Bronx House Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Love the Butcher pizza it was delicious

Cute New York vibe with amazing Detroit pizza. Must try ☺️

Wonderful service! Great tasting pizza.

Very delicious. Will be back again!

Highly recommend! The best pizza I’ve ever had 😃🎉🤩⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🇺🇸

Quick and friendly service. Food was delicious

great food & customer service decorated beautifully

Pizza is delicious 😋, pasta dishes are too. My only complaint is they need some more pasta dishes. Keep up the great work guys and get us some more options on the menu😜😊

WOW!!!! The best delivered pizza my wife and I have had in 2 years of living in lake mary! Unbelievable quality! Pizza delivery arrived fresh, warm and with a kind delivery driver! I tried the beast of burden pizza and my wife tried the nonna meatballs! You can taste the love in the food! Unmatched quality! We will be ordering much more and again! Thank you so much!!! Can't wait until next time!!!!! Highly recommend!!!!

We loved the Nuts and Bolts Pizza!!! Service was amazing! :) my new favorite pizza!

The place is very good and there is very good service

first of all, let me start off by saying this pizza is absolutely DELICIOUS. we just had cheese, but omg it’s so good. i wish i had ordered 2 boxes lol. the only thing i would say is that i wish the server had been friendlier. it seemed like she was completely annoyed by my family (young children) even tho i tried as hard to keep them entertained and quiet. she was also arguing with the cook so maybe she was just having a bad day :/ im a server so i understand the frustrations of the restaurant industry and having to clean up the mess of children. the pizza was so good though, i would still order from here but avoid dining in 😬

Food is good portion size Service is prompt Atmosphere very New York!

An authentic New York style pizzeria in Lake Mary, Florida!! A great find that we are happy to have made. Great team, awesome pizza, and feel good environment. Recommended!!

The food is great! Atmosphere is wonderful! Will definitely return!

Spaghetti and meatballs was huge, Hot 97 pizza was good with just the right amount of spice and atmosphere was good. It was freezing in the restaurant though!

Great Detroit style deep dish pizza. Crispy crust and good marinara. Loved the Fat Paulie sub too. It wa huge! 2 meals in one!

Highly recommend this cool neighborhood gem!

The garlic knots were awesome and the Detroit Pizza was very tasty & filling!

Highly recommended and they were right! We had eggplant Parmesan and it was amazing!! We also had a garden salad with their homemade balsamic and creamy Italian and they were both great! We are from NY but currently live in Florida and this was the only place that lives up to true Italian food. Eggplant melted in your mouth and the sauce was wonderful. Daniella waited on us and what a pleasure she was. Happy Birthday!

Many claim to be but this is truly New York style pizza! Great food and great service.

We ate here for the first time. We ordered the Detroit style pizza not knowing what it was. It came out in a rectangle with sauce on top that was steaming hot. It was the best pizza I’ve ever had. It’s crispy and cheesy and full of sauce. The service was great. I would recommend this restaurant!

The garlic knots are amazing and swimming in butter. server was nice and took care of everything we asked for. great italian place to eat in lake mary.

Today, I ordered the cheese pizza again with extra cheese. Delicious. I also ordered the lasagna balls, omg! The best I've had. I'm from Brooklyn, and I have many Italian friends. These things are addictive, the sauce(gravy) beyond my expectations. Thank you

Great place and the garlic knots are amazing

1st time here, so I grabbed a couple of slices for lunch. One pepperoni and one meat lovers. Came out to just under $9.00, which isn't bad considering how big these were. The crust was New York style, thin crust, just like they advertise. The sauce has great flavor without overpowering everything else. The cheese was plentiful and mild but complemented the rest of the slice. Toppings were plentiful enough to get a taste in every bite. I should have taken pictures, but I was too hungry and they smelled too good. I'd like to try some of their more traditional Italian dishes. Their togo menu only shows full portions, I don't know if they have a lunch special, but I'll be there soon!

This is our second time here and everything is great. The garlic knots and fried lasagna were great apps and honestly all the pizza is really good NY Style pie. 10/10

I usually enjoyed my experience here but this will be my last visit! I ordered half cheese and half with some veggies. I’m Muslim and I cover my hair. There was a piece of bacon on the pizza hidden under the veggies! They should wipe down their stations after doing anything with meat. Some people have allergens or don’t eat certain meat products due to religious reasons. This says a lot about their cleaning habits here as well. If you’re Muslim don’t go here! They may try to sneak pork into your food.

The best pizza in Orlando compared only to the delicious pizzas in New York. The flavor and attention are magnificent. It really is like going to Italy.

Best NY style pizza in Lake Mary. Attentive service and great food. We had a large build your own pizza as well as the house lasagna and it all came out amazing.

Good food, fast service, and friendly staff. I ordered the lasagna and it was pretty good.

Service was great…took us a while to decide based off how great everything sounded! By far some of the best pizza we have ever had….the sauce was 10/10…ricotta and sausage were amazing and the crust was perfect….will absolutely be going back!

I only had a slice to go. Just passing through the area. Good enough to make me want to leave a review. Perfect crust, crispy and firm, yet pliable and chewy. Good amount of sauce, cheese and topping, but not at all greasy or messy. Will be going back for sure

This restaurant has been my new to-go Italian restaurant. Excellent delicious food and service.

Bronx pizza was a “let’s get pizza real fast” place that I found. Now I am going to come here a lot more. Amazing service. Quick and great food. The calzone is HUGE!

Great customer service, loved the atmosphere

Great food. Happy atmosphere :)

The meatball garlic knot sliders were delicious! I got a calzone too and it was very big.

I loved the garlic knot sliders, and the calzones were also terrific.

Bronx house is the best!!! Go grab a slice and prepare to have your mind blown.

Quick/great customer service, menu knowledge, and great food!

Here from out of town, service was on point

This place is absolutely amazing! It’s a must try.

I visited from out of town, great staff, and service! The food was delicious and it was the perfect way to unwind after several very busy work days!

Attention people who are used to pie up north....order from here now! I asked for a well done NYC fold through uber eats and it was the closest thing we've had since Brooklyn. Thanks to the awesome staff for making this delivery customer have a taste of home!

Fast service, food is good, and the place looks clean.

Grandma’s pizza was 🔥🔥🔥🔥!!! Service was great.

Wow! What a great find! The portions were large and the food delicious! I had the baked ziti which I highly recommend. The service was friendly and we got our food fast.

If you want something different and great quality, come to this place. I recommend the Haymaker pizza. Detroit pizza.

The best garlic knots I’ve ever had. Pizza is amazing too. I love the big al

Absolutely amazing pizza and atmosphere

Delicious food, great wine, and a great atmosphere! We usually get delivery, but every once in a while we enjoy dining in!

Service fantastic ! And the pizza was amazing !!

I want to be sure to say the Detroit pizza we ordered was great - however we were there after Trump was hit by a bullet - we went in to eat and they had 3 TVs on and none on local or national news - since we had only heard via text what happened we asked if a channel could be put on local or national news - our server asked and one tv was turned to spectrum- we could see what spectrum was saying but sadly about 5 min b4 we left one of the cooks turned the channel to the AFC fight - very very inappropriate imo - he was giggling behind the counter in the kitchen - won’t eat there again out of principle. He was bald heavy and was wearing a black hat - very disappointing

Bronx House Pizza is a fantastic spot that brings back memories of classic New York pizzerias. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making you feel right at home. Their BH Garlic Knots are a must-try, perfectly golden and drenched in garlic butter—just like the ones from childhood. The Haymaker Pizza, with its hearty toppings and crispy crust, is a standout that keeps you coming back for more. It's a place that captures the essence of Bronx-style pizza in every bite.

Awesome awesome awesome. Everything was great. Love it and will be back on a regular basis!!!!!!!!

Afyer reading the reviews we. ordered a thin crust pepperoni and extra cheese pizza and asked that it be crispu, but not burnt. It was floppy. The crust looked like it was evenly browned, not under cooked or anything. Not sure if maybe the oven temperature should be adjusted. It also needed more flavor, maybe some oregano

Very good service with a smile and excellent New York style pizza.

If you’re looking for a pizza place with LOTS of yummy options this is the place! But I warn you….come hungry! The portions are huge. We ordered a calzone, chicken parm, kids cheese pizza, and chicken fingers and fries. Everything was delicious! Definitely will be back!

Cannot say enough about Bronx House! So delicious and fresh! The GF pizza is the best I have ever had and service was amazing. Will definitely be visiting again soon.

I’ve been here many times and keep coming back. Best pizza in Lake Mary.

This was my first visit, so I ordered just a cheese pizza. There's no better way to test the meat and potatoes of a pizza than to order simply cheese. I was underwhelmed by the product. The crust was tolerable. The sauce needed more zest. The cheese was the best part, but they weren't very generous with it. Overall, the value was on the poor side. The service and atmosphere were good. My expectations going in were high because my experience with other New York Style Pizzerias was generally very good. I would not dissuade anyone from visiting this place, but I wouldn't recommend it either.

They forgot to put in my order.

2nd Time here, seated immediately, server was at the table in just a couple of minutes. Super pleasant and friendly. The pizza is always awesome and service is outstanding. Not a frequent flyer but when we want a good pizza with good service we come to Bronx!

This is not only our second time here but we also have ordered take out. The pizza is amazing and so is the appetizers. We love this pizza place! Service is also excellent!

The vibes: immaculate. The ingredients: better than Papa John’s (all locally sourced). The Pizza: One bite everyone knows the rules 10/10. The crust: You know what’s good daddy.

Best pizza in town! Great service, clean dining room and kitchen.

Very charming place and a delicious pizza!!

Had a great 1st visit here on 6/28/24; everything was excellent, especially the Red Top “Detroit-style” pizza. I really enjoyed it! Seemed to be very authentic, especially with the sauce atop the cheese. The crust/pizza was light and not greasy, which was a plus. Got a free cannoli, too, for writing this review! The employees are very friendly and helpful. Hope to be back again in a few weeks to try another menu item or two. Recommended!

Every visit is great food and great service. Today my daughter and I shared the meatballs, mild wings, and three specialty slices. The food was amazing. The servers work together so well. Overall great place to visit. Prices are good.

By far the best pizza in the state of Florida and I am from nyc where good pizza is everywhere. The food at Bronx house is incredible i literally drove 60 miles once a week to visit their place. Nothing even comes close!!!!!!

We ordered the knots and Calzone. There were 8 knots on the plate. The knots themselves were nice sized but.... only came with one small dish of pizza sauce. Extra sauce is $1. The knots were swimming in what looked like butter. My opinion, which I know the restaurant chain could care less about, is the knots would have been much better and tastier had they been in olive oil. The Calzone had plenty of cheese and other ingredients, but the crust was some kind of tough. It took the steak knives to cut it. No way the butter knives would cut the crust. When the very sweet server asked how we liked it and we told her about the crust on the Calzone she immediately said she would take it off the bill. That was a nice gesture they didn't have to do and we didn't ask for it, but we didn't refuse. All in all we can't say we loved it. We scanned the pizza menu before ordering, but no way 2 people could eat one as large as they were and we didn't see more than one size offered, other than make your our personal pizza. At $3 a pop for eat meat topping and $2 each for each veggie it would have cost more than the large ones ($24 & $25) with just a couple different toppings. We didn't realize the Bronx was a chain until our server told us. Maybe there's something else on the menu we'd like better?

Had 1 of the best calzones ive ever had at this place!! The pizza was also delicious. Friendly staff. We will be back!!

Amazing food, good prices. The workers here are really nice patient and the vibe of the establishment is great

I got the garlic knots and wow wow wow! Definitely coming back just for those!

Some of the best pizza I've had in Orlando

Best pizza place in town !!! Food was amazing and service was top notch for sure. We love coming back and having pizza and wings and garlic knots every time.

Great pizza for meat lovers. Also a great environment with great music played. Would go back.

The pizza and bruschetta is DELICIOUS

Heard about this place from a coworker and definitely did not disappoint! Tried the lasagna balls, a pepperoni slice, and white ricotta slice and ate it all! Will be back to try the Detroit pizzas!

By far the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! It’s cheesy, delicious, and very yummy! 😋

Our new go-to pizza place! My 12-year old grandson said the pizza is “phenomenal.” The hero was excellent (and huge) and the spaghetti and meatballs was also outstanding! Great value too!

Food always great and serve friendly

The food is wonderful!! Wait staff is very attentive and helpful with menu.

My fiancé and I are from Pennsylvania and wanted something quick tonight. Reviews from this place sent us here and they were right. We originally ordered delivery but it did take quite some time so I called and picked it up instead; not a big deal it was 5 minutes down the road and we are just sitting in the hotel anyway. We got chicken parm pizza, amazing. And because I called to pick up instead, they apologized for being backed up and gave us a bag. Thought it was going to be bread sticks but it was cannolis (: and we figured maybe day old ones, nope fresh and still crunchy! If I ever find myself back down this way will definitely order again!

Amazing food, atmosphere, and service! 10/10 recommended!

Pizza was by the slice and it was ok. Sadly no lunch specials offered. But the service was absolutely terrible. The waitresses were not friendly and not engaging whatsoever. Gave me the feeling of being bothersome actually. Had to find one to get the check and stop one if them from taking the leftovers and ask to get a box. Definitely room for improvement by trying other items if they had offered. But the atmosphere and terrible service left a bad impression.

Good pizzeria with good service

Our waitress was Madison and she was great. Personable and friendly, very attentive. Had the cheese pizza to try it out as I am born and raised in the south Bronx and it was as close to home as I have had since residing in Florida. The garlic knots were also great. Will be back to visit again.

First time here and loved everything! Our server Madison was so helpful!! The Benny Blanco calzone was delicious! The garlic knots were amazing! Will definitely be back to try other food!

Everything was soo good. We got pizza,calzone,and meatball. Totally recommend.

So good, so fresh and definitely Bronx Style pizza! Yum.

One of the best places I’ve been too in a while. Amazing atmosphere, service, and food. The cheese calzone I got was the best calzone I’ve had!

Reviewed for the nolis. Everything was really top notch.

Both of our entrees were delicious!! Portion sizes are big and filling. Even our side salad was enough for two and service was excellent!

Love this place remind me of my childhood back in the city great taste the food is amazing the staff very professional and the servers always attentive to us checking we good five star service all around

Pizza is great and perfectly backed to be nice and crispy with a whole lot of flavor.

Quick service and delicious food. Pizza reminded me of NY heavily! Highly recommended!

Great pizza and reasonably priced. Kids loved it. I do wish they had more kid beverage options however.

Great food, Madison was about server she was great!