Gianni's NY Pizza in Bradenton - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

We had the antipasto salad, meatball sub, and double pepperoni pizza and it was all delicious! We usually get the burrata pizza which I highly recommend!

Killer eggplant parm pizza ok wings very good baked great marinade.

12 of us showed up 30 mi utes before closing. They had us fed and we were all done 40 minutes later. What a great crew and awesome food!

From a native New Yorker, this pizza is hands down THE BEST PIZZA in Florida. We drive 20 mins just to have it! Worth it every time!!

It was my favorite pizza but I know what happens in the last months of 2024 it is no longer the same the quality change is less, I loved the pizza for its quality of cheese and it almost doesn't even have cheese even so on 2 occasions I ask for extra cheese even though they charge me additional doesn't matter I just want extra still they don't have enough cheese, I think they have a new employee because not the same and I don't like it, anyway my pizza was very toasted with a very dark color on the bottom as if it was baked for several Sometimes the truth was that it was the best in all of Bradenton but it is NOT a shame but you can still improve since it is a good place, excellent service and a good place.

My new favorite Italian restaurant. Have ordered four times from Uber Eats and haven’t been disappointed. Everything is so fresh and delicious. The eggplant parmigiana is fantastic. The antipasto salad, the cheesesteak, the pizza, the best I’ve had in a long time. Former NYer here and I highly recommend. Don’t forget the Lemon Mascarpone cake. It’s so good I order two pieces at a time.

My husband and I recently moved to the area from Upstate NY. Our biggest complaint was we could not find a good pizza place. I searched online and found Gianni’s. My husband and I stopped in for a slice and we found the best pizza in the area. We will be back! 😊

Excellent NY style pizza always cooked perfectly

Waitresses! Notice plural. We're all amazing. Happy fun helpful and attentive. Food is always amazing and comes out hot. Best wings and pizza ever!!! Go!!!

I looked forward to trying this pizza. Drove 25 mins to do a pick up but was on hold for 22mins. Unfortunately, when we arrived, they told us they stopped taking orders 15mins before they closed. Called from Google page and directly on phone. Its surprising, all the staff could do is look for proof I called after their cut-off.

The food was incredible! The music was terrific!

Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever had in my whole life

Great service, the wings were amazing as well as the pizza. Met the manager Tony, very friendly and professional. Highly recommend!!

Asked for a golden brown pizza. First one well done. Second one partially cooked. Refills? Attention to the table ?. Go back Hell no look at this and you tell me... Golden Brown or raw??? Won't let me post the picture of a raw runny pizza they served. You don't care I don't care!

10/10 food and service would highly recommend. I can’t believe there’s even one bad review on this place. Barstool sports even rated this pizza delicious. Salads are great too, loved the mushroom appetizer and the service is spectacular. 10/10 Also don’t forget about the cookies, I’ve tried every flavor and I love them all! They’re thick, huge and delicious. I will definitely be back

Wow, I can't say enough about the incredible pizza experience I had! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with the friendliest customer service. The staff was knowledgeable and helped me pick out the perfect pizza. Now, let's talk about the pizza itself. The crust was a masterpiece—perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. It provided the ideal base for the amazing toppings. Speaking of toppings, the fresh ingredients took this pizza to a whole new level. The feta added a unique and delicious flavor, while the bacon was perfectly cooked and added a rich, savory element. Overall, this pizza was a solid 5 stars. The quality of the crust and the fresh ingredients truly set it apart. Combine that with the amazing customer service, and you have a pizza experience that is hard to beat. I will definitely be coming back for more!

We ordered two pies, one with extra sausage and the other a Grandma pie. The double sausage was under cooked. The crust was soft and flimsy. I was surprised that other reviewers stated that they had burnt crust. My experience was the opposite. The grandma pie had very good flavor but lacked cheese. There was hardly any cheese on the pie, so it was like eating sauce on bread. They were doing a brisk inside business, which leads me to believe that it may be more beneficial to dine in rather than take out. In fairness, I will say that my son enjoyed the sausage pie. Maybe I should have just asked for it to be cooked well done.

I can see why Dave Portnoy didn’t like the pizza! It was bad. The owner I was not friendly to me.

Soup is all oil and noodles. Skimpy Italian grinder and missing a type of meat. Not toasted properly and my garlic bread isn't a garlic bread knot just bread and the pasta taste like a kid made it. They literally burned the guys pizza before me. Do not go here!!!!

BURNT TASTE AND BURNT BOTTOM CRUST “A picture is worth a thousand words!!” Ridiculous how they can serve this product !! See photo .just to be clear - the pizza tasted burnt . I ordered 2 pizzas - one was totally burned on bottom and the other had the normal dark spots as usual from Gianni’s . This pizza was black consistently on the bottom , not just a few dark spots !! Did I mention it tasted burnt ?? Horrible burnt taste . I will now add a photo of the other pizza I got ( same time ) for comparison . The one on the right is totally acceptable and tasted fine … but on the left ??? BURNT, BURNT , BURNT TASTE !!! Go to Piezanos !!! I did ask for and a normal crust and this one was well past WELL DONE !! You can defend your oven all day long - but THE BURNT TASTE ? Are you seriously defending that too ? I did call and no one answered the phone . Guess they were too busy burning pizzas ! Next time I’ll have to ask for a “ LIGHTER BURNT TASTE “?

Bought the 2 slices and drink special for lunch. The pizza was burnt, crust and bottom black. Not good.

Ordered delivery and it was fantastic!

Went in today to enjoy one of their lunch specials, but was told all they have for specials now are 2 pieces of pizza and a drink or a 1/2 of a sub with French fries. No more 1/2 sub /w soup or any of the other great lunch specials I have enjoyed. I love the food but do not want French fries with my Italian food.

Order ready ahead of time and contained everything ordered. Needless to say food was the best

Used to be one of my go-to pizza places in east Bradenton. Something has changed. I no longer feel comfortable recommending Gianni’s to visitors. Wait times have gone up and quality has gone down since late 2023. Definitely better than most major chains, but you should ask some locals for better recommendations

Food is great! Delivery came way faster than I expected.

This place was my favorite, I ordered 2 pizzas and the sauce was not good even the cheese. I think they changed the recipe. Today the pizza was not good.

Always fantastic pizza! Love this place! Don’t forget the garlic knots!!!!!

They must have changed owners. Pizza isn't the same... It's to bad.. They use to have the best pizza in town... Not any more.

Pizza is very good girl from nyc rates it well

The Best New York Pizza in Bradenton, in my humble opinion! Their lunch special, 2 big slices & a fountain pop for 7.99 is the bomb! I really like their food & service!

Love this place! Pizza is very good and I would literally pay extra for their garlic knots! Good crust. Nice, friendly service. Too far away from my house in Osprey but we go after my son’s hockey games in Ellenton. Definitely worth a visit.

This is a great pizza place that we found by accident. The pizza is one of the best we've had in a long time. You can tell that they use good ingredients. Very tasty and made to perfection. My wife also had their wings and she said they were outstanding. And she's a picky wing eater.... :) The service was also great. Our server was very patient with our group and kept checking on us. Our friends loved the food as well. I would highly recommend Gianni's for a superb pizza experience!

Our favorite pizza in Bradenton! Always cooked fresh, taste amazing. Very good pizza! Would recommend

Delicious food amd great atmosphere!

I love the level of detail you can order online. Good crust

Love their pizza and baked wings!! We eat here 4 or 5 times a month!! Food is delicious! Affordable prices!! Great staff!!

Great food and great service I got the buffalo chicken, personal size pizza, which was huge and my father got a cold sub a half that was huge as well. All of it was delicious. They had gotten my order wrong from an Uber eats delivery and gave us credit the management did, which was amazing. I will be returning again and again because it’s the best pizza around.

Best pizza in Bradenton! this is only place we go for pizza and authentic Italian cuisine. Everything is fresh.. and you'll taste it when you visit. My husband an international Chef.. and he loves it too! A little pricey, but never disappointed! Serving sizes are huge ! So happy we found this place. !

Great food and just good people all around

Great food, great service & really good value for the money... every time!!

Honestly been looking for a really good pizza place and we finally found it.

After reading the reviews on Facebook, I thought I would give this place a try. Another disappointment in the Lakewood Ranch area. I ordered a pizza with extra cheese. I guess they don’t know what extra cheese is. The pizza had barely cheese, and it was burnt and tasted like a piece of cardboard. At that point we were so hungry because it was after 8 o’clock and we just wanted to get some food after my daughter’s basketball game. We spent over $60 on some terrible food. Doesn’t anyone in the Lakewood Ranch area know how to make a pizza????

Online orders for delivery almost never ready for pick up. Drivers almost always waiting and losing income.

The staff is very helpful & polite! The pizza we had was good, not a OMG I can't wait to get another one.

We always order Gianni's atleast once while we're vacationing in the Bradenton area. They never disappoint! Great food, reasonable prices and always friendly staff!

Always great pizza, sauce, and toppings

Friday night dining before New Year's Eve and all the restaurants were packed. We came to Gianni's and we were welcomed warmly by Jacob who served and cleared our table. Everything came out piping hot and we only were able to eat half because the servings were huge. Wonderful ambience comfortable seats. Tucked away in a Publix shopping center, but well worth finding your way to this restaurant. Excellent family style Italian food and pizza.

Pizza is always so fresh and delicious!

Pizza was so delicious, this is real pizza compared to others

I love there cauliflower pizza and all there food. The service is great the food is excellent.

Our favorite pizza place in bradenton. I'm from NYC and it tastes just like home. Smaller appetizers and stingy on toppings, but great food, atmosphere, and service.

Ok pizza ,great manager working today ...

Pizza is some of the best outside our favorite in New York. The waitress was super friendly and highly attentive. The restaurant is pretty basic but pretty much what you would expect for a pizza place. They do have a lunch special that is decently priced as well - I would recommend it.

Excellent pizza. On time service. Friendly staff.

I love Giannis food! I get their cheesesteak often and my husband loves wings and Stromboli. I usually do pickup at the restaurant but delivery is great! I will use delivery more often now.

Pizza was good but I would like a better sauce. I’m spoiled with some of the best pizza’s from New Haven CT

Great to have a excellent delivery service for Gianni's

Food is great don't know about the atmosphere I get my food delivered.

Great pizza, quick service. Can get beer/wine. Also delivery.

Nice place I had the pizza ...very good. Friendly staff . Clean restrooms.

Pizza was delicious! On time, exactly what I ordered and staff was extremely friendly and appreciative. My first time and I will definitely be back to try the Margherita!

Got take out. Food was good, but took a few tries to get the order right. Wasn't any objections or complaints to fixing it, but did have to wait a bit. Especially in light of the polite response, I'll definitely try again some time.

A SLICE OF HEAVEN FOR PATRIOTS 🇺🇸 I recently had the pleasure of dining at this fantastic pizzeria, and I must say, it exceeded all expectations. The pizza was absolutely divine - a perfect balance of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and a rich, flavorful sauce. Each bite was a symphony of taste that left me craving more. What sets this place apart, though, is their commendable dedication to being military veterans friendly. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with genuine warmth and respect. The staff's eagerness to make every customer feel at home is palpable. It's clear they appreciate the sacrifices our veterans have made, and they go above and beyond to ensure they feel valued and welcomed. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it a great spot for families, friends, and even solo diners. The prices are reasonable for the quality of the food, and the portion sizes are generous. I highly recommend this pizzeria to anyone in search of not only outstanding pizza but also a place that truly cares about its community, especially our military veterans. They've won my loyalty, and I'll definitely be returning for more slices of their delectable creations.

New owners it seems. They have changed the pizza crust it's not the same as it was before had the veggie pizza came out dripping with moisture toppings fell off the pizza. I would compare it to Dominos pizza but for a lot more $. Not the same as it was before for sure Long time customer ya lost!

I can't share anything, I was gonna call Inn a take out but when I asked the girl about stuff shells or other stuff she didn't have ni clue so it made me question about the fod

The pizza was not that good. We ordered a whole pizza half cheese half pepperoni and some drinks. The people made us want 45 minutes for a pizza saying they thought someone else got our order.. I would never go here again.

Just had the classic Stromboli and mozzarella wedges deliver with DoorDash, the Stromboli was excellent and the wedges are perfect. Will definitely order here again!

had the eggplant Parm sub and it was delicious

Claims it’s NY pizza, Coming from NY, it’s not even close, Doesn’t even do slices after 3pm, & then asks for 20% tips.

Lunch special was great. Friendly service.

Ordered carry out. Antipasto salad was very good. Also ordered a pepperoni pizza. It was also good but very greasy.

Charming little place. The food was prettier good. The service was good also.

I am a regular through door dash. The care they put into their orders is phenomenal. The food is never a miss. Hands down the best wings & pizza I’ve ever had in my life. I have never been to Philadelphia and/or had a true Philly steak. But I order theirs quite often and my guess is that it would compete. I love this place - a must try. You will be back.

Love ths place. Repeat customer.

Used to have really good NY style pizza. What happened? The pizza we had today was completely tasteless and the crust was soft. Do better! Won't be back

Visited for my first time the other day and tried the Buffalo chicken pizza with ranch and garlic oil on the crust light bake and it was so yummy! Will def be back to try other flavors :)

Very good pizza and Italian sub in proper NY pizzeria style

Great pizza thin and crispy, right on point.

This pizza was AWESOME! Great crust…… loved the crust. Simple sausage, fresh mushroom and red onion. Perfect pizza, crust was nice and crispy but soft.

Been here several times. Always good but tonight was exceptional! Chef Jeff and our server Dahlia were outstanding! The Philly cheesesteak pizza barely edged out the Philly cheesesteak sandwich. The penne pasta marinara was a favorite as well. Highly recommend.

Great food and service. Very friendly staff

I ordered Sicilian cheese pie extra cheese little extra sauce. First time trying this style pizza. It was absolutely gross. Crust tasted like the metal oven. Cheese was def not extra n believe it or not no taste for sauce none! Never buy this again. There ny style pizza is very good. I take my grandkids there. That’s all I’d ever order from here. Never for delivery again.

It's unfortunate, to-go is definitely the way to go if coming here. It's not great pizza, it's okay at best.

The staff was really friendly and made us feel very welcome. The food was good and filling. The atmosphere was relaxing, again made possible by the great service we received.

Great cheesesteak and parmesan fries..fast friendly service

I absolutely loved this place, we are on vacation in Bradenton and we were looking for some Italian food and we were not disappointed at all. Gianni’s has probably the best Philly Cheesesteak that I’ve ever had it was stuffed full of meat and cheese and the portion was big! The fries are also delicious they are nice and crispy and they don't taste like grease at all, I looked at my other family’s food and it looked phenomenal as well. Hailee was a wonderful person and waitress, she was kind, respectful, helpful, and courteous. This was overall a great experience and I will definitely eat here again if I’m ever in Bradenton.

We had pizza from here , it was OK. We also tried the steak and cheese subs, not a fan .

Fuhgeddaboudit! Best pie I've had since being in Midtown Manhattan 2 years ago. Oh yeah and Real Garlic knots!!! The right size, cooked perfectly and dripping with the oil and garlic. If you're in Sarasota don't you dare leave without getting a slice!

We had a small works and a Calzone. The Calzone was a little cold in the center but the concept is good. The pizza reminds me of Blaze but better. The service was spot on, it was slow though, I would recommend Gianni's.

Being from Long Island originally, I can say this is the closest thing to original New York style pizza in the Bradenton area. Great service, nice music. Highly recommend Gianni's A+++

Decent pizza, not the best, nice staff, pretty quick from order to pizza being ready.

The pizza was very good, liked the sauce. The staff were super friendly and greeted us when we arrived. Will go back to try something else on their extensive menu.

Stopped by for a quick pie while passing thru when the reviews were so great and was not disappointed. Some of the best pizza in the area, and they'll do garlic butter on your crust on request and I suggest it

Excellent service. Love the use of fresh ingredients,and the crust is excellent.

The homely environment and clean food were good. This place is very affordable and nice selection on the menu.

Great food and fantastic service we dined in. We were all very happy- My son liked the Alfredo- My wife thought there was too much garlic but we liked it. My daughter got the raviolis - they were great also very cheese. My wife got the burrata pizza, it was great. I got the lasagna, very cheesy but very good for me no such thing as too much mozzarella. We started with garlic knots and meatballs , they were amazing. I will definitely become a regular.

Nothing fancy but the food was great! I had the Burrata pizza- excellent. Pizza crust is so crisp on the bottom, but doughy on top. So yummy! Family had lasagna, ravioli, chicken Alfredo, meatballs and garlic knots. Everyone was very happy!

Ok meal. Unusual service in between lunch and Dinner= where you order at cash register and take a table?

Pizza likes a cardboard.Cold and no taste