Michelina's Italian Restaurant & Catering in Stuart - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The best Italian food I've had! Everything from the bread to the salad down to the main course. Service was great as well

So glad we found this restaurant, it is all around terrific. Recommendable to everyone.

If you want authentic Italian food this is where you will get it. Chef Melissa is incredible. Their Tira-ma-sue is to die for!

Maybe we just came on a bad night… we had high expectations for this place and left extremely disappointed in the food and service. The AC was not working so we were sweating the whole time. Service was slow but understandable since it was busy, however other employees checked on our table more times themselves than our own server. The pasta is what we felt most disappointed as it didn’t taste bad but both lacked flavor. My pasta was undercooked and my fiancés carbonara was extremely bland. We didn’t even take them to go as we didn’t care to eat either one again. It didn’t taste horrible, but for the prices it was absolutely not worth it.

The place is a hidden gem, the food blew my mind. Perfect portions, fresh tomatoes and home made pasta.. the staff is the sweetest group of young waitress and waiters but that did not take away their detail to attention. Again a hidden gem

The restaurant is a little too dark for me, they keep the lights low, but I would like them a bit brighter. Otherwise, the restaurant is excellent!

I ordered the chicken rollatini in my husband ordered the calzone when the calzone was brought out it was extremely ginormous that was the reason why the food took a little longer we were wondering what was happening but all in all everything was great we will return! We went to celebrate a birthday and they gave us free dessert! Great service

I recently hired Michelina's to cater my wedding in February, and I cannot express enough how thrilled I am with their service. From the moment we started planning, their team was attentive, accommodating, and truly went above and beyond to make our special day perfect. Firstly, let's talk about the food. It was absolutely delicious! Our guests couldn't stop raving about it for days after the event. Michelina's not only provided a diverse and mouthwatering menu but also took special care to accommodate guests with allergies. Everyone felt included and indulged in the tasty offerings. Moreover, the service was impeccable. The staff was professional, friendly, and seamlessly managed every aspect of the catering, leaving us stress-free to enjoy the celebration. They were attentive to every detail, ensuring that everything ran smoothly throughout the event. What impressed me the most was Michelina's commitment to excellence. They didn't just meet our expectations; they exceeded them in every way possible. It's no wonder they come highly recommended by friends and colleagues who have experienced their catering at other community events. Their stellar reputation is well-deserved. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Michelina's to anyone in need of a caterer for their event. They truly know how to make an occasion memorable with their delectable food and outstanding service. And as for me, I'll definitely be returning to their restaurant for more of their yummy offerings in the future. Five stars all around!

Had a pan of lasagna made up for a party on Saturday. It was the best lasagna I've ever had.

We're new in town, Stuart FL near Port St Lucie and Google Maps recommended this restaurant. It was fantastic! I don't see the homemade pasta manicotti, on the options below butI got it and it was DELICIOUS! As a matter of fact, today is my boyfriend's birthday and I think we're going back for dinner!

One of my favorites!! Great food, service and ambience.

Very busy family restaurant with great service (well-trained students and responsive servers). The whole Italian ambience was reinforced by the actually excellent Italian food. We will definitely eat there again❤️

Everything we ordered was great. Keep up the

Veal Marsala was delicious! Such great service!

Arrived early for reservation for 5. Friday was my youngest son's 18th birthday. We waited outside with the mosquitos. Seated 10 minutes late. Food was hot. Wedding soup very salty. Not all entrees arrived at the same time. It was obvious someone didn't read the order correctly. My daughter and son waited 15 minutes for thier food. The wait staff didn't notice until we asked for thier meals. Almost didn't get dessert. Staff were too occupied with packing our leftovers to ask. They did remember before tallying the check. The blueberry lasagna was excellent.

Amazing food!! Def a hidden place around here. Everything tastes homemade and the service is quick and awesome! Will be coming back here! Soo many good sounding things on the menu we have to return!!

Our condominium women's group held a luncheon at your restaurant and everything was done to perfection. Your staff, the food and the service was wonderful. Thank you for making our afternoon an enjoyable one. Jeanne Schuler, South River Condo

Unbelievable Caesar salad. The veal Toscana with artichoke and wine sauce was terrific. I’ve travelled to many countries and this meal was very memorable The best Caesar salad dressing I’ve ever had. Next time I’m going to make it my meal.

My company ordered catering for a holiday party. The food was delicious, the ordering was simple and easy and the servings were perfect! We had their trays of chicken parm- the breading was perfect and sauce has great flavor. Garlic knots were best around! Chicken Cesar salad had fresh lettuce, plenty of dressing and yummy croutons. Highly recommend!

Coming to Michelina's for Christmas Eve is our family tradition. The food is amazing! They have the BEST mashed potatoes and garlic knots, all of my kids agree. I tried to take pictures of our food but it was so good that I only got to take a picture of empty plates... Always great service. It's our little local secret.

Always good service, food and atmosphere.

Hands down, the best Italian in the area. My family has been coming here for decades. My folks had their 50th wedding anniversary here and it was perfect, my brother had his 50th birthday here and it was awesome, I'm having my birthday dinner here next week and it will be epic! Skip the chains, eat authentic Italian, I mean, they make and roll their own pasta, get here already if you haven't!! Make reservations though. Tammy is the best server in the land, dine with her!!

Just my humble opinion, but my first thought walking through the door was how tacky. Ugly seats and cheesy white Christmas lights on the ceiling. The waitress was fine. The wine list was limited. Then there’s the most important part, the food. I didn’t even finish my meal. Enough said.

What an adorable place! The food was really good and the service was exceptional. Definitely looking to go again (which we tried on Monday, but, oh no! Closed Mondays!) 😭

This a great restaurant that serves excellent entree choices, prepared and presented perfectly. Service is five star. We keep returning, because it is one of the best restaurants on the Treasure Coast.

This was my second time eating there, my brother in law and family eat there alot. We were there on a Saturday, we did not make a reservation....the lady at the front fit us in before her 6:00 reservation arrived. I thought it was very nice, they could of just said sorry we r expecting a crowd later. Instead they worked out a space for us.....never seen a restaurant do that....so I would say I had a great experience.

Attended a lunch networking event and the food very good and service was incredibly efficient - keeping time with the actual event program!

Michelina’s has the best of everything & the service is absolutely above & beyond anyone in the whole wide world. The atmosphere is incredible and amazing & ditto ditto ditto to the management and entire staff. I’m NEVER disappointed & looking forward to return asap. My thank you is not enough and my thoughts are everlasting!!🙏👌🍾🍷🎂🎈💗💞💕🥰😝😜👌💗💞💕, Fran Sekela

Love a restaurant that is consistent and Michelina's can always be counted on for great food and great service. My husband likes it so much he ordered 2 entrees for himself on our last visit (lasagna and a fish dish). I had the broccoli rabe with sausage. Hard to tell from the photo, but it's a huge portion and I took half of it home for leftovers. Plus it comes with garlic knots and a salad. It's a ton of food for the $$.

We had the most amazing dinner last night!! Not only was the meal outstanding, but the service was excellent. We have been going to Michelina’s for the past 23 years and have enjoyed every meal, which is made to order. My favorite is their Chicken parm the absolute best on planet!!! Michelina’s is family owned and operated by the most wonderful people on this earth. When you are in the mood for authentic Italian, give Michelina’s a try, I promise you will fall in love with deliciousness, like we did 23 years ago!

This place was amazing, the food was great and the staff is one of a kind. Truly one of the best staff teams I have ever seen. They worked so well together.

this place has the worst food and service I have ever experienced. do not understand the reviews here. the place is a total failure !!!

My family had the most wonderful experience with Michele and Melissa and the entire staff. The food was phenomenal and the service impeccable. We can’t wait to visit again. Thank you.

Atmosphere was great along with delicious food and very good staff. This place is a hidden gem. AAA+

Love this place! Was a first time customer a last week. How have I missed this gem? The food is scrumptious! The wait staff was outstanding and we will definitely be back! If you like mussels in white wine sauce, with pasta, this is the place to have it!!

Love the chicken franchise & the garlic knots, always great service❣️

Michaelinas is a very special place. The food is outstanding, but there is so much more! The people who own and work here make you feel like you are a part of their family. If 5 stars is the highest I can go....I say 6!🌟

First time there and will be back, everything was awesome and staff was the best.

The food and service was simply the best!!!

The best Italian food and service,will be coming back soon. Tammy was very professional.

One of our favorites. Always consistently good.

I went for dinner with a large group on Saturday night. The staff was attentive and friendly. Everyone agreed that dinner was delicious. Bring your appetite. The portions are HUGE! Lasagna was incredible and the strawberry cake the perfect way to end a great dinner. Thank you!

Our group of six visited last night and had a delightful meal. The staff is warm and professional, and they made us feel welcome. The garlic knots to start us off were delicious--they were light and soft and swimming in garlic butter. The Caesar salad was fresh, crisp, and perfectly dressed. Many of our group had the stuffed eggplant special and declared it amazing, and the Penne Michelina was scrumptious--tender chicken, crisp broccoli, and sun-dried tomatoes in a delectable sauce. The portions are large--you won't leave hungry. Ten gold stars! We'll be returning soon!

I've used Michelina's in the past for a Wedding Reception and it was TOP NOTCH - Everything was PERFECT - not a single little thing went wrong.... Fast forward - Michelina's catered a work lunch event the other day - once again THEY DID NOT DISSAPOINT! Everyone loved the food - it arrived exactly on time - the hot food was HOT and the salad was fresh and delicious! Thank you once again!

Amazing service and very friendly people

Felt right at home. Service, food and ambiance was great 👍

2nd time there will be back again soon

Elizabeth was great. Apps Dinner and dessert melted in your mouth. Definitely would go back

This experience was really great. We where attended to from the first minute we walked through the door. The food was so fresh and delicious from the first dinner roll all the way to dessert that we took home after the meal. This restaurant and the silverware was sparkling clean and our server was absolutely perfect. I will definitely be back soon.

Food is absolutely incredible, all the way through from the starters, entrees, to the desserts! A must try for anyone into Italian cuisine! Spread the word & tell all of your friends immediately! 10/10! Lauren & Elizabeth were amazing!

Absolutely amazing! First time Here and can't tell you how good is the food and service is exceptional! We will come back for sure!!!!

Great service, friendly staff and cozy atmosphere. Prices similar to other places nothing out of the ordinary. Calamari was ok. Wouldn’t order again. One pasta dish, the uber amounts of garlic in it was so raw it was like eating a fresh garlic bulb. Pasta was good and cooked al dente. Chicken Parmesan was just ok, sauce was not good, not bad nothing really stood out. Broccoli rabe was so bitter it was not edible. Didn’t complain because all the servers were very nice and friendly. I can’t believe this place is a 4.7 on Google. Maybe the pizza or meatballs make this place not sure. If the review was based on the servers only I would say 4.7 is a realistic score. Just based off the food it’s honestly 3.3 All food came hot. Nothing looked unfresh, it just really didn’t hit the palate at all. For the reviews and menu description, we accepted a lot more and anticipated to be blown away. We didn’t take the leftovers home.

We want to warmly praise the entire staff and management for the “over the top” catered dinner that we had last Saturday. The staff was gracious, warm, and attentive, the food was uniformly excellent, and Michele was continuously attentive to ensure the entire evening was flawless. Most importantly, many attendees told us that it was the best “large event” that they had ever attended. Lastly, the attention to details and always being responsive made the planning process easy. Highly recommend to fellow nonprofits and those looking for event catering.

Busy for dinner on a holiday weekend. Service was attentive, delicious food!

Food was excellent. Service was phenomenal .

Food and service were very good. Sunset specials are excellent value. Decor is stylish.

I could not recommend this place more. My grandmother is Italian, I grew up eating Italian food. This tastes just like I remember and everything was incredible.

We had such a nice dinner, we were celebrating my 40th birthday and the staff (all super friendly) sang and brought out an amazing mouth watering chocolate lasagna with a candle. All of the food was so good. I ordered the penne charlmaine, and loved every bite. I will think about how great the chocolate lasagna was for a very long time. Our sever said it was homemade and you can definitely tell, it was very rich, so I couldn’t eat it all, so I savored it by taking the remaining bit to go, then ate on it for the next couple of days.

Wonderful place to eat food is delicious and everyone is friendly!

We went for dinner last night. There were 5 of us. It was delicious!! The staff is so nice and attentive. I had the ravioli special— the pasta is home made. It’s a bit loud but it was so bad. I saw some desserts come out. They looked amazing! Would for sure recommend!!

Lasagna Alfredo with broccoli 🥦

Amazing food and amazing atmosphere!! Took my girlfriend there for a date night and was very impressed. Our server Nick was very funny and provided great service. We started off with the mussels and they have to be some of the best in town. After our appetizer I had chicken Rollatini and it was definitely my favorite. You can’t find another dish like it. Will definitely be returning. Thank you Michelina’s

Absolutely fantastic dishes. Terrific marina and creative specials. The service is young but well trained and management is very outgoing and gluten free aware.

Horrible, horrible. Please do not go to this restaurant if you want veal parmiggian. Starting going there 7 yrs ago very delicious food. Covid hit them like it hit everyone else in business. Only different is other restaurants didn't cut their portions in half. They charge an extra $4 which is expected. But the veal "honestly" was like a piece of breaded printing paper. 90% batter 10% meat. I brought it home fed it to my dog. Will never go back again. If it wasn't for the Italians from New York this place would go broke. Very unhappy.

Michelina’s catered our wedding. So many of our guests said how it was the best food they’ve had at a wedding. We did action stations with tacos, prime rib, and italian all executed to perfection! They’re service and heart impeccable!

Great food every thing about this place absolutely awesome beautiful I will be coming back soon

Spaghetti & meatballs. Excellent! Plenty of food.

So cozy and delicious! From Stromboli to soup and the best pasta/sauces; you’re going to love this place and the prices!

Delicious dinner and service was the best

Excellent food, Nice atmosphere and reasonable prices.

My new favorite Italian Restaurant, wished I had tried years ago. Best Eggplant Parmesan and my friend loved her Chicken Parmesan too, Great House Salad dressing. Highly Recommend!!

Been awhile since we've been here due to covid. We are so excited to see how well this Restaurant is doing. Staff is extremely professional and treats every customer as tho they're very special to then. Staff is attentive to your every need and handles every concern with such finesse and concern. Food as always remains exceptional.

John on server was excellent. Great service Food was delicious. Wonderful place to enjoy a great meal with friends.

We dined at Michelina’s this evening. It was wonderful! Our server, Jillian (spelling may be incorrect) was a joy. She was both professional and willing to put up with our “playfulness”. The service and food was excellent. Special praise for the young man bussing the table. He was efficient and friendly. Overall, our first visit and we will certainly be back. Don’t miss this place! Loved it!

Nice atmosphere with a very friendly staff. The garlic knots are so tasty. I had the lasagna with Ceasar salad and both were delicious. The homemade pasta really makes the lasagna stand out over others I've had.

Awesome food and great service!!!!!

Best Italian food outside of Italy, hands down. Tammy was an excellent server, and the host was also very accommodating and anticipated our every need. We will be back!

Main course was slow to come out but was extremely busy. Other than that food was excellent and service great. Riley and the rest of the team were great and communicative

Amazing italian cuisine!!! They catered our wedding and we were extremely impressed!! If you live on the treasure coast and are craving italian food.. This is where you need to go!!!

The experience was amazing as was the Chicken Parmesan and the cheese cake. Fantastic food !

Excellent food. Lovely owners and service was excellent. Make a reservation though especially if you are a larger group as it is a bit small. Definitely worth a stop.

Great food and service. If you want real Italian food, this is the place.

Michelinas is my favorite restaurant in the whole world! The food is amazing and the best!! It is so apparent that everyone that works there is a family. Our favorite appetizer is the coconut shrimp and the bruschetta. The penne michelinas is an all time favorite in my family, as well as the seafood trio with the fradiavolo sauce. We also love the manicotti with their homemade pasta sheets. We have not been disappointed in one meal we have tried at Michelinas and we have been going there for years. Don’t even get me started on all of their homemade desserts! We have tried almost every single one and they are our favorite deserts of all time.

I had never been there before, but Michelina's is a huge supporter of Breast Cancer causes and groups, such as Race for the Cure. I went there because my wife, Lezlie Brukwicki, is involved in Race for the Cure. Food was great and service was fantastic. My wife and I have returned several times and have never been disappointed.

Michelina’s is the best place to go for Italian. The staff is amazing and the food is superb. Customer service is excellent. The pasta is homemade and the desserts are to die for. The atmosphere is perfect for small parties to large groups. They put love into everything they do. If you like being treated like family this the place to go. You will not be disappointed.

This is by far the BEST Italian food ever! The owners and staff are all wonderful. They make you feel right at home as if you were one of the family. Please give it a try….you will NOT be disappointed!

We had a fantastic turkey dinner today, Thank you for the wonderful food!

The food was great, but we were also incredibly impressed with the service. Tammy is an outstanding server, and the support staff were friendly and helpful as well. Don't forget to save room for dessert, it's all made in house and it's delicious!

The best food & service, I can't believe I've lived in this area as long as I have & this was our first time here. We'll definitely be back! The baked scampi was amazing, as well as the cappuccino and dessert, which is all made in house. John and the whole staff provided excellent customer service. Wonderful!

Great food. Great service! Excellent environment. We will definitely return.

I would have liked to have the vegetables cooked in my stromboli. The vegetables were still raw.

Lovely ambiance, the food always is perfect!

The homemade Lasagna was amazing, and it hurt to get through!! That good kind of hurt where you KNOW you should have stopped eating about 10 bites earlier but it's so good you can't stop! And the Chocolate Lasagna for dessert *chefs kiss* 100/10 would recommend!!

Fantastic food and great service

Soo loud great food service mediocre. Large party in the smallest room . Better places to eat.

Italian Wedding Soup Linguine with Clam Sauce and Veal Saltimboca simply the best!!! Love it here so much

Love, love, love this place. The food is quite good, the service is good and the atmosphere is relaxing and classy. Don't miss out on the garlic soup and the tiramisu is fabulous.

Excellent costumer service from entrance to exit...and meals like back home...yummy..a favorite..🥂

Known the owners for years. Just had our daughters wedding reception dinner here. It was outstanding.

What a great place. Great management, great staff, and greatest italian food around. Thank you for a great experience.