Pink Sugar Pastries - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

You haven’t had good pastries if you haven’t been to Pink Sugar Pastries ! One of a kind and delicious with a large variety!

Petsitting in the area and my friend highly recommended this bakery! I stopped by and placed an online pickup order so the pups could stay in the car, and both the service and food were outstanding. The empanadas were delicious and fresh (just made!) and I can’t wait to try more. A great find!

We had our daughters fifth birthday at Pink Sugar Pastries and they did the most amazing job. They were so attentive and made sure every part of her day was perfect! All of the girls had so much fun and we will absolutely be back! Most delicious cakes and beautiful atmosphere!

My go to place for any celebration. Everything is beautifully made and absolutely delicious.

Great cakes! Ordered a custom Spongebob cake and I was blown away by the final product. They were extremely friendly and made the cake exactly as the picture I shared. If you are looking for a custom cake this is the place to go.

For my son's 3rd birthday, I tried to find a bakery to make a custom cake but even with 2 weeks to spare, every place that I called told me that they were "already booked." Pink Sugar Pastries came to the rescue and created the COOLEST Hot Wheels themed cake -- the employees here are as kind as they are talented!! So many quality items, the store is adorable. Will 100% return for future custom cakes and all of my baked goods!! A+++

Absolutely love this place! Most delicious and beautifully decorated cookies, alfajores and pastries not just local but better than some famous NYC bakeries. Love your Sunday buy 1, get one free deal! Not going to lie, I take advantage of it frequently! Bubble tea flavors are tasty, also love coffee and empanadas! Always fresh, tasty and fulfilling!!!

An incredible array of delicious treats; the alfajores are delicious! The decor is adorable and the staff beyond friendly. So glad they are supportive and inclusive of all. Don't miss this shop!

I will no longer support any business that supports harming children

Amazing empanadas and pastries. Great coffee as well. Supportive of the local community. 🌈

Excellent service, best food ever and super atmosphere.

Not only is the store front so cute and fun but the baked goods are amazing and affordable. I ordered a vintage style heart cake for my birthday and when I went to pick it up I also got cookies and macarons. Everything was delicious and the staff were friendly and kind. I was given a cake pop for free for my birthday. Also when designing the cake they were very responsive via email which worked out great for me. I’ll definitely be back for more.

Everything they make is so yummy! Definitely try their stuff. You won't be disappointed! The owner is so nice!

Best butter cream I've ever had. Cake is moist and tasty. Perfect decoration. The place is clean, bright and staff are helpful and friendly. I have recommended to everyone I know!!!!

A little over two weeks ago, my two youngest kids and I, stumbled upon Pink Sugar Pastries and it was such a good find! The shop is super cute and pink with a modern-day “Eloise at The Plaza” feel to it. It was also very clean, which is always a plus. We tried their teas, a few of their cookies and the guava & cheese puff pastry… 😍 to die for! I had been planning my soon-to-be 5 years old son’s Super Mario Bros. themed party. We decided to order a cake from PSP. After some deliberation on my part and a lot of patience on the owner’s part, we decided on a Mario design. They did not disappoint! The cake was everything my son wanted and more. From the design to the flavors… it was superb! The owner also took the time to recommend a more conservative size which would not only save me money but would still feed more than my estimated amount of invitees. Which speaks to her integrity. I always get way more than I need 🙄, so I really appreciated the guidance. Without question, we will be ordering our future celebration cakes from Mirtha and her team. We’re so happy we found this treasure trove of sweets! -M.C. P.s.The attached photo doesn’t do the cake justice. It was extremely hot and I may have had it sitting out longer than I should have.

Mirtha went above and beyond with the cake for my sons 1st birthday! I sent reference photos and ideas and the cake she put together was even better than we had imagined! She also provided us a sketch of the cake beforehand. She was such a pleasure to work with and we can’t wait use Pink Sugar Pastries again for future celebrations.

Wonderful, wonderful bakery!!! Definitely recommend

My only suggestion would be for the bakers to wear hairnets, we found hair in our baked goods twice. Will still go there since its such good food

Went in there for the first time last weekend late on the day. Everything was so fresh, full of flavor. I highly recommend a chocolate, strawberry croissant!

Pink Sugar Pastries made the most amazing cupcakes and cookies for my son’s birthday! Everything was exactly as they promised - and so beautiful and delicious! All of our guests commented on how wonderful they were. I will definitely be ordering from them in the future!

I stopped here the other day for some treats for a get together with my friend. I tried the macarons and large cookies and they were both so delicious! And such wonderful and friendly customer service. Will definitely be stopping more often!

They just do everything right. From the moment you walk into pink sugar its like you are automatically transported to a bakery you would find in a magazine. Every detail is perfection. The desserts and baked goods are amazing n don't get me started with their Boba tea drinks. If they haven't already thought of it all, boy was I wrong. Trust me, you cannot go wrong with anything you get from here. A huge step up from another local bakery. So happy I found this jem. Oh n the owner is the sweetest person you will ever meet. Good job ladies keep it up!!!

Ordered a cake for Christmas, very nice people, there was no effort put into the cake, will probably be my first and last time

They had a delightful Birthday cake at the ready and Candles for purchase too! Very friendly.

I ordered a birthday cake for my granddaughter. The cake came out beautiful. I did not have any ideas in mind when I came in and she was able to create a beautiful cake with the little suggestions I had!

I love this place. My friend and I took a baking class with the girls, and we had the time of our lives, it was so much fun, and we baked about 16 cookies each, which we got to bring to our homes.

We have been here twice and we loved the cookies and pastries we bought. The cookies are a super decadent treat! The owner is also very friendly and helpful. Our family will continue supporting this local business :) I highly recommend them!

Best bakery ever!!! Everything is so delicious, stuffed cookies cupcakes and cheesecakes, empanadas… Last week I ordered a cake for my husband’s bday and it was amazing, the flavor was really good and the decoration very cute. I loved everything I tried!

Their goods are very good but for bigger orders, they are VERY difficult to work with. They asked me for my order about a month in advance which was fine but then were completely unresponsive after I provided all the details. I ended up having to cancel and go with a more reputable bakery. Do not recommend, I’ve heard other ppl have had similar situations for cakes and advance orders. It’s really a shame… What you said below in your response to me is inaccurate and complete lies!! I tried calling several times and you know i was waiting for a price quote and further information from you which you kept promising you would give me and never did. Honestly you guys are awful for turning this around on a customer like this. I was not indecisive at all, I knew exactly what I wanted I just needed to talk it out based on what you provide. This literally took me all of 5 minutes with the bakery we are pleased to have gone with in our order. I can’t even believe u took the time to count my emails instead of just responding. Maybe 15 emails didn’t need to be sent if we could just got the info we needed…. Myself nor anybody in my very large family here in Carmel will ever step foot in your business. You are despicable and a complete liar!!! I’m appalled by how you handled this. It’s rude and disgusting as a business owner, very unprofessional.

After many years of traveling to Arthur Ave for my celebration cakes I tried finding a place closer to my home. I found this place and gave it a try! Their website has beautiful cakes! The owners are very nice people and the cake was designed exactly how I wanted! The taste was incredible!! The frosting amazing! My daughter’s 21st birthday cake was a hit! Needless to say this bakery will be my go to from now on!! Thank you Thank you!!

I had ordered a birthday cake for my sons 7th birthday and it was amazing! Mirtha was extremely professional and provides a sketch. We were blown away by how great the cake came out and it was delicious! The best part was seeing my sons face lite up as Pink Sugar was able to bring his dream cake to life. I highly recommend them for any special occasion!

Oh my goodness. Ordered different flavored cupcakes to taste try before placing a cake order. The cupcakes were out of this world, especially the all vanilla ones! They looked, smelled and tasted amazing! So looking forward to our cake order!

Outstanding! The epanadas are fantastic!

Well after a bad batch of cupcakes Mirtha make it right and gave me 6 assorted cheesecake cups and let me tell you they were incredible. I literally just left there and when I got back to work I tried the s’mores cheesecake cup and it was to die for. So moist and so much flavor. Thank you again Mirtha I really appreciate it and I will definitely be see you again soon!😊

Making pastries are made here.....cookies are delish. Mirtha also makes some awesome Brioche too. Cakes are a work of art. definitely a must see

Picked up a few goodies from here for the 1st time and they were delish!!! The empanadas were so tasty and the crust yummy and flaky. The mini chocolate croissant delicate and chocolaty and the cupcakes soooo good!!! Can't wait to go back!

So hubby and I stopped there on Saturday and oh my yum! OMY!! We bought mini chocolate croissants, assorted cupcakes and pork and turkey empanadas! Yum yum yum yum! Can't wait to go back!🤤🤤🤤

Would recommend anytime, anywhere, to anyone! New to our area, she single-handedly saved my daughter's 10th birthday when the bakery that I used to use failed. Needless to say, I have found our NEW pastry shop! Her Nutella Brioche is INSANE, everything in there is 100% fresh and DELICIOUS. Her cookies are stuffed, maxxed out to the gills. Not to mention her cakes!! Worth every single dime. She worked with me throughout the process and drew up a sketch of exactly what I had in mind - brought my daughter's dream cake to life! Thank you Pink Sugar!!

my family & i tried a few of their pastries for the first time today, we enjoyed every single one. we will be back in the future to try more of their options :)

I ordered a # 2 cake for my daughter’s birthday. Not only was the cake delicious and beautiful, Mirtha was great to work with and very friendly. I also ordered a few cookies and treats. The snickerdoodle cannoli cream cookie was amazing and my husband was sad I only brought home one. I had such a great experience that I have been telling friends and family that they must go in and treat themselves to something delicious. I will be ordering every cake from Pink Sugar Pastries in the future

They make the best cookies. I highly recommend this place.

I enjoyed all of the treats I got, but the M&M Chocolate Chunk cookie was my favorite! So delicious. It is a beautiful store with very friendly staff. I will definitely be going back soon.

I asked for a number cake with some fruit and white chocolate for my moms 60th. I didn’t expect it to be so pretty and so tasty! Everyone commented on how good and pretty the cake was, it was fresh light, fluffy not overly sweet and just dang good. Mirtha was a sweetheart I was a little late in the game to order and she was very sweet, patient and professional. Everyone asked who baked the cake so they could order for their own events, highly recommend, will definitely order again!

Mirtha and the team at Pink Sugar Pastries are true professionals and their goal is to bring to life all your dreams on your special day . They are true artists and their products are delicious.

MIRTHA is amazing at what she does! Everything I have had made by her has exceeded my expectations!

Best baked goods in Putnam County! Every last item has been a hit--sweet treats delivered as gifts for friends and family, a spectacular Harry Potter themed birthday cake, and all sorts of cookies and brownies purchased in the popup shop and at local festivals. Mirtha is a creative and talented baker; we are so excited to support the new location in Kent, NY!