Michelangelo of North Port in North Port - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Awesome pizza! Would definitely recommend

The gluten free pizza was super good but the gluten free wings tasted fishy almost like rotten chicken. The garlic parm sauce is honestly a thick garlic parm sauce which isnt my jam, but might be others.

The food is EXCELLENT!!! Lots of choices, delicious! Thus us my new, favorite restaurant.

I ordered a 16" Pizza. According to their displayed menu it should have cost 12.95 plus 2 topping @$2.50 each the total should have come to $17.95 + tax. Nope, $25 and change. When I asked why it was so expensive and showed her the menu price on their website, she said that it was old and they don't use that website anymore. Yet i was able to call them from the page. Watch out for these thieves. Reporting this to the BBB tomorrow. If I could post the picture of their menu here I would.

Love the calamari and the arrincini, took home a calzone and garlic knots.

Best pizza in town. Try the Chicken Marsala pizza.

My wife, love this pizza place and the pasta and everything they have is definitely from New York!

Ac vents need cleaning. Bathroom wasn't very clean either.

Very good food, excellent portions. Well not leave hungry.

Best restaurant I have tried in North Port. Moved here eight months ago & been let down close to every time with food from local restaurants. Good food makes me happy 🙏🏽 Please keep whoever is in the kitchen 🔥

We tried the Grandma’s Pizza and it was delicious! Fresh ingredients… you can absolutely taste quality. Desserts are also very tasty. They have lunch specials as well. We’ll return!

Over priced. You can dine at olive garden for a lot less and better atmosphere. Would not recommend this place to anyone

Picked up 2 dinners to go. When I got home and opened the bag I found that the salads and bread were not in the bag. I called in and was given the choice of coming back and getting the rest of our order or the next time I ordered meals there I would get and extra salad and bread. I would 2 salads with my meal. I told them to never mind and I won't be coming back. I don't understand why getting a complete order ready to go. This is the second time this has happened to me a week (at a different restaurant). When I called them and explained part of the order was missing they had the good business sense to credit my account for the meal so I will be going back there.

Small restaurant good food good service.

Since moving to FL from the Northeast. The Buffalo Pizza today was by far the best we had in FL.

BEST HOMEMADE CANNOLI'S! AWE-MAZING WHITE PIE!!! Only Restaurant within atleast an hour north or south that can make a REAL WHITE PIE

Michel Angelo's Supreme Pizza is a flavor-packed feast that satisfies even the heartiest of appetites. Piled high with a colorful array of toppings including pepperoni, sausage, bell peppers, onions, and olives, every slice is a tantalizing blend of savory goodness. The crust, with its golden brown exterior and soft, chewy interior, provides the ideal base for this indulgent combination of flavors.

Came in was greeted right away, felt very welcoming. All the staff was very nice and attentive. Excellent service

Me and my family came in for take out for pizza we got the margarita pizza it was so hot and delicious. Service was easy and fast. We loved the pizza!!! Highly recommend.

Michel Angelo's Chicken Parm Pizza is a delightful fusion of Italian flavors and American comfort food. The crust, perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, provides the ideal foundation for the savory toppings.

Really good pizza! Also, I love the gorgonzola salad. Floors in between counters/appliances are due for their post busy season deep cleaning.

Excellent Chicken Parm! To me its a great take out joint, only thing is its priced a little high.

This place need a good cleaning. Did not like the food, were not able to eat a third of it. First and last time we were there.

5/5/2024.. looked at on-line price of Za..it was 23.95**** get to the restaurant and pick up AND price was higher..WTH..??? If you are raising your prices..PLEASE CHANGE ALL OF YOUR MENU PRICE SITES..I SHOULD HAVE MADE YOU HONOR YOUR ONLINE LOWER PRICE..FROM NOW ON.. I'LL ASK YOUR PRICING..and then maybe go somewhere else ..?? ( this next review was in Dec.2023)..Good meat lovers Za's.... service was good.... clean restaurant.. friend who came with me for first time enjoyed the pizza etc...

I always get a Stromboli at least once a month this time it was much smaller. I usually get 2 meals out of it. And this one was definitely not a two meal. I questioned them but I was told that's what it is, but then when I got home and I always add pepperoni to it and pay extra there was very little pepperoni. It used to be I had to pull the pepperoni out of it because there was so much which was a waste, I agree, but I did notice a huge difference. Also, there was absolutely no flavor whatsoever. I don't know if it was the mozzarella cheese they've changed or something was different when I say there was no taste, there was no taste. Not my taste buds they work, Extremely disappointed.

Stuff mushrooms not to my taste, the wine used too strong almost like a Merlot., little shy with the cheese on the pizza. I ordered a combo chicken parm and eggplant rollatini. There's also a three combo chicken eggplant and veal I think that's what I got there was some kind of dark meat under all that cheese they had a good crowd there

We waited for awhile for a server. I had to go up to the counter and ask for one.I ordered the eggplant parm instead I received chicken parm. I sent it back and they made the eggplant. My pasta was overcooked. My husband ordered the seafood platter for $26. The seafood and pasta were overcooked. The sauce was terrible. He sent it back. The salad was ok and the rolls were the best thing there. They should have stopped seating for a few minutes until the servers got caught up. The cook needs to be taught what al dente is. The whole experience was not good. Definitely would not go back there!

Tried the rest?now try the best staff is top notch and they have the best pizza around coupled with a great staff this place is a must

Average food. Way overpriced. Not worth it. Look around before you spend your hard earned cash. Many other places to choose from.

Their food is always amazing. 👌

Got a take out large pizza $28. Crust was perfectly almost burnt. Excellent crust. Like crisp and chewy sourdough bread. 4 adults fed for $30.

We arrived for dinner and were sat immediately. It took 10 minutes to get a drink. Then ordered salad. Took another 20 minutes to get silverware. Ordered food. Took over 30 minutes to get food all while the tables around us were getting their food. One of our meals didn't even come out. After asking about they they couldn't really tell us what was going on. We ended up getting up and walking out without eating after being there for 2 hours!!! If you are not able to handle dine in and take out close one! This is absolutely ridiculous.

Ordered takeout. Order was ready on time, hot, and accurate. Everything tasted great! Will be back.

Food was on the verge of tv dinners, was told to sit any where we liked then told we couldn’t sit there. Then one of the young waitresses yelled at an atleast 70 year old lady and told her to get out because she asked to sit at a certain table. Couldnt pay me to walk back In There

Disqualified customer service was pathetic. Said 10 minutes wait ti dine,after 20 minutes wait was told could not seat and eat for another 30 minutes because service couldn't handle. FOOD LOOKED CHEAP QUALITY. Went next door to Wings and things got seated immediately and their food was fabulous.

We called ahead of time to let them know that 7 people were coming. They told us no problem, they could accommodate. When we arrived they said 10 minutes then after 15 minutes they said at least another 30. We commented how there were at least 7 employees and only 20 patrons there. They were rude and basically told us to leave. We went to wings and rings and had excellent service and food. We definitely made the better choice.

UPDATE. Once was our favorite go to for handmade pizza in NP. No more. Prices are ridiculous and quality hit and miss. Picked up a “12 Margherita pizza the other night. Burned. $25. Obscene. I felt like a fool. Never again.

The food was amazing. The service was average. Any pasta is a good choice

We've been in NP for almost 2 years, we've heard of Michelangelo's for quite a while, we even knew someone that worked there in the past, yet have not tried their food until tonight. Dig it... The Eggplant Rollatini was absolutely spectacular, cooked to perfection in a homemade red sauce that is authentic and flavorful, every bite was an experience. The pizza was as equally delicious; we had a simple cheese pizza with pepperoni, green pepper and onion, insane! The side salad was super fresh, their home dressing a delicate masterpiece. The side of sautéed garlic and spinach was delicious, while most places drown their spinach in ridiculous amounts oil, not here, it was cooked perfectly. The staff was all smiles and very friendly, we felt welcomed and appreciated. Thank you. So... go there, eat and love, tip well, smile and be grateful we have a place like Michelangelo's in our wonderful neighborhood. UPDATE: the BBQ chicken pizza is absolutely remarkable!

Some of the best pizza i have ever had. And its just as good every single time i order from them. Excelent place to eat.

Without exaggerating we waited 25 minutes for a soup and sandwich during lunch time..no one esle there.. phone kept staff answering phone etc. We left $5 and went on our way for Drs appointment.

Excellent service, friendly and helpful staff, great food!

Their meat lovers pie is my favorite

They catered our wedding a lot of food. Everything was amazing with plenty for everybody. I’m from New York. I’m very picky but the food was absolutely amazing.

Happy New Yorker! Happy New Yorker and I love this place

It was my first time at this restaurant I loved it so much. I will definitely be going back there

Slices are fantastic staff is very friendly... Italian sub also wonderful.

Thank you for donating to our Cypress Falls Relay For Life Event!

Food was large portions, ok flavor.

Their original pepperoni pin wheels are my favorite. I was impressed by the quality and taste of right away. Great Value: Michelangelo's Pizza offers these pepperoni pin wheels at an incredible value. You get a delicious and satisfying snack without breaking the bank. It's a budget-friendly option that doesn't compromise on taste. Perfect Cheese: Michelangelo's gets the cheese-to-pepperoni ratio just right. The cheese is wonderfully melty and complements the flavorful pepperoni. It's the kind of cheesy goodness that you crave when you think of pizza. Sauce on the Side: One thing I particularly appreciate is that they include sauce on the side. It's a small touch that adds so much to the experience. You can dip the pin wheels into the sauce to your heart's content, customizing the flavor to your liking.

I just stopped by today for 2 chicken parm subs.....WORSE SUBS EVER HAD...WONT BE GOING BACK THERE NO MORE. COUPLE PIECES OF CHICKEN LOOK LIKE STRIPS....NO MORE TREEIBLE

I do not recommend this place, the fettuccine alfredo is not good. I called and ordered over the phone and specifically asked if the fettuccine came with a salad and bread (as it says on the menu) and I was told yes, it does. I arrive at the restaurant and asked the young kid behind the counter to add a piece of cake to my bill and he did not. I asked two more times and he kept telling me yes but never did. I arrive home to find no salad or bread. The pasta is lacking flavor and the chicken on top is fried and greasy. Not that it really matters either but the didn’t even use fettuccine noodles

I stopped by a month ago first ordering the seafood platter, then the Pizza, & other dinners, now I'm a regular customer. Like most Florida transplants I searched for a Pizza Place like the Pizza where I came from, Jersey. Michelangelo has Excellent Real Italian Pizza & Dinners! Julio the Pizza man is like a Picasso but his palette is not canvas but the pizza dough, he makes the most visually attractive & flavorful Pizzas I ever tasted. Every item I tried was fresh & tasty.

Food is always great. Excellent customer service.

Awesome food love there pinwheels

The ceiling near the vents are filthy with dust caked on. Right over the pizzas and dinner tables. And it was very hot in there. Even the staff were fanning themselves as well as the patrons.

This place has gone down hill lately.

First slice of pizza in Florida. The food was tasty and the service was great.

A great place to eat. The food was delicious.

The Absolute Best Pizza I’ve Had Since I’ve Moved To Florida Little Expensive But Worth Every Penny.

We’ve eaten here a few times. It’s usually awesome. Tonight, the chicken parm sandwich and mozzarella sticks were not the greatest. Disappointed. Hopefully it was just an off night because we usually love this place! Stuffed meat pizza - delicious.

This is a great local pizzeria. Not to far off 75 for a visit. The wife had meatballs and a salad. Both were very good and the low carb diet was satisfied. I enjoyed 2 very large slices of pepperoni NYC style. Fold and eat while you try to keep the oil from dripping off. Great!

The stuffed shells were delicious. I would order them again. Pizza looked good and I will try that also next time.

Awesome pizza. Being New York City girl it is close to home❤️

Food is great, but unfortunately as long as that bigger kid who seems to be in charge when the owners son is not working is still working there, I will not be going back. My order is wrong every single time he is working. Every single time.. Lost my business and it’s sad because you guys do have good food.

The owner is a young entrepreneur with a very good head on his shoulders. Hard worker puts quality into his product, and the staff are friendly and very attentive to their customers. There are not enough stars to give him.

Place years ago was phenomenal, past say 3 to 4 years went way way down . Don't think I'll be going back for a very long time

Coming from ny there's a reason the line is out the door on a Friday. Also says a lot when my husband is an Italian chef and already makes the best pizza. We gladly eat here when we can't have his pizza

Best pizza I found out here since I moved here.

Family members just moved to North Port and discovered this place FAST, we now order almost every Friday night. Love it.

Not sure of they got a new chef but food hasn't been as good as usual and the air must be broke in there its ALWAYS HOT in there

Booked a reservation for 8 people they only had one waitress for the whole restaurant the service was absolutely terrible. They brought us still partially frozen mozzarella sticks we barely got drink refills the entree of stuffed shells was not cooked properly and very dry. Completely unimpressed at this place will be taking my buisness elsewhere.

Husband called and Ordered 3 chicken Parm. dinners to go. Went to get them and the gentleman at the counter was very nice. I think he was new. I waited about 15 min. Because he didnt know which pasta we wanted. So they needed to get that ready. No problem at all. Out comes this big bag. I grab it and after getting home hubby says where is the salads and the bread.. So I called and the girl that answers the phone explains to me the young man is new and then she says "stuff happens". I understand people are new and they are learning but I didnt need the attitude. Driving back 15 min. (30 min.) to get our salads & bread was really inconvenient. I asked her if she could just refund us some money and she told it would be the same price that salad & bread are complimentary.. we paid $64.00 for those 3 meals and it was honestly the worse chicken parm. that I have ever had. It was tough & dry. If we come back, I won't order that again. Pizza in the past has been good maybe we should just stick to that.

Always come here when we visit our family in Port Charlotte We love the food I think this is our 4th visit!!

A family favorite. All our out of town visitors look forward to eating here.

If you like sour tomato sauce on pizza, bad odor on food, manager did nothing. Frozen pizza could be better than this place

will never be back. hairs in almost every item we ordered. was extremely disappointed in the quality of the food and the service. run by kids who just goof off and talk the entire time without worrying about the only customers in the restaurant. told the lady at the front desk and she just looked at us like it was our fault.

Unfortunately I was very disappointed. I waited over 20 min past pick up time. I also pd for extra sauce not received and cold pizza. The response was the worst part of me want me to do about it.

Pretty good pizza 🍕 for south of Philly. Apps were pretty generic. Haven't tried the entrees yet.

We order from here at least every two weeks. Friendly service here and great pie. Grandmas slice and stuffed meat is really good. Pasta dish I like is the chicken piccata with the artichokes. Will be back soon!

Horrible service, called in an order, stood for over 10 minutes without anyone acknowledging me! Once I got my order my food was tossed on the counter without any words spoken to me. Pizza had no sauce( I had asked for extra) and hardly any cheese or toppings. When my husband called to complain he was hung up on! Will NOT go back!!!!!!@!

Love the vibe it gives walking in ❤️ so Italian ❤️ food was delicious and best customer service ❤️ definitely going back not sure where all these negative comments are coming from 🙄

Dissapointing. Just moved to the area, looking for a good pizza place close by, but you only get one chance to make a good impression, and they failed. Claimed to be closing early, like a whole hour early, because things were "slow." Plenty of people coming in for take out orders, so not sure how slow they were. Unable to order anything, except what was laying around. Took 10 min to order two slices of pizza, even though there were at least 3 people near the counter. Basically they could not have cared less if I stayed or left. There's a Little Ceasars across Price. Guess I'll give them a shot next.

Fantastic pizza and pasta..great value for what you get ..

Usually very good. But last night a little off.waited very long for food..was there from 500pm until 745...disappointed my pasta was cold. But we will go again.

Cearar Salad not like I usual order. They were more interested in Pizza orders.

Yes to everything. Their pizza is amazing

So happy to have found this neighborhood gem on Mothersday dinner- a lot of local places were closed and it was looking like we were going to have to cook… and then Michelangelo’s popped up….Fresh affordable food and friendly service. Our server Jessica was terrific. My husband said his baked ziti was flowered just right. I had the eggplant park it was yummy and I had leftovers. The fresh hot rolls was possibly the best I have had.

If you are going to dine in, there are better places.

All I did was pick up pizza for some family, everything that I visually saw in this place made me want to eat there too. Very clean, and incredible polite service.

The first time we went here it took a while to get our food, but this one was good. Today I brought some friends and I can say that it was a big mistake. The restaurant was almost empty, the tables were dirty (dirty cutlery, napkins and glasses on the table) and it took more than an hour to serve our food. Even though it took so long, the food was not hot when it was served at the table. The employees looked disoriented and pouting at customers.

People always nice there pizza is great closest to home

Been here 17 years. This place was ok to good for a awhile but the last few years absolutely horrible Our last attempt today - pizza under cooked and looked like the cheese was thrown on after they took it out of the oven - not even worth one star - DONE

Everything was delicious...great service!! 100% recommended!

Great place and good! The staff is awesome and fun to talk too! Definitely a place worth trying! Also the pinwheels are fun too

Great pizza and calzones. Great prices

First time back to this establishment in about 4yrs. So much better

Food was excellent. The service was not very good. Took over 10 minutes to be acknowledged and they were not that busy

Placed order by phone went to pick up ,paid and waited 30 minutes before I was told they did not have the pizza that I ordered. Still waiting for rest of order

Service was unorganized, time food was supposed to be ready for us to pick up was almost 20 minutes off, food did not taste hot and fresh