Benny's Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Best pizza in Jersey, you should give it a try, Order veggie special pizza. I guarantee you’ll love it. Staff if really friendly too 🤩

If you're looking for a pizza experience that will blow your taste buds away, look no further! The pizza here is hands down the best I’ve ever had. The crust was the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh, generously portioned, and cooked to perfection. Every bite was pure bliss. But what made the experience even better was the service. Danny was incredible! From the moment we walked in, he made us feel welcome and went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. Friendly, attentive, and genuinely passionate about the food, Danny made the entire experience unforgettable.If you’re craving pizza, this is the spot. Highly recommend!

Not a single complaint great pizza , great service, fast delivery, Francesca’s is the spot

It was so good! Definitely recommended the buffalo chicken!

My friends and myself drove up from Freehold to try the place. The food was nice and hot and really good. I got the personal margarita pizza and it’s bigger than any personal pizza i’ve received from other locations, the sauce was phenomenal, the crust was thin and cooked to a literal perfect crisp. I will drive the 45 minutes to have pizza from here again.

Man, where to start? Best pizzeria i’ve ever been to. Tyler (owner) is such a nice guy. Anyone who steps into his shop will be greeted with his amazing personality and customer service. Food is outstanding!! Truly no other pizza shop in Edison better than Francesca’s. There at Francesca’s Pizzeria, there is so many plates to choose from! Me personally, I really like the Meatball Parmigiana and the pepperoni pizza. Has always been a go to for me. Also, this pizzeria is a great environment for kids!! To anyone who is looking for a new pizzeria to try out, this is definitely the spot to go to. It’s a true gem.

Good food, friendly service : )

The vodka sauce is amazing...best I've had. Loved the tricolor slice and the tiramisu cake. Will definitely be back!

Pizza was super cold, and it’s just a below average pie. I don’t know how this place has over 4 stars

Fire pizza Good service Amazing place to eat

Ordered pizza for my Office From Francescas and it me away! The girls were talking about it all week! Definetley will be ordering from here again!

Writing this review while the pizza is still hot! Excellent Sicilian. Greek salad was great! Happy to have stumbled upon this local gem. Will definitely be back!

Decided to stop in Francescas for a slice during lunch break and I’m glad I did ! Perfect thin crust pie with a great sauce 🍅 !! I was able to meet the owner named Tyler . He was very welcoming and I will definitely be returning 🍕 😎!!! Ps the cannolis were delicious

Some of the best tasting pizza around!! Highly recommend, staff is very friendly and respectful. Atmosphere is great and will definitely come back!

Had lunch delivered to my office from here, very good pizza and very friendly staff. The new owner was very accommodating in explaining to me all the vegetarian options. Also offered free delivery ! My new go to pizza restaurant.

Benny’s has great thin crust pizza! Always great stopping by here when passing by.

Got food delivered from here. Very good quality and fast service. The staff is very warm and welcoming will definitely be back !

Amazing pizza. Amazing service.

I love Benny's! Tne food is amazing! They are so kind and helpful. The music is great too, When I have the time to sit down and relax. Mega stars and hearts for Benny's!!

Benny's is the best slice I've found in Edison.

I wanted to try a new place for pizza, Benny's had pretty good reviews and I decided to try them. I placed my order for delivery not realizing there was a $5.99 delivery fee which didn't show up until I got the order confirmation. I don't know if the delivery fee was from the establishment or the delivery company Grabull. The Grabull website says " their service is absolutely free, all you pay for is the food & whatever fee's are mentioned for delivery or processing and taxes" I did not see any mention of a delivery fee on Benny's website. Also is the delivery fee a guaranteed tip for the delivery person? If it is that person got a big tip because I added on a tip at checkout. As far as the pizza goes, it was just okay, it certainly was not worth $37.23! It's too bad since Pharmaceutical Reps pays for our lunches we order food several times a week for delivery. We can't go over $17.00 per person delivery fee's cut into that $17.00

I paid and when i was leaving with my family he call me and asking did I paid. Also too much oil on the pizza and big pieces of chicken on pizza Discussing Will never visit again

Good pizza, thin and chewy crust. Vodka Margherita was delicious and they took the time to add small details to the pie. (The white was good but needed a bit of salt.) Highly recommended.

Came in for a slice. Delicious bite and sauce. Definitely recommend.

Super chill but $&@! delicious pizza.

Excellent courteous customer Service, amazingly delicious food.

The Woodbridge location was much better. Ordered one of their "signature tomato pies" and got a floppy cheese pizza that tasted like cheese on toast. Not only did the delivery take significantly long, but the pizza was at best a 3 out of 5. They are absolutely lucky we gave them a 3. The meat lovers pie we ordered was just a bad because it was overly salty with a less than satisfying aftertaste. My wife and I were raving about this place to our family after tasting the Woodbridge location's tomato pie, but we felt beyond embarrassed to even recommend it.

Our office manager, Cara, catered our holiday luncheon today from this well-regarded establishment. The dishes were all excellent with frequent raves for the two versions of shrimp. The fra diavolo with the nicely peppery kick came in for special praise. The shrimp parmigiana was wonderful. The rigatoni Bolognese was top shelf. Not to be overlooked the penne with broccoli was perfectly prepared. Its garicky aroma perfumed the table setting. Plenty of nutritious greens with tasty balsamic dressing, fire-oven pan just right for dipping in the red sauces and not to be forgotten, the eggplant parmagiana and standard sausage and peppers fare disappeared quickly. Folks here at Penske South Plainfield know delicious foods when they see and smell it. All kudos to Mario and his people for pleasing this bunch of workers.

Good customer service respectful clean but I ordered plain large pie no flavor couldn't even taste cheese the pizza just had no taste at all this is my opinion

Mario is the absolute best this pizza is REAL NYC in the middle of Jersey!! Fresh REALLL INGREDIENTS sooooo Delicious!!! Come and get it p.s the specials are AMAZING!!!!

Love Bennys! Been here twice and enjoyed every bite! Garlic bread is yummy and so is the white pizza! This time I got a normal tomato pie and wow, the sauce is good. Very friendly staff. Coming here from now on for sure.

Best pizza I have found BY FAR since moving to Edison. The shrimp fra diavolo pie is amazing, I love that the sauce has a bit of kick. Dinners and lunches are good, too, but do yourself a favor and get the pizza!

Great place, great owner. They really put their heart on what they do.

Incredible pizza, friendly owners... Pizza is perfectly crisp and tastes great!

Excellent pizza, by the slice or by the pie, pick up or delivery or take out. The best pizza in Edison family owned and operated. Great place to bring the kids for pizza . I also want to add that we have gone here for dinner and lunch and the place is always very clean. Unlike some other pizzeria here in Edison NJ. Real Italian food. Great food and fast.

This is by far the best pizza I've ever had! We visited the other day for lunch and had the spinach, mushroom, and feta. I don't know how they make the crust both soft and crunchy at the same time and it was just so flavorful. Can't wait to visit again!

the food was amazing, friendly service, nice place. definitely gonna come here in the future.

Very nice local pizza place.. definitely try

***Update*** 1/2/23*** Spaghetti and meat sauce was outstanding! Excellent pizza. Reminds me of sliced I tried back in Dyker Heights and Fort Hamilton and 18 Ave. New local fave pizza spot! ***Update***2/4/23*** Delicious shrimp Diablo ***update***2/16/23 sinful chicken cutlets in vodka sauce

Really good pizza and excellent customer service. And yes, they have fresh hot peppers 🌶

Got weeknights dinner Benny’s. Heard it from a fnd that their Grandma’s pizza( pesto) is good. True.. the flavors are amazing. Their garlic knots are so soft. Tried minestrone soup as well. A new addition to my list. I would definitely go again and again. Space is well maintained and clean.

Pizza is the best I’ve tasted in NJ so far. The food is above par as well. The vodka sauce cannot be beat; never tasted better. Had it here once and even if I don’t order it as a main course, I will get it on the side because I HAVE TO HAVE it when I eat there (yes, it’s that good). Mario is a great chef and always goes the extra mile to treat guests like they’re family. The whole staff makes you feel welcome and appreciated. Even though I’m in Old Bridge, I will drive the 15-20 minutes to go get a few pies to go because it’s definitely worth the trip.

Mario is the best! Not only is he a sweetheart of a guy, but his pizza is fantastic! His catered dishes are exceptional! Great cook! great pizza! Great guy ! Definitely got try Bennys pizza!

The owner and his family treat youu like family. Very warm and inviting. The food, delicious!!! I don't think they have served me anything I did not thoroughly enjoy. I especially love his Vodka sauce.

I go to this place 1-2 times a week not only is the pizza delicious, my favorite is the vodka sause pizza, but Mario and his team are so friendly and treat everyone like family. They make it feel very homie. 11/10 recommend.

Soooooo good. We ordered a bunch of different dishes to try and everyone of them were delicious!!! Mario and staff are awesome. Can't wait to go back.

Food was phenomenal! Best penne vodka with chicken I’ve ever had! Mario the owner and his team make their guests feel like family. I’ve GOTTA be back!

Best thin crust 🍕 around the area.

Excellent Food . I ate there 6 times already and the pizza is Extremely good and the meals are Very Delicious.

Under new ownership Benny and his son are great! Pizza is absolutely amazing ! The Brooklyn way baby!

Very friendly people amazing food

updated review Mr. Mario is now onboard in Edison leading this fine restaurant pizza place..., and is a great guy who loves food and people.... I had a speciality sub made just the other day with added arugula for my girlfriend who works down the street in South Plainfield but its super local to this place, OMG she was so happy she ate half the sub for lunch and saved the other half for her dinner that night while still working a full book of business..., She is an owner of a higher end salon and truth be known really works hard from 9am till 9pm. So she can get hangry and she really loves good tasty clean food... its all here with Mario at Bennys Pizza. original review News Flash, the best pizza maker restaurant owner has opened on Oak Tree Road in Edison. THIS IS THE BIGGEST NEWS you need to pay attention to! Stop in grab a menu..., I did by chance moments ago..., The story is this Benny had opened a restaurant in Woodbridge on Amboy avenue and NOW he has opened this one in Edison. So its his second restaurant. So i seen the new sign days ago and when i rode past today I had seen an open sign. Knowing the sign said Benny's the same font and color, i quickly turned in to go and see. YES..., even the owner Benny was there working with an employee doing a soft opening. We talked some and he is a generous good natured man living his dream to make great tasting foods. I had a slice of veggie pizza as I was on the run. ITS SO GOOD...! Mark my words down. BEST PIZZA IN EDISON AREA is now ready to go! Lunch specials, dinners ,catering trays...., It's All here It's All good, It's All fresh quality ingredients made right. try Benny's you will be glad you did.

Came here for a quick slice found out it was under new ownership from a family from NY who has been in business for 40 years food was AMAZING VERY AUTHENTIC clean place and great staff will definitely be my GOTO spot

New to the neighborhood, we tried Benny's pizza. Excellent thin crust pizza. Their tomato pies are excellent. We also tried their Margarita pie and we were not disappointed. Fresh toppings, quick delivery, our first try was a positive experience. Their chicken parmesan is excellent as is the chicken pesto. This place has great food as well as pizza. Nice people and excellent service, this is our new favorite neighborhood pizzeria.

Just got a classic cheese pizza from the edison location. I give it 5 stars for the thin crust. However, The dough has way too much cornmeal embedded in it, that it has a nasty grainy texture, very unpleasant to eat. I give the crust a minus 3 rating. There is the potential for a great pizza shop, if they can improve their dough recipe. Guess I'm going back to Cicco or Luigi pizza, in south plainfield.

Pizza is perfect and hospitality is A+ I called and placed my order so it can be ready when I get there, and It was. Hot crunchy and thin just how I like it. Best of luck

Tastes different from their Woodbridge location

Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Thin crush. Delicious

The aftermath of coming here….. no bite left behind 😋 freshly made by hand , satisfying from beginning to end

I always go to the nail supply store next to it and my boyfriend & I decided to grab a slice here! Pizza was delicious and the owner was super friendly and provided great service! Will definitely be back😁