Colony Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The lunch special is a great deal

I stopped in here after bicycling at Presque Isle and decided on a gourmet chicken Caesar salad. I thoroughly enjoyed the deliciousness of it and my taste buds were wanting to squeeze a piece of pizza afterwards, I chose a slice of the pulled pork pizza, wow, that was soooo good. The man who took my order was very kind and helpful.

Huge fan of this business. They absolutely nail the customer service end, the food is amazing and the place is always clean. Us at the Riviera Motel love to support other locally owned and operated businesses. We stop in as soon as we start running low on the menus, to make sure everyone who asks about good food knows where to go.

Randomly met the owners tonight. Great people..I would totally recommend their spot!!

Excellent pizza and service. Quality ingredients. Highly recommended!!

Stopped in on the way through and got a Buffalo Chicken pizza. It is delicious the crust is great and the cheese blend w the sauce is fire. Wish I lived closer but this is a good spot the reviews didn't lie. Had a good vibe too the best the type of local spot

Really dang good pizza. Friendly waitress, good prices, delicious pizza. Might be our new tradition when we visit Erie.

This place is amazing highly recommend. The place smells amazing. Everyone is very friendly.

3rd pizza we have ordered and for a $25 steak delux the toppings were miniscule. Little flavor also. Green peppers were raw. All 3 pizzas didn't have enough toppings. After tonight I had to write a review of my disappointment.

AMAZING PIZZA. I’ve been to Sally’s in New Haven and this is definitely better! 10/10!!

The taste profile was amazing! The live music outside was great! The people working there were awesome. Overall recommend for people traveling in from out of the area!

Loved the specialty pizza options and the customer service was great!

Fancy oven! Sub par Pizza. Sloppy and floppy. When you have an oven like this your pizza should have a nice browning to the cheese Especially if you ask for it well done and the crust with nice crisp. The dough as a nice flavor but Doesn't hold up to the massive amount of cheese and sauce making it a total mess. Pizza is an art and hopefully they can turn this into at least some sort of painting one day! Knowledge is power. 5.6

Wow. Fantastic pizza. Hoagie was delicious. I wouldn't change anything. Whoever said "there isn't any good pizza in Eerie, PA is a damn liar (i said it). The young lady behind the counter was a sweetheart. Took time out and talked to us about the shop and the pizza. This is now my only stop in Eerie for pizza. Great job. Love the decor and the vibe. Don't change a thing!

Pizza is super good. Excellent crust! Will definitely be back!

Without a shadow of a doubt the best pizza I've ever had. My family and I loved it. Will be back. You can sense the passion when you walk through the doors.

Quiet hometown feel, great pizza, and amazing staff. This place is worth driving out here to try!

great price, great food, love the garlic sauce and pizza 10/10

Absolutely wonderful!!!!! They have outside seating which is awesome on a beautiful day! Super kind and fast service! Very clean and comfortable establishment! You'll love it! We got 2 pizzas, wings and fries mushrooms! They brought outside to our table! Great Wood fired pizza with quality ingredients you taste! Wings were crispy and saucy if that's how you like em, we do!!!

Phenomenal pizza and calzone, cooked to perfection!!!!

Stopped in today for the first time ,we ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza , and the Italian weeding soup pizza both were very good will definitely be back

THE BEST PIZZA EVER! The sauce is so delicious, and the pepperonis were so good! I usually don't care too much for pepperoni, but I found myself grabbing the pieces with more pepperoni on it. We got liquid money chicken wings, and they were amazing!! Usually, I cover my wings in ranch, but I didn't have to because they were so flavorful! I can't wait to be back!

Pretty good food. Fresh and hot when I arrived.

Great pizza, great staff! First time here and they are now my go to pizza spot in Erie! The sauce is what sold me! Love a good pizza that holds form with sauce that packs a punch!

Wonderful food! We were so happy to find this style of pizza in Erie! We had the broccoli chicken ricotta pizza and a pepperoni meatball calzone, delicious! Definitely will be back again soon!

the staff at Colony Pizza and Catering is hands down helpful, amazing and friendly. the food is perfecto!!!! Hands down best pie around, salads are hearty, new wings are cooked to perfection. A++++ every single time, highly recommend

Amazing pizza even better owner tho def will be back!!

I decided to stop and get a 12"half cheese, half pepperoni pizza at the colony Pizza shop. I was very happy with the appearance, and taste of the pie. Very little flop and a nice crust and bottom. They use the old world pepperoni that curls as it cooks. I don't know why, but I like when it does that. It cost $13 bucks and will worth it imho. Front guy at register was friendly and was happy to help. I will go back... I have pics of the pie, but there isn't a way for me to upload attachments... Trust me, they look good.

The staff were very friendly, our take out order was ready on time and nothing was missing. The pizza was good. I really enjoy that it's handtossed made from scratch dough. The only issue I had was that it was pretty burnt around the crust, indicating being in the oven too long.

Hands down, best pizza in Erie.

Was at Splash Lagoon & always look for local places, the pizza and hoagie was perfect. Met the owner and he was a real good dude, will eat there again the next time the family is in town. The owner had people from New Kensington , 412 to 814 was on the pizza box. Loved it

Food and service is excellent. Highly recommend.

Man when someone told me to check this place out cuz they highly recommended their pizza they sure weren’t wrong very tasty pizza, the pepper cheese pepperoni ball was good as well the dough had a sweet taste which worked well with the spicy pepperoni and pepper cheese, pizza definitely deserves an award pizza was pretty much prefect down to the crust tho it was my 1st time I’ll definitely be back to check out more, thanks for the great service and food

The staff was so welcoming and accommodating. Answered all questions cheerfully. Customer service was top notch. The Pizza, Hoagies, and French fries were all so delicious. 5 stars!

Pizza was disappointing, more like school cafeteria pizza. Had higher expectations given the rating.

Had their pizza recently. It was excellent. I really like the sauce they use

Our Absolute Fav pizza place since they opened! People are so nice an friendly owner is awesome! Food is always Fast Hot an Fresh!!! Happy an Worth it EveryTime from Food to Service an Family like atmosphere! 100% recommended!

The gyro ball is awesome and the pizza was fantastic and there's Pens plaques all over the walls... what's not to love! Who the heck wants "NY style" when you can have PA Perfection Pizza... I'll be visiting here again real soon 😋😋😋

They had some fresh dough Sicilian cuts!!! That's a hard find. Staff was great.

If you’re out of town and looking for a great pizza place this is it. Great food at fantastic prices

Sick and tired of small business crying about how expensive everything is,we the customers feel it too. Ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza, picked it up. Got home and realized it was just mushroom. The best part was when we called to bring it to their attention that Larry could have cared less. First he blamed it on VNET making their phone full of static,not the case as the order was clearly repeated over the phone. Then he put the blame on us saying that we should have known that $19.07 wasn't enough for a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza. We don't work there or own the business. What I do know Larry is that we will NEVER be back. One thing you're forgetting. There are plenty of pizza shops in Erie. Just get it right for any future customers,can you do that Larry?? More than likely NO.

Eric (I'm assuming the owner) was extremely friendly from the time I picked up the phone to order a large order for a group of kids to when I arrived and he went above and beyond to make sure we not only had everything we needed but that we were well taken care of to get the food to our bus. The pizza was incredible, and the steak salad was absolutely delicious. If you're in the area and need pizza this is the place to go ✊🏽

Hoagies were absolutely delicious! Eric makes all his dough in-house, was super kind and charismatic, and he didn’t kick us out for being Bills fans! If you’re in town this is the place to go

Highly recommend. Went there the other day to grab a pizza and some cinnamon knots, they were fantastic. Best pizza in Erie!

Best meatball sub I’ve ever had!!

A first time there excellent food very nice atmosphere.

This pizza shop screams Pittsburgh! Order a white pizza with pepperoni, you won’t regret it.

We were welcomed immediately when walking in (first time there). As much as I wanted 15 other things on the menu, especially the option to have white sauce which is MY THING.... My daughter and I each only had a slice of oringial cheese pizza and it was DELICIOUS! Sauce and dough were amazing. Seating inside and out.

Some of the best pizza I've ever had

We moved to the east side of Erie (NW HCreek) last fall. We tried some local pizza places, but were disappointed. My neighbor said he drives across town to the west side to get pizzas, etc. from Colony. Today, we finally got a Colony pizza (the CBP). This is the best pizza I've had in a really long time! My wife described it as "perfect." They make the pizza dough right there every day, and it was perfectly cooked. The BBQ sauce was delicious, as were the toppings. I know where I'm going to get my next pizza! Btw, the owner and his assistant were very friendly and helpful in helping me choose my pizza. He said he's been in Erie 30 years. Go there, keep him in business, and we'll all be happy!

Thin and crispy, refreshing and balanced sauce, and the perfect ammount of cheese. Really outstanding and will probably be the only pizza I eat in Erie. However, there are too many black and gold decorations for my liking. Could use a touch of red white and blue. GO BILLS!

Tried the pizza for the first time yesterday n its by far my favorite in erie. I'm not a fan of overwhelming amounts of sauce on pizza and that is very hard to find but I found it here lol. The home made dough was delicious too. The Pepperoni on top had a little crisp too them and spice. Yummmmm all around.

I've gone so much the owner recognizes me. Best pizza in Erie!

Great local pizza that my whole family enjoys!

Stopped in and grabbed a hoagie on my way back to Cleveland. I was hesitant at first because of all the Steelers stuff on the walls. But...this place is amazing! The food was absolutely delicious and the staff were extremely friendly!

I've been searching for good pizza in Erie, and this is it. Has an authentic taste that reminds me of the pizza I used to get when I lived in a big city. I just tried it for the first time last night, and my husband and I finished our large cheese, pepperoni, onion and meatball pizza today. It's even better the second day!

Quite possibly the best pizza I’ve had in Erie.

I stopped eating pizza for awhile because I got tired of the same old same old. I tried Colonys pizza and was very pleased. Excellent dough, sauce, cheese and the pepperoni that cups when baked. Awesome so I get a wheel every Friday to start my weekend. Bonus is they are Pittsburgh fans who hoo.

I'll be honest I don't usually review food places but this time- we had gotten pizza from here and there was so much grease it wasn't even enjoyable. The toppings also fell straight off the pizza basically kinda sad 0/10 would not recommend 👎

What’s not to like? Pizza by the slice and homemade ranch; soooo good! Just might be the best NY-style pizza in Erie! Small area to eat but mainly a takeout place. Super nice staff. Accept Apple Pay, etc. Highly recommend!

Used to go to Eric bs corner shop 20+ years ago. Still really great pizza. Will definitely be back.

Pizza and subs were fantastic! Staff was friendly and efficient & the place was Clean. We will be back!

Excellent pizza and hoagies! Ray is a master craftsman. The pizza crust is thin, crispy and delicious. And the steak sandwich was savory and satisfying. Highly recommend. Turns out Ray is from Pittsburgh, which would explain why the food is so good.

Food is always to the best quality. The owner takes pride in what he serves. May I suggest the season summer spinach strawberry salad ( with chicken for me ) while its available. It was my dinner and it was enough to eat for lunch the next day. I wish I would have taken a picture to post. 🤤 The pizza is always cooked just right. Support local! Highly recommend. Feel free to try some of the homemade cookies or sweets. 🍪🍬

Friendly customer service.. Was my first time there and lady was Uber nice

We had a Cheese Pizza, a Pepperoni Pizza and Breadsticks. Thin Crunchy Crust. Lots of good cheese. Owner is from Pittsburgh and He has Sports Memorabilia in the Eat In Dining Area. We chose to Eat at the tables out side. Good Pizza, Good Sauce and Cheese. Friendly Staff. Very Good Experience. Give it a try.

My wife and I stopped there to eat with our daughter and 2 grandchildren. I ordered the veal parm, it tasted like it was pre-made and then microwaved to serve . My wife and daughter ordered chicken Florentino, it was tasteless and cold .our grandson ordered artichoke dip and our granddaughter ordered cheese pizza , they liked their dishes . We had a waitress who cared more about rolling silverware instead of taking care of customers, we had to get up and go find her when we needed something. My wife and I took home leftovers, the dog needs to eat .

Delicious pizza and subs here for sure! Went here for the first time recently on the recommendation of a friend and it will surely be a regular stop from now on!

That's was a tasty pie. The garlic knots with meatballs and mozzarella in them was a nice surprise. Like little delicious 2bite size treats for for your mouth.

Absolute pizza perfection every time. Amazing food and even more amazing people! Definitely recommend ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

This is the first great pizza I’ve found in Erie

Really good food! New favorite pizza joint! Highly recommend!

I have found the best pizza in town. It is the thin crust and little pepperoni that Erie loves. The taste is great! Pizzelles are the best in town too. Thank you for doing pizza right again!

Ordered from here for the first time tonight and they were absolutely amazing! First there was a mix up with my order and they were very apologetic and remade my order also let me keep the pizza that was incorrect. When they brought the correct pizza to my car they also brought me some cookies and apologized once again! The customer service was outstanding and then the food itself was outstanding! I will definitely be ordering again and encourage others to try them as well!!!

Ordered pizza for Colony Pizza again tonight. Hands down the best pizza in town. Alway have a good experience. This the only pizza worth ordering. Great friendly staff.

Called and placed order. Was told it would be 45 minutes. Went to get and was told it would be another 30 minutes. After another 40 minutes, was told that they either gave our pizza to someone else or put it in wrong. Absolutely terrible. If you can't handle being busy, don't have a business.

Ordered a pizza from here for the first time and was pleasantly impressed. I think this is going to be our new pizza place. Really great quality.

Fresh dough pizza with an excellent sauce. A nice spice to the sauce without being overwhelming. Excellent quality toppings. We will definitely be back.

Great customer service. Very good pizza by the slice. Salads are also good. Did not like b there Stromboli. But everything else I've had there has been very good

Best pizza in Erie! Friendly owners and staff.

Ordered a large pizza and it was delicious!!! Also bought their cookies, and YUMMY!!!! Highly recommend this place!

Wonderful steak tip dinner. Friendly staff.

The city's best new pizza spot. This place is CLEAN, has great ingredients and is always delicious. The experience of Eric B is very evident in this one.