Whit's Frozen Custard - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Take out and outdoor patio. Love it. Daily and weekly flavors.

The ice cream is really good, the girls who work there are kind of the worst. They don't really know how to do their jobs which is fine but one girl spilled my milkshake on the counter while sliding it across to me and didnt offer to remake mine even though a third of it was now on the counter.. while this was going on, another girl was complaining about only receiving four tips for the day... like, I wonder why!

Great menu and all the workers are so friendly!

Love their rotating flavors. We always pick up a Pint and take it home for a week night treat

Love there chocolate plus Oreo chunks and pecans or almonds

Such creamy goodness! Do not pass up the chance to enjoy a Whit’s frozen custard!!

Ordered an Oreo whitser and it came with 1 Oreo on top and the rest was vanilla. Can’t believe they mcflurried me

Picked up some pints and taking them home to enjoy!

Pros. I/we enjoyed our ice cream there. The staff was friendly. We will return and just eat in our car. Cons. They have plenty of seating but no umbrellas to shade the area.

A true hidden gem. The staff was so friendly and the custard was delicious.

Always lots of options and it is great everytime!

This place never disappoints! The custard is delicious, and the staff is always cranking out the treats quickly no matter how busy!

One of my favorites. Sometimes long lines.

Whit's is our favorite ice cream joint!

From severel states away visiting Columbus area, was looking for small local ice cream shop. We found lots of choices and flavors. A bit far from our hotel but definitely worth the drive!

Love this place for custard and custard cookie sandwiches

BRING BACK QUARTS OF PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE DOUGH!!!

This store is fantastic. Black Raspberry Chip and Almond Joy are excellent flavors. It's always a great day when they open in the spring after their winter hibernation. The staff have always been great.

Way better than DQ, still. Quality is maintained. Update, new crew, I ordered a Heath Whitzer-like DQ Blizzard, not much Heath Bar; wife ordered Reese Pieces Whitzer, they used Reese Cups, and said they didn't have R. Pieces, she would have ordered something different if she knew beforehand.

Fast service. Friendly employees. Great dessert!

Que delicioso helado, en un hermoso establecimiento

Vanilla or chocolate. Add or mix in toppings. Super underwhelmed. Grocery store or drug store have more exotic flavors and offerings. Wasted trip. Left without buying anything. Seemed pretty clean and the high school girls running the place were nice but not outgoing or interested in making a sale.

Had the strawberry shortcake. It was delicious.

Delicious!! Excellent service!!

Bourbon Praline Pecan.... THE BEST EVER!!❤️‍🔥💯❤

Simply delicious and love the staff. If they are having Almond Joy, get it.

Great place and great people too.

The best place to get frozen custard!

This location is a walk-in shop. The staff is very nice! The frozen custard is great. My favorite thing to get here is the chocolate custard Sunday with fudge, caramel, and brownie bites. I think they have some of the best brownie bites in Columbus. I usually get a mini which is $4.75 and it is actually a decent size.

My favorite place. Try it you’ll love it

Such great custard and good customer service. I have lived in Pickerington for 10 years and just discovered it this year. It is hidden at the end of a drive-thru

The best. Every flavor is amazing. Blue berry pie, caramel cookie dough. The best

I wish they had non dairy since im lactose intolerant now because of my new medication but definitely good ice cream

Love that Whit's is so close. Favorite flavor Almond Joy. Great team.

The special (Almond Joy) a was delicious.

This place is amazing and the staff is ALWAYS very friendly.

Delicious. Really great ice cream.

You can’t beat their frozen custard, which in my opinion, is better than ice cream.

Very Yummy. Not much seating but that makes sense cause tons of people come in and out. Service is fast. ♡ Good prices. I love the chocolate chip cookie dough on vanilla. ♡

My wife and I have gone three times, and had a great experience each time. Their banana splits are my favorite, and are amazing! We've always had good, friendly service as well. We know what to expect here!