Maiden Lake Supper Club - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Great cocktails and food. Beautiful surroundings, friendly, efficient staff.

You must run to this place! Among the best prime rib I've ever tried. Tenderloin with gorgonzola to die for. Scallops out of this world. Best liver spread I've ever had. Drinks on point. Lake view spectacular. One of the top supper clubs I've ever been to. I cannot wait to go back.

Had an excellent meal tonight, best ever. The bartender, Julie, provided great service and drinks and recommended the Scallop special. It was one of the best meals I ever had! My husband had the hand breaded perch which was also delicious.

Great Steak! The Gorgonzola Tenderloin is my go-to steak there every year. Been going here for at least 40 years!

I make sure to stop here every visit from Arizona to see my parents. They love it, best walleye around, and I can also purchase gift cards for my parents to go when I’m not in town. Excellent wait staff as well!!

Had a delicious dinner Saturday evening with the family. The drinks at the bar were tasty and our server, Jenny, was the absolute best! The place was packed but Jenny and her co-workers kept pace. Thank you Jenny for the 10 star service!!!!

We had cocktails and appetizers on the patio for a wonderful evening. We visit almost every year. Beautiful spot.

There is no better place for food on the Northwoods. The outdoor decks are great, and a full service bar outside is the icing on the cake.

Had an amazing dinner Sunday night at Maiden Lake Supper Club! It was busy but enjoyed the patio by the lake and outside bar. Had a cocktail and an appetizer of lobster bites. The staff took our order and once our table was ready sat us in the dining room. Such a great view! Service was excellent and so friendly! True supper club with various breads and veggies and spreads. My tenderloin was the best I’ve had. If busy enjoy the experience and come hungry. Highly recommend!!

Beautiful deck overlooking the lake for cocktails. We had a very nice table in the dining room with a nice view. Service was top notch

We were an unexpected party of 14, and they were full. They went out of there way to accommodate us. We sat on there nice deck area and had a drink, and when it was close to the time to seat us, they took our order and names. When we were seated, they started serving the food almost immediately (and it was very good). I would strongly recommend it!

A true supper club. A must for my family and I whenever we're in town.

Love this place! The food is excellent, service is great! There can be a long wait, but it’s worth it. You sit outside on the beautiful patio on the lake, order dinner and will be brought inside to your table when your dinner is ready.

The best Supper Club in the state! Service, food, drinks, atmosphere, it can't be beat!! Beautiful lake view.

Hostess was very rude. We were not treated kindly at all. I ordered a tenderloin medium well and it came out so raw and bloody. We will never go back! Not impressed at all.

Beautiful location, excellent food and service. What a treat!

A can’t miss place Food A+, Bar service A+ Staff…outstanding

Mother’s Day Dinner with my husband was fantastic!!! We got the Parmesan Tenderloin and Halibut with lemon crème sauce and both were amazing in flavor and quality. We will definitely be returning. Staff members were kind and accommodating even though they were about to close down right before we got there because it had been a slower night. Apparently they aren’t usually open on Sundays and we got lucky to walk right into a table which I presume never happens. View of the lake was stunning. Highly recommend!!!

Good food great times! Can’t wait to see the new line of craft beers!

Typical supper club with a simple menu

A great supper club in the northwoods. Everything was perfect from the service at the bar and the dining room! Will definitely be back. Thank you for a great evening.

Been here many times, always very good!

Our favorite place to go for dinner!! The food, atmosphere and staff - always excellent!!

It was delicious 😋 went for my birthday dinner with my Aunt. ❤️❤️❤️

I went to dinner by myself for my 70th birthday and another table bought my dinner and I never told anyone there that it was my birthday. It was so nice of them and my dinner was fantastic.

Exactly what you want in a supper club

This place is amazing, extremely busy, but has customer service down to a science, it was a long wait but they keep you busy from the time they take your order until you get to your table and start with the relish and cheese tray until the main course comes. The food I ordered wasn't to my liking but it was something I hadn't eaten before so was really wasn't their fault,

We have been there MANY times and we celebrate or anniversary every year here! Can’t say enough good about it ALL! Food is INCREDIBLE!!! Thank you Maiden Lake…. We’ll be back!! Highly Recommend this picturesque north woods gem!!

Best supper club in wi… the food is to die for and the view is amazing.

Go here. You will NOT be disappointed!

I have been coming to Maiden Lake Supper Club for many years and have tried most all of the menu items. Prime Rib on Saturday night is the best of the any that I have had the opportunity to try in the Midwest. Walleye and roasted duck also are amazing. Atmosphere and staff are excellent

Stopped in with family group of 9 and didn't have to wait long for a table. The bartender kept us quenched while waiting. Waitstaff was quick to take our orders. We had veggies and dips at the table while we waited. The soups and salads were delicious. Our entrees were generously portioned and delicious as well. We elected to take dessert to go. Beautiful scenery enjoyed throughout the evening.

Always FANTASTIC..over the top customer service n fantastic food!

We arrived early at 4.00 p.m. Sat down about 4.20. Was out by 5.30. All good with that and food plus service. Only complaint is it is a small seating area and it was loud. Husband and I couldn't hear each other talking.

The best walleye, bar none! Fantastic Northwoods location. There is usually a 1-2 hour wait for dinner during the summer but that’s the best part! Hanging out on the deck, overlooking Maiden Lake and having a few Old Fashions while you wait for your table makes for a perfect evening.

A true supper club from cocktails to dessert. Staff was all super attentive and fast, even tho they had a hiring sign up, as all restaurants seem to have nowadays. Martini menu had many interesting varieties. I choose "Honey Badger Don't Care", made with pomegranate liqueur and honey whiskey out on the tree covered deck with a perfect view of the lake. Dinner includes an appetizer plate of baby carrots, crackers with cheese and liver spreads. Also choice of soup, small loaf of warm bread, and side salad of mixed greens. I had the special of the night, Alaska salmon with southwest seasoned crushed tortillas, roasted sweet corn relish and avocado crema, on top of a creamy tomato risotto. Fantastic combo of flavors and textures! My husband had the seafood Alfredo. Super cheesy sauce and tender scallops, lobster, and shrimp. Good size portions so there where leftovers to bring home. Had to bring home dessert also as we couldn't pass up a coconut cream cake or brownie cheesecake. 😋 Kudos all-around on service, atmosphere, and food!

Our 2nd attempt to get here, and we're very glad we succeeded! Arrived at 3:45, and after a drink on the outside deck with beautiful views, we made the first seating, with a table overlooking the lake. The atmosphere was perfect..a good old fashioned WI. supper club! Our server...Jennie was great, the courses were timed just right, and everything was exceptional. We had the lightly house breaded scallops and the gorgonzola tenderloin as our main courses, both were excellent! Worth the one hour drive to celebrate our anniversary...We will be back!

Jackson, Ellie, and Tori were absolutely phenomenal. They took such good care of our party of 8. And they played all our favorite songs even though I’m sure we were annoying as all get out! ❤️

Beautiful surrounding. We came after a rain and had an hour and a half wait so decided to partake of the outside bar and view. It was my first time having a Wisconsin Old Fashioned and I loved it. The service and food were great. I had the prime rib and was not disappointed--it was perfect. We will definitely be back.

Been here 6+ times and you can't go wrong with the walleye or the duck... awesome! Prices are higher, but you get what you pay for on food quality, service, and lake view/atmosphere.

The bar inside is great, as is the one on the patio. Both were amenable to making drinks not on the menu. The dining room was beautiful. All of the staff were attentive. The wait was quite long but was accurately predicted by the server and expected based on the popularity of the place. The popularity is well-warrented as the food was all excellent! The only negatives would be that as of my visit, the door of the wheel chair accessible stall in the women's restroom would not close. Additionally, the patio has narrow, slanted steps down to the first level.

Atmosphere was great. Sat outside on deck overlooking the lake drinking a good old fashion. Hostess said about 75 minute wait. Went to table 15 minutes early ( good). I had broiled walleye, wife had beer battered perch. Walleye nothing special (8). Breading falling off the perch(8). Enjoyed the relish dish. Service was excellent. Guess I was expecting little better food for the prices. Other people really enjoyed the steaks.

Amazing views! Food is good. I love that you can order by the water and then move in to Dine.

Excellent guest service and excellent food!!

What a place! This is a must stop but expect to wait a long time during their busy hours (like 3 hours of wait) however it is well worth it! I came here to check out their Bloody Mary for @WiscoMary but I was super impressed with their food and the location. Lucky me I sat at the bar and I was served immediately I had a lemontini and their deep fried Lobster I would have that again and again it was that good. I did order Bloody Mary but gave it to my new friend sitting next to me but I did taste it and it was delicious. Thanks to Zach for his great hospitality!

Perch was amazing. Very friendly waitress. Gets extremely busy and crowded.

Patio for drinks with a Loon,Order there...have another OFashion.Get seated with liver and cheese vegy tray. Chicken rice soup and salad above average.Maidon Lake Combo was my usual.. Seafood Supreme is it now... And I haven't tried the beef yet 🙃

Lovely sitting out on the patio while waiting for a table. Great food, great service! 5 star supper club in the Northwoods.

We started off with an Old Fashioned sitting on the deck with gorgeous views of Maiden Lake. Our server took our order and escorted us into the dining room where we had probably the best hand breaded walleye ever, followed by an amazing slice of strawberry cheesecake. Overall it was an excellent dinner experience.

Nice supper club south of Lakewood, Wi. Friendly and attentive wait staff. Very good food. Plenty of outdoor seating on the 3 level deck overlooking Maiden Lake.

The food and service were nothing short of excellent! I’m looking forward to coming back to try something else. Our experience was amazing!

Maiden Lake Supper Club is a gem of a classic supper club. The old fashions were delicious. Traditional ordering at the bar, relish tray, crackers, soup, and salad all included in the meal. Our group enjoyed steak, stuffed shrimp, and prime rib. After dinner drink options, including ice cream drinks were boozy and delicious. The service and views were excellent. A must stop supper club!

Absolutely delicious, they do it up right, excellent service & food, very friendly

The food & service was great. My open-faced steak sandwich melted in my mouth. The only drawback was the Women's handicapped bathroom. The toilet was short & the hand-rail slanted downward. Every time I tried to get up, I slid back down. Took me 5 tries before I

First time here for a Friday night fish fry. Service was great and food was delicious! After dinner drinks are the best!

Awesome place. You feel appreciated that you are there,

Everyone was super nice and friendly, even the customers! Service and atmosphere was great and the food was amazing. We will definitely visit again

Food was awesome, the staff was top notch.The best supperclub anywhere.

M.J. & Trina always have things top notch!

Always delicious! The prime rib is amazing! Old fashioneds are the best!

On top 14 WI supper clubs. I see now the food is great. Tenderloin cooked perfectly and cod was great too. My wife said better then inshalla, so she liked as well. I came at 530 on Saturday and was done eating by 7pm. They give a lot of appetizers for free here, fill u up. Cheese dips, salad and soup and loaf of bread and crackers. Fully satisfied.

Food was amazing and lots of it!! I had the special , garlic chili tenderloin. My husband had the shrimp. The view was gorgeous 😍

What a great and classic supper club!!! Service was great even though they said they were short handed. Great menu with some options - scallops for example - that you rarely see in the great North Woods. We all ended up trying the hand breaded seafood choices - walleye, perch, scallops. All were excellent! Classic drinks at the bar, relish tray at the table with cheese, pate and crackers (!) and great desert choices. Next time we will try the steaks since they all looked delicious. Friendly and professional staff. A definite stop if you're in the area.

Food was just ok had to wait for ever was not worth the wait

We have.been here three evenings & we have loved our interlude each time the patrons we're awesome & the sunset absolute perfection! The food was delicious!

We went to this supper club at a time when their summer staff was gone, so we had a 2-2.5 hour wait on a Friday night. However, they have a beautiful outdoor area that we sat in with a lovely view of the lake that we fully enjoyed. I'm glad we chose to stay and wait because the food was excellent! The wait staff and bartenders were friendly and the restaurant was clean with a great ambience. I would absolutely eat here again and highly recommend giving it a try!

Despite being shorthanded, the staff delivered service with a smile. Food was excellent. Love the outdoor decks!

Beautiful outside bar and seating. Best seafood and steak in the north woods.

Very delicious!! If you're looking for a fancy restaurant go here. Beautiful view of maiden lake, romantic setting. Each meal was $20-30

The host, bartender and waitress were all very prompt, professional and polite. Very cozy dining atmosphere with AMAZING food. I got the hand breaded scallops, my better half got the chicken Alfredo. Both were spectacular, along with the combination appetizer we got. It truly felt like a fine dining experience should, and it's something neither of us have seen in a long time. The restaurant is located right on the gorgeous maiden lake and the scenery speaks for itself. It is an absolute must visit in this area, and while there was about an hour and a half wait friday night, it was WELL worth it. Give it a shot and be patient. You won't be disappointed

Love this place! Beautiful scenery and great food.

Get there early if you want to eat with a big group. Great food and great atmosphere. Northern hospitality at its finest!!!

I've been coming here for 25 years and MJ has always taken care of my family and I. The food is always consistently good, the drinks are made well, and the atmosphere is wonderful overlooking Maiden Lake.

This dinner destination has few, if any peers in the larger geographic area. Superb atmosphere, friendly and attentive staff, great bar service, and memorable dining experiences have become standard expectations, even though no place and no staff are perfect. Oh yeah, the food is equally amazing. I look forward to every visit. #OldWorldCharm #TraditionalHospitality

Such a gem! Great food, service, and atmosphere! One of our favorites.

Too bad the hospitality didn't match the beauty of the location. Called in advance to make reservations, told no reservations accepted - says the same on the Facebook page. Drove an hour forty five minutes, walked in at 4:05pm, only to be told the wait was 1:45 due to the fact they had 60 reservations and only 45 seats. Waited for 5 years to visit from Wisconsin Supper Clubs book by Ron Faiola. Probably the single worst experience I have had in 50-60 years of dining out, or should I say attempted to have.

Excellent food and service. You will not be disappointed!

An incredible Supper Club in the north woods with a million dollar view while you wait for your table. When we arrived we were told the wait was two hours. Other groups left, but we stayed and were rewarded with wonderful cocktails and an app on the deck overlooking a local lake. My ribeye was amazing and the baked potato was perfect. My only negative thought, not a criticism, was how quickly the rest of the meal was seemingly "rushed".

Fantastic steak. Beautiful place. Great service!

Food and service were great! It was out first time there. We will be back.

Patterned after Ishnala on Mirror Lake, they did a fantastic job! Beautiful views on their tiered deck outside with great cocktail menu and appetizers while you wait for the excellent meal inside. I had the salmon puff pastry...EXCELLENT

My family and I visited Maiden Lake Supper Club on Saturday night. As could be expected on a weekend, the wait for a table was lengthy but the staff makes every effort to ensure that you enjoy your visit while you're waiting. The outdoor deck had plenty of tables to wait comfortably with a great view of the lake. There is a small bar available for drinks and appetizer orders. Menus are provided while you wait so you can consider your dinner choices. The staff will take your order prior to being seated to minimize additional wait time when you get your table. Our meals were excellent and the service was exceptional. Highly recommend this supper club if you're in the area.

The food, hosts and atmosphere are 2nd to none. Always a pleasurable experience. MJ, Trina and the staff are the best!

Best food in the county! Great atmosphere and friendly young service staff.

Classic Wisconsin Supper Club, and one of the best! Awesome views! Great bar/drinks. Awesome outside three-tiered seating area with a belly-up bar. Incredible food, from appetizer to desert. It does not disappoint!

Food was great! In portion, timing, quality, and taste! Beautiful scenery on the back deck and the staff was very helpful and friendly. Highly recommend if in the area

Amazing food! Awesome drinks! The service was outstanding! Someone even bought the shirt off my back.

Food was great, being able to sit on the deck and watch the lake while sipping cocktails and watching the lake while waiting for our order was wonderful. Food was very flavorful and done right. And the efficiency of the staff and their wonderful personalities was a great treat. We enjoyed our experience and will come back in the future.

Everything was delicious. My husband ordered the tenderloin special and I ordered the broil walleye and broiled scallops. The loaf of bread at the table was warm and delicious and the soup and salad was delicious also which was included with a meal. We also ordered dessert which was a blueberry lemon cake which was excellent. Would definitely go back.

Always awesome service and food.

Extraordinary atmosphere, excellent food and great service!

One of the best supper clubs I've ever been too. Great staff, wonderful views and the steaks were outstanding!!!

The Walleye was awesome!! Great staff.

We really enjoyed this supper club! One of the best up here!

We had the best prime rib dinner. The service was also great. We will be back.

If I could give 10 stars, I would. Maiden Lake is an annual stop for us, and although we didn't make it this summer, we had a tremendously great Saturday night dinner a few weeks back. Bartender among the most efficient I'd ever seen, and he obviously taught his younger brother well, who was bussing in the main dining room and was the fastest I've ever seen. Service as always was top notch, and the food was spot on. Please continue to support these local businesses, they are working so hard in such a challenging environment.

You will not find a better meal in this area! Maiden Lake has the best walleye and steak hands down.

Excellent food, service and view. Pretty pricey but well worth it. If you are in the area I highly recommend stopping in.

Absolutely Incredible owners, staff, ambiance, view. And out of this world FOOD and service!

Enjoyed beautiful cocktail hour on outside decks.