Custom Cakes NW - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

What a treat!! We’re thrilled with the cupcakes they poured their heart into this weekend. We purchased 200+ cupcakes for our daughter’s wedding and not one was left afterwards. Everyone loved them. The delivery was perfect, the setup was exactly what we wanted, service was phenomenal, and they tasted amazing! :)

I cannot adequately express how above and beyond my expectations Renae, at Custom Cakes NW, delivered in making our wedding cake. I have celiacs disease (I’m allergic to wheat) and wanted to be able to eat (and enjoy!) everything at my own wedding. I spent hours & hours searching out bakeries that made gluten-free wedding cakes and then driving (as much as 1.5 hrs each way!) all over the greater Portland and Salem area testing them, before finding Custom Cakes NW—in my own backyard—and what a find it was! It was the clear winner of all the cakes we tried, BY FAR. Our cake was not only beautiful, but it was absolutely DELICIOUS! Moist and tender, the perfect amount of sweetness. Perfection. I/we could not have been happier. We told our celiac and gluten sensitive guests that it was gf and they were so stoked to get to share in eating the cake and EVERYONE raved about how wonderful it was. It was a massive hit! I/we couldn’t have been happier! Not only that, but Renae was so easy to work with—her input was so valuable, regarding what type of icing, etcetera—she delivered it to our reception, set it up for us, *and* it was more affordable than any of the other bakeries we’d tried or considered (and none of the others came close to being as good!) we especially loved the gf chocolate with caramel mousse filling and buttercream icing. Amazing! I’m ordering one for my next birthday and our anniversary. Seriously, best cake ever. Oh! And the pavlova (naturally gluten-free) was also freakin’ delicious and beautiful too!! (shown in last pic :))

Renae made us an absolutely beautiful (and delicious) cake for our wedding last week. She was super easy to work with and provided us with a ton of different flavor options. We would absolutely recommend to anyone in need of a cake!

I’m so happy we decided to go with Custom Cakes NW for our wedding. Renae was incredibly communicative throughout the entire process, promptly responding to our initial inquiry, and accommodating any special requests we had. The tasting process was really fun, and she gave us lots of flavor ideas we never would have even thought of. And most importantly, the cupcakes and wedding cake were so flavorful and moist! She really is the best in the business.

This marks my inaugural Google review, a noteworthy occasion considering my extensive use of Google and its services since the late '90s. Regrettably, words alone cannot adequately capture the essence of Renae's character and the exceptional quality of her confections. Several years ago, my then-fiancé and I scoured the Portland metro area in pursuit of the perfect wedding cake artisan. Armed with a curated list of vendors derived from online reviews, we embarked on a daylong cake-tasting journey, visiting 5 or 6 establishments (a cake-filled odyssey that proved to be, in retrospect, an ambitious endeavor for a single day). Renae's establishment was our final stop, and despite our cake fatigue, her creations immediately resonated with us. The one-hour drive was a trifling investment compared to the extraordinary cake that awaited us. Our multi-tiered masterpiece, each layer boasting a distinct flavor, surpassed all expectations. Its deliciousness prompted a cascade of compliments, underscoring the reason for Renae's numerous accolades on WeddingWire. Since that momentous day, we have evolved into devoted patrons, annually commissioning Renae to craft cakes for special occasions. The raspberry pinot cake with vanilla buttercream has emerged as our perennial favorite. Renae's ingenuity shines through each year as she varies the design and buttercream color, yet the cake's impeccable taste remains unwavering. Our love for her creations has led us to progressively larger orders, a testament to our desire for an extended indulgence in the delectable leftovers. Renae, a masterful baker and perpetual learner, continually hones her cake designing skills. This year, she unveiled an impressive and stunning application of a recently acquired technique. My admiration for her extends beyond her existing expertise to her unwavering commitment to continuous learning. Without reservation, I wholeheartedly endorse Renae to anyone in need of a cake for a wedding or special occasion. Disappointment is an impossibility. Despite her perpetual busy schedule, Renae has consistently made time for our requests, solidifying our commitment to indefinitely sourcing our cakes from her.

Our cake was amazing!!! When we did our cutting at our wedding, both my husband and I went right back in for seconds. We didn’t eat the cupcakes but heard they were amazing as well. Unfortunately someone through out our wedding cake before we could save it, and we were both very upset since that was the best cake we’ve ever had. We plan to inquire in the future.

Beautiful, delicious and amazing service. 5 stars isn’t enough! Custom cakes was able to take direction and create a truly incredible flavor that we both loved. We still have guest raving about our wedding cake! I could not recommend costume cakes more

Renae made 3 different cakes for our wedding because we couldn't pick just one flavor. On our wedding day she put extra care into the set up and made sure they were in the perfect spot. Our guests all ended up sharing so that they could each try the different flavors. Besides getting married, the cake was one of the highlights of that day.

I am compelled to write a review because Renae went above and beyond for a client last year. Renae could have legally cancelled an order one month before the wedding because of circumstances that were out of her control. But instead, knowing that the bride would not find a baker to make this cake in one months time, and while grieving the loss of a very close family member, she went above and beyond to complete the cake and get a reputable person to deliver it. In this rare instance a mistake was made on the contract and neither party caught it. The client wrote, "She had written down the wrong shape and unknowingly I looked past that detail." When a client receives a contract they have a responsibility to review the information and check for accuracy. By paying the invoice you are saying that you agree with the terms of that invoice and contract. It was unfortunate but both parties share the responsibility of that error. As for the delivery I was hired to complete, it was by the numbers. There was no "breakdown and setup" for this cake as it was delivered already put together. I asked for the onsite coordinator and the bride is who showed up. She asked why it was not square and I could only tell her what was on the contract and to call the baker after she returned from her honeymoon. I couldn't change the shape but I did go shopping for to-go cake boxes that she had requested and brought them back to the venue. At the end of the day this was a gorgeous cake that almost didn't happen. I applaud your dedication Renae. Job well done.

Just celebrated my 1 year not long ago. This review is mainly on the professional aspect of things after signing the contract and an aesthetic mistake made to the cake. I received a call about a month from my wedding date with the owner saying she was going out of town and instead of canceling my order she was going to still make it and have a friend deliver it to the venue. Honestly that stressed me out. And in reality it's not legal to just cancel a contact. That's the whole point of a contract. Delivery was a huge hang up at first. She mentioned having a policy that if a cake is more than two-tieres she doesn't allow pickups because her name is on the line, but after some discussion she said she would allow someone else to come pickup my cake if they signed a waiver. Fair enough. I ended up putting it in the invoice that I was going to pay the delivery fee (it was per mile). Her friend showed up and instead of seeking out the DOC to go through the breakdown and setup she was going through the information with me when I had to be in the bridal suite getting ready. I was honestly bummed out when I first seen it and still to this day when I look at pictures. The shape of the cake was not what I requested. It might seem like something miniscule to some, but the shape I wanted was very important to me. I stressed that during our consultation. She had written down the wrong shape and unknowly I looked past that detail. I wanted traditional square shapes. My H remembers me saying that. Round is on trend and overdone imo (nothing against what others like). My engagement ring is princess cut, my wedding ring is princess cut in kite setting, my dress had square shaped diamonds embroidered on some of the lace. The shape was important to me. I had even rented an ornate silver square cake holder. I ended up using it because I had no other choice last minute so there's definitely that distinction. It was still cake at the end off the day, but when you pay a good chunk of money, you hope and trust that it's exactly what you want.

Beautiful, yummy, fun desserts for weddings, and parties.

Renaes cakes are incredibly delicious and beautifully designed. She was great to work with and her black forrest and vanilla / fresh blackberry cream cakes were to die for!! We only wished we would have ordered a bigger cake so we would have had more to enjoy after our special day! Would highly recommend her to anyone looking for the best cakes in the newberg area!!

Custom cakes NW made us cupcakes for our toddler's birthday and they were a big hit! Minnie Mouse themed with pink vanilla cake and a strawberry creme frosting. Kids and parents loved them.

Effing excellent! Not only was the cake exactly what I wanted, it also tasted like fluffy heaven. :] Thank you, Renae! I appreciate your attention to detail and being so flexible. Made "J Poo's" bday epic. ♡

Renae was amazing and made a beautiful cake for our wedding. The flavors were exactly what we wanted, not just a list we were forced to choose from, she was patient with us even with postponing for covid, and the pricing was amazing especially considering she stayed and served it at our wedding. She went above and beyond any expectations to make the cake and delivery excellent.

Renae exceeded our expectations! Made a gorgeous cake based on a custom idea. Delicious and visually stunning. Will order again for special occassions.

The best baker in newberg. Beautiful cakes. Highly recommended.

I love Renae she saved my daughters 1st birthday the bakery I've been working with for 2 months canceled 2 days before my daughter birthday do I was referred to Renae and god bless her she agreed to do it and I'm very happy with her work it was beautiful all my family and friends loved it! It tasted so good and her price for a 3 tier cake was amazing and she also did a smash cake it was so cute I would definitely work with her In the future thanks again Renae sorry for the late review

Renae is amazing, just like her desserts! She was so kind and easy to work with, and she offers gluten free options, which was perfect for what we needed. The cake was absolutely delicious, and all our guests loved it as well! If you’re looking for someone to create the perfect wedding cake for your big day, look no further!

DELICIOUS! Custom Cakes NW was a huge hit at our son's wedding! Renae listened to our needs and desires and then used her professional expertise to create 4 different cake flavors our guests raved about. Whatever your cake needs - birthday, wedding, retirement, holiday - Custom Cakes NW is the answer!

Wow, wow, wow! Renee with Custom Cakes is amazing. She offers a variety of different flavors and can do gluten free too. She provided us with a beautiful and delicious three tier cake for our wedding that was delivered and set up in one piece. Additionally, we hired Renee to make a croquembouche to go along with the cake. And seriously guys, those things are not easy to make, but yet Renee made it happen. Both the cake and croquembouche turned out amazing. We love her cakes so much, that we have made Custom Cakes our designated cake place for birthdays and special events. You guys can't go wrong in choosing Custom Cakes NW.

Renae makes the best cakes! She is very professional and works hard to meet her clients needs.

My new husband and I loved the carrot cake she made with cream cheese frosting for our wedding. So did our guests. My only regret is that we didn't order more of it. It ended up being even more popular than the chocolate cake. (Also personally, I preferred the cream cheese frosting over the butter cream)

Awesome cake Kind of one I always love to eat

Renae at Custom Cakes is always prompt and professional. With so many decadent and delicious cake flavors, filling, and frosting choices - it can be hard to choose just 1! Our all time favorite is the vanilla cheesecake. It's a perfect balance of decadent creaminess and slightly sweet. With high quality ingredients, the flavor is one of a kind. Beautiful designs for weddings and events, as well as simple custom desserts for smaller affairs. We love Custom Cakes!

I loves the flavors of all the cupcakes that were made, coffee was our favorite. We got two cakes and cupcakes for our wedding. Also the top of my wedding cake after sitting in the freezer for a year was so good. Who can do that??? You have to try her homemade frosting.....OH man...I would recommend her to anyone in a heart beat.