Polar Bear Ice Cream - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

The BEST milkshakes and soft serve

Great ice cream excellent service

Above average taste but not the best.

came here when I was a kid and now an adult 15 years later . still the same great ice cream with friendly faces all around

Great place. Best ice cream in town

Absolutely most favorite ice cream spot for summer! Owner is great! Always has new flav of soft serve. Kids love it!

great value, friendly staff, good vibes

DELICIOUS ICE CREAM!!! when it’s open and I have time it’s my go to place!! staff are so kind and friendly! they have so many flavors and they even have italian ice too!!

Garbage… to say the least. Very confused, how this place gets good reviews, really..?

Best price to portion ratio. Cool flavors too

Great ice cream. Great gummie bears. Nice people. Efficient. ❤️ 🍨

I've been coming here since I was a kid, it was called Polar Cub back then. Still great soft serve Ice cream!!

If you only except cash try to get an ATM on premises or something so your customers doesn’t have to go up and down the highway twice

Best most reasonable priced ... Really tasty combos... Chocolate chip cookies and chocolate ice cream... OMG!

The BEST I've Cream on Route-36! Hands down!

Best ice cream !! So many options!! Been coming here since I could remember with my parents now I bring my kids! Same owner as always he’s great!

Lovin our Polar Bear treats!!!! Yummmmm!!!

If you're looking for a place to indulge your sweet tooth, look no further than Polar Bear Ice Cream! This charming ice cream shop offers a wide variety of delicious ice cream flavors, including classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla, as well as more unique options like cookies and cream, Stawberry, etc. But that's not all - Polar Bears also offers an impressive selection of shakes, with flavors to suit every taste. What sets this ice cream shop apart, however, is the quality of the ice cream. Everything is made in-house with the freshest ingredients, ensuring that every scoop is rich, creamy, and packed with flavor. Plus, the staff are friendly and knowledgeable, always happy to help you find the perfect scoop for your mood. If you're in the mood for a sweet treat, Polar Bear Ice Cream is the perfect destination. Whether you're craving a classic cone or a decadent shake, you're sure to find something delicious here. So what are you waiting for? Treat yourself to a scoop (or two!) today!

Never had issues. It is CASH based business.

Good selection of ice cream and Italian ices. The best chocolate banana milkshake!

Polar Bear has been one of my favorites since moving to the area. The Campfire S’mores is amazing! I met the owner the other night and it made it even better. His passion and commitment to quality makes me so happy to be a continued customer.

Do you love creamy delicious ice cream? Hire about affordable for the family to go out and get ice cream? If so... you have to go to polar bear it is the best ice cream in the area.

All the flavors that I've had have been delicious!!!

Nice people and excellent ice cream

Nice prices and great ice cream

Love the freshness and variety of flavors. Black Raspberry Blast is my new Favorite 😍 Just know before you go to try, it is a cash only spot.

Good ice cream for the price, friendly staff.

Wowzers! Had the Lemon Bar ice cream and it was to die for! Easily one of the top three ice creams I have ever had! You have to go try it!

It is walking distance close, but so are other places…. Polar Bear is a staple in this area and known by so many visitors. Staff is always great and the owner is always friendly. I either go with the Campfire S’mores or soft serve chocolate. I love Campfire S’mores, but be warned, I think it is very sweet.

This place is an absolute must in the summer! They have such delicious ice cream and amazing sundaes! Just make sure to bring cash as they don't accept credit cards. Highly recommend!

Great ice cream.. the small sundae is already big! So good

Me and my parents been coming here a long time since I was a kid and they never are bad. I recommend the banana flavor with a cone or get it in a cup with chocolate. Said flavor is pictured.

Delicious😋 - chocolate with chocolate sprinkles in cup.

Great place nice people fast service thank you keep up the great service

Old school ice cream store. Great ice cream

Its the best. The sprinkles are better tasting than other places the ice cream delicious. When you ask for hot fudge you get hot fudge in every bite unlike cold stone with their 1 tbsp rip off. This place beats them all. The service was great.

Solid ice cream near Sandy Hook Beach.

Favorite stop when in the area - huge cones - fair prices - excellent ice cream

Great selection of a soft serve and hard ice cream flavors as well as a ton of different toppings Very inexpensive and staff was super friendly! Just don’t forget to have cash they do not take cards.

Love this place! Staff are great and very friendly!

I didn't think it was for me I'm for everyone