Cucinella's Brick Oven Pizzeria in Madison - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Best Pizza in Madison………… Love it…..

The food and service are always spot on. My husband and I have had date night there on more than one occasion and always look forward to when we can come back on another date night

Stopped on the way home from Wild Adventures. Fast and excellent customer service! If we lived closer, this would be a staple for our family.

The pizza was delicious, sauce was amazing and staff was very friendly.

Great pizza and service! My little guy had a great time playing with the toys and the chalkboard. He enjoyed his slice of pizza. Thank you.

If you a re looking for that real Italian style pizza and food this is your place!! The staff is extremely welcoming and friendly. we have a family of 7 an the portions are perfect and filling for the price you pay. I love the lunch special they have that i get during the work week, a 2 topping pizza, drink, and a salad for like $12 and the cinnamon knots and garlic knots are off the chain. Highly recommend.

EAT HERE!!! It’s amazing. Great service, friendly staff, food came out quick—-and it was delicious!!

We are new to the area and so glad we tried Cucinella's! A cool spot and our new favorite pizza place. We got a pepperoni pizza with garlic knots and a caesar salad, all of which were delicious!

Nice little pizza place a bit off the freeway but worth the stop.

I moved here with my 6 year old twin boys in March. I had family already here and they brought me here. They come regularly. From when I walked in the staff was super nice. There was a nice seating area for larger groups. LOVE the chalk board wall for the boys to be distracted while waiting for dinner. I have only had the pizza so far but it delicious. Reminds me a bit of home.

Stopped in just before close on a long road trip, staff could not have been more kind and pizza was incredible.

The staff is always excellent. Restaurant is clean and well stocked. Food is always fresh and delicious. Ordered the ravioli with spinach artichoke sauce and sausage pizza.

Just go eat here. Don't think twice. Amazing pizza, garlic knots and cinnamon knots. I can't wait to try more from the menu. Staff were sweet and helpful. I will be back!

Delicious fresh baked pizza at a local place. Traveling and staying near I—10 and looked for a local place to eat. Just a few minutes into the town for fresh baked pizza.

This is our Saturday night dinner spot. We LOVE Cucinellas! The staff is always friendly and takes good care of our needs. Best pizza we’ve ever had in the states.

Mine was to go but always delicious

This place is a hidden gem in a small town! We had a pizza and it was fantastic. Can’t wait to come back and try the lasagna.

Pizza is great!! Managers are amazing. Great family environment. Staff is always super helpful and have options for everyone!

This is our new favorite restaurant. Pizza and calzones are fantastic. I'm not a big salad eater, but their caesar salad is so good I crave it. "The Nick" special with the big salad and two 12-inch 3 topping pizzas will have two of you stuffed and have leftovers for one or two meals at home.

Genuinely better than any pizza I’ve ever had in my life.

Everything about this place is perfect. Personally I recommend the calzone but you really can’t go wrong with anything! Also, the girl at the front was incredibly sweet and makes the experience that much better!

Tried for the first time while driving through town after spending all day at Wild Adventures with the family. The staff was so kind and went above-and-beyond to accommodate our tired crew, and the pizza was delicious and reasonably-priced for the size + amount of toppings. My favorite was the chicken-bacon-ranch. Will definitely be back!

This food was amazing!! 10/10. Stoped here on the way home and it was great!

The best pizza around!! friendly staff, the restaurant is a bit cramped and warm but do not let that fool you on how great the food is !! Treat yourself to some cinnamon knots... you won't be disappointed.

This was a great little find for us. Tired of the trendy spots and wanting a real lunch, a simple bite to eat, we popped into this very simple pizza joint a block from the big courthouse in the center of town. The menu is simple just as we were looking for, all the regular items, pizza, calzones, salad, what was not simple was how incredible the calzone was. We had a really crisp fresh salad and a great calzone. I mean, I really liked this calzone. There was friendly conversation with staff and customers who gave us some tidbits on town. It was easy to just fit right in and join the chatter in the little dining room. They were very kind to a couple of "passing through" types, the staff and customers were quite genuine. If you're looking for something trendy, this is not it. This is just good food and friendly service. I always judge a spot by what I get to eat and how I am treated, but I also pay attention to how many locals come in and are known. The locals see these spots on the regular and if they are return customers, if they are known, that is always a very good sign in my book. Give it a try, and then go for a walk around in the courthouse and park just a block away. Cute town, great calzone and friendly people. We really enjoyed Madison and in part, because we had belly full of good food and were treated kindly upon arrival.

Delicious food. Friendly staff.

What an excellent pizza! Happy ladies make great pizzas here. We were just passing through Madison on our way from New Mexico to Georgia for a family reunion. You can tell it’s the locals’ favorite by the steady stream of customers/friends who came in and out while we were there. Good job, ladies!!!

Travelling from Orlando to Texas, we are si glad to detour for 9 minutes. We have been in Orlando for 9 days looking for good pizza (we failed three times) until now. Drive off the interstate and you will not regret it! Come to a simple town and a simple eats at Cuccinellas Brick Oven Pizza.

Pizza is always amazing. The cauliflower crust was really good. The staff is always bright and kind.

Just passing through town and found this gem. Awesome pizza, garlic knots and I know good pizza. Wish I lived closer but I do know that I will be back when I’m in the area.

Food was out super fast and the service was incredible. The workers were super nice and the food was incredible! Ten out of Ten!!!🤠

Huge delicious pizza, loaded with veggies and cheese. Yum

Update Again today, This Pizza And Naomi and Tabby, Good Food, Good Conversation, Clean store... The Lasagna is out of this world...... Cuncinella's is a no-brainer, Good people equal good service and food.

Delicious food and friendly staff, pizza night is always a treat when I order here.

Our riding group ride from Tallahassee to Madison to eat here today. We arrived with 15 motorcycles and 18 people and were great upon arriving. They had a separate dining area for our group which was great. The staff was friendly and our food did not take long at all and it was very good. The pizza sandwiches and salads were excellent! We will definitely be back as they made us feel very welcome thank you! Jeff Roland SCRC

Surprisingly yummy pizza in a place one wouldn't expect it! They even use fresh (not canned) mushrooms. Thanks a lot.

As always employees are friendly and visit you frequently while you eat to make sure your food is and time is well. Pizza is as good as it's always been toasty crust with the perfect amount of sauce. Cheese and pepperoni. I honestly wish I lived closer to buy their pizza more often it's hard to find a good quality pizza

Great pizza. Amazing glazed knot dessert rolls. Fair prices

Best Pizza, Chicken Salad and Salad in Madison florida

Looks like a hole in the wall, but the food is good.

Our brick oven pizza was mushy and crunchy. The staff was great though

I stopped here to pick up a salad to eat later in my room. The atmosphere is great with a sunny, friendly vibe. I ordered a chef salad to go. I could hear one of the people in the kitchen tell someone they were out of something. The response I heard was to substitute something though I didn’t hear what. I guessed I might have one change in my salad. The menu states that the salad has romaine, onions, bell peppers, black olives, tomato, ham, cheese, boiled egg, bacon, and turkey. My salad had no onions, no bell peppers, no black olives, no ham, no hard boiled egg, no bacon and no turkey. Essentially, it had none of the things that make it a chef salad. It was loaded with cheese and included what appeared to be an entire jar of (maybe) pepperoncini which I don’t like. At the bottom of the container, I found what I assume was Italian chicken breast and pecan chicken salad. I am guessing they thought those two (add-ones for $3 and $4 respectively) were fair trades. I’d much rather they’d asked me if I was ok with it as I didn’t care for the Italian chicken either. I’d have chosen something else on the menu to take with me.

Best Italian food we've ever had. The true definition of a hidden jem. Try the lasagna, It was so good we got an extra to take home!

Came for dinner while staying at the local Best Western. Staff were friendly, service was quick. Everyone liked their food: lasagna, chef salad, Italian subs. Plenty of locals picking up food on a Friday night.

We come to Madison, Fl for vacation. This is where you come for Great Food, Great Service.

Had a great lunch with my special lady.

By far, this is the best restaurant in Madison County, Florida. It isn't a fancy place (think small/cozy with a few booths), but the food is delicious only matched by the friendly and welcoming service where no one is treated like a stranger. Fresh pizza made to order, salads, and a few other Italian dishes like lasagna. There are keto-friendly options, cauliflower crust for the gluten intolerant, and lower in calorie options (think basic salads). Sweet tea is outstanding. It is our family's favorite and we eat there every opportunity we get.

Always enjoy. Going to cuccinelli's good atmosphere. Good people, good food

Best pizza ANYWHERE! Excellent service! Fresh ingredients! Absolutely love this place! If you enjoy salads, excellent Julie Salad too!

Try the Spinach Artichoke Ravioli and Garlic Knots. I promise you won't be disappointed.

Amazing place perfect for a pizzeria great wings too

Great food and great service!!! Will be coming back!

Great pizza great service thanks

Great pizza and excellent service. Naomi was amazing!

Pizza was delicious and the service was excellent.

Great food & service! They also have gluten free options of pizza!

Loved the pizza ! New to town definitely our new place for pizza 🍕

Staff went out of their way for us .

Rustic, home cooked Italian fare. Super friendly and comfortable.

Their garlic knots were very good! The large calzone is the biggest I’ve ever seen! The people there are super nice and will give you nicknames if you’re lucky!

AMAZING service and food! Accommodated our large party and made sure we had everything we needed!!

Fantastic place. Small business, BIG portions. Try the chicken bacon ranch!!

Found this place by accident and we decided to try their chicken bacon ranch pizza. It was amazing so we went back another day to try their calzone. It was one of the best I have had.the garlic knots are fantastic. The staff is outstanding they will answer any questions you have . And they way they interact with you will make you laugh. If you are look for a good pizza place with friendly staff . You have to try cucinella's. I promise you will not be disappointed

This place is one of the best pizza places I've been to. I'm rather picky about my pizza. The restaurant is run by a local family who guess great workers and they know how to treat their customers and their employees. I've been coming here for many years, since it was under the old ownership. It's always been great. I've tried everything on the menu and I've never been disappointed. Great food. Good value. Friendly staff. You cannot go wrong. This place is worth driving out of your way.

Always a wonderful experience! The food is delicious

A little slice of heaven hidden in at small town. This place is amazing and a mist stop when traveling threw north Florida. Food and service never disappoints!!

This is the best pizza I have had in 3 years since I came from New Jersey

My family & I recently moved here from Indiana & found out about this place. We decided to try it for the first time tonight. We ordered a large meat lovers & 2 orders of garlic knots..The service was great, the food was excellent & even though they were slammed with orders coming in, the phone ringing off the hook, we could see everyone working their butts off, we didn’t wait long for our food at all..All the people working kept smiles on their faces & had happy sweet demeanors about them. Would definitely recommend this place as I know my family will definitely be future customers..

Absolutely delicious pizza. Staff very friendly.

They had a chalk wall in the dining room that my 1-year-old absolutely loved and it kept her entertained until we ate

Their lunch special is not one to miss, amazing people. Highly recommend and don’t forget to grab a brownie

We were camped at Ragans Family Campground and decided we wanted pizza. I called ahead for take out. The pizzas were ready shortly after I arrived. They were delicious! The toppings were quality. It was not greasy. They were boxed properly and still hot when we ate them.

Wonderful staff, even better food!!! I personally love the meatball sub.

This place is great! Excellent food and a friendly staff!

Best pizza in town! The lasagna and spaghetti are also very good.

Love the family friendly atmosphere and best pizza in town.

I ordered the Calzone then added bacon and fresh tomato. As I took my first bite and my mouth felt the flaking, crispy, yet somehow also fluffy crust; I was already muttering "OMG". Then I tasted the freshness and quality of the ingredients.... Again, before I even finished chewing my first bite...I muttered, "OMG". I'm 42 and travel for work. I eat at a lot of Independently owned restaurants. This is hands down, the best pizzeria I have had the pleasure of trying. My Mom and I judge pizza on how good the crust is. So, I took her my leftovers. She warmed them in a skillet, to get that fabulous crunch back. My Mom did the SAME thing. She just kept saying, "OMG", after each bite. She too, felt the sadness of knowing this pizzeria is 2 hours from home.

Best Keto bowl I've ever had! I will return.

Wonderful place. Clean and friendly. Good is delicious!

One word describes this family pizza place, Awesome!!

Had a delicious calzone. The bread was soft. There were plenty of Italian seasonings available for those of us who like extra heavy! I would only suggest they serve it with warm marinara.

Amazing authentic family owned Italian food and amazing service!

Very good place I've became a regular and the foods always good and the workers are so nice and talkative

Me and my girl drive from Live Oak Florida to Madison Florida for the pizza it is phenomenal

Awesome little town pizza place

Delicious Italian food freshly prepared, and the owners and staff are so nice and welcoming. They are also very active in our community helping others. I highly recommend trying one of their subs. So fresh and delicious!

Decided to stop on our way back from a state park. spur the moment and had an amazing experience. Service was great. Food was awesome. We will be back for sure!!!!!! The calzone is amazing!!!

Super friendly staff and the pizza was great!!! Loved it and will definitely go back!!

Delicious supreme pizza was perfect and loaded with everything! Would highly recommend this restaurant

Small, family owned and homemade taste. The food was amazing! The tastes were on point. Great price and large portions. Definitely going back.

AMAZING!!!! this place is phenomenally good. Perfect place to munch down on after a swim in the springs. the food was hot and everyone is friendly. The ONLY reason this was on the more expensive side was because we bought so much!!!

My favorite place to eat in Madison

Pizza and garlic knots were awesome

One the best local-owned places around. I drive 40 minutes to eat this pizza.

Small town pizza place good pizza.

Had a 15 hour road trip and along the way decided to go to this local place, and didn't dissapoint at all! They had great brick oven pizza, reasonable prices, and very friendly staff!

Food is excellent! We come here all the time. We have had their pizza, pasta’s and subs and all have been excellent! The service is friendly and polite! Very family oriented! Highly recommended!

My husband and I stopped in and had lunch today and shared a delicious pizza - it was one of the best I have had. The owner was very engaging and shared the history of the business - she was very friendly. The other staff were very friendly and engaging as well. We will definitely visit again when we’re in Madison to enjoy some of their other dishes. I heard the lasagna and spaghetti are excellent - can’t wait to try them.

Had the stromboli it was great I'll be back.

First time coming here. Apparently it's a favorite in this small town of Madison. After ordering tons of people piled in. We ordered italian wrap and meatball sub. Both were delicious. I would recommend eating here.