Solle's Pizza - Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews

Will have to give you guys a 3 star review. The owner is a great guy 100%. The salad and wings are amazing, but….i got 1 large 3 topping pizza, that lacked the toppings, I mean I barly had any onions and even less mushrooms, 1 small 1 topping pizza, small salad and 2 desserts and it was around 80 BUCKS! Very pricy. The pizza is normally pretty good. This time all I could taste is a strong cheese, I’m thinking it’s parmesan cheese, it over powers everything. You can’t even taste the sauce nor the toppings due to this over powering flavor. Will give it another go and ask for no parm or whatever that cheese is. Also the pizza wasn’t crispy at all, very floppy and greasy. I like it very crisp and ask for thin and crispy. It was thin and soggy. And yes I ate it fresh out the oven.

How you gonna charge a dollar for an ordering fee. Big turn off. Pizza good but greed is uncalled for. 20 $ for a large cheese I think is sufficient. Scratch that dollar fee poison. Smh

I am absolutely in love with their Sicilian pizza. My go-to treat for really good pizza.

Phil the owner assisted us and even personally delivered our pizza and apologized for a missing cheesey bread on a previous order. 10 out of 10 will order here again, the only thing better than Phil's customer service was the amazing pizza and shells.

Wish they had a better spot. Its in an odd place for parking. Great place.

The staff work from a perspective of 'doing their best in the moment.' The food is consistently delicious. I have generally ordered with friends and we collectively order a variety of pizza or pasta dishes. Today I ordered on my own and requested a side salad; it was awesome and granted to me for dietary reasons. Wonderful people with a love for their customers!

Solle's os making Tallahassee beautiful with their assolutamente, the best meatball sub.

Awesome food and service and the people are fun. They have a good time with their customers. Right out of Brooklyn. Get outta heah!!!

Great pizza, fun staff. Definitely will eat here again.

Small storefront pizza joint. No real place to dine in, with a few tables outdoors. Mostly takeout. Best NY style pizza we have found between Tallahassee and Pensacola. They also have lunch specials. Very affordable!

I have to update from my previous rating of 5 stars as we have had more than one disappointment with burnt crust and extremely thin crust. On my last experience (yesterday) they managed to burn it and make the crust soggy at the same time. This is my last time. We try and support local businesses and have been going to Solle's for over 2 years. The staff are very friendly and that's why I gave this two stars.

We were in the area on our way to Panama and were craving pizza and We stopped by here. Pizza was delicious and they were quick!

Food absolutely amazing. Ordered garlic cheese bread (phenomenal) and chicken Alfredo (even better). Realized when I got home my Alfredo was missing the chicken, so I called and they said to come back and they would have it re-made correctly and with no hesitation or any questions made me a whole brand new FRESH hot meal. Also let me keep the order without the chicken for leftovers! Great customer service and even better food, I’ll be back often.

The quality of the pizza was poor. In addition, 2 out of the pizzas tasted old…Very disappointing

This is the best pizza in Tallahassee. We ordered two pizzas, a slice of cheesecake, and a cannoli. Normally we'd reheat the leftovers the next night but there are no leftovers😀 The flavor and bake is on point and the service is quick and excellent. If I was on death row this would be my last meal.

Best pizza place in town! Great pizza and great staff.with excellent customer service..they really care about the customers..

I was hesitant to go back, as I did not enjoy the pizza we had when they first opened. We decided to give them another try, and so glad we did! The crust was perfect and had a good flavor. The sauce had a good flavor, and the people working were super kind and professional. We will most definitely be back. Good job Sollle's!

This place is a gem! Their antipasta is loaded with fresh ingredients, their pasta dishes are massive and affordable (especially the cheese tortellini and chicken parm), and the pizza is my favorite in town. Delicious every time.

Hands down, the best pizza in Tallahassee. Staff is always friendly and welcoming, atmosphere is cozy, just all around a great little pizza joint. 10/10 highly recommend.

Stopped in on a random thought. Fantastic pizza! Kid had the meatball sub. He inhaled it. Great staff, can't recommend this pizza joint enough. So glad we stopped in. 😁

Frozen store pizza tastes way better not sure how this pizza place got such a high rating

Their is food exceptional I would recommend this establishment to anyone seeking authentic Italian dishes

First I gotta say, being from New York I’m very skeptical when a place in Florida (or anywhere) says “New York style pizza”. I ordered a pizza pie and some wings. And I told them I would give my honest review. The lady told me: “I know you’ll like it cuz I made it” and I can’t front… she was right. 👍🏽 The only “complaint” I had was not enough pepperoni (I love pepperoni) so I’ll just tell them next time to drench my pizza in pepperoni. There was a slice with just one pepperoni on it. But the taste n texture made up for all that. I actually felt like I was having a slice from back home. So I salute you 🫡 🔹small parking area 🔹it’s in a gas station lot 🔹no seating inside 🔹one outdoor picnic bench on the outside 🔹I’d call ahead and order your pizza for pickup (It will take a while > 20-30min) I’ll be coming back - extra pepperoni for ya boy 🍕 This place is Crispy Kartel Certified 🫡

Anyone that calls this the best pizza in Tallahassee is out of their everloving mind. But it's also an indictment of the absolute piss poor pizza scene, and the food scene in general, in this backwoods hillbilly hayseed town that THIS is the pizza they rave about. People here just simply don't know what good food is. They just don't. No clue. It's sad. This pizza is bar pizza. It's beer pizza. It's pizza you eat after a night of drinking to soak up the alcohol. The cheese is not great quality and very salty. The sauce has no balance. All tang. The crust is floppy and bland and way too thick for "New York Style" pizza. And our pizzas both had crusts that had a weird funky smell to them like burned wheat or maybe like...an old cruddy oven? This pizza is nothing more than Five Star Pizza quality. The chain called "Five Star," that is. And maybe it's even worse? Sad that this is what passes for good pizza here. What an embarrassing town.

They seem to have a very bad staffing problem; there aren't enough employees to keep up with the workload. I tried calling to place an order on a Tuesday night and I was on hold for 10mins to no avail. Then I placed an order online for delivery and I was given a wait time of about 50mins. Ok not too bad I thought. Well now it's been an hour and a half and I tried calling the store but it no one is answering. Who knows if I'll even get my pizza at this point. I guess I'll just have to have my fingers crossed. This is the first time I've tried ordering from them and will be my last.

Great pie. Nice crispy crust and great flavor. Highly recommend.

Horrible customer service. Tried to order on the website and it was nonresponsive. The most horrible and unprofessional experience is the experience I had on the phone with trying to order. I called the first time and tried to order and started placing my order and was hung up on. I called again and tried to place my order and heard laughing from the person taking my order and heard laughing in the background as I said my address. This is a horrible business and I will never even try to order from your business again.

First time and won't be the last. Speedy delivery, good food and good service. The pizza arrived sooner than expected. I highly recommend Solle's Pizza.

My favorite pizza in Tallahassee.

Pizza like no other the ingredients made the difference the hamburger was incredible the sausage the mushrooms, every ingredient you could taste the difference and this pizza weighs about three times more than a standard pizza. definitely incredible pizza eating experience. I think you’ll be definitely happy with the pizza from here. Thanks Limomike..

Absolutely fantastic pizza and killer wings. Their daily specials hit the spot, and the staff and owner are wonderful. The pizza is traditional NYC, and you savour every bite. The price is somewhat higher than some other pizza places, but it's all quality. For what you get, its a better value than those other places, and their delivery fees are the best around. Definitely recommend Solle's, even coming from a Chicagoan family it's my favorite pizza around.

This is the best pizza in town. The white pizza is my favorite, and the calzones are also amazing. Must try.

This was our first time and we will be back to try it again. We just had the 2 slice & a drink deal. The ingredients were fresh and it only took 5 mins to receive our food. The staff was friendly. The pizza was NY style, but I'm hoping next time they have something deep dish. Like I said, we will be back.

Great pie for those who like real ny style pizza. They pay attn to the details. Thrown evenly. Seasoned well. Pop the bubbles. Beautiful crisp. Thank you

Take out; pizza is wonderful.....crispy, flavorful and in no need of extra condiments

We ate there on Saturday 11/25 at the CollegeTown location and it was FANTASTIC!! The owner went across the street to buy ice for our drinks. We sat outside and he came over to talk with us for a while. He and everyone else were so nice. The one guy told me that my Stromboli was about to blow my mind, HE WAS NOT WRONG!!! I stepped back in before we left to let everyone know "WE WILL BE BACK!!!" It was a great experience. I mentioned that my friend told me to try the place and when I told him her name he recited her order to me!! CUSTOMER SERVICE ANYONE??!! I am counting the days until we can go back and try out something else from the menu!! Thank yall for making a not so great day better!!

Great daily specials and great thin crust pizzas.

Hard working staff!! Amazing Food!!!!! 👏 I'm getting hungry typing about it!! Try anything on their menu and you will not be let down!! 🤗

The pizza was Excellent! We ordered the Sausage, peppers, & onion. It was awesome!

Reminds mea so much of New York style pizzeria’s def a 10/10👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽

Awesome pizza! Best in Tallahassee!

Just moved in the area of Solles Pizza , My movers dispatcher , Also my Realtor all recommended this Pizza place to me . I’m very great full I fallowed through, Ya got to try the meatball sandwich too, the Pizza and meatball were the best . I’m a Navy veteran that’s traveled the world including Italy. I know good Italian food , this place is good.

The best pizza 🍕 in Tallahassee. Prepared by the friendliest crew around. Always a pleasure 😊.

We've been wanting to try Solle's for a while but it isn't very convenient to us. Very glad we finally did. Classic NY pizza. The crust, the sauce and the cheese were all perfect. Been disappointed by a decline in a few other local spots so it's great to find a new pizza that's worth the drive.

The owner of this place is genuinely the Tiger Woods of hospitality and pizza. Never had a better slice of pie in my life. The entire staff was so welcoming to me and my friends, and let us hangout for hours on end with no pressure to leave at all. Would full heartedly recommend.

The owner is Tom Brady of pizza. Service is unmatched with great vibes and a great staff. The owner told me “stay here for an hour or 8 hours , my restaurant is place where people can come here and have fun with good food.” I recommend to anybody to come here and grab a great slice accompanied by amazing service of smiles and hard work.

Huge calzone! The price for two slices and a coke is pretty good. I really enjoyed the pizza, and liked that they offered Beyond Meat crumble. Other toppings seemed very fresh. The cheesy garlic bread was also huge in size. Really great price for some of the best pizza I've found in the city.

Great pizza and service. My fiancé enjoyed the vegan option, and our daughter/myself enjoyed the ground beef topping on our pizza. The taste justifies the price.

Food excellent!! Everything is so fresh....forget Pizza Hut or Dominos. What a Gem that I am just now trying.

This is a great local place to pick up a good pie

Wonderful food and wonderful customer service! They went above and beyond for us tonight. The pizza is great and the closest to authentic Italian pizza in town.

Friendly service. The pizza was very good!

Delicious pizza! Well-seasoned sauce and excellent crust. The slices are huge! Don't let the small parking lot keep you away.

The pizzas are very tasty! It doesn’t look like much from the outside and parking can be a little tricky but the food is killer. Call your order in and add about 10 minutes to the pick up time but make sure to try the lasagna special.

Looks can be deceiving. This might be their smaller location, but the flavor and quality of food is still top notch. You will not be disappointed trying them out.

Food was great my first time trying them and I had the best experience ever will be back to this place for sure... definitely do try the wings.

This is authentic New York style! It's amazing we accidentally found this place looking for dinner after a weekend full of moving. Subs are hearty, stromboli was so big and the sauce with it (I could have used more), the garlic bread and cheese bread were good. Can't wait to try it again..

Very clean, very polite, positive atmosphere. Great food, great specials everyday. The best pizza in Tallahassee.

We tried this place originally because they supported the Florida High Cheer Team. So glad we did. Online ordering was easy and ready when promised. Food was very good. Only "ding" is for parking. I have an F150 and it was difficult to maneuver the small space. Next time I'll order delivery. Will definitely use them again.

Love the customer service and pizza!

Solle's is definitely a favorite for myself and my family to order from but tonight they went above and beyond. There was a mistake with my order which I only realized after returning home. I called Solle's to let them know what had happened and they offered to fix the mistake right away. I drove back and waited for a little bit while my pizza was remade. The staff has always been very kind and courteous and tonight was no different. This has been the only time that a mistake was made when ordering but it was quickly and efficiently resolved. I will definitely be returning to Solle's and supporting their business. This is a small pizza joint that packs big flavor and even bigger customer service. Thank you guys so much for all of your help tonight and keep doing what you're doing! Whether you're a local or just driving through Tallahasse, Solle's should be put on your list for places to try.

It's surprisingly delicious and authentic. New York style for sure. I reminisced as the aromas engulfed me upon entering. Pizza making was impressive. Hand tossed as it should be!!! Have not seen such craftsmanship in a while! Drove 30 minutes at the bequest of my five year old for PIZZA! It's totally worth it. Will definitely return. Mouth watering as I anticipate another slice.

It was okay, I has higher expectations for the pizza because my homie talked it up. Interested in trying other things on thr menu 6/10 on the pizza.

We ordered the 20 in. Pizza w/3 toppings & large order of Buffalo wings to b delivered for the 2 of us. And let me tell u it was the best ever!! Even the box was inviting & great. Delivery guy was prompt & pleasant. We WILL ABSOLUTELY order there again & HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT. Even the guy taking our order was an A+. Go get u some of this deliciousousness. ASAP. THANK YOU Solle's. Jim & Pattie Buchanan

I love their eggplant parm. Yummy. Best little Italian pizza takeout in town.

I am a cook so we rarely do take out Solle’s is something the guys at work get so we did Italian take out. We got the anti pasta and Stromboli . It is excellently prepared/ filled with meat, crust to perfection, sause magnificent. So I went back and told them . They gave me free sause to eat our leftovers. Don’t let the tiny facility fool you. Highly recommend Barbie

Ordered the Lasagne Dinner special. Very flavorful and cheesy. The garlic bread is always a winner! I also ordered the Chicken Parm special