Casa Di Pizza in Bradenton - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

My first visit I got the Philly Steak and Cheese - it was GREAT... next visit got the pizza... meh... stick with the sandwiches.. Crust too thick... tasteless sauce and cheese... very mediocre pizza..

Absolute trash pizza…had a few slices cuz was hungry but… airport type cruise ship pizza. Great service, the owner is nice, told me he’s been there for like 20+ years but yea.. if ya want chucky cheese vibes, these guys can compete… if you’re looking for “real” pizza, this is not it unfortunately because it’s a killer location.

If you want AUTHENTIC Buffalo food, this is your place! 💯 Kevin is doing a great job. The chicken finger pizza was fantastic! Keep up the good work! Go Timon ☘️ / Go Bills!

Best wings in Bradenton… loved the hot and lemon pepper mixed off the firepit. Pineapple Coleslaw was unique and great addition to the wings. Everything was great.

I've never been inside, but I do enjoy going in at times to pick up our food.. It seems like everyone would know everyone's name. Love the fact that the food is delicious every time, not just when certain ppl work. Highly recommend ordering from the pit and a deep dish the crust is 👩‍🍳 💋😚🤌🏽

I am at a lost for words!!! This is my favorite pizza spot from back home ( Buffalo NY) my family and I drive here from Apollo Beach all the time, today was the second time the the food was absolutely horrible!!!!! Seems like they lost their touch!!! Definitely not Buffalo style!!! I'm gonna blame the cooks on this one because Casa is usually on point!

Great service but the food was disappointing the pizza was extremely greasy

Loved sharing pizza with my family. Was great!

This place always had decent food and fun atmosphere. Now that they’ve expanded, it’s even better!

Pizza was one of the best in the area!

Best wings in the area! Only way to get better wings is to go to Buffalo!

Called to do a pick up order for a large pizza I told them I want the large with one ingredient for 23.49 he argued with me that the price is incorrect I Said it’s on your website menu for that price he pretty much called me a liar and said it will be 29 dollars with tax if you want it .. not happy I told him never mind and he seemed he could careless about my business and quickly hung up

Best pizza/wings in town ! Had to drive 50 miles but worth it. I'm from Buffalo and their dead on with recipes !

Heard good things about this place and wanted to love it. Decided to try it tonight. Everything looked great until I found a HUGE hair in my pizza. Thought it may have been mine but this hair was EMBEDDED and COOKED into the pizza so clearly it was not mine. I am too grossed out to eat the pizza now. Wings and calzone are good tho. Just check for hair. I have a video of the hair inside the pizza as well.

The pizza has great flavor, not sugary. The fries must be double fried. They were delicious. The menu has many choices. Wonderful place.

Very friendly n the best food in florida

I don’t know where 4.5 rating came. Self-service, the food was not tasty. We ordered a large meat liver pizza and onion rings, everything was too oily, it’s like they put onion rings into not heated deep fryer.

This location is in Manatee county, I live in Pasco...so after a 90 minute trip there and calling ahead/ordering.. Had order read back to me over phone and of course after driving home ANOTHER 90+ mins (in rain now) the food wasn't prepared like on receipt.... clearly no visible lettuce on philly..

Frequented this establishment until tonight my fiancé and I got food poisoning from the hot wings. It was clearly food poisoning as we both got violently sick within minutes of eating. I called to let them know as a courtesy and all they had to say was “I’m sorry”….. disappointed and will not be returning. Beware of the wings. Used to be our favorite…

This place has the BEST pizza 🍕 and the calzone and Stromboli are great too.

True Buffalo inspired cuisine. I drive over an hour from Clearwater to get a slice and wings.

Great Pizza, crust and sauce are special.

Good pizza better wings ... pizza reminded me of pizza hut

Not my personal favorite pizza. I like no flop crust. This one you need to eat with a fork and knife.

Spaghetti and meatballs were delicious as the salad, and garlic bread 5 stars

My go-to pizza place! Not only is their pizza good, but the Stromboli & Bosco Sticks are great as well.

Above average pizza, friendly people

We ordered 1 pizza and 10 wings for 57.00 and the pizza looked like it was cut by a child. When we ordered the guy on the phone was so rude. The delivery person was very nice.

Love this place! Little spot of buffalo in Florida. They have tons of bills memorabilia on the wall. Great vibe. They recently remodeled the inside as well and it looks great. I highly recommend the chicken finger sub. Exactly like from back home.

My husband is super picky about wings and these are the best around.

The food was good. The atmosphere was nice, calm, and friendly, The greeter/waiter was such a great hostess. Explained everything to me and recommended some good dishes. It's definitely a place I would go back to when I am back in town. Bathrooms were single bathrooms, and were clean too. It appears to be a family-friendly place but do not know for sure as it was during the day when I went. It is a pizza shop though. Nice experience.

The worst pizza for $35 I’ve ever had for delivery a bunch of red sauce and no cheese. What a disgrace.

Great atmosphere and great wing special. Good pizza. We had a hard time finding a pizza shop that was open and stumbled on this place. Very creative menu. Great family story. Go Bills!

Best pizza & wings in Bradenton!

Love this place! The food is always delicious and reasonably priced!

Awesome pizza! Great Beer! Great Service Especially if you like pizza

This is a restaurant we have in our hometown for pizza is good everything was good you should try it

Great food and loved the cheese steak!

A wonderful, friendly. excellent pizza neighborhood restaurant.!!

Little taste of home in Florida. We loved it!

Buffalo pizza & wings!!! Best in the world. *Mic drop

I've never had such delicious pizza! The beer on weck and fries were delicious 😋 it was definitely worth the drive from Wesley Chapel

No nearly as good as 5 years ago

I usually do delivery Alwsys great!!

Fantastic philly sandwich. Large and worth the $.

Pizza was doughy not cooked long enough and the wings were very dry and had no meat on them. Unfortunately won’t be coming back

It was my first visit, the restaurant was almost empty but i was sitting there for more than 10 minutes waiting for the server. Then I left making this to be also my last visit..😔

Best pizza and wings in Bradenton!

Great pizza and wings. Order at the counterand they bring your food to the table. Good beer selection for a small place. Food is consistently very good. They expanded a year or so ago so there's plenty of seating now. And outside seating also.

Pizza slice definitely has a personality like no where else. Buffalo style food, the toppings are spicy and different, the crust is buttery and fairly toothsome. Stretchy cheese. The wine selection offeres only Sutter home. Great wings, onion rings are awesome, fried mushrooms good. Beef on wexk, big juicy subs, terrific homemade pasta dinners, calzones, stromboli and much more..Specials Mon thru Wed. Offer individual slices with toppings 35 cents,each. Not fancy..dine in or take out. I love Casa Di Pizza!

Top notch. Best pizza in Manatee County. Stromboli is amazing and the grilled hot wings are unmatched.

Asked for Lunch combo: 2 Italian saugage slides. This place was a fam favorite but not sure what’s going on. The sausage was cooked separately and it was coming off. I’m all for supporting local spots but common.

My husband and I got a pizza and chicken wings from Casa Dia pizza and it was burnt. Couple days later after making a review a manager called and promised to make it good but never did so they lied I even answered and sent him text messages and he never replied

Not bein' biased bein' from Buffalo and workin' at Casa di Pizza there for ten years, but damn the pizza recipe traveled quite well. Tastes just as it did in Buffalo in the 70s.. 80s.. 90s and beyond! G🏈 BILLS

Great place to eat. The food is delicious. Lots of variety for Pizza, Subs, pastas etc.

I personally don't care for the food . Everything tastes off... especially the spaghetti...beware of the runny watery spaghetti. The sauce does not even stick to the noodles.. and if you get sausage instead of meatballs it tastes like wet dog.

Food took 50 minutes. The manager did compensate us, but all we heard was pizzas were taking longer. We order subs.

The pizza was very good, and the wings even better!!

As a person who lived in Buffalo, NY, this was the best pizza in Florida...The service was great...helpful & kind people...In the short time I was there we went 2x's & it was a 45 minute drive...Will definitely go again when I go back to Florida !!!!🍕🍕🍕🍕

This place used to be really good but ever since they remodeled, the prices have gone way up and the service has gone in the toilet. Was charged $15 for a beef on weck sandwich and an extra $1.50 for a tiny plastic cup of au jus that should have come with the sandwich as is the Buffalo standard. The waitress dropped off the food and never once came back to check on the table. She didn't get the zero tip that I wanted to leave because I just can't do that but she did only get 10%.

Absolutely love this place. The owners are from Buffalo and I grew up not far from there. Great food reminds me of back home. GO BILLS!

We took an Uber to pick up our pizza that we ordered spending money on it Uber there then come to find out the chicken wings and pizza is burnt wings are hard and crunchy $40 down the toilet

Delicious pizza (we got pepperoni and supreme)Lively fun atmosphere with multiple screens for watching football! Quick, courteous service! Highly recommend!

Service was a little slow, but in there defense they were very busy, maybe not enough staff, food was good, good sports bar atmosphere, this is a place I would return

We have ordered from this place many times and the last 5 times we ordered or ate in the restaurant their staff just can’t get it right. Poor service poor quality food

THEE Best Cheesesteak in Bradenton, IMHO, Make sure you go during a Buffalo Bills game! Good food, good service, friendly atmosphere.!

35 minute wait to get my $25 sandwich. Fortunately for the group of six that came in after me, ordered after me, but received their meals before me I won't be back.

Hands down best pizza in Bradenton

Great pizza. Many styles. Salad was good too. Lots of indoor seating and some outdoor too.

Wings took forever to come out, near the end of our meal, and then were fried to crisp and dry. Disappointed as I heard such good things about this place. The white folks next to us came after us and got their wings way before us and theirs looked great. Hmmm? Read the other 1 star reviews; best believe this place treats minorities differently.

Recently ordered gluten free and 1 regular pizza - $63.00. Will never order anything. Reg pizza went into garbage and gf dough was a store bought dry flatbread......half to trash. Such a waste of money. In further will order from the chain stores.

The staff is always friendly and efficient. Awesome pizza and as usual the best Philly Cheese steak

Great pizza and wings!! Table service can be a little slow.

Got wings. Ordered medium hot. Next time I'll order hot. Nice people

If you like Buffalo sports franchises, and great Buffalo style food, like wings, hotdogs, and other western NY inspired sandwiches!

As long as you have plenty of time, it's pretty good. Don't come if you can't wait a half hour for your food.

Amazing Buffalo Bills fans and all the food choices are delicious

Sat outside & watched Buffalo Bills game on TV. The bar has a lot of Bills memorabilia which was nice to see in Florida since we are originally from upstate NY. Everything we ordered was very good, especially the pizza. They offer varieties of pizza. Ours was thin crust like an authentic wood fired pizza you get in Italy. Service was also very good.

BURNT AND DRY Wings. First time was good but nothing since has been. Even going on a day where everything should have been freshly made. Pizza... even after asking for them to cook it a little longer, bittom of pepperoni pizza was soggy while edges of meat were charred. Very disappointed 😞 Won't be back.

Excellent food and service, just like home!! Best pizza in Bradenton!!

I’ve been here 15 times never left a review. Sometimes it gets super busy sonservice u have to be patient. But the reason is the foood it’s good constant. Salads great fresh dressings good. Pizza good. Pasta awsome. Wings the absolute best in Bradenton period best the BBQ are smoky and to die for with the blue cheese amazing. Love this hidden Gem. Only Complaint with the expansion the Bar is way too small. Need to expand again 🤣. Seriously this place is the best neighborhood and Wing pasta place to go too. 10 dollars 2 meatball and spaghetti special. The bomb !!! Garlic bread salad and the main course Bam

Great food and people working there!

Casa Di Pizza in Bradenton is a culinary haven, bringing the authentic flavors of Buffalo, NY to Florida. The grilled buffalo wings are a revelation, perfectly capturing the essence of crispy perfection that's notoriously hard to master. Intriguingly, the secret behind their mastery lies in the meticulous science of wing preparation. The last surviving family member of the original Buffalo restaurant ensures that every detail, from the cooking technique to the seasoning, is perfected. The result is an unparalleled crispy wing experience that sets Casa Di Pizza apart. Beyond wings, their Buffalo favorites like subs and hot dogs are crafted with such precision that each bite feels like a journey back to the heart of Buffalo's culinary heritage. Don't miss the chance to savor these exceptional flavors – Casa Di Pizza is a true gem in Bradenton.

Excellent! Pizza is the best in the area I've had so far, and I'm from Philly and been here since January 2018. Crust is perfect beautiful combination of spices in the gravy/sauce.

Inconsistent food. 55% good but the other 45% poor quality is becoming enough not to bother anymore. Our last pizza was burnt. Crust and bottom were just burnt, black, and not edible. Being Buffalo natives we were thrilled to have you close by.We had family visiting and the reaction was this was the worse pizza we've ever had. Papa John's is better at times. It's a shame because we know you know how to do it right but the sloppiness or lack of caring is showing.

The pasta dishes were huge and incredibly good! The pepperoni pizza is really good

Fantastic food, great service, and the best wings and pizza in Florida, no one can beat this restaurant

Very nice local restaurant. Great New York style food with generally cheerful and fast service. I've ordered from them many times for their small catering double pizza bundle and we have dined in there a number of times with family and friends who have come into town and it has never disappointed us. Their wings and ribs are absolutely incredible.

The wings where delicious and the pizza came out pretty quick even tho they where busy. Was referred by a friend and I will definitely be going back

They clearly can't keep up with the demand if you show up at 7:40 pm and there's a 2 hour wait to receive pizza at your table. I guess, they expanded but not their ovens and if they did that too it's not enough for the demand of the area 😔

Delicious little pepperoni'. I will not pass by here without grabbing a pizza to take home(also great spot to eat lunch) Great customer service that makes you feel as tho they appreciate your business and want you to return.

I’m assuming they favor the online orders and to go orders. We were in the dining room 40 minutes and never saw them serve anybody. We left after a half hour of waiting for our pizza. another table came in and ordered about 15 minutes after we did, and the whole table received their food before we did. When we left and asked for our money back for the pizza, they did charge us for the drinks and they kept the tip. We only drank half of our drink and we were informed it takes at least 30 to 35 minutes for a pizza. The girl that we dealt with was a little smug. Good luck

Honestly, the best wings and ribs I have ever had. Great flavor!

Casa di Pizza offers an exceptional dining experience with its delectable pizza and mouthwatering chicken wings. The abundance of TVs broadcasting sports creates a lively atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings. The military-friendly environment, coupled with an attentive staff, enhances the overall dining pleasure. A true haven for those seeking great food, drinks, and a welcoming ambiance. 10/10⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Our favorite joint for Pizza or a casual dinner. Love having dinner on the sidewalk tables with our puppy. Staff is great and always takes good care of us.

The least friendliest “ Buffalo bar” I’ve ever been to. First visit tried the pizza, it was good not great. Second visit tried the chicken parm sandwhich, should have gotten pizza. The chicken was so tough you could’ve even bite thru it. Didn’t seem to matter bc not one of the four people being the bar asked me about it. Prices were fair that’s the best thing I can say

They close before the listed hours.

Buffalo style pizza at its finest. Wings great and having Labatts blue on tap is the hat trick. Just wish they would open a location in S Sarasota.

Our family stopped here for lunch while traveling. I had no expectations and frankly expected your typical limp, tasteless pizza. I was so wrong! Their pizza is crisp, flavorful, and the kind of food you crave long after you leave (proof - I'm writing this weeks later because I started thinking about how good their pizza would taste right now). I got the veggie pizza and every member of my family got a different type of pizza for their slice. Everyone loved it. Sadly we don't live anywhere near Casa di Pizza, but if you're fortunate enough to stop there, don't miss it! Great selection of pizza and other food. Good service and you can sit outside (yes, it's in a strip mall, but the food is so worth it).

Not from the area but needed a bite to eat while working and tried this place randomly. So glad I did. It was absolutely delicious.