Rico's Pizzeria in Bayshore Gardens - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

I ordered a pepperoni Stromboli, I got home to find out it had jalapeño and meat. They said oh sorry we thought you wanted all that! When I specifically said only pepperoni! Then they wouldn’t give me a new one or my money back! Some customer service they have 👎🏽👎🏽👎🏽👎🏽 if your reading this just go to san remos pizza way better!!!

Perfect laid back dining with pizza sliced

Rude ! They ended up being out of cheeseburgers and chicken tenders instead of saying anything they just delivered the food, but still charged us the full amount I’ll never order from this place again

Great pizza, I think his name was Phil, absolutely great service. I will definitely be back

The only place I get pizza from amazing family never had anything meatballs on my pizza sandwiches chicken parm everything's outstanding

The very best pizza and Italian food in Manatee County by far!

Ordered three pies for take out. One out of three were good. Vegetarian had very little vegetables on it. Margarita was slim on sauce and mozzarella cheese. On the dry side. Then there was the music playing that was full of vulgarity. The website is one of the worst to navigate to get to the correct store.

Quite possibly the worst pizza we had. Stay away from sausage. We have no idea what it was. Ground up something and hardly anything. It's New York style. Giant pieces. Not much pepperoni either. Stay away from this place

Margarita pizza OH MY GOSH!!! Excellent! Thank you, guys!!!

Literally the best. I always get the pepperoni roll. This location tho. Don't go to the one on manatee Ave. They are very skimpy with the cheese. This one on 26th is absolute fire

Great food and great people. I’m from Philly and it’s really hard to find it here but this spot is really good.

I called late very near to closing and the man who answered was very kind and said he'd still whip me one up in 15 minutes for pickup. It was perfect! Thank you!! 😊

I've had a hankering for a pizza. We met after our chores & stopped in for lunch one cold rainy afternoon. Good choice. Excellent sauce and fresh toppings cooked on a great crust.

True american, creamy salty... good for sharing

The food was good. Large portions. The girl at the desk where u placed your order was very rude and pushy to hurry up and order. Ask for extra sauce when I left with leftovers. She didn't follow through.

Love the pizza, mozzarella capresa, and the Stromboli. Fast service

This was delicious pizza! Felt like I was in Italy.

Small pizza place on 26th street but BEST pizza in Bradenton, and we have tried them all🍕 Phil is awesome and what a hottie!

Best pizza you can find south of Jersey

First time at this location cook was very nice the cashier was great this place has lots more food than pizza I had I had 4 pieces of pizza and a alicolic beverage place was clean I will return to this business anain.

Absolutely delicious NY, NJ pizza. Finally great pizza in West Bradenton. I have searched everywhere for this 🍕🍕😁😁.

Amazing pizza! Definitely will eat here again.

Always a good consistent pizza. The pizza is like your favorite neighborhood local pizza shop.

Very friendly service and the pizza was delicious. We also ordered a chicken cutlet sandwich that was very good.

Cute pizza place. Guy is always nice. And food is always good

It took me awhile to find a pizza I liked in Florida and I thought I had finally found it. I’ve ordered pizza from here often but last weekend I was completely disappointed. The sauce had no taste like it was watered down, the crust was dry and had a weird smell also smelled burnt but wasn’t, and the same for the cheese. I wish I would have just taken it back. Sadly I don’t think I’ll be back after that experience.

Their ingredients are great and the calzones/strombolis are enormous.

Lasagna was Terrible. No cheese, no meat waterery sauce. Won't be back.

Bad customer service the girl has nasty attitude never going back

Great experience. Guy at the counter was also cooking the food and he was great. Cared about our experience. Food was amazing. Will be back.

It is awesome when you can stop by for a quick slice and get great service. Thanks

Good pizza available by the slice

Always fast, friendly, and delicious 😋 😍

Great local pizza shop, good food and service.

I've been making pie for 20 years in north jersey for my families pizza joints. Best pie and knots I've had in Florida yet. I couldn't have done a better job myself. Keep it up guys. Yuz got a customer for life when I'm in the area.

We recently found this absolute gem of an Italian restaurant and loved it. In a little shopping mall that you would probably drive past but DON'T! because it's great. Well priced and great portions, we had garlic knots (amazing) their large half cheese half pepperoni pizza (massive) and. Veggie pizza (really good) 10/10 for everything

We ordered an all meat pizza, very skimpy on toppings. Average pizza at best

Honestly, life changing food. The bread passed the knock test. The staff is super fri ndly and family. Paulette is extremely pretty ❤️

Great food! The best calzone in town!

om Goodness! Excellent (Large) calzone!! excellent service too can't beat the food

Have been eating here for years at different locations. Very excited that this one is to far to drive and get their delicious pizza. Owners/ staff are always a pleasure.

Best pizza in town reel up north style pizza and all there other Sicilian food is the best to. small family owned and operated makes a difference. I highly recommend this place and all 7 other ricos .

The food was delicious, and the staff were very polite and helpful. Definitely recommend this place.

Great pizza, decent prices. Paulette was our server and couldn’t have been nicer.

Service a d food were Awesome the only thing my mom didn't like was they didn't have ice for the drinks

Great slice. Decent prices. Good portions. Only wish they were able to stay open later, great hole in the wall.

The best pizza in Bradenton…the true taste of fresh ingredients…and prices are very reasonable for the quality of product…thank you…