Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Good Lord have mercy what can I say about this ice cream it's always on point, I have nothing to complain about this ice cream is the best I tell you the best I love Jeremiah's

I always pass by here on my way to school and never thought much of it until today when I actually decided to try it. WHAT THE HELL???!!?!? It’s SO GOOD!!! I ate the Birthday Cake flavour and my dad ate the Strawberry Shortcake flavour and they were equally delicious. The urge to order another one was strong, but hey, money doesn’t grow on trees and I’m kinda broke (TwT) Anyways, if you haven’t already, GO THERE!!! You won’t regret it, I swear!!

Many options to create your own customized gelato, Italian ice and ice cream. You can choose to add a variety of sweet toppings. The employees are super friendly and attentive. There are also outside tables for you. Drive thru is available. Parking is limited. Sign up through the app to receive offers and discounts including a free choice on your birthday.

Visited Orlando, Florida area and was told to try this fabulous concept of yumminess. They combine Italian ice with soft serve ice cream. The Italian ice alone is amazing and made with real ingredients. Then to include the crazy combination of soft serve was over the top! If you are in the area where these are located, do not miss this place!!

We visited Jeremiah’s Italian Ice with our family of seven, and it was an incredible experience! Each of us ordered something different, and we had a blast trying each other's choices. The variety of flavors was amazing, and every single one was a hit. The staff was friendly and efficient, making sure we had everything we needed. The quality of the Italian ice was top-notch—refreshing, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. This place is a must-visit for anyone looking for a sweet treat.

They say they close at 11pm on a Wednesday night. I got there at 10:40 and they’re already closed. They should fix their time on their website or honor the time that that they say they’re open until.

Delicious ice creams, a lot of variety of flavors. Just highlight that despite having many employees, sometimes they take time to prepare orders.

Not flashy, just great. Everyone goes there and leaves smiling because the stuff is great.

They had excellent menu choices. Interesting and what I chose was satisfying.

I don't usually like Italian ice, but mix it with ice cream? Yum!!

Great service today. He got our order correct and packaged to go perfectly. All tastes great!

I like the ice cream and all, but what I don't like; is that when they change a flavour on the board, you have to either remember how it's made or you can't have it. The people there always give us lids or no lids when we ask for a lid on only one. Despite this, it is pretty good, but not healthy! Ha

Tbh it's kinda annoying for the payment tablet to ask us to tip on already high priced ice cream..

The Girl working the window was very customer service oriented. Liked coming to this location. Felt like a valued customer. They should have name tags so they can be recognized.

Nothing really to be said this is iconic Jeremiah's Ice location where the legend started! Bring the kids your date and enjoy yourselves to a wonderful treat.

It's a great place for a treat and hang out with family.

Great place for a treat. Many flavors to choose from. Cookies and Cream is my favorite. The only complaint about the place is they are always very slow. Not sure why it takes 4 minutes to scope some ice.

The Gelato and Ice cream is really good, but there isn't much space to sit and enjoy it. Since it's central Florida, it melts really fast. It's also not really a food you can eat while driving.

We had a blast celebrating Leap Day. It's a treat going to Jeramiah's, and although we have a location close by, going to the original location is special. The gelatis are so good and it helps to have the app to get items off the "secret menus" and earn points toward free treats.

Been going to this place for about 6 months. Love it.. my family and I are hooked

Beautiful presentation. Prettiest Jeremiah's order ever! Thank you for the great customer service 💕

Best place for kids to get a quick dessert. The staff is friendly and efficient. The property itself is not always the cleanest, but still a great place.

Great little spot for sure. Love going with the kids. The treats are delicious. Service is always good.

(Aloma Location) they have a new promo out this month for bogo on Mondays, just make sure to ask for it or they will charge you regular price. I was charged regular price and when I went back to show them they had a hard time honoring their bogo deal (as advertised) and the manager on duty (guy with brown hair) tried to talk circles with me instead of ringing me up the right way. That experience was ridiculous and that manager was also just as ridiculous for not trying to honor the deal. His excuse was it was the first day and his employees were not ready and had forgotten that it started because they usually don't hold specials.

What a great place! I’ve been going here since I was in College. Great to see them growing so much. They have so many great Italian ice option and if you mix with the soft serve ice cream, you get your Gelati. My favorite flavor is Black Raspberry with Vanilla Ice Cream. Give it a try! Enjoy!! ✌🏻

The ice is good but I've noticed there's hair in the ice cream and now I found this thing that came out the ice cream my daughter was eating. Out of the different locations I've purchased this location tends to have different things in the ice creams

Great place for ice cream! Great staff and very convenient.

One of best ice cream places in Orlando

Best place for a cool treat in town!

Outstanding cake batter gelati!!

Employees are always friendly, and the flavors of Italian ice are amazing!

Our least favorite is Sour Green Apple, so when that’s the only sugar free flavor we cut back on our purchase.

Even though it was super busy on a Friday night, the staff was so energetic, positive, and patient! Isabel made my day with little sample gelato cups so I could choose my perfect blend of flavors. I'll be back again soon!

Love this place. The workers are always super nice and the gelatis are to die for. First Italian ice place that never gave me a stomach ache, even with how filling it is

Always a great place for a lil treat!

I love Jeremiah’s, it’s delicious and the staff is super nice and efficient!

Very nice place for a quick dessert! They have ice cream, Italian ice, and a combo of the two called Gelati. They let you have samples of the combos, so you can find the flavor combination you like best before you buy a big cup of it. This is red raspberry ice with chocolate ice cream

Helados deliciosos y excelente servicio y atención al cliente

I’ve been going to this location for years. They had special flavors on the menu today and, even in a small gelati, blended chocolate and vanilla ice cream and layered two flavors of ice. Total for two people was under $4! Highly recommend the rewards app!

I like coming here, though it's been nearly 2 years... I moved away and when I moved back into town, you better believe that this was one of my first stops in town... The Strawberry and Vanilla Gelatta are the absolutely, unequivocally, hand-down best of the best ! Why go here , because you can ! The service is exceptional and the employees are so friendly and outgoing, amazing , really !!!!! 5+++++

I've been going here since it opened.The Gelato is too good to describe, my favorite stop.

One of the quality chains in Florida definitely give this place a shot!

Had the Key lime coconut pie limited edition flavor it was excellent. So good i forgot to take a picture of it lol

GREAT food. Fish was excellent..

Gotta love Jeremiah's Italian Ice. I've been to many different locations many times, and I've never gotten less than a five star experience. The services is always quick, the stuff is always delicious, and even the price is always right. I stopped by here one day on an ice cream day I was having, and I got their infamous Gelati, which is a combination of their core ingredients, Italian Ice and Soft Ice Cream. I forgot what flavors exactly, but it was probably one of their very helpful recommendations. This local chain has my heart, and if you haven't been to one yet, now is the time, as we are quickly approaching the brutal Florida summer.

I was disappointed because the young lady misunderstood my ordered. I ask for chocolate ice cream and when I got home I had chocolate ice in I waited a good while. Because it was a valentine special buy one get one free. So I go back to Jeremiah's in the line is crazy long. Just when bad home 😔

Good icecream, subpar service. When i ask for a medium I don't want am extra large 😭

Love the pumpkin pie the best. Hate that it's seasonal. Other great flavors

Super Exquisito.. Me Encantó Está Combinación.. Estoy En Orlando Y No Conozco Ninguno En Miami.. 👍♥️😃

LOVE this place there ice cream is to die for its amazing so tasty

Great snack, great service. My kids love to get their own ice and eat it with us.

Yum! Cookie butter + horchata!!

Ice cream was good. The gender fluid looking girl who looks like she cuts her own hair needs to work on her attitude. She handed us our ice cream while talking to her other employees, no goodbye? Weird