Paper Fig Kitchen in Sanibel - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

This place is a must-do if you’re looking for some easy and delicious meals for your condo or a picnic. They have really delicious sandwiches, soups, small desserts like giant brownies, cookies, and lemon bars as well as take and heat frozen and fresh case foods. We tried various things on multiple visits - seafood bisque, chicken salad, potato salad, potato puffs, lemon bars, and the Brit Brit club sandwich. For drinks we had the iced tea, which was fresh and delicious both times, and iced coffees, which were also perfection. It was all so good and reheated very well. I could easily eat there every day. The fresh case offerings rotate, and Tuesday is the day they stock up/change over, so be sure to check their website/socials to see what they will have.

As the only vegetarian in my extended family sometimes it's hard to travel with them. Tonight when dinner was served there was nothing for me to eat. When I got to the Paperfig they had just closed but the owner let me purchase some dinner. Their food is amazing. I had the orzo salad and the berry salad. I will be coming to them again everytime I'm on the island.

This is a take out place with food that you can heat and eat at home. The sandwiches were very refreshing for the HOT Florida weather. The salads were fresh, light and refreshing. There are 3 little tables outside the restaurant for customers to enjoy food.

Lovely little walk-in, walk-out diner. Healthy options, coffee bar. Worth a stop!

Update July 1, 2022: Paper Fig has been hands-down the #1 spot we look forward to visiting while on island. The sides are “meh,” BUT the Mother Clucker is an incredible sandwich! I would recommend it to everybody we would talk to. In fact, we sent a couple there the other day. Although they said it was “fabulous,” they commented that “the chicken to bread ratio is off.” Today, we stopped in and I can’t agree more. The price has gone up (to $17 for the Mother Clucker) and the amount of chicken in the sandwich has substantially decreased. We ordered several…and they were all the same - lacking a substantial amount of chicken. While the sandwich is good, I just don’t believe it warrants an $17 price tag! While the Paper Fig used to be a favorite spot, I don’t see us returning anytime soon.

Very flavorful sandwiches! Small seating area outside and friendly staff.

Best place on island for fresh food! Great coffee. And the hot tattooed chef ain't bad to look at.

Fantastic lunch. Elote was especially tasty

The pie was very good. I thought I could get lunch there as well. Hard to tell what they have on the menu. Very small counter area. Lady in front of me was ordered a wide variety of fresh fish etc to go.

This place is top notch. The food and service is the the best in comparison to most places on Sanibel.

Had an awesome Korean beef taco today for lunch. The tea was great…so wanted a refill. The brownie was a good ending too. The box and silverware the lunch came in we’re done nicely and tastefully. Like having a super good picnic on the table outside the restaurant. The food was so fresh and delicious. Highly recommend.

Our office ordered lunch today & we tried here. It was pretty good & I enjoyed it.

Food was healthy and delicious.

Deb and Jeremy handled all of our wedding weekend catering and just absolutely blew us away. The food was amazing, the staff was incredible, the planning process was easy and fun – it was all perfect. All of our family and friends still say that our wedding was one the of the best they've been to, and I think that largely due to how excellent the food and service was. 15/10 would recommend! Can't wait to stop by Sanibel again soon and pick up some food from their storefront, too! The tastiest!

Never usually write reviews about restaurants but I cant help but commend paper figs awesome service and food. My family moved to Sanibel last year and this is my go to sandwich/lunch spot on the island every time I visit; food is always consistently delicious and the service is great. Cant say enough good things about this place!

Outstanding chicken salad wrap.

Best place on Sanibel. This place is amazing. We got our last meal here (grab and go) and ordered a few different sandwiches, sides, and dessert and this place is a gem. The Britt Britt sandwich and the D.Y sandwich are amazing. Everything is fresh and made with love. Highly recommend!

We have been coming to Sanibel for 26 years this is a fantastic much needed addition. The grab and go concept paired with excellent food is 🙌🏼. The selections are great and lots of gf options as well. I had the Autumn salad with chicken and it was enormous- ended up only eating half and saving the rest for dinner. Husband had the Britt Britt sandwich and raved about it. Thick carved Turkey and well worth the $.

Great place for lunch, we come here every day when we are in Sanibel. It’s so good, we have even considered making the 2 1/2 hour drive from where we live on the east coast of FL just for lunch! Great sandwiches. Hard to decide which is best, but try the Britt Britt turkey, Frying Nemo Grouper and Southern Comfort Chicken for sure. Very good service. Only wish they were open for dinner!

Absolutely amazing food! I would eat here for lunch every day if I could.

Same owner as 400 Rabbits and let me tell you...they know a thing or two about delicious food! Most of the food on the island isn't very good, and way overpriced. Tourist traps. But this place is PHENOMENAL (Korean beef tacos, my goodness!) and they have a some amazing gluten free options! For delicious food on the island stop at Paper Fig, 400 Rabbits, and Cielo. You won't be disappointed!

Yesterday, we stopped to look for a place to make sandwiches for lunch on the beach. We usually get Publix subs but on this day we were unsure what we wanted to do. At the last minute, we pulled into the first strip mall we found on the way to the beach and discovered this store. Overly impressed by the selection and display of homemade foods. They made our food in quick time and packaged it in individual lunch boxes with care. The sandwiches were outstanding and would whole heartedly recommend getting lunch or dinner there. There are tables outside to eat. We are definitely coming back for our next visit.

Best sandwich of my life (southern comfort sammie)!! Highly recommend coming at the beginning of your trip because you’ll want to come more than once. Amazing service and amazing food!

Wow, just dug in to the Mexican street corn. Best we’ve ever had. Absolutely delicious! As a gluten free family, it’s so tricky to find places to eat as we travel. But you’ve earned our repeat business. So glad we found you! Thank you for being so wonderfully kind, too. Wishing your business all the best (and much-deserved) success!

I can't stop eating here! It's a small, efficient, deli with done of the most amazing sandwiches I've ever had (try the Britt Britt!). Always friendly, and served in recyclable/compostable containers :)

Delicious high quality food!! & great staff

A neighbor dropped some food off from Paper Fig when my father was in the hospital. Every single dish was delicious. The quiche was incredible, as were the salads, and I can’t believe I’m saying that about a salad. I’m looking forward to trying the rest of the menu. Great work!

We stopped in the Paper Fig to get something to take to the beach to eat. I looked at the menu but was unsure because of some of the ingredients their sandwiches contained. I usually don't like things that contain more than the basic condiments. Everyone in the place was very friendly & helpful.My wife & I decided to get the BRIT BRIT CLUB along with the cucumber & red onion salad. We also got a slice of Key Lime Pie for dessert. We went to the beach and had our lunch there. I must say the flavors of the BRIT BRIT CLUB were amazing! One of the best we have ever had. Then there was the Key Lime Pie. Words cannot explain just how delicious it was! I called them to reserve 2 more slices on our way back to Cape Coral. We got stuck in traffic that was not moving, so we found a parking lot we could park in and walked a ways so we could get the 2 pieces of Key Lime pie we ordered before they closed. Once we had dinner that evening, we enjoyed our Key Lime Pie which made for a perfect evening. If you want Key Lime Pie this is the place to go. Their sandwiches are great too, but the Key Lime Pie is out of this world. Keep up the great work everyone!! We will be back to see you again!!

5 for the Korean Tacos!!! They were delicious!!! 4/5 for the other things we tried. My mom got the veggie Greek burger- needs more flavor, and grilled cheese was okay. 5/5 for the taco though :) And the monster cookie is DELISH. Great service too :)

Food is amazing! Our favorite place on Sanibel. Great fresh case selection, and freezer section for dinners you can take home with cooking instructions, because who wants to cook on vacation?!

We stopped by this great little spot on our way to the J.N. Ding Darling Wildlife Refuge to grab some of the grab and go items for a picnic. The counter service was excellent and the food was delicious - we enjoyed the tuna salad, chicken salad, orzo mediterranean pasta (to die for!) and potato salad sides. I would highly recommend this place!

We had wonderful friends treat us to a meal it was wonderful came ready to heat & eat!!