recognized a classmate from fourth grade who is going to Olympics (gymnastics)

Got two pizza and cheese sticks that were supposed to be under 50-60 bucks but they overcharged me almost 100$

Pizza hit the spot very good service

We ordered from Upper Crust Pizza 3 times during our trip and each time our food was delicious! It was delivered HOT, timely and with a smile. The delivery driver was so friendly and courteous and made sure we had plenty of papergoods when the food was delivered. The supreme pizza is fantastic, the stuffed shells, the chicken broc alfredo and the garlic knots are all worth ordering!!

Visited late one evening with a friend, and was so pleased at the service, the beer and the bites … The staff were super friendly and will be back!

Worst sandwiches I’ve ever had. Wow, where do you start?? How about the rock hard stale bread? How do hoagie rolls go stale before molding in Key Largo?? The meat (Turkey Sub, Hoagie)-I know the publix across the street sells better quality lunch meat than that, and you couldn’t have printed pictures thinner than the meat portions on these things. The cheese?? I had no idea the government was still producing and handing out pre-sliced cheese product! Never have I taken a bite of a restaurant sandwich before and immediately said “damn, I wish Subway was still open”. What a waste of time and money.

What a down to earth place to finish my day and have some amazing people around me … like Martina who is the best hostess in Town… great selection of beers and yummy pizza and the great atmosphere that makes you come back for more….!!!!! Bravo. Good job you guys and keep the delivery coming and the good vibes …don’t forget to have a tiramisu or even a cookie on your way out.. Thanks again.

Service was good and the server and owner were friendly. Fresh ingredients on the pizza but the crust was disappointing. The crust is the star of a pizza and this crust was lacking probably because the wrong flour was used. High gluten pizza/bread flour is a must for a good pizza. The pizza was overpriced and the IPA at $10 a glass was as well. We wish this establishment all the best, looks like they are trying.

They never disappoint, Great pizza every time 👍

Great pizza and vibes. I would return when I am here.

Super fast service and delicious pizza, salads and garlic bread!

Very fine pizza with a crispy base! Friendly service! Best key lime pie I've ever had

Great pizza in Key Largo. The sauce specifically is very good. A true pure tomato sauce that's not overdone with seasonings and is just delicious. Great service and a great atmosphere. Small indoor seating area that's a fun place to hang out. Great mozzarella sticks too.

Great classic pizza. Buy it buy the slice. Amazing! 🔥

Upper Crust Pizza is an absolute gem! They serve the freshest pizza with a homemade dough that is simply unbeatable. It's become an all-time favorite for our entire family. We all love it! Their selection of draft beers is the best in the Keys, and I highly recommend trying the Pilsner Urquell on draft – it's like a taste of heaven. The owners, David and Martin, are hands-on and always make you feel right at home. They add a personal touch that makes every visit special. The full Italian menu offers a great variety of dinners, sandwiches, salads, and of course, incredible pizzas. This place truly is the best hidden gem in the Keys. Enjoy your visit – you’re welcome! Cheers!

My recent visit to this pizza place was nothing short of a nightmare. Not only was I denied entry because of my well-behaved canine companion, but this establishment also forced my child to wait outside in the car as a result. The staff's lack of compassion and understanding was utterly appalling. It's astonishing that they would prioritize their no-pet policy over the well-being of their customers, especially when the dog posed no harm. This level of insensitivity and inflexibility is unacceptable. My family and I felt unwelcome and disrespected. I urge pet owners and parents alike to find a more accommodating and humane place to dine.

"I was thoroughly disappointed by my recent visit to this pizza place. Not only was the service lackluster and the food subpar, but I was also shocked by the staff's unwillingness to accommodate my furry companion. Despite my dog being well-behaved and on a leash, we were turned away at the door without any consideration or explanation. It's a shame that this establishment values their arbitrary rules over customer satisfaction and inclusivity. I will not be returning and would caution other pet owners to steer clear."

Quick stop for cheese pizza. Good price. $20 for a whole pie.

Way over priced.and the food sucks

70$ plus tip for two large mediocre and cold pizzas which took 90 min to get to my place. Will never eat here again!!!

From Chicago and this pizza caught my attention. Crust is perfect, not to saucy, and the cheese stretch is on point. There French fries are fantastic

Pizza was delicious! Crust was super crunchy.

By far the best beer in the keys! Pizza is also fantastic. Super hard to find delirium tremens and chimay beer! Owner is awesome and friendly! We will definitely be back.

The best Pizza I've had since leaving NY. I highly recommend this place, exceeded my expectations.

We had a great experience with the staff at Upper Crust. David the owner gifted us a cute glass for our 25th and Tay was our waitress. She was very sweet and attentive. We met Lisa and Emily as well and all of them were incredibly hospitable. The food was good and we would definitely go again if ever in Key Largo!

We had lasagne, it was great! Will definitely get again. Freshly made, the gravy was rich and delicious, cheese bubbly. We have typically ordered pizza , which we love too!! And BTW, best beer selection in the keys!!

Lasagna was great!! Server was super friendly Best! Best beer selection in the keys

This place was amazing. The owner Martina was great! Me and the wife walked there from the Bungalows Resort and had great food, great company and beer is always a plus! :)

Had meat lovers pizza . Was very good, but menu price said $18. Was actually over $30!

Their seafood pizza was unbelievably good. Can’t wait to go back!

Excellent food and great service!

Staff was very friendly and accommodating and the food was excellent! Loved the pizzas. We would definitely stop here again.

The pizza was delicious and the place very clean. I recommend 💯

Great pizza and great meatballs!

Got a sausage sub and it turn out to be a wish sandwich. Like wish it had some sauge on it . it had four or five little balls of sausage on it . no more then a nady could eat .sicks avoid this place . over priced and under feed . guess the good review are the people who drink their.

Great crust and sauce. And I just moved down from up north. Best pizza I've had in the keys.

Got a pepperoni delivered to the hotel. Decent pizza. Cooked well, not greasy. Said 40 min, took 1 hour but it was fresh and warm. Wasn't disappointed or amazed.

The service and delivery were terrific, the reason why I'm only giving three stars overall is the price was just from planet Pluto. Small cheese pizza and six wings ended up costing $32. It's just too much Pizza was competent not OMG, the wings were pretty good. It's just normal pizzeria food, which is fine with me is just way too expensive for what you're getting

Been in Key Largo for a month and this is the best Pizza 🍕 that we had. We'll definitely be back....

pick up location. did not have cheese (?) for subs. no pickles for subs either. got home and portion of sub bread was stale. turkey was so..sweet..maybe not good. couldnt eat. garlic and spinach pizza was delicious. fries were average. $39 for 1 pizza, one sub, a beer and a coke- average for keys. do not get subs. this is a pizza stop only!

Stopped in for a few slices to go. Courteous service. Not bad pizza for Florida.

The pizza here is so flavorful, great crust, roasted garlic...yum. great pizza menu options also. The server was attentive, knowledgeable and helpful. The inside of this place is nothing fancy. Reminds me of the 90s. Not that there's anything wrong with that. 🙂 You should eat here.

Upper Crust Pizza is BY FAR the most INCREDIBLE restaurant in the Florida Keys! We saw Upper Crust Pizza on Instagram and knew we had to go and try it. When we arrived the staff greeted us with a very warm and friendly welcome! The atmosphere in the restaurant was amazing, and the food was even better!!!!!! We ordered pizza (which was home made) and it was sooooooo delicious! The caprese salad was also super fresh and 100% worth getting. One in my party also was astonished by the outstanding beer selection they had. He ended up ordering an IPA and was given a walk through by the owner of the different beers they had and where they came from. We were smiling ear to ear the whole time at Upper Crust Pizza. The whole experience was out of this world! I am definitely coming back for the pizza and the vibes every time we go to the Florida Keys! Five Stars all the way!

Stopped here for dinner, ordered some pizzas. They were the worst pizza we’ve ever had, the steak fajitas pizza was inedible 🤢

Wings were great. Pizza is not my style being from the Philly area. Check the taps before you sit down. Sounds like they rotate frequently and the waitresses can stay on top of the beer list.

standard pizza nothing special. Prices isn’t terrible for pizza18$. Exact same motzarella sticks as kwik trip gas stations. The mozzarella sticks were $12 for five of them. Not really sure what their price point comes in for the weight of a pizza to stick. 😵‍💫 key gouger alert.

I had a large salad a pepperoni pizza and an eggplant sub delivered..the large salad is huge and fresh...I ordered the pizza thin and crispy.. it came out perfect and the eggplant !! Omg!! Definitely the go to in Key Largo!

The pizza was tasty, the staff was friendly.

One of my favorite local spots for pizza. The owner David makes you feel at home. Great selection of beers on tap. Everything is always top notch! The meat lover’s pizza is a personal favorite. They are closed on Wednesday’s.

I went here with my wife niki. We ordered a meat lovers pizza and beer. It was delicious. Probably the best pizza in key largo, along with cici’s. Will come back.

Good pizza and stuffed shells. Not a fan of the house dressing, but they charge for other dressings. Very small, bar like atmosphere.

Just popped in to grab a takeaway and was super impressed. Very cool place inside and the pizza was amazing! Really good. So fresh! Will definitely go back to eat inside. The menu was awesome and they had a mega selection of beers too. Good music, big tv with sports playing and well priced.

We loved the pizza! Great lunch!

My most recent trip to Upper Crust Pizza in Key Largo, Florida, was a delight, and our waiter, Sarah, added to our enjoyment by being amiable and attentive. The pizza, without a doubt, was the highlight of our trip. We chose to indulge in one of their pizza selections, and we were very pleased. The pizza was a delectable masterpiece that demonstrated the restaurant's commitment to making tasty, authentic pies. The Margherita pizza was very excellent, and I had the pleasure of tasting it. The tomato sauce was tasty and creamy, the crust was delightfully crunchy, and the melted mozzarella cheese was the great finishing touch. My dining partners enjoyed their pizza selections as well, each demonstrating the dedication of Upper Crust Pizza to providing excellent pizza.

We ordered the caprese 14" pizza, garlic bread, and salad to split between 2 after a messy snorkeling adventure that was ended short by a passing storm. The food was delicious, and we tucked in just about everything.

Pizza is always great, service as well.

Way faster delivery Then they told us! Delicious pizza, BEST WINGS AROUND!!!! amazing delivery driver!!!!! ♡♡♡♡♡

Way faster delivery then they estimated! Super nice people, amazing delivery driver! She rocked!!!! Delicious pizza and BEST CRISPY FLAVORFUL SAUCY WINGS!!!!!!

Great pizza and reasonable prices for the area.

The deep dish meat pizza we ordered was horrible, the red sauce tasted like it was Campbell’s tomato soup. The calzone had no ricotta cheese and looked like a flat cheesy bread from dominos. My family and I were very disappointed.

Probably the best value in town had the tuna melt and a slice of pizza and a Coke for under 15 bucks can't beat it! They are very consistent as well I wish they had sweet tea only regular tea... so I get a root beer and the root beer is really good

Before taking that long drive back to Ft Lauderdale I decide to stop here with my brother and enjoy a slice He ordered 2 pepperoni slices and I one meat lovers plus garlic knots Can't complain about price because it's the keys but service is bogus and quality is compared to gas station pizza My meats lover was a cold slice of pepperoni with pan heated meat on top not even incorporated in the cheese you can literally tilt it and all will fall off out of the two pepperoni we only got one but hey at that point we just wanted to bounce place has potential along to offer

Only had take out but food was great. Great pizza and wings!

Upper Crust in Key Largo has a pretty large menu, we tried the Calzone and Lobster/Crab ravioli. Both were delicious, ravioli came with delicious garlic bread and a side salad (Which was larger than expected). Calzone was nice and crispy, sauce had good flavor ( Large enough that I saved half for another meal). Plenty of choices on the menu, pretty much anything you want other than Chinese or Sushi! Craft beer selection was quite extensive also, definitely worth checking out if you are in Key Largo or the Upper Florida Keys looking for a decent meal.

Very mid food, mid service, atmosphere is verrry average. We had a white pizza not on homemade crust and my son had a meatball sub with frozen meatballs. The food wasn’t horrible but you for sure aren’t leaving there saying “we love that food”! Good place to get a beer and something in your stomach I would say.

Nice little gem of a restaurant that were glad we found on the drive to Key West. We'll plan to stop there everytime! It's not just pizza. Amazing Italian dishes across the board!

Great customer service. Nice place to go and eat and the pizza was GREAT.

Come before 5pm when it's fresh! But the beers are amazing. That's all enjoy!

Somehow great beer selection , now that I know I would come here just for beer and a slice of cheese. Glad I did not order a whole specialty pie... All the pizzas are just some basic cheese pizza (feels frozen honestly) and then they warm up your "toppings " on top of the cheese pizza.... If you order a slice of vegetarian Get Ready for a weird warm salad with carrots and broccoli. I had to dump mine off and eat with a fork. My kid's meatlovers was the same, warned up meat on top of the cheese. If THIS is what the "upset crust" is then that's what they should say is "Add a toppings to your slice." Disappointed to say the least

Great thin crust with good tasting bacon and sausage .

Tolles kleines Pizzarestaurant mit einer großen Auswahl an sehr leckeren Pizzen!

Outstanding pizza and choice of microbrews. A good variety w delicious sauce and eclectic choice or just plain pizza

Very good customer service. I was pleased with the top grade service. We ordered the garlic rolls and a pizza. The food was good and there were no issues with it. I smothered my food with garlic. Good tip for this area because of the mosquitos in the area. That evening I didn't have to put spray on. Getting back to the subject. Service was good and food was good as well. I would recommend this place to anyone that wants pizza while in the keys. Happy to have found this place.

The food was terrible and when it’s so dam expensive that’s unacceptable and didn’t match the prices on the posted menu online at all some as much as 10 dollars more just left me feeling tricked and robbed professionally

Fabulous place for pizza... their crust and sauce are homemade, made fresh daily... I definitely recommend to anyone that is in that area... trust me, you will NOT be disappointed. Thank you Upper Crust... great pizza.

I ordered a pickup, with some cheese sticks. They want to charge me $40 plus tax. This places a tourist attraction. Good not even good.

Kept kitchen open to get us a late night bite when we got in late to Key Largo... super frienly staff and yummy subs!

Great service we got here 25 minutes before hand and at 11 am the lady came out to my mom and I in the car to let us know they were open.

Place is over priced and terrible. Ordered two slices of pepperoni and a beer which cost $17, pizza was terrible microwaveable with slices of pepperoni added and the beer wasn’t more than 8 oz which isn’t a pint. Terrible terrible place.

Absolutely perfect thin crust pizza, carefully prepared, niformly proportioned

Goid but not pet friendly even don't offer to sit outside. Only if you ask

NEVER HAVE I EVER GOTTEN steaming hot pizza!! They open the box and you see beautiful clouds and streams of steam rising from your pizza.

NEVER HAVE I EVER GOTTEN steaming hot pizza!! They open the box and you see beautiful clouds and streams of steam rising from your pizza.

The seafood pizza (for $30) did not have much seafood on it. Maybe 10 pieces of imitation lobster and crab meat. One slice had 2 pieces on it. The bacon and pepperoni pizza was edible but not much flavor. I gave it 2 stars since it was edible.

This place is crazy expensive and the food was horrible, we didn't even finish it. The server barely spoke or even looked at us and the service was slow even tho there was only one other family in there. It was really bad all the way around.

Ordered 3 pies to go and while I had to wait a little longer, the pies were hot and the the tast was fantastic. Crust was not like any other pizza place. First time we had pizza with no leftovers or plates full of crust. Definitely going back

Excellent suggestion by our VRBO host. We're tourists that have traveled all around the Caribbean, USA, Mexico & Canada. This place has a great beer & wine selection. We started with the fried mushrooms which were good. They were hot and fresh tasting. We then had the 12" seafood pizza. It's amazingly delicious. It was plenty of pizza for 2. We only had 1 slice left over. The waitress was polite and attentive. Highly recommend this place.

I am very satisfied with the service and food. Great place to have lunch.

Outstanding selection of brews and pizza options. Great appetizers! The fried mushrooms 🍄 were very good. The seafood pizza was very good. Highly recommend for local ambience and food.

Very special pizza place in key largo. Always go here when I'm in the key largo area.

Excellent what a find! I needed the experience. I don't care for IPAs and they had the best IPA ever experienced. But I took the word of a Czechoslovakian bartender what would he know about beer . Czechoslovakian Brew some of the best beers in the world. David also installs Draft Taps in the Keys for other establishments . He is good. Then the food. Well I usually prefer deep pan crust sometimes called Chicago. My friend and I ordered a special and found out that it was awesome I looked at him and said I have to agree. I was looking for someplace special and found it right here. We traveled the length of the coast. This was the one our this so far. If you miss this one shame on you!!!! Although we need some Czech food on the menu Nejlepší jídlo a pití na míle a kilometry! Skvělá atmosféra, nejmilejší lidé, zejména českoslovenští. Son of Marenka

It's okay but there is nothing Cuban about the place. I rather get my food and go. It's kinda dark, small and boring inside.

Great little stop as we rolled into the keys later than expected. Not much else open and the food and service were both very good.

Loved the food, but really loved the humor and sarcasm that our waitress had to offer.