Muzzarella Pizza & Italian Kitchen-Kissimmee - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I'll start off by saying this, This isn't the first time that we've eaten here.. we ate here in April and thoroughly enjoyed the food. However, fast forward to yesterday when my in laws purchased pizzas for my daughters birthday. They ordered two combination pizzas, one cheese and one pepperoni. When I bit into one of the slices of the combination pizza, there was something hard when I bit down and thought before I checked that it must've been a piece of the sausage.. when I pulled it out of my mouth.. it was a piece of glass. This is very concerning because I have four children that could have swallowed that piece of glass and as a precaution, I have thrown out the rest of my pizza. And as much as I hate to say it, I won't be back after that.

This is a real gem here in Kissimmee! The folks that run this place LOVE what they do. A lovely dining room and a thriving take out business. When you walk in the door the kitchen's aromas are a true delight. A fabulous wine selection! Go and enjoy.

We are so happy we ate here on vacation, it was the best meal we had in Florida, and some of the best marinara I’ve ever had! Highly recommend!

Tried them yesterday for late lunch thru Uber eats delivery. They had bogo meatball sub sandwiches. Everything tasted great and potions were fair for the price. Would definitely order again and want to try some other menu items

Pepperoni Stromboli is very, very good. Highly recommended.

It is eaten super delicious! The service and attention is excellent….

Dude, it's brutal, the food is tasty

If you want to eat something with a spectacular flavor, I recommend you come here. Our experience was unforgettable. I recommend it.

Not sure why the reviews are so high. Its pretty average. Had to knock it down a bit from 4.8.

Was my first time!! I was looking for pasta on my way home and this place came up…. I decided to stop and but the service is horrible. I was greeted but after that I sat for a hour before she came back to take my order and when I got my food very under seasoned and my salmon was over cooked… Their was one person working the register and serving all tables. To add insult I seen her drop and pick up things off the floor without washing nothing or her hands.. so you may have a pepper shaker on your table that hit the floor and put with the rest for the next day… she touch cash drinks and floor without washing her hands.. I will not be going back

Juan was incredible! Service spectacular, absolutely recommend this gem of a restaurant.

Everything was wonderfully delicious, I'll be back.

Food took over an hour to come. Ordered the Chicken Marsala, the pasta and sauce were good but the portion was tiny. Chicken was not edible and ended up throwing it away.

Ordered pizza and chicken parmigiana sandwich delivered through Uber Eats and both were outstanding. The bread from the chicken parm sandwich was soft and delicious. The pizza was not greasy and was delicious. We plan on ordering and/or visiting again.

Very good place, the pizzas are delicious

I have to say this is one of the best Italian Restaurant in the Kissimmee area. Everything tasted so good and fresh. We stared off with the garlic knots and the muzarrella caprese. We then ordered the penne pasta with shrimp, the sauce was to die for, freshly made. We also had the White pizza which was cooked perfectly. I definitely recommend this place.

I hate to be this person we loved the one in lake underhill so decided to try this one out tonight & it totally disappointed us , the pasta tasted burnt , the cheese on the calzone was cold & we waited a little over 45 mins for our food ! Totally wont be back we had high hopes

The place is okay. The food is alright, nothing great or mouthwatering, just regular. I tried the mozzarella sticks, the special pizza and strawberry lemonade (which was watered down, flavorless).

Ate here a couple months back and the bruschetta appetizer and the burrata was really tasty as well as my chicken with pasta dish, but my father-in-law's pasta plate was swimming in oil, and my husband said his lobster pasta tasted like it was store bought and reheated. Our waitress was really kind and attentive, and the place was nicely decorated and clean, but we all left feeling like we would not come back again.

Delicious pizza and rolls. Excellent service.

Very nice and clean place. Great food. Excellent service. Thank you Juan you're the best.

I bought food for my coworkers while we were setting up an event. I forgot to keep the itemized receipt so I could expense it. After some back and forth, Liz was able to help me out and get me a picture of the receipt. Thank you so much Liz!!

Nice place, good food and close to Valencia. I was going to bring my colleagues from next week, but they charged 4% for credit card fee and itemized the fee as “cash discount” on the receipt even though there is no discount. That is not discounted price on the menu, instead its additional credit card fee. I dont like this kind of tricky business. I love the food, but am sad i will Not go back to this place.

Delicious food in a family atmosphere without waiting and a lot of tranquility. Excellent.

Great pizza and garlic rolls! Service was superb as well. Staff were very nice and accommodating, especially since we had 4 little ones with us. Place was very clean and had a cool vibe.

I’m going to start this review by saying this is my first time at this establishment. First impressions are decent the place is in a nice little mall kind of area, looks nice and clean inside. So the place is ran by Hispanics not Italians, customer service fell a little short for me as I was welcomed with a confused look as to why I was there didn’t feel very welcoming but needless to say as I was ordering the friendliness did start to come out. Let’s move on to the food, I ordered a chicken parm sub and a fettuccine Alfredo with chicken The chicken parm sub fell short to my expectations with the under seasoned chicken and lack of sauce but needless to say was satisfied since it’s almost impossible to find a good chicken parm in Kissimmee it was not bad by any means but just didn’t have that pop I was looking for in a chicken parm sandwich Moving on to the pasta, the Alfredo seemed to be 90% cream and little to no cheese, basically inedible as I felt the cream flavor was so strong it ruined the pasta and I was in fear for my toilets life if I continued to eat it, the grilled chicken breast on the other hand was nice, a basic salt and pepper maybe garlic powder taste to it. Total price for pasta and a sandwich was $32 not including tip which is definitely on the pricier side. Overall I think this place could use some improvement in the flavor department and again I’m not upset because I can tell their ingredients are fresh and made to order which is pleasant, I will come back and try some other things on their menu as they left me with some hope in this restaurant.

Really great food. A no nothing location with great service and a wonderful assortment of cooked to order menu; and cooked to perfection!

Pasta was really good but I was served 5 pieces of Ravioli for my plate… Even the waiter was impressed but when I mentioned the amount was extremely low he did not care. We also ordered a steak and it was not good at all… Very dissappointed

This is the restaurant’s “Chicago” deep dish pizza. As someone who is from Chicago this is just pizza with a thick crust.

Everything was so good! Gluten free pizza was one of the best I've tasted! The calzone was so tasty!

I was pleasantly surprised. I walked by the place 100x never noticed it. Found it on google maps because of the reviews. Clean restaurants, fresh food, quick service, affordable prices, and tasty pizza. Highly recommend this hidden gem in BVL.

Very good place to spend time with the family, the owner is very friendly, the girls who serve are very friendly and the pizzas are really good

This place was awesome! The staff was super friendly and fun. They made great recommendations for dinner. We ended up having an Assisi (meat lover style) & Margherita pizza, the Muzzarella Chicken, Chicken Parmigiana, some bruschetta, garlic knots, zeppoles and peanut butter cheesecake. All of the food was amazing! This is definitely somewhere I recommend and would come back to! I wish there were one in Pensacola!

We happened upon this little gem of a restaurant. The atmosphere was charming, staff amazing and the food was so delicious.

Delicious Italian food Everything tastes so good. Also great customer service.

Very little sauce on pizza. Was a great cheesy bread.

Restaurant was lovely. Our appetizers and meals were very delicious. Wonderful experience

Best pizza I’ve had in Kissimmee Orlando. The sauce must be from hi quality plum tomatoes or something like that. Most pizza sauce tastes too cooked down with a bitter bite like tomatoes paste. Crust flavor is excellent as well as how it’s cooked. Hi quality ingredients in clouding plenty of fresh chopped garlic. Sampler was very good. But I’m real picky about my lasagna ricotta ratio. I will not go to any other pizza place ever. The atmosphere and service are excellent!

Delicious food! Loved everything we tried. And the server was very sweet!

Hands down great pizza! Does not disappoint 🙌. Great atmosphere. Will definitely come back! What a gem❤️

Excellent service, delicious food, recommend the spectacular sangria 👌🏽

There should be a line out the door for this place! Food is excellent!! We LOVED the pizza (plain and pepperoni)- some of the best we’ve had and we eat pizza in NJ and NY. We also loved the garlic knots, light and slightly crispy on the outside, not too doughy- perfection! Sauce was delicious. We went back for the pasta and were not disappointed. The fruitti de mare was to die for! Seafood super fresh, pasta homemade delicious, sauce amazing!! Lobster ravioli were yummy too. The bruschetta was made with the same very fresh ingredients and tasted so good. We ate here 3 times in the 5 days we were in FL! We will miss it when we leave. Place was very clean and service wonderful!!! HIGHLY recommend!!

Great service and good is the best Italian experience highly recommended

Delicious authentic Italian food. Loved it.

we ordered pasta for our company Cano Health and it was awesome and delicious I give it a 5 stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

The food is amazing as well is the server I would recommend coming here on a daily basis or for event

Visited on a Monday 2/19/25. Great food delish! Server super nice, perfect place for my family. Pizza cooked to perfection and the Shrimp Scampi tasty. The shrimp plump and not over cooked. This will be our spot.

Outstanding meal. Super cute and friendly. Very reasonably priced. Definitely recommend.

The food was delicious, we ordered vegetable stromboli with chicken and mozzarella pizza (the base is super crunchy) the garlic bread was super soft!!

Delicious food. Great service. Friendly staff. The unique detail was several flies around us. Hopefully you can fix that. Overall it everything was great

Every time I go, it NEVER disappoints. I’ve tried different items from the menu and so far everything is delicious!!

Food is wonderful. Very authentic. They did get several things wrong on our to go order.

This place is a hidden gem in Kissimmee, Florida. Located in a strip center, it is very non assuming. We had the sampler appetizer, baked ziti and seafood pasta. It was all amazing. The house made Sangria is one of the best I’ve ever had. If you are attending an event at Silver Spurs or just in the area, make time to enjoy a meal here. We will be back!

Come here all the time food is delicious but the portion sizes are small. Barely any sauce on pastas and salad dressings. Small pasta portions every time. Nice rustic look inside maybe with a play of some Sinatra or themed music it would feel a bit more cozy. Also frustrated sometimes bc some of the employees speak little or no English so it’s hard to order or ask for things . Parking also is usually an issue here . I think with a few small tweaks, it can easily be a 5 star

Excellent Italian food, good and kind service.

Our waitress was amazing and the food was delicious.

Había estado un par de veces y en general todo había sido 👍🏼. Sin embargo hoy, todo cambió…la pizza ya no era del mismo estilo de las 2 veces anteriores, desmejoró enormemente. Como para completar la noche, el padre de una familia joven se había estacionado en el puesto reservado para personas con dificultades, sin estar autorizado por ley para hacer uso de ese beneficio. Al entrar le pregunté a la Sra. que parecía la manager del restaurante, si conocía al dueño del vehículo en cuestión, me dijo que no, ya que podría ser cliente de otro restaurant que colinda con ese; y el resultado fué que esa familia joven era muy conocida por la susodicha Sra. y el resto de las personas que allí se encontraban. Mientras tanto, mi mamá tuvo que caminar un buen trecho del parking (tiene 88 años) ya que ese desadaptado ni se molestó en disculparse y mover su auto para que pudiese hacer uso de ese puesto ya que mucho fue el esfuerzo por conseguir ese permiso en el tax collector. Quiero hacer énfasis en el hecho de que tanto la manager del restaurante como los empleados conocían al infractor que se estacionó en el puesto indebido. Y si, es verdad que ellos no tienen control sobre esos puestos, pero habiéndole dicho a la manager de manera explícita y taxativa sobre el motivo de mi molestia, y luego ver la manera tan amigable y familiar con la que se despidieron, me dió una enorme molestia e indignación. Y no se preocupe por el tema de la comida en lo que a mí respecta, nunca más volveré

Food was delish, excellent service. If i lived in the area, this would be my go-to joint for pizza/pasta.Gonna return and try the desserts for sure.

Execelente comida y servicio! Volvería y lo recomiendo

This place was quite an experience. At first, it’s decorated very nicely and it makes you want to eat there. The staff is very friendly and helpful and the service is excellent. My favorite however was the food, wow. I was blown away at the presentation and the amazing flavor. The pizza crust is crispy and soft at the same time and the taste was excellent! I will definitely be back with my family. Highly recommend. This place is a must try!

This is a restaurant you have to try!! I have never had anything I didn’t like

Super delicious pizza A+ and their home made Sangria wow the best. Thanks against for the service I defenetly coming back

This is the 2nd location that Muzarella has opened and it’s just as good as the original. The restaurant itself is beautiful. It’s cozy, without feeling crowded. The food was excellent and so was the service. This place still continues to be my absolute favorite of all for amazing food at great prices, combined with excellent service. Try it, you won’t be disappointed!

I show up almost at the time of closing the girls are so nice they prepare my personal chessse 😍😍😍😍pizza really fast excellent service and tea good pizza 🍕 5 plus stars ⭐️ Thank you

Went with a group of Friends for a birthday! We were a party of 8, which sometimes leads to not so great service Not here. The service was amazing and the food was fantastic! Definitely get there if you can- we will next time we are back in town.

In the area for a softball tournament and drive by. It is such a great place. Like a hidden gem! Our kids loved the food and the dessert was over the top. I got the baked ziti and couldn’t stop setting it. Our server was soooo sweet and wonderful with the kids. We are going back today.

Amazing food and great staff. The choices are endless and the presentation of the food is amazing. Definitely a great place for a first date or even to bring the family.

Such a cute spot with amazing food and service, 10 out of 10!!!! Highly recommend!!!

Had dinner here last night with my husband. 1st time. A wonderful little place. Had to wait awhile for the food but it was so worth it! It was hot and delicious. I had the chicken Florentina and my husband had the trio. The sangria was excellent. Will definitely be on our top list.

Came over for lunch with my fiancé to try a new spot out. We had the muzza fries and cheese pizza. It was so good! The waiter was so nice and friendly and the food came it really quick. Definitely coming back!

Food was really good. Garlic knots were tasty. The Muzza Fries were crispy and super flavorful. Their pizza was good! Stack some of the Muzza Fries on their pizza and prepare your taste buds for a trip. Definitely going there again.

Excelente Comida y servicio. La atención de nuestra mesera Elizabeth fue excelente y muy amable y atenta.

Best mom in pops place in Kissimmee, Great Ambiance. SANGRIA! Everybody in the restaurant, I swear everyone had one in their hand. There wasn't anything we ate that we didn't absolutely love.

5 star pizza Amazing crust tasty sauce and quality cheese new pizza place acquired!

Great food. Sangria was delicious!

Una asmofera bien acojedora. La comida delicious ordene chicken Alfredo y le doy 100.

Everything we ate here was absolutely amazing. The service was incredible as well. Will definitely be back.

Cenamos allí a comienzos del mes de octubre. Ambiente acogedor y familiar. El sabor de las pastas muy rico, los knock con ajo esponjosos y frescos, la pizza sabrosa e igual el calzón. Salón limpio, empleados muy amables. Muchas bendiciones y éxitos.

Cute little gem! The lobster bisque was rich and delicious! I highly recommend the Barata as well as the Fettuccine Carbonara! Great drinks too! The sangria was an absolute hit with my family! Kind staff, clean environment, great atmosphere!

Muy buen lugar, meseras amables y cómida buena

Incredible! Probably the best eggplant parmigiana and Alfredo I’ve ever had. It was so good I forgot to take picture but here’s one of my leftovers.

Great food and great prices too!

Food was really really good. Highly recommend

Very nice place to eat. The pizza was very delicious and the service was great. The only thing I didn't like but it more me, that the tiramisu desert was delicious but to small. I wanted more. Sorry.

Best customer service. Amazing food, where every bite would transport you to Italy. A real New York italian cuisine with a Latino touch. My whole family were so happy and please of this experience.

This place has it all! The food is superb the staff is super attentive and the location is really cute! You must try the house sangria it was delish! The portions are great both appetizers and main dishes. The best part is they have carry out so you can enjoy the flavors at home! Let’s not forget, dessert! Yum! Best cannolis I’ve had in a long time fresh and crisp!

Muzzarella Pizza and Italian Kitchen came to the rescue for our office lunch today, and it was an absolute delight! The service and attentiveness provided by Jani was prompt, and the food was nothing short of fantastic. We ordered a variety of Italian dishes, from Margherita pizza to Chicken Parm, wings and every bite just hit the right spot. What truly impressed us, besides the delicious food, was the attention to detail in packaging - everything arrived hot and in perfect condition. The portion sizes were generous, ensuring everyone was satisfied. Thank you, Muzzarella, for delivering such delicious Italian food right to our office. You've earned a special place in our hearts and our go-to choice for Italian cuisine. We'll definitely be ordering from you again!!