Big Boy's Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Stopped in for a few slices because I was starving. Modern decor, great, friendly service and most importantly delicious food definitely will be back.

I’ve Had pizza from everywhere - NY, Naples, Rome wherever and tried all the best spots. This is my favorite NY style slice anywhere. Foods incredible, new ownership is amazing and super cool too. Authentic stuff and also got offered free food and drink. Go and guarantee you won’t regret it

Great Italian pizza and the owner is an amazing person! Will come back here!

I ordered a whole Petey Boy hot sub. It came with fresh mozz, tomatoes, breaded chicken, prosciutto, balsamic and pesto. It was so good! The bread was fresh and better than what I was expecting. I think it’s rare to find a good pizza spot that really adds the love to their bread. I’m excited to try the rest of the menu!

AMAZING. Best Supreme pizza, CheeseSteak Stromboli, and chicken Parmigiano that we have ever had. The quality of food, size of meals and the price is so much better than OHIO. This family styled restaurant deserves more attention and more customers to soak in the dining room and great pizzeria atmosphere.

Always stop by when I’m in the neighborhood. The pizza is great and the sandwiches are even better.

Me and my daughter went there multiple times. They are very welcoming and the pizza crusts are delicious. Loved it!

Editing my review since change of ownership and about two years later. This place still rocks, awesome food and awesome atmosphere no complaints here👍

They’ve recently gotten new ownership. Jeannie, one of the owners, it’s like the Italian mother I’ve always wanted. She’s awesome! The food is exceptional, quick service and nice little vibe inside. My pizza was cooked perfectly. It’s a Top 5-10 pizza in the area for sure and that says a lot. Will be coming back!

We were there for a private party. We were treated with multiple items...calamari, eggplant rollatini, chicken franchise, rigatoni bolignese, Shrimp parm, veal saltimbocca, . Everything was cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. The only other thing I can say is try this place...you will not be disappointed!

We got the roasted garlic and spinach pizza. I wanted to tell you I tried getting my old pizza place to make this exact pizza. They did as I asked, but it didn't come out as well as yours. Yours is PERFECT! Thanks again!

Dynamite, every entree cooked perfectly. Very nice dining area. Warm delicious bread. Will Remember this spot.

I’ve ordered the eggplant parmesan dinner a few times over the past couple mths. The eggplant parmesan is very good, they don’t bread the eggplant which I like. The salad is good and the pasta is good. Just tried the meatballs for first time and they are very good! On one occasion I had an issue with the gal who answered the phone being a lil impatient and rude but the owners handled the situation with the utmost professionalism and courtesy and took care of me and I haven’t had a problem since. Good food, good portions, reasonably priced and excellent customer service. The owners are the best! I have only ordered delivery so can’t speak on the atmosphere but I’m sure it’s good.

Fantastic pizza and nicest staff!

Fantastic food and service. Family owned business and they are a pleasure to deal with.

Best garlic knots that I ever had. They were extremely moist and flavorful. I also enjoyed my pepperoni and pineapple pie.

Overall, I had a wonderful experience dining in at Big Boy’s Pizza. The food was delicious and the hospitality was amazing.

We ordered two pastas last night and they were both delicious! My other family members also order from here often.

Great place , I ordered a takeout and the were very helpful with explaining the content inthh sandwich. Made us very feel very comfortable in placing the order.

Order takeout. The food is fresh, delicious and the portions are large.

Phone ordering was simple and easy. The person taking the order was knowledgeable and offered to apply day specials to my order even when I didn’t know about it. Payment was processed over the phone with no problems. Pick up was in time and the food was ready and hot as it should be. Aside from all that, it was delicious. We love Big Boy’s Pizza. Thank you.

Awesome staff!! Food is always fresh and above my expectations. Portions are also beyond what I expected. I feel 5 star rating is not enough and a sixth star should be added for an establishment like this one.

As a lifelong NYer who knows his pizza, I can honestly say this is one of the best pizzas I have ever tried. Wonderful staff and service. Great new management. Highly recommended!

From the second we walk into a warm family sized greeting everything was perfect. Food was fresh and tasty. Plan on going back real soon.

Best drunken chicken parm in NJ. Great people, great food.

Pizza was delicious and huge! Got a plain and it was really good, tomato sauce tasted fresh and the cheese was stringy. People there were super friendly and made the pizza well. Would go back.

I highly recommend Big Boy's Pizza for an excellent pizza experience! The taste is unparalleled. It's, without a doubt, the best place in town for pizza lovers. Every bite is a delight – they truly excel in delivering pizza perfection!

Very personable, food is great! They deliver!! Yummy crispy pizza!!

Got the spicey vodka sauce pasta with chicken and loved the meal! Would recommend and will definitely get again!

Took out — great sandwiches and pizza!

I’ve been here several times already under the new ownership, and I absolutely LOVE everything I ordered! I’ve had the baked ziti, eggplant rollatini, Tuscan wrap, and “the cugine” which is half chicken parm in red sauce and half in Alfredo sauce. The baked ziti and eggplant rollatini was so DELICIOUS! They use high quality cheeses in all their dishes. “The cugine” was amazing! The chicken parm in Alfredo sauce was so good! They make a very delicious Alfredo sauce. The food here is far better than any of the other pizza shops in the area. The owners are so warm and welcoming too. I rarely give out 5 stars, but this place deserves it. I highly recommend Big Boy’s Pizza in Marlboro!

Friendly staff, hot, fresh food. We really enjoyed it!

Pizza was very good. Great service….

Great pizza, great service, and great place to sit and eat your pizza. Probably the only place I see with good service compared to any place.

Pizza was cooked perfectly. Veggie pizza was excellent. Lots of finely chopped veggies. Cheese pizza was delicious. No runny oil. Crust was crisp but not burnt. Our new favorite place.

Ordered shrimp fra diaovlo with rigatoni! Absolutely delicious thank you!

Food was good, but they gave me the wrong sandwich

Stopped in to grab a slice after a hard day of yard work. We came to pick up some takeout from Sichuan Cottage next door, and decided to get some slices for takeout as a snack. Man oh man did that pizza hit the spot! I got one of their meat combos, and a mushroom. Cheese pull was *chef's kiss*, the crust was just the right thinness and crispy, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio was spot on. Sauce was seasoned just right, and not overly sweet! I'm impressed! We'd been going to Marlboro Pizza but now we found a spot that has truly won us over. As per ambiance, the place looked very clean and there was plenty of seating if you wanted to come with a party for sit-down. The employees were very kind and friendly, could've stayed there for hours just chatting. Will be back!

If ubare in the area.. it's a must visit for food.

Everything was great! The Vivaldi pizza was delicious 🤤 especially as I was craving something with artichokes it hit the spot!

For pizza enthusiasts and foodies exploring Marlboro's culinary scene, stumbling upon Big Boys Pizza might just be the highlight of your gastronomic journey. As a cornerstone in the Marlboro community, Big Boys Pizza has been serving up slices of joy to the locals and visitors alike. Here's why this pizzeria is gaining traction as a go-to spot for those in search of the perfect pizza. Ambiance and Service: Upon entering Big Boys Pizza, the ambiance hits you with a warm and welcoming vibe that promises a casual yet delightful dining experience. The staff at Big Boys Pizza makes you feel right at home, with a friendly smile and attentive service that adds a personal touch to your meal. Menu and Specialties: Big Boys Pizza offers an extensive menu that goes beyond the traditional pizza offerings. While classics like the Margherita and Pepperoni are perfected here, the pizzeria also presents a variety of specialty pies that tantalize the taste buds. Quality and Taste: When it comes to quality, Big Boys Pizza doesn't cut corners. Each pizza is a testament to their commitment to freshness, with dough made daily, high-quality toppings, and the perfect blend of spices. The crust strikes an ideal balance between chewy and crisp, providing the perfect foundation for the rich, flavorful toppings. Takeaway and Delivery: For those on the go, Big Boys Pizza has made a name for itself with its efficient takeaway service. And if you're looking to enjoy their delicious pizzas from the comfort of your home, the delivery is punctual and reliable, ensuring that you receive your meal hot and fresh. Enjoy the best pizza in Marlboro!

Food was great delivered when they said

Can’t speak to the atmosphere because I’ve never eaten there, but as far as pizza goes I love it. We’ve been looking for a fresh new pizza place close to us and found it. And a bonus is the coupons they’ve been texting me to save me money!

This is my new to go pizzeria! I live about 6 miles away and have 3 other pizzerias near me but I frequent these guys because their food is delicious! From the pizza to the salads to the sandwiches to the pasta dishes. Youre missing out if you dont try these guys out. Their regular slices are just like I used to have in Brooklyn. The sauce on them is crazy good. We ordered a grilled chicken with broccoli rabe the other night. Not only was the price incredibly reasonable but the size....crazy huge! We got 3 meals.out that one sandwich. Try these guys. You will love them!!

I went here for a lunch recently with some friends and had a cheesesteak, slice of Sicilian, and a slice of bbq chicken. The pizza was good and reasonably priced. I was not impressed by the cheesesteak but it was not bad, just not awesome. The manager/owner is very polite.

Under new management. Hallelujah! Food is fresh and delicious. Ask for extra sauce every time because it is sooo good. Love the rice balls. Need a good pizza place within walking distance and this is it!

The pizza is delicious and the restaurant looks completely brand new since the new owners took over Big Boys Pizza. They also have lots of other options on the menu. I will definitely repeat.

Since being under new management, the food is 10000 times better. Hands down, one of the best chicken Parms I’ve had and I am very picky. I brought my family home pizza and they can’t wait to come back and eat. Staff and service were very friendly and helpful. Will definitely be back.

It's not the Big Boys of old.. It's just average now. Nothing special. Unremarkable slice, nothing that differentiates it from the dozen other pizza places in the area. The chicken Parm slice I had was very floppy.

So to start off with, I called in and asked if the deep dish was Detroit style of Chicago style, I was told "like Chicago style" well it's not; it's a round Sicilian. It's okay just light on the sauce

Pizza was ok. Wasn't nasty tasting. The person behind the counter serving slices did not use gloves, touching money, multiple credit cards and slices back and forth until she removes the slice from the spatula positioning it into your bag, using her bare hands yet again. Unsanitary turnoff. 2 stars is generous.

Went to get the grandma slice and definitely legit. Fresh and very flavorful. Great quality and perfect crust. Can’t wait to try other items on the menu.

The owner is a really good guy. The food is excellent! A great, laidback pizza/lunch spot that I have become a regular at!

Awesome dinners I will say no more

Would highly recommend Big Boys! The service is wonderful from the husband and wife team (Todd and McKenzie). The food is amazing! I got catering for a large party and everybody kept asking where I ordered from! I would definitely order again!

Food is fresh, hand crafted, and delicious. Quality here stands out compared to your run of the mill pizzeria. I would highly recommend. The price and portions are unbeatable in this day and age.

Penne with vodka sauce was excellent. Chicken franchese was good but sauce had a weird texture. Chicken was good quality but they only gave us 2 pieces that were on the small side. Shrimp scampi was flavorful but 6 small shrimp reminded us more of an appetizer. Caesar Salad was terrible don't even bother. $5 coupon incentive was nice but we won't be ordering from here again. Sorry guys we really wanted to like it.

Always a delish meal! Chicken Parm Pizza is a must try!!

Great food. Friendly and accommodating staff. Menu was a variety of dishes to choose from. Will definitely be back.

Amazing seafood scampi!!! High quality food. Homemade mozzarella!!! Definitely worth the drive of an hour! Highly recommended

Pizza spot on little salty but crust great , we ordered kids chicken fingers and fries don’t bother. Fries great fingers are small over fried and dry my kid tried one and that’s a wrap . Ceased salad is insanely lemony to a point that it ruins the flavor . Will definitely order pizza but that’s where it stops