Buffalo steakhouse & seafood in Key Largo - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Food is delicious! Good portions too!

Great food great service I highly recommend

When you don’t want fish in the keys, this is the place to go. Clean, great service and atmosphere. Highly recommended.

Great food. Mashed potatoes are amazing!

Seriously, the best food in Key Largo! It’s BYOB, but the atmosphere is absolutely amazing!!

SUPER GOOD AND VERY GOOD SERVICE❤️

Excellent charcoal-fired food and the spectacular atmosphere make you feel like family. Very good service!!!

The food and service was great and meats delicious 😋

Very good meat and excellent service!

We arrived and ordered drinks half the stuff on the menu was not available. No pasta, no chicken strips, they had steak but my wife didn’t like the options so we left without eating.

Excellent meat, great service, I recommend it ❤️

So my son and I explored this lil hole in the wall, such a cute spot and the food is so yummy, such a family atmosphere. The people that work here are so sweet!! We’d def come back here with a bigger appetite.

Daniela and Keily served me 100% recommended, the food was super delicious

Food was excellent We recommend the ribs and the matched potatoes and avocados as sides

Had a great steak. Friendly staff. Go visit.

on vacation around this area. So so good! We went there twice and it was delicious both times. Good service, clean atmosphere and great friendly staff:)

Don't be fooled by the look of this place, the food was absolutely amazing. Really juicy steak with fantastic fresh kale salad, mashed potato with some extra and chicken wrapped in bacon was stunning. Very friendly people and nice atmosphere. Highly recommend, you won't be disappointed.

Ordered for delivery and while it came fast we know why. The burger was raw and not safe to eat. We had to throw the whole thing away. White rice was a little sticky which I like but the rest was crunchy and not cooked long enough.

All delicious food, juicy meat, cozy atmosphere and good service. It is a very good experience!

This was place caught us off guard. You walk in and question if you are at the right place but if you love good food it’s the right spot. The (s)mashed potatoes are awesome. The filet, grouper and ribs were so good. Can’t recommend this place enough, the server was great and quick. Wish we took pictures before it was all gone. Try sitting outside it was too hot for us on this day.

Very good food a little wait but worth the wait

Daniela the waiter was super helpful and patient with us nothing but the best service coming from these folks, and the food was amazing delivered on time warm and mouth watering

Food is better than high end steakhouses! Casual environment is deceiving. The food is incredible. The mashed potato’s, grouper and even the kale salad was amazing.

Went for our anniversary ordered the wings they were hard like bricks. Absolutely disgusting

Excellent food and very good service, I recommend it 100%

Food was cooked in old grease. Wings came without sauce and they were overcooked.

Does not look fancy from the outside,and fancy it is not. But it's clean and modern. But the food is fantastic at a very reasonable price! Large servings on top of that! By far the best meal I had in the Florida keys! Highly recommend. Pro tip: they do not have a liquor license, but you are welcome to bring your own beer or wine!!!😃

Incredible service! A little expensive for the size of the dish, the farofa tasted old and the picanha was slightly cold.

food and service was amazing! ❤️

Excellent place, clean and cozy, the meats very delicious, spectacular flavor, and very good service, the girl very attentive

Wonderful food Brazilian Style, laid back atmosphere.

The food was amazing we stayed close by and went to the fish house but the wait was 1 hour so we looked for some were else and we got lucky the food was great

Very tasty and good food!!! Very nice people!

Don’t go !! Just don’t go ! Flies dirt and food is horrible the worse I ever had. Sitting outside with flies everywhere you feel like eating at the trash dump. Waited over 45 mins for food just to trash it

Walked in at 9:15pm from driving 5 hours from central Florida. Another group of Spanish speaking individuals walked in 5 minutes after us. The other group of people had menus, drinks, and ordered their food while we sat there ignored. We waited 20 minutes total and nothing happened. Went 1 minute down the road to Lazy Lobster and received great service.

Friendly staff and delicious food. Come hungry!

Great place to eat have dinner and on Saturdays live music great atmosphere great servers Erick is one of the best cooks I have known

Delicious burger and Daniela served us amazingly

The best food you can try...I recommend it 100%...exquisite customer service...eating here is another level ✌🏻

Excellent Cuban food to enjoy 100%. Cayo Largo dresses up with its offers and services to the consumer THANK YOU

Best filet mignon I've ever had.

Food was awesome, service size is generous, priced just right... Take a taste of their sweet potato fries... Very good...

Bufalo Steakhouse & Seafood offers the best steak in the Florida Keys. From the moment you enter, the warm, welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff make you feel special. The steak, cooked to perfection, is juicy, tender, and full of flavor. The side dishes complement the main course perfectly, and the impressive wine selection enhances the dining experience. With exquisite food and outstanding service. Bufalo Steakhouse & Seafood is a must-visit spot in the Keys. Highly recommended!

Great food. Daniela was very nice with us.

Daniela served us, a super nice girl, the food was very tasty, I recommend the place 💯, it is very nice. Thank you Daniela for the good service

Quality Food quality ingredients friendly service. We left happy and full! Los tostones son increíbles!

Food is amazing steak is tender and full of flavor!

Very good service and spectacular food. I recommend it.

The best charcoal-grilled meat in the keys

If your looking for something different in town besides seafood, Buffalo always stays consistent with great quality meats & side options. They're also one of the only late night kitchens open til 11pm every day

Very nice place to enjoy the food, the food was very delicious and the mango juice was excellent, thanks for the attention Erick and Yamile… I will return soon.

The food super Good,the service is amazing.The picanha is the best 😋😋😋😋

Go 🦬 My wife and I where staying at a local resort and decided to try this place. The Chef here takes pride in his work. Great attention to detail. Deliciously prepared & seasoned lamb chops and Ribeye for me and the Mrs huge Portions for reasonable price. The sides where Buttery Mashed red potatoes, rice, fried Yuca and AMAZING KALE SALAD that really impressed me. 👌 All this including the appetizer was under $100.

The best charcoal meats that exist 300% recommended

We had the best time on a Saturday night with Daniela taking care of us and CJ playing the best music outside. The food is to die for!! You can bring your own alcohol as the liquor license is pending. It was a blast even with torrential downpours towards the end of the night. We will be back!

Super restaurant, the food is exquisite, the best in the keys

The best shrimp cream in the keys are the best

The food is very good, I love the tension, everything is very delicious 🙌🏻

Great food and service! I will definitely come here again

Love it! Ca.not wait to return. All dishes were delicious.

Food was absolutely amazing! Staff was amazing as well

Great food and excellent customer service

Very large portions and delicious food. Steak was wonderful and shrimp was delicious. Well Done to the chef. Hidden Gem.

Amazing customer service. Food is very authentic, cooked right in front of you. Meat selection is great and very affordable, definitely will be coming back.

Great place the food was amazing. Great salad and the fish tacos where the best

In general I liked everything, but of everything I ordered I loved the Catalan cream, ufff, it was so delicious,

We were just looking for a quick bite to hold us over, so we decided to try this place out. We loved the decor, the staff was super friendly, and the food was outstanding. We had more than enough food.

The food is spectacular, very very delicious, I recommend it 100%..

Great Brazilian style meats with a friendly staff. Delicious!

My first time was there and I ordered ribeye and taste amazing 👏 I love it even white rice was so delicious and dear server she is ( Dani) amazing ask for her when you get there thank you guys

Everything was excellent.. food was fresh and service was outstanding

Delicious dinner and great service! Daniella was great. Will definitely be coming back

Very delicious food in general, desserts, coffee and great service, highly recommended for your trip to the Florida Keys.

Very good quality and attention, I recommend it 💯

I loved Daniela's attention. The food is spectacular, a super good atmosphere

Daniela's service is spectacular. I love super delicious food, I recommend it 100%. The place is super nice

Hate to complain. Seldomly do. Never got a chance to experience the food. Not even a glass of water. Service gets -2 stars. Actually waited almost 30 minutes and no one ever came to the table. Guess they are flush. Cheers to the small businesses' in the keys. A local should open close. Wish I was marathon. Steak and seafood restaurant is always fire. Time to head to largo. Clean up

WOW! the place doesn’t look like much but WOW! What a meal: picahna rice and corn. The presentation was like 5 start restaurant. The tastes was even better. Delicious, tasted homemade: natural and FRESH. I’m definitely coming back.

The service is very slow, the waitress doesn’t understand anything, however the food is pretty good but you can find better in key largo …

He recommended them 100% L or better for long key

Just what the keys needed! Amazing Steaks, Appetizers, Great food and service!

An excellent place to enjoy a tasty meal, it always surprises you

If you are looking for a good steak 🥩 this is the best place, wonderful experience, I recommend it!!!

Excellent service!! Extensive & Delicious steak and seafood items in the menu at reasonable prices. Owners and staff are very friendly and respectful. Must try the Pichana, I highly recommend it!

Above and Beyond Expectations!!! Lamb Chops were PERFECTION!!! Highly Recommended.

Excellent food, service and pirice!

Very good Restaurant, the best barbecue in Key Largo. Everything very delicious 😋 and very good service.

A spectacular place to spend time with the family, exceptional food, I recommend it 100%

Excellent place...delicious food as well as its service and atmosphere...I recommend it 💯%

The treatment was very pleasant and friendly and their prices are excellent. I really want to go again. Congratulations to all the people who work there.

Nice place, very good variety in the menu, with a unique and schist flavor, the service and customer service with efficiency and speed, very comfortable with the attention of Miss Tatiana who gave me excellent treatment and service.

Good quality food and Tatianas servicio was amazing.

A good place to spend a pleasant time with good food.

We went out for a late dinner and stumbled upon Buffalo Steakhouse & Seafood. We sat at the open kitchen bar and were blown away by the parade of meats that came out of the kitchen. We got filet, yuca, kale salad, rib eye with mushrooms…every bite was so fresh and delicious. We are so happy to have this place so close to our house. We will be back and can’t wait to bring our friends next time!

I loved the service, the food and the atmosphere was super nice. I recommend it 100%.

My name is Jessica, I live in Orlando, I was visiting Los Cayos where I ate at this great place, the food is magnificent, excellent, very delicious. Delighted with the Treatment of the Waitress Tatina Leyva Ramos as well as the other colleagues 10/10 Visit it 👌🏻🫶🏻

Wow! Everything was delicious. It's been a while I don't enjoy so many awesome flavors in just one meal. We ordered Picanha, fried Yuca (excellent!), black beans, ribs, an khale salad. Super recommended!!

My husband and I felt in love with the delicious tasty food after having lunch we order some to go as well. The place is nice and clean and all the staff were very friendly and polite. Definitely a place to come back to when we come back to visit.

Great vibes, spectacular food and perfect service. The music is excellent! Thank you. I highly recommend this place.

A hidden gem! An incredible little steakhouse, the chef really pours love into the food and it really shows! Hands down best steak in the keys, not even a fair chance to any other restaurant offering steaks. The sides and appetizers were equally delicious. We will 1000% return again. Highly recommend!