Pettinari's Deli, Pizza & Meats - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Very good pizza and subs. Fresh meats, including ground beef, are very good quality. Fresh poultry, pork, and steaks of all kinds are available. Fresh sausage made in-store. Son and his wife took over from his father Dom some time ago. He made many upgrades. We are lucky to have this store here in Hilton. The owner provides very good customer service. You can still see Dom around helping out. Highly recommended!

Stopped in for slice of pizza as the outside had "pizza wings". Walked in and was amazed at the delivery counter and the prices were fair. Nice little gem and customer service was amazing. Will definitely be come for lunch often. Pizza was chew and delicious much love was put into the pizza and ingredients

Friendly family business with good prices and great quality. A Porterhouse steak is by definition a Porterhouse.

Love local businesses and it's such good quality.

5/23/24. Well this is an absolute shame. I have been coming here since Dom opened years ago. Ordered a small sandwich which I have purchased countless times. This picture says it all. 4 thin pieces of deli meat. This used to be a great sandwich!.

Such a great store! Their Sandwiches, salads, and pizza are all top notch. Great selection in their coolers and freezers. The meat counter always has something tasty in it. If you don't live nearby, bring a cooler because there will definitely be something you'll want to bring home.

Best meat in the Rochester area.

This is the best place to get meat and subs

My buddy requested I get some meat for the grill. I live in Florida, but used to frequent Pettinari's when I lived in area. I ended up here. This place is the bomb. The prices are good and the fresh meat was superb.

We love this place. Great family run business. Meat counter has great selection. Known for large varieties of sausages made in store. Variety of items in freezer cases. Never know what you'll come home with. Enjoy going there. Typically, beer specials or other beverages. Great selection for a small store. We have never gotten food to go, only food items to cook at home. Frozen perogies are very good in several varieties.

Meat is super fresh, Deli is clean, and the staff are inviting. Prices are great as well. Pettinari's also supports local fire departments in the area and assists with raffles. It's a great business to support.

Every time I come in service is amazing food is awesome especially the sausage 100% even the steaks perfect. Everything else in general awesome!

Great seafood boudin sausage. This is a creole spicy sausage with rice in it. Tasted just like Louisiana

Friendly staff, fair prices, Great choice of steaks, chops, chicken and sausages.

It's all about the meat here, home made meat sauce for them garbage plates is prime. Best west side cheese steak subs and the unique selection of sausages is amazing here. From mild & hot to Josh Allen, jalapeno, & french toast breakfast sausage it's all so good.

I'm from down south where some of the best BBQ pops up in unlikely places and this reminds me of that except I get the plate and it's always plenty for the money. Folks in person have always been pleasant. The interior could use some sprucing but I like it as is which is old delicatessen style but I'm biased.

Great food! Very friendly staff! Love this place.

What a surprise! I had no idea this adorable little shop was here . I don't eat meat but if you're looking for a deli / butcher this is definitely the place to go. Great fresh variety and good prices.

Family owned, wonderful staff, were I get all my meat and deli items, prepared food is phenomenal.. 5 stars plus

Fantastic italian market! Why get your meat at a chain market, when this locally and family-owned deli has very high-quality meats and great deli food. Bought beef filet last week, and it was sooo good!

Ordered 4 filet mignons for a special dinner celebration. Our steaks were amazing! Highly recommended! If you haven't been there - make the trip. You'll not be disappointed.

Best steak bomber around plus really good meat cuts.

Grew up eating here and loved it. I happened to be in the area so I made sure to stop. Kitchen was closed on Sunday, ordered a cold sub and went back home. They never put any cold cuts on my sandwich just lettuce, tomato, onion. I called them and was told there is nothing they can do unless I drove back out there (an hour away). Then they said they'd follow up Monday when a manager was on duty. Never heard back. Super disappointed with how the place has changed over the years. Such a bummer

We now buy all our meat products from here,and frequently buy prepared foods also

Best subs around!! They also have the best homemade sausage and the steaks are fabulous!

Had some great subs from there a few weeks back. And can't wait to go back.

I love this place. They have the best Italian sausage around

I'm there 3 times a week...Best sausage, great ribeyes too..

Great quality meats ! Get a sub ! You won’t be disappointed. Amazing!

Great quality food & amazing people ! The atmosphere was great & everyone was so friendly. They were quick , clean , and fulfilled a big order for us in a timely mannerx

Pizza 🍕 and subs are good I wouldn't say the best but not the worse. They have awesome meats and all sorts of good stuff in the coolers

Ya never know what tasty treat yur going to find here. They pack alot into a little place

Great Place, Run By Amazing People !!! Fresh Product and always Great Prices. It's very nice that they carry local vendors, smaller , hard to find products. Joey and his staff are Awesome !!!!!!!

One stop shop for all your meat and deli items. They make some of the best tuna subs I’ve ever had.

Great homemade sausage and excellent strop steaks!

Fresh cut meats are very fresh, Supreme cuts with little fat, great prices.

A hidden gem in Hilton, NY. Excellent deli. One of the best subs I've ever had. The staff was excellent. Will definitely go back. Top Notch.

Best meat and foods hands down.

Steak bomber with provolone, mushrooms, pep and onions- our fave. My husband and I share it. Call order well ahead, they get busy and sometimes wait time can be longer than I'd like. Italian sausage is very good.

They have the most respectful workers ever! I feel so appreciated and cared as a customer!! The worker named Paul is so caring and patient. Loved it!

This place is family owned and awesome ...I love the homemade sausages ...they make great subs ...good prices and great people..

Top rate place to purchase all of your meat needs

We bought fresh meat from the butcher counter. The steaks were very good and reasonably priced. I got a couple of hot Italian sausages, and they were the best I have had in many years.

The meat market has fresh high quality selections. Plenty of options are available in the freezer section. Take Out is ready when they say it will be. Great candy rack.

Do not go there. Their sausage is awful... Totally kidding. That's me trying to keep the lines down. The sausage is absolutely amazing. They make it all there. .

Best meat around, great boarshead cold cuts

Great meat case. Unique and delicious sausage flavors. Good meat prices. Super friendly staff, owners are awesome! Fish fries are delicious too!

Lovely local place with great people. The meat is amazing and priced very fair. (cheaper than wegmans and tops and better quality!)

Wish they would advertise more offen hate driving 20 miles to find out they don't have what I want but everything there is excellent and prices are great picked up beer brats today and Mancini

Love this place got a great sub after golfing service was great and I was just happy to be there

Food was great are very pleasant people

If you are looking for a variety of homemade sausages, look no further! The owners take great pride in the product they turn out. The customer service is great and don’t forget they have a variety of local products as well as some national products they sell throughout the store. Be sure to follow their Facebook page for updates on what variety of sausage is being served that day, if it’s not updated, give them a quick call!!

Fantastic service friendly environment fresh top end food and always great prices. Love this place and will continue to visit as much as possible.

Love that they are family owned. Their meat, chicken and deli is awesome. Their food is excellent as well. They have a nice selection of beer and drinks in their fridge. They are always adding new products and everything is a hit. The staff is very helpful and friendly.

I was recommended to check this place out by someone calling themselves a foodie. I hate the term, but I like food and it is clear this person does as well, because they were 100% right! Awesome selection of meat, at affordable prices. All your favorites in the cooler: filet mignon, strip steaks, bone-on pork chops, poultry, etc. And the frozen selection had favorites such as rack of lamb, mahi mahi, duck, etc. I was advised to check out their sausages, as they are creative and unique. I haven't dug in, but I'm pumped for the Maple Blueberry Breakfast Sausages! It was lunch time so I ended up getting a small deli sub which was on a hard roll and was the perfect size for a quick, filling, but not overwhelming lunch. Medium, would be a nice dinner portion, and large would be a gut buster or 1.5 to 2 meals. Check this place out! Not only is the meat selection fantastic, but a good deal of it is sourced locally. And don't forget to stock up on beer, they had all the favorites like mass market pilsners and lagers to the national and local IPAs, DIPAs, sours, etc. This place is worth the trip regardless of whether its close to you or not. Visit and review, so others can find this place and keep it doing its thing.

We have been going here since we moved to Hilton about 7 years ago and it just gets better every day. They have good food with good prices. It's what a small town deli should be. Great beer selection if you are thirsty too. Lots of craft beers to supplement the usuals. Also, they have these great specials on different things like off flavor seltzers to try.

They were very busy. Food was good. Will go bad

Excellent pizza glad you are doing grub hub I will be a regular.

Very nice place, good selection of everything, good service give them a try

Always friendly staff. Quick and easy service.

Amazing local stop. Best butchers in town. Always supporting local businesses!

I had been told about this deli by a friend who lives in the area. So we decided to check it out.. I was surprised that ìt was a gas station too. To me inside looked like the usual Italian deli. I stood there while a customer before me was being taken care of. I noted that she must be a regular since they were calling her by first name. When she was done I was just standing there waiting for service. There were at least 4 employees. It just seemed like a long while before someone acknowledged me. So service was slow. Finally a young man asked me if he could help me. He was friendly. I gave him my order for meats and cold cuts. It took a while so I looked around the store. They had everything from bread, milk, eggs, and cheese to seafood. My order came too $88.00 which I rounded up to donate for a local family to adopt a Ukrainian child. My husband got a hot roast beef sub while he waited for me. When we got home we very much enjoyed the sub. It was delicious. The next day I cooked the porterhouse steaks and they were absolutely the best. The cold cuts taste fresh and delicious too. I will definitely be going back.

Favorite meat market ever. Moved to hamlin recently the land of nothingness. Just a short drive here to get the best meat ,subs, and pretty dang good pizza too. *update. Been going for 2 years. Would still leave same review.

Great cuts of meat that wont break your bank account!

Great food to go along with an amazing selection of meats,and cold cuts.

Our dental office ordered lunch for a training meeting we were having. It was SO good! Delivered on time, soup was so delicious and piping hot. Wraps, subs and salads were amazing. So glad we ordered from you guys and you were able to accommodate our group! Thank you!!

This place is just the best ever food is amazing staff is beyond friendly can’t recommend them enough.

I would drive 45 minutes to get my meat cuts, subs, pizza & other goodies here, but luckily I only live 6 minutes away 🤣🤣

Bought prime rib was the best ever.

We have been customers for many years. We love all the new products especially their sausages and steaksl. Owners are super friendly and helpful. We also are almost weekly buyers of their delicious pizza.

Great selection of meats and fish!

Great place to buy steaks. Good subs also.

If you dont love there food you have no taste budd

Holy cannoli, how did we just learn about Pettinari's! Deli meat was so competitively priced! Pre made ready to cook stuffed pork chops, stuffed chicken breast and meatloaf made this week's dinners so easy and incredibly delicious!

L9ve this place! Owner is so kind and very helpful! Is a family traditions store just like little Italy 🇮🇹 😍 ❤

Always quality food and products!

I have to say the owner is a great person and stands behind his products! They have great homemade sausage and other meats. My favorite is that they now carry Cheesy Eddie's cheesecake. I highly recommend them.

Great meat..Salads too..and I'm picky af..

Absolute best eggplant parm sub I ever had, great prices on their fresh cut meats Went in for a bag of ice, left with much more Very nice employees too

Such a cool little store/butcher/deli/gas station. Def glad I stumbled onto it, they had some cool random throwback "penny candy's" and the meat cases looks absolutely fresh and stocked well. Kind of in the middle of no where so was def surprised. Def will be back when I am through that way.

Really happy with the customer service and all the options! Great steaks and large selection of deli items!

Can't wait to try the sausage I bought service was awesome I'll be back for sure

Great selection of meat, fresh Italian Sausage, many local items. Good craft beer selection.

Great meat case and subs. Nice selection of gourmet local brands.

Been here a few times since they remodelded and im impressed. They have a great meat selection with all kinds of different sausage combinations. They also sell everything else that you associate with a convenient store. Definitely worth checking out for your next bbq!

Awesome local business. Amazing specialty sausage made in house that change frequently. Carry many other local favorites

20 minute drive or more from my home but great selection of meat and chicken they always have different stuffed chicken and a lot of different sausage flavors I like it on the hotter side so I always like the jalapeno and cheddar and the habanero and cheddar now all we need is some ghost pepper well worth the trip

Excellent service and amazing sausage, try the mancini

Bought Steaks, Italian sausage, Chicken,Pork Chops and Subs very good awesome people!!!

Itialian sausage is to die for. Amazing meat market

Our ITALIAN ASSORTED subs were the best we have had in years. First time there and many more visits to come.

Great deli for all kinds of meats

If you are looking for fresh, local meat, Pettinari's is the place to go. Everything is fresh, and the prices are very reasonable. I ordered a pond of chicken wings, just the flats. When I cooked them in my air fryer, they turned out amazing, and they did not shrink at all. Well worth the money!!

Best little store in Monroe County

Best place ever! Wonderful fresh meats, amazing food and so many locally made products! Our favorite place to eat and the owners are the sweetest people! So thankful to have a place like this local!

That local family owned deli that is a favorite place to go!

Very nice people. Exceptional sandwiches available, Philly steak to die for. Massive meat case with all kinds of cuts and sausages. A very worthwhile stop.

Bought fresh meat and so far everything is great. The quality is good and priced similar to a Grocery store. Was very busy on a Saturday afternoon. Will try more items next visit.

There is no better place to get sausage.

This is absolutely the best meat market. Extremely delicious food, homemade sausage.....Hawaiian punch is the best kind!! Very friendly owners and staff. Definitely try this place out! I guarantee you will come back!!