Rufino's Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

It’s my favorite Pizza but they don’t actually open until 1pm or 2pm even though they open at 11am. When they open… all they have even after an hour of opening. Is cheese, and a couple of other pizzas. They never have the buffalo chicken rolls or calzones or stuffed pizza. Pretty frustrating when you go… and they’re NEVER fully open.. if you’re not ready by 11am with basically everything. Don’t open yet.. strange way to run a business when you don’t have all of your product made and ready to sell until 2-3 hours after you open. Oh and you can use real chicken on your buffalo chicken and chicken parm rolls. Charging $7-$8 for fake chicken is crazy..

I was at the outlet mall last month and stopped in at the food court for a quick bite to eat. I ordered a slice of Grandma's Pizza and was blown away. We decided to order an entire pie for lunch today and it was just as amazing. We went with a half and half, (half cheese and the other half with with jalapenos and pepperoni). I can honestly say this is the best Grandma Pizza that I've had in St. Augustine. The garlicky sauce is rich with chunks of tomatoes and the crust is light and crispy. They use a quality cheese here and aren't skimpy with the toppings. I placed my order at the counter and it was a good wait as they were busy, (will probably call my order in next time). It's also somewhat of a pain dealing with the mall traffic but totally worth it.

Delicious pizzas and good service

Got a meat stuffed slice for about $6.50. Very tasty and super filling. Plenty of selection for mid-afternoon. It's a weird spot in the practically empty food court in the outlets. Plenty of seating though I got it togo. Fast service.

Good lunch place for working people's nothing fancy just good food fast

Very good pizza they have here. Super thin and crispy pizza. Pretty good for Outlet Mall pizza

It was perfect, the crust was thin and toasty, and the toppings were plentiful. Temperature wise it was awesome!! Also I was visiting from Newport Richey came up there for some shopping!! (Everywhere)😀

Great pizza on point in the food court in the mall. You get tasty slices and awesome stuffed pizza. Also freak garlic knots..this is an awesome joint. I'll be back.

The pizza is so good that I drive 25 minutes to get one.

This was seriously some of the best pizza my husband and I have ever had. We got two slices of cheese pizza and stuffed veggie pizza. It was so good; that we debated on going back for more so we’d have some in our hotel fridge for later. We’re from out of state and typically try not to eat foods we have back home, but this was worth it. Definitely recommend! (Three pieces fed my two toddlers, husband and I)

Had a pepperoni pizza to go. Good tasting pie! Staff was friendly. Located in the food court at the outlet.

Garbage pizza will never eat there again

The sandwich type pizza with toppings inside was delicious.

Pizza was great!! We will come again next time we are in town!

Delicious pizza! Don't let the fact that this place is in a mall food court deter you, as advised by other reviews. Definitely worth a try!

Service was good. Pizza was greasy, and it wasn't hot, and the cheese wasn't really giving me NY pizza vibes.

The pizza was spectacular! Really good ingredients here and Will blow your expectations.Please give this place a try if you’re looking for good pizza! 🍕

The best pizza in town! And I’m a New Yorker. Frankie recommended a slice of pizza to me and it was delicious! Not only is the food, great, so is the service! Friendly, nice, and good food. A home run!

Food was ok.. typical pizza.. AFTER ee ordered the guy manning the pizzza oven DROPPED the dig wood pizza spatula ON THE FLOOR.. then PICKED IT UP and used it. Will never eat here again.

This is in the food court for the outlet mall, BUT don't let that fool you. The NY style pizza is phenomenal. With all of the other food vendors vacant, there ends up being a ton of seats and it's a nice quiet spot. The staff was very attentive and efficient. Ordered some individual slices and a whole pie to go. Slices were done almost immediately after sitting down, and then the pie took only 15 minutes.

A five-star gem! This pizza spot wows with a perfect crust, fresh toppings, AMAZING cheese a tomato sauce. Every bite is a delight. Highly recommend! 🌟

Best pizza in North Florida. I drive from orange park just for this pizza.

The food is amazing.There service was absolutely amazing as well love it. Will be back🩷🩷🩷🩷

Oct 2023: Still the best pizza in town! Joseph thank you for ALWAYS bringing your A++ game and making sure you treat people with respect and dignity. I appreciate you 🙏🏾🙌🏾 I hope y'all have continued success! ____________________ We moved into a house nearby and this was our first meal. 💖 The people who work here are truly awesome, they are very kind and made a stressful day so much better! The pizza?! This pizza haunts my dreams. 🍕👻Seriously, guys don't hesitate to stop in and pickup a pizza and thank me later! Thank you again to the Rufino's team. You made out first day magical. 🍻

My son and I decided to get a large pizza(veggie) for diner and stopped at Rufinos and ordered one. Delicious,amazing pizza!Just like my home town pizza in Queens!!

Best Pizza in St Augustine!! Mwah!!

If you want a hole in the wall pizza joint with some seriously good pizza at decent prices, this is the place

I was shopping at the outlet mall and grabbed a piece of pizza. It was some of the best pizza I've ever had, definitely a 10 out of 10. I had the white pizza. The staff were super cool.

Best chicken parm and pepperoni roll in NE Florida! This is really hard to say when you come from NYC..

Best Pizza in St. Augustine area. Garlic knots fantastic and great sauce!

There, pizza takes me back to NY. This is a must stop when visiting St Augustine outlet.

Awesome great pizza with a light crust!

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Crispy, thin, airy crust. NY style pizza at its best. I've been coming down here every year for vacation and this place is a hidden gem. Excellent pizza!!!

Went above and beyond. Great value great food.

Great pizza, while on vacation i order pizza over the phone. When i got there to pick it up i realized i ordered pizza from a food court. I was nervous i may have made a mistake. I did not, Florida pizza has never been as good as home but this place is really good .hands down the best pizza ive ever had in Florida.

I love the pizza and garlic knots

Surprisingly awesome pizza !! The stuffed pizza and garlic knots! We were hungry and there were very few options at the Premium Outlets StAug. We were wary about food court food but was very pleasantly surprised. Costs very reasonable too!

This is the best pizza south of NY for the last 5 years! Always consistent always delicious! Thanks guys for being here ❤️

It didn't work for us. Dough was not done and we had to throw almost half of the large pizza

Consistently excellent NY style pizzeria. Wish I lived closer to the outlet!

Delicious pizza. This is one of the best pizza I’ve had in Florida.

Great pizza, thin crust, made fresh.

The owner made it personally, the entire staff were sooo nice!! BEST Pizza in town!!

I really good pizza. It's usually hard to find a good pizza place, Pizza Time in downtown Saint Augustine has really great slices but this place has delicious slices and they are way cheaper, highly recommend.

Great pizza. Good thin, crispy crust. We always get a slice when we visit the mall.

I'm so delighted to have found the world's BEST PIZZA!! Took my 57years; I highly recommend that any fellow pizza lovers check out the awesome "zza" serviced up at Rufino's!!

Sunny and Joseph made sure my slIces were fresh and hot. Highly recommend this spot in your in the outlets!

Absolutely Delicious pizza!!!! Some of the best I've had. Don't let the long line scare you , they are very quick! Yummmmm!!! Sooo.. good

I was skeptical of mall pizza but this place is great. We call-in for pick-up every Friday night. Hidden gem!

We got a large cheese that pizza was delicious customer service was wonderful will be back for sure