Eaton Good in Key West - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Awesome spot, food and atmosphere. They close for a summer holiday! But are back open in October

Place was closed till October with no google map notification

Food was AMAZING!!! We all said it was “the BEST pulled pork sandwich we’ve ever had”!!! Coleslaw, Mac and cheese and pickles were chefs kiss!!!

Growing up in the Bradenton Florida area, I’ve had my fair share of BBQ but I literally think this was the best I’ve ever eaten anywhere. We tried the ribs, pork belly / burnt ends, brisket and pulled pork sandwiches. All six of us were kind of shocked at how good everything was. The pulled pork sandwich comes with cole slaw on it which I’m not usually a huge fan of but I liked the first bite so much I decided to pass on any sauce to add. Also the pulled pork was the perfect consistency and seasoned to perfection. We also got the mac and cheese which was also moist and flavorful. This was such a pleasant surprise for a Key West trip and I would highly recommend. The only thing that was regrettable was that we didn’t find it until our last day here. If we would’ve tried it earlier in the week we would have visited a second time for sure. Kudos for a job very well done!!!

¡¡Delish!! All around super yummy eating, great sides, amazing barbecue skills at this place, I’ve tried almost everything on their static menu(they do special stuff a lot of the time too) and recommend it all (especially pastries in the morning w/ cafe :) MUST TRY. Hella fast service too. You won’t be dissatisfied. The chefs know how to bake and cook, like damn! Literally have not had a single bad thing from here. They also make pizza sometimes and turkeys on thanksgiving!!! Those boys be working hard.

Great food, nice people. Everything fresh.

LOVE Eaton Good! I spend several months in Key West every year and this is one of my favorite spots. A place that genuinely cares about the food they serve and it shows. Love what they’ve got going on! Excellent food, excellent people.

Jerk chicken was great, loved the rotisseries aspect! Brisket was good, but loved the sauce and pickles even more! Pulled pork sandwich sub pickles for slaw was awesome! Will be back!

Unfortunately, so underwhelmed. The pulled pork sandwich was clearly reheated which made it Luke warm and the buns soggy. The 1/4 lb. of brisket was over cooked and dry; and finally the jerk chicken was not jerked!

I was in key west for 5 days and I think I ate here at least once a day if not more. The food is incredible and the guy who runs it is super friendly and helpful. I have celiac so it’s really hard for me to eat out especially when traveling. not only was he knowledgeable about allergen safety but he made me a completely custom gluten free sandwich that wasn’t even on the menu. If I could give that sandwich 12 starts out of 10 I would.

Had there $1 wings Wednesday. Smoked buffalo. WOW! Not spicy but simply delicious sauce they make. Wings were good sized and Juicy. You like wings these are go to in key west

Easily the best meal we had in Key West. You can tell these guys truly care about the food their putting out. Welcomed with a big smile, recommendations were on point, and more than fair prices. Go here.

We had a nice Jerked chicken, Bahn mi sandwich, roasted cauliflower. We went back to try the citrus herb chicken and roasted carrots 🥕. The outdoor tables were a nice touch for ambiance.

We came for lunch and came back for dinner! The foods are delicious!!

Friendly staff, knowledgeable about food allergies. Food is great!

Just plain good good, fresh good flavor The rooster 🐓 begs for food. Service was great. Outdoor humble building, but don't be fooled. Among the best in Key West

WOW a hidden gem! My daughter in law said let me take you to get some great food at the old sandwich shop 1000 Eaton St. OMG! we did take out but was it awesome! I had the jerk chicken with slaw and mac and cheese. Enough to bring home for hubby to try! Caribbean BBQ with lime twist yummy for your tummy! parking beside the right of the building and outside picnic seating for on site dining. You WILL be eatin' good at Eaton Good.

That boy can cook! Best lunch spot in Key West in my opinion

WOW! Just wow! A great little restaurant run by an incredibly nice young couple. The food is amazing and left us speechless. The owner and his wife are extremely friendly and did everything to make us feel like we were in good hands. We are on vacation and come from Germany and have to say that this was the best food we have eaten in America (Miami and Key West). We are very happy to have found Eaton Good and can only recommend a visit to everyone. If we have the opportunity again we will definitely come back!

Great spot for BBQ! Had a nice lunch under the covered patio with the 1/4 chicken and jerk chicken cesar wrap. Was not disappointed with the mack and cheese side! Would definitely come back.

Food was quite good. My husband liked his chicken club. The wings were saucy and well received. The chicken salad sandwich - ordered breadless - had finely minced chicken with fresh parsley and topped with fresh cuke and tomato slices. The jerk chicken Caesar wrap was fresh, lemony tasting. Drink selection was bottled beverages including water and beer. Lunch for 4 came up to $73. Seating is only outdoors but is covered for shade. Portion sizes were generous.

What great service! At first we left because there were no fries for the kids... the nice guy behind the counter was very helpful and immediately recommended something nearby for the kids. And when we came back to get the second part of our dinner from him, he was almost bursting with joy. We had a great chat with the boys and had a great meal. Great people, experience, service and food. *****

If you’re a foodie, this is your place. The food hits all the senses! If you’re reading this today 4/28/24, stop what you’re doing and go get the porchetta and provolone pressed sandwich on house made focaccia. I’m told this only comes around once a year. Officially the best sandwich I’ve had in my 46 years on this earth. We also got the jerk chicken and it was fantastic. Unfortunately, we got our food to go, and now I’m sad because I have to drive 35 minutes in the wrong direction to try everything else on their menu before heading north. Bravo gentlemen! Bravo!!!

Everything was awesome! Can't wait to do it again!

Food was delicious - I ate the lemon and herb 1/4 chicken, with roasted carrots, Mac and cheese, and coleslaw. All were great. Cookie was also great. We ate close to closing time so were the only people there, but I could see it being more buzzy earlier in the evening.

The food was good, although somewhat different. Drink options were limited. Get there early because the best stuff will run out-- smoked wings.

Patrick and his staff are amazing! They are churning out the most incredible barbecue items anywhere with a friendly attitude. The pulled pork, the chicken, etc are all fantastic and don’t miss the brisket on Saturdays! The sides that are available are beyond creative and flavorful. Eaton Good is a must visit when in Key West. Great staff! Great food! Great vibes!! Just awesome!!!

The name doesn't lie. We were eating good at lunch! We got the pork sandwich with a side of mac and cheese, and one of the best Bahn mi sandwiches in KW, with a delicious twist of being on foccacia. 10/10 would recommend 👌

This place is an awesome addition to old town. Perfect for lunch or dinner... the chicken and Mac and cheese are my favorite. Detroit style pizza on Friday's is a must try. P.s local tip: they do coffee and pasty's in the morning- best in Key West without a doubt. (Skip the tourist trap across the street!)

I had been wanting a Cuban sandwich and then found this place- let’s just say that I was devastated when I was too full to finish it. It was big enough for two people, but so good that sharing was not an option. The sandwich had crispy bread, pulled pork that was smoked to perfection, melty cheese, and refreshing pickles. If you happen to be a coffee person, like me, the Vietnamese coffee was absolutely delicious. It was smooth and rich, and was the BOMB. Overall this was the best sandwich I had in Key West, and I highly recommend eating here! (I would have shown a picture of the sandwich, but it was completely decimated before I could even write this review)

Best spot we found on Key West during our vacation! Highly recommend the mac and cheese and turkey club.

Eaton Good is a decent little corner restaurant just far enough away from Duval. While the food was pretty solid, the service and greed left a bad taste in my mouth. After I paid and left a tip, which I don’t know why I did because they don’t really serve or wait on you, I asked for a cup for water. The guy, I’m assuming who runs the place, said they were out of plastic cups and only have bottled water. I looked behind him and eyed the massive stack of cups, both plastic and paper. Then he grumbles ‘we don’t serve water out of those cups’ and then says something to the effect of ‘and we don’t have a water source’ as he’s standing next to a sink. Are you kidding me dude? I left a tip larger than the cost of a bottle of water, but you’re still trying to press me to buy a bottle of water.

This is a MUST,when you visit!! Staple if you live in Key West! Amazing food, scrumptious baked goods, staff is kind, friendly and welcoming!

YUM! Everything was delicious but the Mac n cheese was dryyyy

Came across by accident but pleasantly surprised. Friendly and clean and delicious. Slightly outside the busy downtown so it's perfect to still be able to people watch.

This is our first time eating here since last March and the food is even better than the first time. The owners are great and now they serve breakfast with home-made pastries! I’ll be back in the morning.

Very good bbq. They definitely know their craft. This is how you want your bbq to taste. All the sides were delicious as well

All round an excellent place with the best food in Key West. Loads of flavour, textures and colorful food. Jerk chicken is great, brisket and baby back ribs so tender and full of flavour. Sides are so good, too. Menu changes over the week with great specials, so ask! Great service and a very friendly place - a must visit if you enjoy good food.

Excellent food, great service at a great price. A must eat in Key West.

Food is good, healthy but filling. due to the price not sure if this would be my first choice

Neat barbecue style place with a roadside meets gastropub feel. Outdoor seating or Takeaway. The banh mi and chicken caesar were on point, and great sides too roasted cauliflower and potato salad. Highly recommend for a relaxing, delicious lunch.

Very good food we had the goat cheese burgers. It was awesome!!

Absolutely KILLER food! Possibly the best on island... Try a cookie too they were the best cookies I've EVER had! Staff was incredible and Patrick a great dude! 5 stars all the way around, THEE brightest gem in a town full of gems!

This place is outstanding. I finally ordered to-go after living here for 4 months and always wanting to try. I could not decide which side I wanted with my chicken, so I ordered them all! They all sounded so delicious and everything really was super flavorful and unique. The customer service was also exceptional and he even threw in two cookies to my order. I will be going back!

I wish I could give them 10 stars! We’ve now been here 3 times on our trip. As soon as you walk in the door, you’re greeted by them and it’s just a really great vibe all around! We’ve tried almost everything on their menu at this point and nothing disappoints. If you can be there on a day they have their BBQ, DO NOT miss it. We will definitely be back (probably multiple times) next Jan when we’re back in the Keys!

Incredible food, excellent service. A small selection of hand-cut delicious meats with perfect sides. I think they do specials on different days, specialty coffees are available earlier in the day, and pastries/breakfast items in the morning.

I'm orginally from NC where we know good "que" chicken and pork. This was "bone gnawing good". I did half pork/chicken, roasted carrots and mac n cheese. Thank u for the great food and a full belly.

BBQ, Chicken, MacCheese & Tater salad were superb. Service and staff were stellar.

Stopped for a quick bite off the beating path. Wow! Definitely recommend. Perfectly tender juicy jerk chicken. Curried cauliflower and coleslaw delicious sides!

Wonderful eatery ! Loved the sides!

Food was only ok. Cole slaw was so salty we couldn't eat it. Service was great, however.

Omg!!! You have to try this guava cheese croissant. It’s the best thing on earth.. and I’m French!

Pulled pork, chicken, cole slaw and roasted carrots were DELICIOUS!!!! Would go back again and again!!!!!!

Prices are too high for the quality of food. It’s a smokehouse but they only have a small electric smoker. You can only smell it when you walk inside. Don’t get me the wrong, the food is good, but the price is too high for what you get. It’s quieter than Duval because it’s off the beaten path, which is nice. But we left slightly disappointed after spending $42 on two small plates.

The best place hands down for breakfast pastries, amazing. If you are in key west, Do Not Miss Here. Open for lunch and diner also. This place rocks, the chicken was so full of flavor and moist even though it's smoked. But the sides, damn! Some of the best vegetables ever, vegans go here for the sides, seriously, best cauliflower, Kale Ceasar, everything was amazing. Staff was great! But live alittle, get those wonderfully burnt ends, perfectly puffy little chunks of heaven.

Why is it that a nice bakery / coffee shop like this cannot offer iced tea when they have a large assortment of coffee options?

An excellent meal, a whole chicken cooked for 4, with delicious accompaniments! Served very quickly with very pleasant servers! Very good value for money ! I highly recommend

Looking for a place for a coffee to get out of the storm and found a little gem. Key lime croissant to die for and great brisket sandwich. Great friendly service, owner cares about his food. Wonderful! And it was the best coffee I've had so far. And a place to sit out of the rain or the sun. What more do you need?

Whatever you do, order the pork belly burnt ends! Unbelievable!

Great food. Pricey but worth it

Great barbecue- We had the Saturday special - Pork burnt ends and 16 hour smoked brisket - Both were excellent- The sides (potato salad and the slaw) were well executed as well - The chocolate chunk cookie was maybe one of the best that I have ever eaten-

I really recommend this place, so tasty.

This place is so awesome and is the new reigning king now that cole’s peace is no more (rip). The Bánh mì is where it’s at. The bread is perfect and the amount of toppings are just right. A truly delicious sandwich. And they gave me a free croissant! And their cappuccino was top notch. No doordash deliveries sadly but you can’t have it all and they are super nice there so you end up getting an uplifting social interaction as well as your delicious sandwich and coffee. Tldr: They’re 🔥

I haven’t had the pleasure to eat there yet but we catered their Thanksgiving dinner and WOW!!!! Absolutely delicious!! 100% recommend.

They offered catering for Thanksgiving day, and it was excellent! They packaged everything very well. It was hot and ready to serve. They offered a wood fire rotisserie turkey that was perfectly cooked, well seasoned, and juicy. The sides were just as great! They offered mashed potatoes, gravy, stuffing, Brussels sprouts, and sweet potatoes. We just added a few of our own sides and good to go! It was really good and great customer service.

Delicious freshly prepared whole foods! Will return!

Brother this was the best food I’ve ate in a long time

Order Puzza in Advance, pizza only available Fridays

The food here is so dam good. Finally there’s a place in town with professionals in the kitchen.

After coming to Key West for the last we find a hidden gem. Eaton Good is this years winner. Stopped in and had Pulled Pork, Mac and Cheese and Coleslaw. Each done with a different flair that was excellent in taste. The hospitality was second to none. Can’t wait to try the rest of the menu!

Excellent food and service!! Kale Caesar + chicken was DELISH! Cauliflower was perfect!!

Delicious food and friendly staff. Easy to order online, pick up, with parking at the restaurant, and go.

just had lunch from Eaton Good on eaton and this place was great i would recommend anyone go by and try this place i did a jerk chicken wrap and potato salad and coleslaw all homemade and the flavors blend wonderfully

Sandwiches were fantastic, ordered a bahn mi and pulled pork sandwich, and the sides were killer, ordered the potato salad and macaroni. Employees were super friendly and informative. Can’t wait to go back and try the brisket and their pizza. Highly recommend this delicious spot in Key West. Thank you!!

Popped in for the re-opening and tried the “Italian” sandwich. Deliciously crafted on focaccia bread with an aioli spread and pepperocinis to tie it all together. Along with this, I also enjoyed the delectable pulled pork which was both tender and flavorful. The tasty food coupled with the attentive service I received from friendly staff is what makes Eaton Good one of my favorite places to dine in Key West, right here on Eaton Street!

Great Brisket! And the Pork Belly Burnt Ends are the Best!

Two guys working, the owner and a great right hand man. The brisket melted like butter in my mouth and had insane fat content that was some of the finest I’ve ever had. Next, the curried cauliflower. BOMB. Absolutely integral to a meal here. Mac and cheese is my BBQ staple and this Mac is fire with shavings of some cheese on top. They have assorted beers iced down in a cooler and it makes it feel like your friend is cooking up BBQ while you have a beer: great spot, great service and I will definitely return!

Fantastic, Fantastic, Fantastic!! We got most of everything including a cookie. Between the 3 of us we demolished almost every single dish. The barbeque ribs ranked the highest among us. Delicate, tender and full of flavor. If you're a lover of curry, the cauliflower will have you raving. Best place for social eat and the staff was amazing. We ate with three local friends and had a blast. Deciding where to eat was difficult for our trip until we stopped here and found a return favorite. Hats off to the chef for every dish and friendly atmosphere, I can't recall a spot where I ate almost every dish and wanted more of it. If any one finds themselves at the bottom of this rave review, I cannot stress enough on stopping by and trying every single dish.

This place is must go to for the best food on Key West. We went there 3 times because the food was phenomenal. Pork Belly Burnt Ends, house made Mac N Cheese, Philly cheesesteak, curry cauliflower, all absolutely amazing food!! Excellent job to them and team.

Absolutely delicious. You have to try the Philly cheesesteak. Not the usual fare. Slightly spicy and top notch.

Great vibes and even better food.

Most of the menu was gluten free for those needing!

Omg! Came in from Atlanta and saw this place online and had to give it a try. Food was amazing and the owner and staff was great. Had the scotch bonnet mango BBQ ribs with ginger lime cole slaw and the burnt ends with keylime kale Cesar's salad. Meats were so tender and flavorful and salads were fresh 😍. The cowboy cookie was delicious. If your in Key West, stop In and have a great meal!! 👍 Thank you to the owner for a pleasant experience.

Unbelievably good BBQ, especially for the price. Didn’t catch the gentleman’s name at the counter who served us, but he was extremely friendly/amiable. He even gave us a complimentary cookie for dessert. If he sees this, please put a bigger sign out front! We passed by on our bikes while looking for it. But Eaton Good is certainly worth the venture off of Duval.

OMG everything we had was awesome and they were very great and pleasant to deal with and that Mac n cheese is to die for.

Attention: Gluten Free and everyone else. Do not let Eaton Good slip by. -sensational food. The smoked jerk chicken, coconut shrimp, Cuban sandwich, roasted carrots, and lime slaw are OFF THE CHART! The chickens add character.

Nicest people and the food is simply incredible!!! The sides are absolutely 5 star rated and the chicken was just magnificent....super juicy and the flavor was throughout the meat. We will be back soon!!!!

Excellent BBQ. We had chicken, ribs and pulled brisket. It was all amazing. Got to talk to both owners about their journey into this restaurant and was completely impressed.

Omg! This place has 5 star quality flavored food! You would never expect such a fantastic gourmet flavor! The ribs, chicken, and dont get me started on the best mac n' cheese and brocolli sides ever! Don't underestimate these guys...they really know how to cook and flavor everything! We also had the honey pork bellies....this place could easily be transformed into a high-end restaurant. Patrick was very friendly and I promise, you will not be disappointed! Just go! Try it! You will be back!!

This place is absolutely delicious. What a welcome addition to Old Town Key West. They continue to expand their selection, which is already fantastic. Do yourself a favor: get a couple friends, and order the burnt ends, the ribs, the brisket, some sides and park yourself at an outdoor table. A couple cold beers, and you're good to go.

If you are a fan of BBQ done right, this place is a must. We met the owner/operators, Chris and Patrick, and not only are they super nice and friendly but they are experienced restauranteurs who know what they are doing and it shows. We tried the brisket, ribs, and jerk chicken, plus several of the sides and everything was delicious, including the key lime mousse. It was so dang good (their house BBQ sauce is amazing), we went twice during our Key West visit. An easy 5 stars. Highly recommend!

This place is absolutely amazing! We attempted to try everything, and we came pretty close. We had the brisket (drool worthy), the ribs, the burnt ends, the cauliflower, the broccolini, the carrots, and the Mac and cheese. Just… a perfect meal. Portions were large, food was perfect, and ABSOLUTELY CANNOT WAIT TO RETURN! 🤤🤤🤤

The reviews on this place were good, and so we decided to give it a try. Oh my goodness, it was so good. We split the half order of pork belly burnt ends, which comes with two small sides. We got the carrots and the cauliflower, because they sounded interesting. It was all fabulous. Do yourself a favor and give this place a try.

Food was unbelievable…meat was incredibly tender, moist, and flavorful! Sampled the burnt ends, ribs, and brisket, and it was impossible to pick a favorite. Had the broccoli, cauliflower, carrots, and mac and cheese for sides. They were uniquely flavored, and I appreciated that they weren’t greasy and fried. It was quiet, a nice change of pace from the hustle and bustle of other places in Key West. Patrick was very friendly. I would highly recommend!!!

Holy WOW!! This place is AMAZING!! SO FREAKING GOOD!! We will be eating here no less than twice a week!!

The food is outstanding and the crew is great! Loved that the main focus is the food; followed by a very chill environment with music and outside eating! Felt as if I was transported to Texas! Congrats to this crew! Great addition to KW! Hopefully they add a limited breakfast menu, would be great!!

Really enjoyed what I've tried so far: pastrami sandwich and bbq pork sandwich. The chocolate chunk cookie was scrumptious and really enjoyed side of sweet potatoes. A welcome delight to the neighborhood!

Local flavors. Great service. Clean tropical ambiance. Awesome food.

Delicious delicious food - every item is so well seasoned, cooked and good portion size. Jerk chicken, Mojo Porchetta, Curry cauliflower, Mac n Cheese and Sautéed broccolini. And don’t miss their Key lime Mouse… yumm!!

We stopped in for lunch and tried the jerk chicken, coconut shrimp, broccolini, mac, and sweet potatoes. The staff was incredibly friendly and everything was delicious. We’ll definitely be back the next time we visit KW!