Italian Food Company in Key Largo - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Antonio is was great! Had a wonderful dinner ☺️

Great atmosphere and great food. Sever Antonio was awesome.

Amazing authentic Italian food. Service and staff are on point.

Great food and service. Italian music and outdoor seating with huge fans made the atmosphere really authentic. Melissa was our waitress who went the extra mile. Thanks

Best pizza in the keys!! We’ve been coming her for 2 years and still our favorite restaurant. We love coming during lunch but dinner is just as special too as they have live music on the weekends and the atmosphere is perfect enough to make you want to stay! Tana is our girl! She makes each visit feel like we’re family and remembers our favs every time! :)

Looking for a restaurant for dinner we went to this pizzeria we ate well, the pepperoni pizza was good as well as the bruschetta and the caprese salad. We had a good time outside thanks to the fans, despite the heat.

Loveeeee the food, atmosphere is awesome! And Antonio the server was the best! Def going back!

Antonio was OUTSTANDING!! we were a party of 29 people including 16 kids. He managed everything so professionally and kindly. The food was great and the atmosphere was everything we needed for our family and friends getaway.

We were a group of 30 and Antonio provided absolutely excellent service. The food was delicious and the service impeccable.

I ordered the veal expecting a tender cut of veal I have literally had round steak that was more tender than that unchewable! And they still charged me 36 dollars for boot leather! I have no problem paying good money for a good meal left hungry and sad because it was my wife’s 65 birthday. Disappointed to say the least!

Our meals were delicious! We will definitely be back! Our server was Antonio. He was very friendly and attentive.

Yes I said it 5 stars down the line. Absolutely the best food in key largo. The service was spot on.. get there early got super busy

No AC We understand everything and we wish you all the best for bringing real Italian cuisine to Key Largo, but having to eat outside when there is no wind and the temperature is 94F takes away your appetite. We didn't even get out of the car in your parking lot. We go to Key Largo often, next time we'll stop. Best wishes again.

Neapolitan pizza chefs. Delicious pizza, homemade desserts or imported from Italy. If you are looking for really good pizza in Key Largo you are in the right place!

The position is good and also the atmosphere. The service is fair but the wine served in the water glass is not good. The food is nice but the mozzarella was not so good.

Food and coffee where amazing.... Antonio was excellent and would highly recommend 👌

As good as New York pizza exceeded my expectations and great service in a cool location. 5 stars

Delicious pizza with high quality ingredients. Excellent pizza restaurant for Italians in Key Largo who want to feel at home again

Outstanding Italian place and excellent atmosphere in Key Largo! And that pizza is Gluten free, one of the best!.

Excellent place to visit, food was delicious, atmosphere perfect, staff friendly, attentive and knowledgeable. Definitely worth a visit, we would definitely go here again.

Delicious meatballs. Nice and moist. Waitress was very nice ♡ surprisingly cool for an outdoor dining experience

The wonderful place with such a cool Miami atmosphere. The best Italian pasta that I have ever tried in the USA! Very nice customer service as everyone was so nice and friendly. And special thanks to our server, Antonio who took care of your mood, comfort and mood. Definitely recommend for visit ❤️

Very warm welcome, good food, but very expensive!

Had a great time! Amazing food, service, and atmosphere.

The calamari and shrimps, so fresh and delicious and the pastas amazing, and our server Anthony was so carefull even he was running arround all the time, he provided the best custumer services we could get, and also the place is the best i ve had eat arround

I went to eat with my girlfriend and the pizza was amazing, I'm Italian and considering Naples is not around the corner I was quite impressed. Also thank you Antonio nice service and nice name buddy 👍🏼

Antonio is the friendliest server Definitely request him

Great and fast service from Antonio

Absolutely wonderful Antonio was an absolute delight made our entire night. Definitely a key staple

Amazing food and awesome service from Anthony! Go and eat this food!

Antonio was our waiter. Very friendly, great recommendations and excellent service! Loved the burrata salad.

Great wood fired pizza. Easy on the sauce, decent on the toppings. We took it to go so can’t say anything about eating in. Tasted delicious.

Great food! Cosy Italian setting. We were served by Antonio. Wonderful guy, top service!

Food was so tasty and fresh, we ordered the Margheritta and Riccota and Prosciutto Pizza and they were both the real deal. And Antonio was very attentive and looking after our every needs.

Delicious food Antonio was very friendly and helpful

Great food and great service! We’ll probably have lunch here tomorrow. Amazing service from my buddy Antonio.

Great service! Ask for Antonio!

we had the best lunch at the italian food company and antonio has been absolutely wonderful so friendly and professional the food was great the deserts are out of this world and we def will come back thank you so much for the best experience ever and my daughter fell in love with her chocolate nut cake to the point where we have to stop on the way back from the keys

Absolutely delicious! Antonio provided phenomenal service! Great recommendations, perfect level of attention.

Antonio was amazing! We loved the food and the service was great. We are from NYC and we are impressed! We will be back

Antonio our server was amazing! they accommodated our large group with friends and kids and we had the best time. Great food, great service, an amazing night.

Great food. Server Antonio was excellant

Super delicious, highly recommended. Antonio served us very kindly and attentively, explaining all the dishes and his excellent service.

Our food was delicious! Service super fast. Antonio super friendly and excellent host! We will come back soon!

Excellent food and Antonio's unbeatable service Our new favorite restaurant

Absolutely amazing! The best Italian food I have ever had. From start (appetizers and entrees) to finish (dessert) everything was superb. Had a variety of entrees - pizza and pasta dishes - and the flavors were delicious. Fantastic service from Antonio also! Can’t wait to come back.

This was the BEST Italian food that I’ve ever had! Antonio was quick and efficient and timed the food coming out perfectly. His customer service was top notch! My husband and I were blown away by the food - we got the bruschetta, Diablo pizza, pear pasta, tiramisu, and cream puffs. Every single thing was incredibly delicious. I can’t recommend this place highly enough!! Definitely make a reservation!!

Best Italian food in the keys and then some. Pasta is always al dente and flavorful Had a prosciutto and burrata sandwich on pizza dough with crusted parm cheese that was probably one of the top 10 sandwiches ever. Add Antonio’s excellent and courteous service and the whole experience is beyond excellent

Great atmosphere and delicious food! Our server Antonio was also friendly and very attentive.

Wonderful food and our server Antonio was great!

We enjoy coming to Italian food Co, food is always delicious and Antonio gave us great service

Antonio my waiter was great had a great time food was amazing definitely recommend

Maybe I’m the outlier here. The pizza was cooked too quickly, so a little burnt on the bottom but under cooked at the same time. So much bubblegum chewy flop. Asked for garlic on the pizza, clove chunks cut in half spread over the pizza.... I love garlic, but damn. Fried mozzarella was good, the rest of the meal was not. We got pickup, but the inside looked inviting.

Very kind staff and amazing food. Special shout out to Nichole for her quick, amazing service!

Best Italian restaurant in all the keys beautiful place, food was amazing and they music make the place perfect !!!🤩 we love it 😍 !!!

Everything was wonderful! The atmosphere, the food, and Tana! Plus, our dog Moses loved it (including the side of meatballs)!

Awesome service, ask for Tana. Took fur baby, so accommodating.

They did a great job at making sure your experience was amazing.

Worst dining experience of our vacation. We arrived at 845 pm and the staff was SUPREMELY irritated we were there. They quickly snapped “ you have exactly two minutes to place an order”. No menu was offered, and we had to just quickly name a basic pizza we hoped they had. It was abundantly clear they all wanted out of there at exactly 9 pm. Typically, seating would close at 9. We were told to stand in a waiting area while servers bought out MANY platters to meals. Then, they asked us to MOVE in the tiny waiting area we were designed to so they could literally roll silverware for the next day. We were treated like actual burdens. Additionally it was HORRIBLE pizza. There was zero fresh mozzarella on my simple margarita pizza and the dough wasn’t remotely cooked. As you can see by pictures, it was so much raw that it was floppy. Sadly it was completely inedible, as was my son’s pepperoni pizza. I wish I had anything positive to say but I do not. If I could give zero stars I would. As a business owner myself,, I would never treat customers..even late arrivals.. as an annoying inconvenience. Very rude service and awful pizza.

They rushed us out when we arrived 20 minutes before closing time, but told us we had two minutes to order. We wanted to wait outside but they told us we had to wait in a tiny bar area then told us to move from that bar. We wanted to dine in but had to order to go… the “pizza” was basically just a disk of raw dough. Probably the worst service I’ve experienced in years. I eagerly await the owners passive aggressive response.

Fantastic food. Meat lasagna is one of, if not the best, I’ve had. Rivals Rosemary’s in NYC. Dilma and the rest of the staff were great!

Great food and great service. Our waitress Tana was very kind. Highly recommended.

Chicken Picatta special was one of the best I've had. Antonio was a very courteous,attentive, and informative server!

We had such a great experience. The venue itself is dynamic and fun. The service with Antonio was quick and efficient (just like we like).

Great experience and excellent food. Our waiter Antonio was excellent and attentive. Highly recommend.

Food was delicious. We got 2 different pizzas and they were both so good. Tried the meatballs and burratta with truffle oil and they were so yummy. Antonio, our server was very friendly and helpful in choosing what to eat. Highly recommend.

Antonio was a wonderful server, engaged, helpful, and knowledgeable. Food was killer, as were the desserts. My family has added the restaurant to our list whenever we visit the Keys.

Best Naples (Italy) style pizza! Super fun vibe. Would definitely come back. Huge thanks to Antonio for being an awesome server and so accommodating to our never ending needs.

Food, service, DJ and Antonio were amazing!!! A must go to.

The food was excellent and very good service from Antonio. 100% Recommended

Very good food And a very good service by Antonio I highly recommend

Antonio was so amazing!! Made our dining experience fantastic!!

Stopped in on the way back home. Ordered fries calamari and shrimp and burrada salad with truffle oil for appetizer. Very fresh and delicious! We ordered two pizzas as well… Diabola and pepperoni. Excellent! Reminded of being in Nápoles. Antonio., our waiter was exceptional. He was really friendly and recommended a fabulous dessert imported from Italy. We will definitely be back. Thank you

Absolutely love the authenticity of this place. If you've been to Italy you can see the similarities. Antonio was amazing. Super knowledgeable and very sweet. He took care of our family and sent us on our way happy and full. Recommend 10 out of 10!

Antonio was great and very accommodating!

We had a reservation at 8:15 pm a Saturday and our Server was Antonio. He was fantastic and so was our food. Everything came out fast and was very delicious.

What a surprise Italian restaurant in the Keys, Ask for Antonio to make sure you get an amazing experience

Thanks Antonio for the amazing service

One of the best Italian food places. Not just in the Keys, anywhere. The food is spectacular, the Tartufo Mushroom pizza is amazing, and one of my favorite desserts anywhere is the Pear & Ricotta pie, trust me you need to try it. Antonio has served us on a couple of occasions and he was excellent again. But regardless of who our server is the service is always great. This place is a Gem and we are blessed to have them in Key Largo.

Lovely atmosphere, great food and Antonio was a great waiter. The chicken Parm sandwich was MASSIVE! Garlic bread is also amazing.

Came down and enjoyed a nice dinner, amazing atmosphere, great food, and Nicole is an amazing waitress.

Very good authentic Neapolitan pizzas. Pleasant environment despite a boring location, they have made it cozy. Friendly staff

Yummy mimosas!!! Only outdoor seating available so keep that in mind.

Authentic Italian, Tana was amazing as a waitress. Napoleon Pizza was incredible. Great selection of deserts also.

Antonio was very attentive and provided great service.

Service from Antonio was great. The pizza, as always, was fantastic.

Fantastic Napoletana pizza! Service was also excellent. We had Antonio for lunch and he could not have been more helpful! Recommend reservations for Friday nights.

The food was excellent and Antonia was a warm and convivial host.

Antonio was amazing! Great restaurant.

Always delicious. Great one man band. The server Antonio was great.

Antonio was awesome. Food amazing. 2 locations in two days.

Great food Antoine was excellent

great, we had antonio and he was amazing!

Antonio you were amazing! We for sure will be back again.

Great time here! Food was delicious and atmosphere was great with great music. Antonio our server was great!!!

Antonio was the best server ever! The chicken parmesan sandwich was great.

Good was great Antonio our waiter was friendly and courteous highly recommend

Our server Antonio was excellent! The food was delicious. The outdoor patio seating was ample and very comfortable. Thank you for the great experience!

Great food, great ambience, Antonio our server was great as well!

The food was extraordinary! The taste made you feel like you were dining in Italy. The food service was fast and good. Our server Antonio was very attentive.