Pizza Mania in Wesley Chapel - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Ordered online for a specific time. When I arrived pizza was ready and hot! Great pizza and friendly service!

We were looking forward to going there all day 🤠 Got there late, like 40 minutes before they closed. They were still courteous and polite. The pizzas were delicious 😋 And we didn't feel rushed. Great service and great pizza 🍕💯

The best pizza and Caesar salad you will ever have

Giving 5 stars because this is the most comparable pizza to NY in the area. I’ve been on the search and found it. Pepperoni was delicious. Thin crust and so good! Reasonable price and reasonable size.

My friend and I recently had Pizza Mania twice in the same week. We ordered the Pizza Italiana, Meat Lover's, Calzone, garlic knots, and Philly steak and everything was hot, fresh and consistently GOOD. We both remarked how incredible the taste was, how fresh everything was, and above all, how generous the toppings on the pizza, the calzone, and even the amount of meat in the Philly steak was. This is my new "pizza and more" go-to, and it should be yours too. True NY style deliciousness. Ignore the chain restaurants and support small businesses like this that serve quality food at a comparatively fair price.

Pizza mania has gone way downhill. This used to be one of the better pizza spots in the area.

I found Pizza Mania by happenstance while visiting my daughter and her family in Wesley Chapel, FL. A very pleasing experience. Their pizzas are delicious and I will be a repeat customer. My daughter tells me that she didn't know Pizza Mania was there but has been back several times since. BTW, they have a varied menu and if their other offerings are as good as their pies, they will do well.

The bruchetta was great and the pizza was very hot as it should be and tasted great. Another great pizza.

I picked up an order to go (5/4/2024 evening). The service was professional and I had high expectations about the food as I had read good reviews. I ordered a pizza which was ok and seafood pasta. This latest was supposed to have a combination of seafood with spaghetti (I specifically requested those). Pasta came with noodles, 3 shrimps and very few mussels. Extremely oily and no white wine sauce. If you like good pasta with good taste this one is not it.

Comfortable little pizza spot. Good prices. Lunch menu is cool Caesar was kind and humble. Definitely recommend. Spicey clucker

Messy service, burned corners, slow delivery. They even put the holders upside down into the pizza. I guess they wanted to add some plastic flavors into it.

The pizza is SO GOOD! The people always check in to make sure everything's alright, most surely coming back.

This place became our weekly pizza night tradition! The Margherita pizza is as a NYC as it can be and the chicken francese and marsala is to die for! Do yourself a favor, and try them. You won't be disappointed.

This is the first place I went to when I moved to Florida. The food is great and the service is also great.

Ordered a pizza and stromboli from them, added specific instructions not to include several things on the stromboli but they were included anyways. Called to ask for a refund and was told to "ask for so and so and you could have a free stromboli next time", instead I asked for a refund and was told it would be a few days for that but it was never refunded a few weeks later. Food is good when made to order but this has happened multiple times and it's pretty disappointing for an almost 20$ stromboli.

Love the cheese pizza. Don't need anything added to make it taste better. Family owned and they are always consistent.

Best pizza around. Food is always hot and wait staff is very attentive.

Absolutely Horrible!!!! Came in 1 hour before closing and the staff rushed us out, even offering a box before we began eating. Pizza was burnt. We would not recommend and we definitely won’t be returning…EVER!!!!

I’ve always liked Pizzamania since I moved here in the early 2000s. Recently, I don’t know if the chef had changed or something but it tastes better than ever! Ordered a large cheese pizza last night and it was delicious! This is my go to pizza place.

The Pizzamania crew are doing it all right! The best pizza pie and delicious food south of Hoboken, NJ !

We had the Chicken Parmesana w/ spaghetti and a cheese pizza for the kids. The dishes were delish and very tasty. Prices are reasonable if dining with the fam. The only negative thing was that hey had Fox News blasting. When I go to a restaurant I prefer it to be a delightful peaceful experience, and not one with such loud news. I can watch the news at home not a restaurant.

I ordered the veggie pizza. On the menu it says that there is spinach on the pizza and nothing about broccoli. There was spinach and broccoli on the pizza. I HATE broccoli! It ruined the whole pizza. If they would have listed it on the menu I would have asked to leave it off. They don't put very many different veggies on the pizza either. All the veggie pizzas I have gotten have onions and peppers at least. This only had spinach, broccoli and tomatoes. it was not that cheap either. I probably won't be going back. I called them about the broccoli and the just said it comes with spinach and broccoli even though it was not on the menu. They did not offer to correct it.

These people are passionate about pizza the real deal.

Best NY style pizza around! Florida doesn't have many great pizza places, but Pizza Mania never disappoints! Been going here for many years and we'll always keep coming back.

I love the pizza and salad . Great service and customer service 👏

The good: food (always consistent) The bad: Service Been coming for over 15yrs but the service tonight was just horrid by one of the server girl. But this is an exception to the norm. I hope not to see her again.

Very good pizza for sure, good atmosphere, very good customer service...

The best pizza in all of Florida, and arguably the world. Fresh spring water is imported from the ancient aqueducts of Sicily to craft every pie. The sauce, legend has told, was a lost ancient recipe of the Davinci family found hidden in secret Medici vaults.

The best pizza and pasta!!! The best pizza and pasta!!!

My first time at this place was December 24th 2023 this was my first time my boyfriend and I had went here to eat at this restaurant and it was amazing I couldn't believe how flavorful everything was it was so good to we wanted to bring some home! and it was very filling there was more than enough the customer service was awesome and the food was so so so good I couldn't believe it was great! I wish I had pictures to share but unfortunately the storage in my phone was completely full.

First timer, and I have to say that coming from up north, this pizza was great! John puts love and care into his pizza and has a wonderful sense of pride in the food he prepares. Ordered 2 pies well done, and they were tasty and cooked to perfection. I'm so glad we found this little gem. Grazie!

The pizza is amazing here! Customer service is always excellent, Best Pizza in Wesley chapel, FL. Don't go anywhere else but here you will love their food, and they treat you like family. Thanks pizza mania team!

It came to our attention when placing an order for pickup that Mania added an additional fee. What the fee is for is not mentioned. As restaurant owners ourselves, this is bad business.

Got a pizza mania pizza for takeout. It was only half cooked. Very very disappointing. It’s the first time I’ve gotten pizza from them. I normally get dinners and have no complaints. I was surprised how terrible the pizza was..

Always enjoyed the food. Great group of people.

Excellent pizza . Best I've tasted in Tampa

Pizza was good and the wings were fire. Nice staff

The Best ... Pizza, Stromboli, Philly Cheasesteak, Spegetti, Salad. Johnnie's the best pizza maker.

We use to go to pizza mania all the time but the last few times has been terrible. The pizza is not the same. The last time we ordered the other day, our pizza was incorrect and the sauce was just watered down. It was disgusting. We couldn't even finish a slice. No answer when we called back about our problem. Just not worth the price or time.

The best a man can get. Oh wait that Gillette the best you can get all of this pizza helped me get through a battle with long Covid. I couldn't taste anything but this pizza I don't know why, but it saved me literally. I thank them every time.

A great place to eat at! The food was incredibly tasty, and the portions were impressively generous. We ordered pepperoni pizza and couple of sandwiches! All turned up good.

We’ve visited this location three times. It’s delicious and we are very pleased with the food portions and services. This will be our go to for pasta pizza cravings :)

Best pizza place in town! Everytime you walk in they treat you like family and handsdown thye have my fav style of pizza. My go to is the cheese pizza, so good!

The best pizza in 20 mile radius if not more!!

A GREAT local pizza spot and they have gluten free pizza!

1st time trying Pizza Mania. The customer service and hospitality of this place is superb but sadly The white sauce veggie pizza left me sick through the evening and morning hours. Woozy nausea feeling and my stomach is just not feeling well after eating here. The taste of the pizza also lacked flavors but the amazing customer service made up BUT I can't overlook or dismiss the sickness the pizza gave me, so I won't return.

Such a welcoming, friendly vibe from the staff! I ordered pickup and forgot to get a drink, so I went to buy a bottled water when I arrived and they gave it to me for free. Pizza and Arancini are delicious and the prices are great too!

The pizza was New York style. It was very tasty and had lots of toppings. Service was excellent, friendly and quick. I would highly recommend this place.

Disappointed in the pizza. We had read good reviews on line and we thought we would try it out. We Ordered the Hawaiian and vegetarian pizza, hard broccoli stems were very bad tasting in vegetarian pizza and Hawaiian had little sauce and no flavor. The onion rings were good though. Will not be returning.

I have ordered from Pizza Mania many times but today the large gourmet pizza I ordered was COMPLETELY BURNED on the bottom and the crust!!! Of course you can imagine how MAD I was especially since our entire order was over $50.00 !!!! I have requested a full refund for pizA I could not eat nor my family. In this economy this is not acceptable!!!

Food is delicious and service was amazing!!! Our new favorite spot!

Best pizza in all of Wesley Chapel!

Great fresh pizza. Friendly staff. Beats the heck out of Little Caesars.

Pizza is always very delicious! This is our go to place for family pizza night!

Wow...I'm feeling a bit disappointed. I'm new to the area so I was excited to try Pizza Mania. Don't get me wrong the food is good, it's just NOT what I ordered. I ordered a personal hawaiian pizza with mushrooms and GREEN peppers and a side of garlic knots. What I got, was everything EXCEPT GREEN peppers and a pizza riddled with onions - thank goodness I'm not allergic to anything.

Updated my review because I was wrong. This place was amazing. I spoke to the owner and he cleared up any confusion. Great food and service

Very dirty environment. So i decided to order through Uber and all of my food was just thrown in lidless pizza box. No bags or way to detect if the driver hasn't been munching on my food or not. And the driver had a pizza bag but couldn't use it due to loose food! So that means the food was cold as well. Horrible location.

Never disappointed! Best pizza here in Wesley chapel!!

While ordering I noticed multiple bugs on the floor, the place looks awful and the pizza was basically a thinner version of little Caesars that costs more. 😅 I'll stick to NY Pizza.

Great service and wonderful food never disappointed

Everything was fresh and delicious the service was very welcoming

Perfect NY pizza every time. We love to eat pizza here. It's always perfect, and their sauce is awesome, in my opinion. It's been our favorite for about 8 years. We've tried many other pizza places, and although some are a close 2nd, they're just not as good. My husband and I always say Pizza Mania is the best. Always great service. We also love the fried mushrooms, onion rings, and french fries. If you're a northener looking for a NY style pizza, give Pizza Mania a try.

If you like real New York Pizza look no further. This place has really good pizza, Everything on the menu I have had has been five stars. The price is good, the service is good and the food is good. I still have not found a pizza place I like better anywhere in Tampa and I love that this is in Wesley Chapel close to our home.Edit : changed to 4 stars which is being generous last 3 times was not good, don't know if new owner or what

Got to be honest I called take out the other day one of the pizzas was very good, the other pizza was about 75% burnt it was my fault I should have checked before we left I'm sure they would have made it right but I got home and really did not enjoy myself with that particular pizza but like I said the other one was very good it was plain cheese I would recommend this place just check your food before you leave !

Really good pizza. Would come again and they have a wide variety of things to choose from the menu

Best pizza I've had in a long time since new york.

I would have loved to give this review a 5 star I am a regular customer at pizza mania . Their food is amazing I go every week there are wonderful ladies that treat their customers amazing . But on Wednesday night I went in to dine in the cashier had a braid and she was lovely greeted me when I walked in and said have a wonderful afternoon when I left . My waitress was not the best her service was okay but she had earbuds on while serving tables . She has short hair and tattoos but who serves tables with earbuds on that is disrespectful to the customers . No waitress should wear earbuds while serving a table . Other than that the food was amazing !

White pizza with spinach and chicken was Superb!

My family enjoyed the pizza. Very tasty and the price was good. The pizza is a little thin but still good.

The owner is awesome and so welcoming! Not to mention the pizza is amazing !

Ordered from here and ate here and always great food. Probably the best pizza in Wesley Chapel and Lutz. Crust is awesome.. If you dont give them a 5 star then well lets say you dont know pizza.

Fantastic service and great food. My new pizza spot.

it’s okay. . I’ve had take out 3 times. The first time was really good. It wasn’t pizza. The last 2 times I’ve gotten pizza to go and I mean it was just okay. A little sloppy but I could eat it.

I love Pizza Mania! It's consistently good! The family that owns the restaurant makes you feel like you are part of their family. I enjoy seeing them when they are here from Italy. I'm so happy you all found Wesley Chapel all of those years ago! I highly recommend this joint! 💜

The closest I have came to new York pizza very very good

I go here often with my elderly mother since it's very close to her. We like the pizza and it's pretty friendly but it's very casual and you can't go if you're in a hurry they are always understaffed.

Our recent stay in Wesley Chapel led us to order in from Pizza Mania - not once but twice in 4 days! Great food, very quick for pickup 20-30 min both times. One time we ordered pasta and meatball subs and the second we had pizza. Plenty of options to satisfy everyone!

Had an excellent penne with grilled chicken and tomato sauce. Sicilian pizza is a very large slice of very good. Lighting is kept intimate. Chairs are a little hard on you; if you eat slow bring a cushion. Portion is adequate and not too much. Overall. A nice place to eat good Italian just byo cushion.

Great tasting pizza, we had a Pepperoni and another with Mushrooms and Meatballs! They were both excellent! However the pizzas took 20 minutes longer than what was stated online as the pickup time. Still a definite place to visit for the amazing pizzas!

The pizza is always good here. They do their job but I wish they would be a little bit more friendly and outgoing. Not that they're rude or anything but just when you look at them they seem like they don't want to be there.

This was a great spot for us to go as a group for lunch. We were able to get in and out during our lunch break without issues. The food is amazing and it’s always best to eat fresh from the oven. The staff is great. Will be back soon!

Best Philly cheese steak sandwich I have tried.. lots of delicious meat mixed with cheese on toasty bread for around $8.. so good I had not tried anything else in this place and sometimes I'll drive far just to get that awesome Philly cheese steak sandwich!

I just went to Pizza Mania off of Bruce B.Down. The Best Pizza!!! I am from NY just moved here 3 months ago and could not find a good pizza place until now. The owner and the staff is extremely nice. I highly recommend this place.

We were attracted to Pizza Mania cause my Son had ordered the Sicilian Pizza, OMG , Pizza was big , lots of cheese and great flavor. few days later I wanted to go personally. Service was great, Food was delicious, I had a lasagna that came with salad and bread, 😋. Wife had a stromboli, it was delicious too. (BIG) Manager came to our table to check out the service which it's a plus to me when it comes to customer service. Prices were decent..I will definitely go back 👍

Closest thing to Bronx pizza. Reminds me of Diana off of 177th & grand con crs Delicious. Pizza Mania thank-you 🍕 🍕 🍕 ❤❤❤

dined in for the first time today. we usually carry out but decided at the last minute to dine in. they shifted gears quickly and accommodated us no problem. we get pizza mania weekly - loyal customers! great to see the good service continues with dining in.

Was in town visiting family and this restaurant was recommended. We ordered some entree and a pizza. All the food was prepared perfectly and the portions were more than fair. We received outstanding service the entire time we were there. I noticed there were plenty of families eating there and many seemed to be regular customers which always tells me that it is a good place to eat. I would highly recommend this place if you find yourself in the area and will surely eat here again when I visit Wesley Chapel.

Both dine-in and take-out. Dine-in was great , everyone was very friendly. Excellent cauliflower / gluten free crust pizza (best I've ever tried). Above average salads for a pizza spot. Their plain pies are outrageously good. Truly NY style pizza.

1st time and if your looking for NY style, you just got it. I’m from PA and very picky about pizza. Florida doesn’t have great pizza, this place was fantastic.. I definitely recommend. We will be back. The garlic knots were fabulous also :)

Delicious Stromboli and pizzas!

Good NY style pizza. Sicilian slice was real good

Great pizza. The staff is always friendly. The owner is the nicest. If you’re celiac, the gluten free pizza is great, too.

I work at this plaza and I never see anyone go in here nor do I ever see it busy. I went in for the first time to give it a try and now I see why no one is ever in here. Service was rushed and careless, I ordered pasta and it was pretty awful. Also, the place is so ugly and sad and quiet inside? Every part of this business needs a makeover.

Service was terrible, food was worse. Appetizers came out with food. Veal Parm sub was all breading, the bruschetta didn't taste great after waiting a long time for it. Everything seemed pre-made and frozen, which has not always been the case here. Used to have this food catered and ordered it for take out often. At this point I wouldn't recommend it to ANYONE. I truly hope they can turn it back around to what it was.

Convenient. Staff was polite. Pizza was ok, pepperoni and cheese. Chicken wings were great!

New England style pizza in Tampa Bay. Reminds me of Papa Gino’s. Good service, short waits. The Pizza Mania supreme and classic cheese are our faves. The garlic bread is Spicy Hot with garlic…definitely won’t have any vampire problems for at least a week. Love it! Try them out!

Pizza was delicious ! I tried them for the first time and pizza was good! I am from NY so pizza is hard to find out here that comes close to NY but me and the kids loved it! Can’t wait to try some of the other items on the menu. Definitely recommend. Staff was very nice too!

Nice variety of toppings for the pizzas. They also have a wide variety of pastas, sandwiches, calzones, and salads to choose from to name a few things.

Good pizza but they were out of most the beverage, some appetizers so

Always delish and has never disappointed. The calzones, pizza by the slice (not on their web menu), and sandwiches are always great and perfect when you need greasy pizza