Maggies Magic Muffin House - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great selection and always delicious!!

DO NOT EAT HERE Ask to see kitchen!!!! Place is nice up top but have you ever seen the kitchen and where and what they cook all muffins in 😷 one day I was there and the water department was there and I watched the worker leave and he said “I can’t believe this is legal” and he never did come back. Their bowls are legitimately moldy and they still mix muffins in them. Surprised people haven’t gotten sick because of this place. Wouldn’t be surprised if they have been sick!! Never will I go back after seeing the behind the scenes of this place. 😵‍💫 totally not okay and very disgusting. You should be shut down. HEALTH INSPECTORS SHOULD SHUT YOU DOWN

Very dirty and unsanitary. Very unprofessional establishment.

I've always driven past but finally got to stop in and try it! It truly feels magical being tucked away right off of Southern Blvd. Their case is huge and they have so many wonderful muffin flavors. My favorites were the lemon, strawberry filled, and pistachio. Can't wait to go back for more

My favorite place to grab a quick breakfast with my daughter on the weekends!

Couldn't resist stopping in to grab a muffin during my work day. Such a cute place! So many delicious options to chose from. I had a hard time deciding. The muffins are HUGE and tasted absolutely wonderful. I will definitely be back again and again. I can't wait to share these with friends and family when they come to visit. Maggie's muffins are definitely magical 😍

Absolutely delicious! They we're so good we couldn't decide which one's to get. Very great value and so yummy even at 2pm. Definitely recommend trying!

Very delicious and an interesting atmosphere

I know this place was here for years, but on this particular day, my mother-in-law was in the car and remarked she would like to see what they had. I was really surprised at the huge variety muffin flavors they had. They were a little pricey but they are very large and very good.

The muffins and breakfast sandwiches were delicious. The staff were very helpful and friendly. The shop itself is very clean and cozy, would highly recommend.

Most moist fluffy delicious muffins you will ever have

Visited for the first time yesterday, this shop is so adorable! The muffins...WOW...my only complaint is I cannot stop eating them. They are so good! Definitely go and get one!!!

Love the muffins, worth the price, so yummy.

This place! Made my first stop in this morning and was greeted by the sweetest lady. She was busy but she happily made me a breakfast sandwich (perfect!) and I cannot wait to try the muffins she recommended. Will be back! Brightened my day ☀️

Love love love Maggie's! Found out about them a few years ago I have to go at least once a month! Great treats huge muffins!

Best muffins around! Hands down!

Some of the best food and coffee I've ever had and I am always treated so so kindly. I've never had a bad experience here and I will always come back!

Great food, great people, great muffins! Well worth it no matter what you get.

Amazing. Period. Atmosphere is quaint and very intelligent. Do your taste buds a favor and let them know you love them still.

A super cute little place! We were finally in the area during open hours so we stopped and grabbed some.muffins. We got an assortment of muffins to try. The muffins are huge and all very good! Everyone was really friendly and helpful!

1st time ever going. Got 4 muffins. They have about every kind of muffin you can imagine I highly recommend everything was sooo good. Keep up the good work A+ will definitely be back!!!!

I liked the way the muffins were crispier on the top. Pretty good muffins.

If I could give more than five stars I would.. the lemon blueberry muffin is the best muffin that I have ever had in my life!!

The owner basically told my driver that we would get what she gave them and was very rude AGAIN. That's the second time this has happened and when the driver refers to the owner as vile, that's pretty bad. This place will never get our business again!!!

Well ... I am in CalifornI craving a banana walnut muffin ... how #sad is that😊🥰

Hole in the wall type of shop. Had mini muffins for our girls for free, and had an amazing selection of muffins. We got a dozen, 3 breakfast croissant sandwiches and mochas. All delicious. After a few days in the refrigerator the muffins taste so good, and not dry. Be returning back for sure.

Best muffins in tri County area. Period.

Service is great and muffins are unbeatable

Very nice employees & very clean & the muffins. Yummm..

The best muffins in the Valley! I love the Birthday Cake and Sugar Cookie ones!

First time here. Muffins were very stale, had to be at least day old or more. Paid full price.

Cute place ,very creative and comfy environment

Very nice selection of delicious muffins

Amazing muffins, great service, all the flavors sound great, prices are just right

Wow-best muffins ever!! We got an Abbey Road and Orange creamsicle. They were both AMAZING! So soft and big and full of flavor. What a cute little place!!

Just like the name says, those muffins are magic.

Muffins good, lot of varieties, breakfast sandwiches were good.

OMG! Our muffins were soooooo good! It was hard to decide what flavor to get. So we bought a half dozen to last a bit longer! I had a carrot cake muffin with cream cheese icing on. 🥕😋😋 It was so fresh and moist with big chunks of walnuts in too!

Great little place in the middle of nowhere. The selection was outstanding. It's a must stop by to get your muffin.

The selection of muffins is amazing. So many different flavors to choose from some I've never heard of. This is a must stop at once in awhile for a great muffin. The owners are very very friendly!

Delicious muffins & great customer service. Fresh baked daily.

the best muffins in Ohio . hands down.. truly magical

The muffins are delicious. However, the croissant egg sausage and cheese breakfast sandwich is more than enough for me to order from here!

So this hidden gem is amazing. I wanted something for breakfast but the idea of doughnuts was ugh. Saw this wasn't far from my office. Just WOW! The muffins are small cakes, and the flavors! This a fork required style muffin. Will be returning and probably ordering for the office too.

Magic muffins, Maggie makes the best. Each muffin is a meal in itself. Fantastic flavor I'm every bite.

First time visitor but won't be my last

I got the good vibrations muffin which was delicious! I was overwhelmed by the amount of muffin choices offered. This place is quaint and wonderful.

Ordered a carrot cake muffin and it was dry, and hard. I reached out through messenger and told whoevwr answered...They offered to do NOTHING! Very disappointed!

First time trying this morning. The bacon, egg, and cheese croissants are amazing and affordable. Can’t wait to try the muffins!

Everything is consistently good! Great service.

24 years in business. Made from scratch daily and the lemon muffin with lemon filling that I ate was truly the best muffin I have ever eaten

Decadent. First time I had stopped, will stop again. I forget what this was called in the display case, bit it was amazing.

These muffins were simply amazing! I got a dozen for my co-workers and everyone loved them.

Haven't had a Maggie's Muffin for years since they are no longer in Austintown. But was near the Boardman location with my mom recently so decided to stop by. Got a half dozen assorted muffins and we weren't disappointed - still delicious! Very moist. So many flavors, you will have a problem choosing a favorite.

Always fresh delicious and the staff is awesome

If you've ever been here, you know why its 5 stars. If you haven't been here, you absolutely need to. This is my go-to place for gift baskets for any occasion, too. Condolences, congrats, get well, happy wishes... everyone appreciates these muffins and are always something to talk about!

Great place, kind service and best muffins!

Friendly staff... Good selection... Definitely worth stopping by to see what they have available...

They have a really wide selection of muffins (small cakes), and good sandwiches

Breakfast burrito was good, adequate. This was my COVID post-vaccine treat. Muffins amazing, fluffy, moist, huge, crunchy crust. I bought 1/2 dozen for peers at work. Blueberry, blueberry+pomegranate, NY w cream cheese, Apple cinnamon, chocolate+cherry, and I forget what the last one was.

Great muffins at a good price. Wide variety of unique flavors to choose from

The best muffins around. So many flavors to choose from.

Very friendly & great muffins but a little expensive but most are worth it.

Always a treat to go, love the selection, great staff.

Muffins were great, but the three egg sandwich on a croissant was terrific filled with flavor!

Best giant muffins EVER...always fresh and what a selection...

These were the best muffins I have had in years. They have the nice homey flavour that big corporations lack. They are huge muffins and they all tasted great! I will definitely be coming back. The ones listed below include: lemon filling, red velvet, chocolate with chocolate chips, blueberry pomegranate, pistachio, and all happy together(has walnuts, chocolate and caramel).

Maggie's has great breakfast sandwiches and many different flavors of mammoth muffins!)

My daughter and I went last week for the first time ever.These muffins are amazing, you will never have anything better, can't believe I haven't been here before, this is gonna be a regular stop for us from now on. They have every flavor you can imagine and then some!

My mom, Peggy, used to work here. It is a quaint little bake shop, with monster size muffins and all sorts of interesting flavor combinations.

Muffins ok, Coffee was cold and wasn't a Latta, may go back for muffins but not coffee.

Our first visit to buy some muffins was confusing. We ordered a peach muffin and it had no taste to the muffin itself..ofre in the peaches. The pistachio was an off colored green with a fake pistachio taste. Then they have english walnuts in a pistachio muffin...not pistachios! The muffins were moist, tender and fresh! I don't think we will be going back again!

So friendly, great food! Always love to support local businesses!

Wonderful muffins and so many to choose from

There are very few things I miss about Ohio, but Maggie's is one of them. Used to hang out here in high school with the owners daughter, and the muffins were divine. They're huge, the flavors are seemingly infinite, and are just so beautiful. May have to send my parents to get some to bring me next time they visit.

Huge selection of muffins. All so delicious.

Yummmmmmm! These muffins make great gifts.

Great little muffin shop and a nice change from the typical donut shop. The muffins are HUGE and delicious with an amazing array of flavors. An excellent find on a road trip!

There was such a great big selection of muffins it was hard to choose just six. Good place for a lunch too.

Always neat, staff is friendly, very little wait time, and of course every kind of muffin you could think of available and fresh.

Awesome variety and always tasty!😊

egg salad is delicious. however, the gnats flying around the muffins kinda turned me off from getting those

We ate lunch here and it was amazing! I had never tried warm potato salad and it was great!! Croissant roles are perfect and got a few muffins to go - they are like small cakes ❤️❤️Yum!!

Yummy muffins. Great breakfast sandwiches.

Stumbled upon this place when I was searching for local breakfast. I’m not from anywhere close to this location, BUT LET ME TELL YOU if I ever come close to the area again I will be returning for sure. The sweetest lady helped us, cut up a whole muffin to let me try it, and then was very patient while my boyfriend and I tried to decide what to choose from because everything just looked and sounded so good. The sweet lady told us she just had a fresh batch come out of the oven so we went with one of those and my goodness was that BEST MUFFIN EVER!!! we ended up getting 3 others and they are just all so delicious and big! So big and filling that it is worth every penny. You will not be disappointed by coming here!

So glad this place is still here. Taste is just as wonderful as I remember.

That was a good place I will be going back if I'm in the area

Great blueberry cheesecake Muffin.

Friendly service. Awesome muffins!

Oh my these Muffins are tremendous! ! Good prices, so many options. They all look so good, I went in for one.. then couldn't decide and got 5... hahaha!!

Amazing! Delicious and great personalities!

I definitely underestimated the muffin selection... there's no way you'll be able to try all the ones you want in one visit. they're decent muffins. place is tucked away off one road from the Southern Park Mall.

I love Maggie's. The muffins and service are everything. It's always a real treat. My students and I had a blast eating our muffins. I called because I needed to place an order for the next day and it was super easy.

Such a great, cute little shop!

The smell of deliciousness hit me before I even got to the door of this place! SO GOOD! So many giant muffin flavors to choose from & they're ALL to die for! Will DEF be going back!

Cute and quaint little shop that has much more than just a delicious variety of dreamy muffins. You could spend an hour just trying to decide which one tickles your fancy most. They also have sandwiches and coffee which makes it easy to meet for a quick bite or coffee

The muffins were delicious the service was was good. I felt very welcome.

Muffins are fresh, great variety, best muffins period

I love there muffins the coffee cake cream cheese is excellent I try to go wherever I am out that way

I loved this place! Breakfast sandwiches coffee and muffins. It couldn't get better than this. It also has free WiFi if you want to go hang out for an hour or so. The oreo muffin was so good I forgot to take a picture.